Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Marketplace buyer now wanting money back

110 replies

lonelylou09 · 12/12/2023 23:00

Aibu to refuse to refund?
So I advertised something on marketplace. A lady messaged saying she definitely really wanted it so we organised a time during my lunch break for her to come and view it, which she did.
She said she had wanted one for ages so was really keen to have it.
Asked me if I'd lower the price so I did by a bit, wanting a quick hassle free sale.
She then insisted on paying for it upfront as she didn't want me to sell it to someone else even though it was a large item so she wasn't able to take it then..All sorted.

Then she spent 10 minutes (after paying) second guessing herself wether it was right for her. I gave her several opportunities to have the money back if she didn't feel happy..no pressure at all.
She hummed and hahhed and said ...no I want it so it's fine. I said 'are you absolutely sure because I'll give you the money back now?'
She said ' no I'll take it'.

So it was left with me saying I'd remove all the adverts and let the other people know it had been sold and wait for her to say when she could collect it.
Deleted all the adverts for it and she's just messaged now saying she's changed her mind and wants her money back.

I will more than likely give her money back but I really feel like saying I'm sorry ..you've wasted an hour of my time, you insisted on giving me the money upfront and you said from the first message you really wanted it.
I missed having lunch to meet her. Then I have to arrange to meet her again to refund her...plus redo the advert and wait again for them to be processed and approved.
Would I be being unreasonable to say no? It's yours come and collect it please. Or deduct some of the refund for my wasted time?
Wwyd?

OP posts:
Weddingblues23 · 13/12/2023 00:40

Its a windup but id just send the money back by transfer and be done with it. It's not worth the anguish. It takes approx 1 min to put an ad up on marketplace.

lonelylou09 · 13/12/2023 00:37

@GladTidyings I know it's normally all a mine field of people driving prices down, being late or not turning up or then demanding they come now to collect or else!
I wasn't in a rush to sell and had 2 other people Interested so I didn't want to take the money until it was going anyway...she could of asked me to hold it while she thought it through but she didn't.
I had a guy turn up and do that to me with the money when I sold my car. He drove the price down before viewing anyway..came to view.. agreed an even lower price and then short-changed me! I pulled him up and he said he was short as he stopped for coffee and food on the way and would drop it round for me 🤣🤣 never saw him again but the car was back up for sale days later at treble the price

OP posts:
lonelylou09 · 13/12/2023 00:30

@littlemousebigcheese well it would all be recorded if she did something like that as there is CCTV there.
I've messaged the other person who was interested to see if they still want it for an easy solution but I do feel like it's her issue now and if she has changed her mind then she can sell it on herself and have the hassle of time wasters.
If I was selling something that then didn't work or didn't fit ect I'd be more than happy to refund

OP posts:
Umtydumpy · 13/12/2023 00:27

Personally I'd agree to refund and relist it now at a slightly higher price so that she thinks she was getting a bargain (as no doubt she will see it), she will no doubt be in touch to say she actually does still want it then..if not just tell her to come and pick the money up as I don't see why you should have to go out of your way again.

GladTidyings · 13/12/2023 00:26

Ugh deal with this sort of stuff all the time. Sometimes avoid marketplace altogether, at least with postage you’re not beholden to people umming and aahing in the build up or on the doorstep!
I’m skint so lately have been selling any which way. Had a buy turn up to buy something tonight, from ebay. I insist on PayPal upfront but he was already messing me around and I just wanted the items gone so agreed to take cash on collection.
he fumbled around with loads of change, started counting it then gave up and dropped it in my hand saying ‘it’s all there’ and swiftly left.

i could see it wasn’t all there, counted afterwards and it was only a bit out but still bloody rude!
I hate being messed around, I’ve got less tolerant with time, I tend to shut down sales early on if someone’s giving me awkward vibes.
someone asked me so many crazy questions about an item currently selling new so info freely available, plus my listings are always very thorough.
It was a higher value item and I didn’t want to get the money and then refund her, she bothered me so much that in the end I refused to sell it to her.
she found me selling it on other platforms and reported me to every platform for refusing to sell to her!
had some shockers when giving away freee stuff too, really rude, demanding, grabby and ungrateful .
on the flip side I have made friends from marketplace etc and during a really sticky patch lately I’ve earned a much needed few hundred quid from clutter.
i sometimes regret the things I didn’t sell and gave away but it really is a lot of work so sometimes I just have to let it go.
i still have mucho clutter but hoping I can sell some more and have just sorted two big charity bags.

WiddlinDiddlin · 13/12/2023 00:18

Nah, its now her item you're kindly storing for free for a short period. She bought it, as seen, there and then.

Tell her:

'Sorry, I double and triple checked with you before taking your money, gave you several chances to change your mind. That cash has now gone to farrier/feedstore/bottomless pit that is horses and I can't refund. I suggest you collect it by X date and sell on if it doesn't suit you'.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 13/12/2023 00:18

lonelylou09 · 12/12/2023 23:21

@VeniVidiWeeWee what do you mean by 'buyer beware' ?

For private buyers the legal phrase is caveat emptor.

It means, unless the law explicitly says otherwise, the buyer cannot change their mind unless the the seller has misrepresented the item for sale.

