Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Marketplace buyer now wanting money back

110 replies

lonelylou09 · 12/12/2023 23:00

Aibu to refuse to refund?
So I advertised something on marketplace. A lady messaged saying she definitely really wanted it so we organised a time during my lunch break for her to come and view it, which she did.
She said she had wanted one for ages so was really keen to have it.
Asked me if I'd lower the price so I did by a bit, wanting a quick hassle free sale.
She then insisted on paying for it upfront as she didn't want me to sell it to someone else even though it was a large item so she wasn't able to take it then..All sorted.

Then she spent 10 minutes (after paying) second guessing herself wether it was right for her. I gave her several opportunities to have the money back if she didn't feel happy..no pressure at all.
She hummed and hahhed and said ...no I want it so it's fine. I said 'are you absolutely sure because I'll give you the money back now?'
She said ' no I'll take it'.

So it was left with me saying I'd remove all the adverts and let the other people know it had been sold and wait for her to say when she could collect it.
Deleted all the adverts for it and she's just messaged now saying she's changed her mind and wants her money back.

I will more than likely give her money back but I really feel like saying I'm sorry ..you've wasted an hour of my time, you insisted on giving me the money upfront and you said from the first message you really wanted it.
I missed having lunch to meet her. Then I have to arrange to meet her again to refund her...plus redo the advert and wait again for them to be processed and approved.
Would I be being unreasonable to say no? It's yours come and collect it please. Or deduct some of the refund for my wasted time?
Wwyd?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blondeshavemorefun · 14/12/2023 23:35

slithytoveisascientist · 13/12/2023 23:32

Again, you don't need to delete marketplace posts to stop advertising them. You just mark them as sold. It's one click. It's then only one click to put back on sale should the need arise.

This

Where did she meet you to see the item

If not your house ?

I would have told her to go there for money

But get why a bank t is also proof

slithytoveisascientist · 13/12/2023 23:32

Again, you don't need to delete marketplace posts to stop advertising them. You just mark them as sold. It's one click. It's then only one click to put back on sale should the need arise.

VioletBeauregardeTheFirst · 13/12/2023 17:32

Sexlivesofthepotatomen · 13/12/2023 16:01

Have you even read OP's posts? The buy didn't collect the item, it was too big for her to take there and then so she gave OP the money to hold it for her

You know there's ways of pointing out someone is wrong without being unkind?

I have reread the OPs posts and yes she did say it was paid for and not collected so I was wrong. But as I said, there are ways to point it out without being rude. An example would be to quote the part of the OP post that mentions she didn't collect it and tag me. No rudeness required.

lonelylou09 · 13/12/2023 16:42

@Sexlivesofthepotatomen I said I didn't have money in the bank as she paid cash so now have to go to the bank and pay money in...another hour wasted but rather that than have to arrange to meet her again..also there's then proof she's had the money back ...just to cover myself

OP posts:
Sexlivesofthepotatomen · 13/12/2023 16:25

MyrrAgain · 13/12/2023 16:19

Yep but it's either drive to the bank or drive to meet the buyer and potentially get mucked around by them again and waste time. Safer to transfer so there's proof. Or tell the buyer she'll have to wait until op goes to town and the bank which might be several days! Too bad.

Anyway the whole thing is a mess really, why did this random woman leave cash for a random seller and then drive off without the item? Seller could just bog off with the cash or deny it was ever paid etc etc

Ignore my previous post, OP has done a bank transfer despite saying she couldn't

lonelylou09 · 13/12/2023 16:24

Oh should add though I did tell buyer that if the other sale didn't go through then as far as I saw it the item was hers so deal with.
I deleted the item totally because for me it wouldn't be right still advertising something that was sold and paid for in full.
The fact that she didn't take the item was down to her transport at the time...truck in the garage for the day...so as some have said I could of just kept the money anyway. ( I wouldn't but know people that would!)

OP posts:
MyrrAgain · 13/12/2023 16:19

Sexlivesofthepotatomen · 13/12/2023 16:00

OP has explained why she can't do a bank transfer

Yep but it's either drive to the bank or drive to meet the buyer and potentially get mucked around by them again and waste time. Safer to transfer so there's proof. Or tell the buyer she'll have to wait until op goes to town and the bank which might be several days! Too bad.

Anyway the whole thing is a mess really, why did this random woman leave cash for a random seller and then drive off without the item? Seller could just bog off with the cash or deny it was ever paid etc etc

lonelylou09 · 13/12/2023 16:18

Update...
Thanks to everyone for your messages!
I got back in touch with the other person who was interested and they said they would come to look this afternoon.
In the meantime the original buyer messaged me again saying they would be willing to accept a refund minus a small amount for being a pain basically.
The other person took the item for the same price even though it wasn't quite right for them.
So now original 'buyer' has been refunded via bank transfer minus the amount she offered to cover my time ...so everyones happy!

OP posts:
lonelylou09 · 13/12/2023 16:15

@Sproutier ..it's not my fault she didn't want to take the item with her...that was her choice. She stated she would be back to Collect it as soon as she could! If someone went in a shop and left their bags behind the til to collect later on and then didn't go back to collect..that's not on the shop to sort out!

OP posts:
Sproutier · 13/12/2023 16:12

GladioliandSweetPeas · 13/12/2023 15:51

Incorrect as the buyer has paid! So the contract is complete. Do your research

Ok I have tried to look up but I'm not getting anywhere, it keeps serving me up house buying.

How can the contract be complete when the buyer not only hasn't"t received the item, but doesn't know where it is, and seller has no plan to deliver it? Are you saying the contract has absolutely no notion of the buyer getting the item? I only have a layman's understanding but surely there is an obligation on OP not to just walk away with the lady's money.

Sexlivesofthepotatomen · 13/12/2023 16:01

VioletBeauregardeTheFirst · 13/12/2023 13:53

If it's been in her possession she may now have damaged it so you might not be able to sell on. Just something to be mindful of. Why would she do that? Your previous experience with Marketplace sellers tells you there's sharks out there.

Have you even read OP's posts? The buy didn't collect the item, it was too big for her to take there and then so she gave OP the money to hold it for her

Sexlivesofthepotatomen · 13/12/2023 16:00

MyrrAgain · 13/12/2023 14:53

Ask for her bank details and transfer it over. Then she can't say she never got the money. Then block her. but give her a telling off beforehand. Maybe deduct 10% for admin 😂

OP has explained why she can't do a bank transfer

GladioliandSweetPeas · 13/12/2023 15:51

MercanDede · 12/12/2023 23:35

From a legal standpoint you don’t have a leg to stand on.

  • she has the legal right to change her mind prior to taking possession of the item no matter how long that is. 9 hrs is nothing.
  • you have no right to keep her money unless you have it in writing with her signature that she agrees it is a non refundable deposit.
  • she didn’t ask or demand you take down the adverts, that was your decision. You could have legally sold it to someone else and then told her sorry, you never completed the transaction, I have a buyer that is willing to proceed, so here is your money back.

Incorrect as the buyer has paid! So the contract is complete. Do your research

MyrrAgain · 13/12/2023 14:53

Ask for her bank details and transfer it over. Then she can't say she never got the money. Then block her. but give her a telling off beforehand. Maybe deduct 10% for admin 😂

burnoutbabe · 13/12/2023 14:36

Pookerrod · 13/12/2023 13:41

I’d post this in Legal as opposed to AIBU. I’m not a lawyer but have done some legal exams due to my profession and I think you may be on dodgy ground legally as she hasn’t taken possession.

The item is in your possession so the transaction has not yet completed. She has given you consideration in the form of cash but you haven’t given her anything as yet.

The only way you could force completion of the transaction is by delivering the item.

But check this out on the Legals board.

well i mean she could sue for specific performance and get the item. Which is what the op wants, her to take the item

But she can't sue to cancel the contract, there is NO frustration here, the item is there ready to collect!

SecondUsername4me · 13/12/2023 14:30

I'd probably message "I'm sorry to hear you no longer want the item. As it now belongs to you (and I am storing it for you), please arrange collection in order that you can sell it on, if you no longer want to keep it yourself. I can store it until 22nd Dec after which point I will need to dispose of it to make way for a replacement I have purchased to go in it's place"

Basically - it's hers, you are storing it for free, it's her job to sort out selling it if she doesn't want it.

MsFogi · 13/12/2023 14:23

Tell her how much of your time she has used (and will use) and tell her your hourly rate and give her the choice of picking it up or coming to get a refund minus the cost of your time (may even be she needs to pay you more for her ´refund’ 😁).

TheOccupier · 13/12/2023 14:09

I'd just give the money back and relist. I sell on FB Marketplace and it's really only a couple of clicks to reactivate/repost an advert. If you get wound up by this sort of flaky behaviour then Marketplace is not for you!

viques · 13/12/2023 13:53

littlemousebigcheese · 13/12/2023 00:17

You say other people were interested so I'd just give her the money back and relist it. It's too awkward otherwise as you'd have to be there when she collected it and who knows what could happen? She could bring burly mates to intimidate you, or get really angry and it's just not worth it in my eyes. Tell her it's frustrating as you gave her several opportunities to have the money back at the time but that you're happy to refund. Then just relist, resell and move on ♥️

Re list but include the phrase NO TIMEWASTERS PLEASE prominently in the advert. She is probably still looking for a similar item, will spot it and know who you mean.

For a refund she needs to provide her bank details so you can refund her directly at your leisure and not have to hang around waiting for her to show up.

VioletBeauregardeTheFirst · 13/12/2023 13:53

If it's been in her possession she may now have damaged it so you might not be able to sell on. Just something to be mindful of. Why would she do that? Your previous experience with Marketplace sellers tells you there's sharks out there.

JenniferJuniper80 · 13/12/2023 13:46

Tell her you've spent the money but you will re-advertise the item as and when you get time. Remind her you took the adverts down and wasted your lunch break selling it.
Then promise you'll give her her money back once it's sold. Probably some time next year. She's not entitled to a refund so that's the best she can expect.

I bet she arranges to collect it.

Pookerrod · 13/12/2023 13:41

I’d post this in Legal as opposed to AIBU. I’m not a lawyer but have done some legal exams due to my profession and I think you may be on dodgy ground legally as she hasn’t taken possession.

The item is in your possession so the transaction has not yet completed. She has given you consideration in the form of cash but you haven’t given her anything as yet.

The only way you could force completion of the transaction is by delivering the item.

But check this out on the Legals board.

GoonDog · 13/12/2023 13:17

There are some pathetic people on this thread.
No wonder society is a mess.

27icey · 13/12/2023 13:16

Offer to refund her and tell her you've found someone else that is keen to take it. Due to scarcity mindset she'll probably change her mind again and say that she now wants it and that it's hers because she's paid for it. Then tell her she needs to pick it up within an hour, otherwise you are going to give it to the other person.

Secondguess · 13/12/2023 13:04

If you do refund her, give her the same banknotes she paid with. If you refund any other way you could find you're left with fake notes and have given her real money.

Personally I'd tell her that she can collect the item and resell it herself- your recent experience has put you off selling it yourself again due to timewasters.