Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To realise I made the wrong choice 15 years ago?

34 replies

Santashelperisonstrike · 12/12/2023 22:01

I’ve seen threads on here where people have realised how lucky they’ve been for meeting their OH, but has anyone realised that they’ve let a great relationship slip through their fingers?

I’ve just come to the realisation that my uni boyfriend was the love of my life and I messed it up. I split up with him for no bigger reason than we left uni but had jobs in different towns (only about an hour away). He was really hurt about it and wanted us to stay together.

Fast forward a few years and we live close to each other and hang out in same group of uni friends. We both got married about 6-7 years ago to other people and each have kids. My marriage wasn’t happy and split with ex soon after my second DD was born.
im now in new relationship which is good, but feel
there’s just something missing.

I still see my relationship with my uni boyfriend as the benchmark for my relationships, but no one has come close.

Before there’s a pile on, I just want to say I have no intention of starting anything with my ex boyfriend. He’s happily married and I know that ship has sailed.

but I can’t shake this feeling of sadness, that splitting up with him was a sliding doors moment and I made the wrong decision.

how have you dealt with your regrets?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
millymog11 · 13/12/2023 09:03

I believe that some of the agony around relationships not working relates to the fact that it is not just the person but you also have to have met them at the right stage of life/stage of maturity for you both to be a good match for each other. So character/personality wise you might be perfect but if the timing is not right on either side, then either one will walk away where it could have had real potential as a relationship OR you both force a union and then it goes horribly wrong at some point down the road because one of you (or both but usually one - the one who was "persuaded" into the union more than the other) leaves to sow the wild oats (for want of a better phrase) they feel they did not get a chance to before they committed to you.

Lessons (i) true love and compatibility is extremely rare (ii) never think you can persuade someone into realising that they are "ready"for commitment. They eitehr feel they are of their own volition or it will come out in the wash somewhere down the road

queenMab99 · 13/12/2023 08:35

When I look back on my life, I see that I married the wrong person, for the right reasons, I divorced after 22 years and 2 sons. However, I later married someone else, who made a huge difference to my outlook on life, was a rock when one of my sons died, and gave me 20 years of never being bored and laughter. I would never have married him, if I had met him in my 20s or 30s, for various reasons. I would not be the person I am now, if my life had been different.

ArchetypalBusyMum · 13/12/2023 08:35

I think also, a great connection makes you feel so alive, when someone 'gets' you and you are drawn to each other and it's all easy and nice it's a kind of bliss.
As fabulous as my kids are it's a parent-child relationship and whole there is no contest for the depth of feeling I have for them, it is a different part of you that is in play.
So it's ok, for you to yearn, but I agree with @Firefly2009 that there is no single 'one', another person with whom you found a special connection would have these feelings evaporated because that yearning and the regret with it would go. Meantime you can acknowledge to yourself you are human and need to be seen and wanted and if you're sad sometimes be patient with yourself and seek comfort from what you can.

babbi · 13/12/2023 08:26

@Firefly2009 excellent post 👏

Gnomegnomegnome · 13/12/2023 08:26

I regret getting with my ex but I wouldn’t have my 4 lovely children. That’s the only decent thing to have come from it.

GladioliandSweetPeas · 13/12/2023 08:25

Oh yes! But he didn't see me as 'the one' and was, looking back, emotionally abusive & controlling. So I probably shouldn't see him as 'the one who got away'. However, I've never had quite^^ the same connection with anyone else either before or since him. Quite sad really.

babbi · 13/12/2023 08:25

OP I’m sorry , those feelings are all too strong and regret is sad .
I got the opportunity to reconnect with my first boyfriend.. the one who got away .
Had a great ( passionate 😉) time for a couple of years and don’t regret that opportunity but it didn’t work out and I’m glad about that for so many reasons . It would not have been a good thing for us to have stayed together since our teens but I wouldn’t have known that if we hadn’t that second chance .
It let me lay the ghost of him to rest .

in short , I’m trying to say you are probably not missing what you think .

Take care , I hope you find happiness.

Santashelperisonstrike · 13/12/2023 08:18

@Firefly2009 this is a very good point. Went out with uni bf for 2.5 years which is nothing really. I know he’s a decent guy as we are still in wider friendship group, but your experience just shows how you can’t trust your earlier perception.

I know he can frustrate his DW at times, so it’s possible that he would’ve driven me nuts as she’s far more patient than me!

If I’d split up with my now ex-H before we got married, he’d be the ‘one who got away’ but now I wish he’d got away and saved me a lot of hassle!

be careful what you wish for, right?

OP posts:
Firefly2009 · 13/12/2023 07:59

How long were you with your uni boyfriend? I am guessing the fact that he moved away wasn't really the only reason you ended it. The problem is that if you had stayed with him you'd have been wondering what else was out there.
Either way, the grass always seems greener from the other side.

I had a rare good relationship in my early to mid twenties. We were only dating for a year or so, and I was busy as a mum at the time; he was super supportive and I didn't have to make a huge effort with him, he just really was into me. It broke up due to work taking him away. For a very long time, he was the benchmark of the perfect, ideal man and I honestly felt for years that he was the one who got away. It hurt my heart to think about it, honestly. On the other hand, it gave me hope for there being great guys out there.

We got back in touch about 15 years later and exchanged several emails. Still the same as he ever was until we delved a bit deeper. I have since realised the guy is a totally narcissistic!! Not in any malignant sense, but he's super weird, very egotistical and love-bomb-y; I just didn't see it back then. And I'm not saying there's a correlation to your exBF at all, only that things are not necessarily as great as you think they'd be. And I kind of regret that we got in touch and got to know him again because it ruined that one nice memory that I have!

You will find someone better than him. You're probably feeling low because of the split you've been through. This will pass. Just look forwards. There's never just one great person in the world for you.

TookTheBook · 13/12/2023 07:51

But do you regret your children? They are real and exist.

Have you had therapy or counselling to work out what you are pining after (in relationships especially but overall in life)? It's like you're latching onto a fantasy and regret rather than facing what you actually want to think about - what you want to do next.

Porageeater · 13/12/2023 07:45

Normal to have ‘what if’ sliding door thoughts but also it’s impossible to know how things may have turned out and could just have easily been for the worse as better. Philosophical is the way to be.

The happiest people live in the moment apparently, not too much in the past or the future.

MrsJellybee · 13/12/2023 07:44

You do know in the alternate sliding doors reality, there’s a version of you writing on Mumsnet about how you married your safe Uni boyfriend and regret not finding out what else is out there. We can never know the outcome of the path not taken. Accept your choices as valid and move forward with your life.

Ploctopus · 13/12/2023 07:32

Rose tinted glasses, OP. It’s easy to look back and think that things could have been perfect, but if they had been at the time you wouldn’t have split up just for living in different cities.

There’s a reason why it didn’t feel worth it to you to put up with that inconvenience at the time.

CalistoNoSolo · 13/12/2023 07:28

God, naval gazing over past relationships and 'the one that got away' really is self indulgent bollocks. If you're dissatisfied with your life or the relationship you're in change it. But it's incredibly naive to think some guy you dated 15 years ago is going to make your life wonderful.

Santashelperisonstrike · 13/12/2023 07:24

thanks everyone for your replies - have read every one and it’s made me feel a little more philosophical about things. I think I’ll also use this feeling to seek out what I really want in life. I sometimes think these negative thoughts can actually point out what’s wrong in your life in the present.

@surreygirl1987 I’ll read that book- sounds like it might be relevant!

@wronginalltherightways @MiddleParking I know- I’m so happy to have my kids- wouldn’t change them for the world, and as a pp said, if I could go back in a Time Machine, I wouldn’t.

But I always think with this kind of regret is that I’d never have known them. I’d probably have a couple of kids with uni bf who I’d similarly not change for the world!

Thanks @ArchetypalBusyMum for you’re very comforting post.

OP posts:
surreygirl1987 · 13/12/2023 00:37

Read the book the Midnight Library. All about regretting life decisions.

wronginalltherightways · 13/12/2023 00:30

You remember that you wouldn't have your children if you had picked differently, that's how.

x

MiddleParking · 13/12/2023 00:11

Aren’t your kids a pretty powerful regret-killer re who you ended up marrying? You wouldn’t have had the ones you’ve got!

youcandanceifyouwanna · 13/12/2023 00:01

I feel like I've messed up a few aspects of my life. I've tried to understand my thinking patterns at the time I made those decisions and learn from them, can't change the past but I can try to learn from my mistakes.

ArchetypalBusyMum · 12/12/2023 23:40

When you're young you make all kinds of decisions for an kinds of reasons which with hindsight turn out to be based on ignorance / short sightedness / naivete / impulsiveness / lack of self knowledge... All kinds of things which as we get older and wiser and know ourselves and the world better we hopefully make fewer and fewer decisions which are based on shaky ground... Though no guarantees at any age!

It is possible that this was one of those and that's the thought that's gripped you.
However, had you recognised you had gold and worked it out, you could very well have ended up saying he's great, but we got together so young I don't feel I've ever had chance to spread my wings and I got tired down so young I feel stifled...

The hard part about life is that it is all made up as we go along and the spending path remains cloaked and opaque and imbued with what night have been, as this relationship never went sour, that might have been is still a significant mystery.

I think the only way out of how you feel is to work towards acceptance of what has gone before and where you are. Young you couldn't have chosen better because the decision was taken in good faith knowing what you knew at the time. Had you remained together the 'what could have been' question would not still be hanging in the air, but many other alternatives may have arisen, not necessarily good.

You know that connection was rare, you have a hunger for something like it, which is natural but you also have other enviable things in your life. Children, health, friends and other things... The longer I live the more I think that no one gets a life without some sorrow or loss in the mix, you can only learn to treasure those you love and make sure they know they are important as you don't get out of life more than what you put into it and each connection is precious in its own way.

Small comfort in the dark of the night sometimes I know, but the more you behave with determination to love well the less power the regret has over you.

mikado1 · 12/12/2023 23:09

I heard a psychoplgist respond to this question before and I think she was right. She said if it had been the right relationship for you, you wouldn't have broken up, simple, or you would have found a way to get back together since. I think if only realising this after 15 years it's even less likely to be accurate or you'd have thought it previously, and it's much more likely you're looking with Rose coloured glasses.

SkaneTos · 12/12/2023 23:05

You don't know what life would have been like with your uni boyfriend.
You don't really know what he is like now.

Enjoy the life you have now.
Enjoy being a mother to two lovely children.

Passingthethyme · 12/12/2023 22:55

You're just thinking the grass is greener. If you really wanted to, you would've stayed with him.

Santashelperisonstrike · 12/12/2023 22:47

@Curlywurlycaz2 i miss the connection. It was so easy. We were compatible in so many ways, and I’ve struggled to meet anyone who has really given me butterflies- but I realise that me just be a ‘first love’ thing.

@Cupcakekiller i think you’re right. I know it’s very different when you’re in a long term relationship as an adult.

@Behindyouiam agree that my younger self made the right decision at the time - I suppose I didn’t want to settle with my first proper boyfriend.

But in a way, I regret having such a great relationship so early. I didn’t realise what a good thing I had. I thought relationships like that ( and men) grew on trees. If I’d known what a rare connection we had, I would’ve maybe taken more care.

i also think I appreciate the stability he would’ve offered. As I get older, that’s a bigger factor. But I valued that less in my early 20’s.

OP posts:
Naptrappedmummy · 12/12/2023 22:45

I’m the same. If I had a Time Machine I wouldn’t get in it, because I love my DC too much and wouldn’t want to change events. But I spend a lot of time thinking about it, what might have been, why things played out the way they did. It all makes me a bit sad.