But, IANAL.

littlemousebigcheese · 13/12/2023 00:17

You say other people were interested so I'd just give her the money back and relist it. It's too awkward otherwise as you'd have to be there when she collected it and who knows what could happen? She could bring burly mates to intimidate you, or get really angry and it's just not worth it in my eyes. Tell her it's frustrating as you gave her several opportunities to have the money back at the time but that you're happy to refund. Then just relist, resell and move on ♥️

lonelylou09 · 13/12/2023 00:15

@whynotwhatknot no 9 hours is not long, but she contacted me about the item, she wanted to come and view it ..which she did...she insisted she wanted it and insisted she paid for it there and then ..even though she couldn't remove the item until another date.
She could of had the money back at any time..she refused.
If she had thought about it and then changed her mind without paying ..fair enough..even if she had left a deposit and changed her mind ..fair enough...but she insisted she bought the item then and there!

OP posts:
lonelylou09 · 13/12/2023 00:09

@MercanDede of someone bought something second hand from an individual after personally seeing and handling the item then unless it is faulty there is nothing wrong with not refunding them on a mind change.

OP posts:
lonelylou09 · 13/12/2023 00:06

@MercanDede id love to know where you are getting this legal information from as you don't even have a right to refund from a store just because you have changed your mind.
I told her I would take down the advert as she hadn't taken the item so it wouldn't be right for me to still be advertising it as for sale.
I surely couldn't of legally sold it to someone else after she had already paid me for the item?
I tried to say to her several times to not pay, to go away and think about it and she INSISTED.
As she was in no position at the time to take the item with her I didn't want to take her money. We stood and discussed it further and I said several times for her to take the money back and she refused.
This was after her seeing several images of the item, viewing the item in person and saying she definitely wanted it. She said of she had been able to take it there and then she would of done.
If she has taken the item and then came back 9 hours later saying she had changed her mind I'd not even entertain the idea of a refund.

OP posts:
MercanDede · 12/12/2023 23:58

Anyway, all the tough shit posters that have done this illegally are quite right in that you can follow suit and get away with it scot free because the average person can’t afford a solicitor’s letter much less small claims court. Doesn’t make it right to do, but if you have similarly a flexible moral code you can certainly tell her tough shit, I’m keeping the money, it’s your problem now come and get it.

MercanDede · 12/12/2023 23:54

lonelylou09 · 12/12/2023 23:49

@MercanDede it wasn't a hard sell at all.
She said she didn't want to miss the opportunity as she had been wanting the item for a while. I didn't ask for the money as she couldn't take the item ...she insisted on giving me the money even when I said to her to think about it first or pay on collection as I would of preferred that.
Even after she gave me the money I said several times if she wasn't sure she should take the money back.

You were happy enough to take her money even though you could see she was not entirely sure. You didn’t refuse to take her money when you should have. You could have offered to reserve the item for say 24hrs when you saw she was uncertain and second guessing.

MeMySonAnd1 · 12/12/2023 23:50

Though luck, just say you offer no refunds and that it will be ready for her to collect straight away. Tell her that if not collected by Sunday evening it will be taken to the tip.

lonelylou09 · 12/12/2023 23:49

@MercanDede it wasn't a hard sell at all.
She said she didn't want to miss the opportunity as she had been wanting the item for a while. I didn't ask for the money as she couldn't take the item ...she insisted on giving me the money even when I said to her to think about it first or pay on collection as I would of preferred that.
Even after she gave me the money I said several times if she wasn't sure she should take the money back.

OP posts:
whynotwhatknot · 12/12/2023 23:46

i dont really think 9 hours is that long to change your mind

MercanDede · 12/12/2023 23:36

lonelylou09 · 12/12/2023 23:24

@Thisilldo ...that's a very good reply.
Part of me feels tight as I'm normally so nice but I gave her many opportunities at the time to change her mind there and then so part of me thinks ...it's yours..if you now don't want it .you sell it on!

You did a hard sell. The agree now or it is gone. That’s not a nice tactic.

MercanDede · 12/12/2023 23:35

From a legal standpoint you don’t have a leg to stand on.

  • she has the legal right to change her mind prior to taking possession of the item no matter how long that is. 9 hrs is nothing.
  • you have no right to keep her money unless you have it in writing with her signature that she agrees it is a non refundable deposit.
  • she didn’t ask or demand you take down the adverts, that was your decision. You could have legally sold it to someone else and then told her sorry, you never completed the transaction, I have a buyer that is willing to proceed, so here is your money back.
tachycardigan · 12/12/2023 23:33

I wouldn’t give her her money back. Tell her as it’s Christmas you’ve spent it.

lonelylou09 · 12/12/2023 23:33

@Houseplanter must be a common thing then!
This is an outside item but would be stolen if left out to be collected. So chances are I'd have to arrange to meet her again to collect the item to make sure it was collected safely.

OP posts:
lonelylou09 · 12/12/2023 23:28

@EvilElsa that's just what I was thinking. I'm not sure why I should have to redo the advert and waste more of my time sorting out another sale just because she's changed her mind 9 hours later

OP posts:
AnneElliott · 12/12/2023 23:27

I wouldn't refund quickly as you've had all the hassle. I agree I'd put it back for sale and she can have the money back at the end of Jan or if the next buyer pays you - which ever comes first.

lonelylou09 · 12/12/2023 23:26

@justanothermanicmonday1 she doesn't know where I live ..just where the item is.

OP posts:
lonelylou09 · 12/12/2023 23:24

@Thisilldo ...that's a very good reply.
Part of me feels tight as I'm normally so nice but I gave her many opportunities at the time to change her mind there and then so part of me thinks ...it's yours..if you now don't want it .you sell it on!

OP posts:
malmi · 12/12/2023 23:22

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 12/12/2023 23:07

What's the item? Has she used it now.doesnt need it?

She hasn't used it. She never collected it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread