Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if you’re the white parent of a mixed race child in the U.K., you should educate yourself about race issues and racism?

237 replies

Yabberwocky · 12/12/2023 21:56

Just that, really. You should make an active and consistent effort to inform yourself, try to understand what your child might be dealing with, recognise microaggressions, that sort of thing.

I’ve been musing about my own childhood and upbringing. Wondered what people thought.

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/12/2023 19:19

Thornrose · 13/12/2023 19:15

I'm a white mother of a mixed race child, well grown woman now! Having a black partner for years before dd was born exposed me to racism and made me really understand and experience it in a way I never had before.

I was living in Brixton, late 90s. My social life, friendships and workplace were very diverse. I despised racism in all it's forms. I thought I got it.

But the comments and looks and attitudes dd's dad and I received over the years were eye opening to say the least! Some white Police officers were particularly charming I remember!

When dd was born it continued in a different way. I was very wary of taking dd out without her hair done as I felt judged as "one of those white mothers who can't look after her dd's hair." I was educated by our lived experience.

I've always told dd I will never know exactly how she feels but I can listen and support and help.

I've made sure she has people in her life who do know exactly how she feels and they are there for her when she needs that shared experience I simply can't give her.

It takes a village...

I agree that I learnt a lot about racism as a result of living with a partner who wasn't white. I thought I was reasonably aware of it before I met him, but my eyes were definitely opened. Having a mixed race dd then further added to my understanding but I'm definitely still learning!

Thornrose · 13/12/2023 19:15

I'm a white mother of a mixed race child, well grown woman now! Having a black partner for years before dd was born exposed me to racism and made me really understand and experience it in a way I never had before.

I was living in Brixton, late 90s. My social life, friendships and workplace were very diverse. I despised racism in all it's forms. I thought I got it.

But the comments and looks and attitudes dd's dad and I received over the years were eye opening to say the least! Some white Police officers were particularly charming I remember!

When dd was born it continued in a different way. I was very wary of taking dd out without her hair done as I felt judged as "one of those white mothers who can't look after her dd's hair." I was educated by our lived experience.

I've always told dd I will never know exactly how she feels but I can listen and support and help.

I've made sure she has people in her life who do know exactly how she feels and they are there for her when she needs that shared experience I simply can't give her.

It takes a village...

Prune2024 · 13/12/2023 19:06

Family of mn
If a white man and black dad seems soooo apathetic, where do you stand if white dad doesn't acknowledge racial difereneces?

MCOut · 13/12/2023 19:01

@IncompleteSenten if you already know how he feels about the matter, from a pre-emptive perspective, you have already demonstrated that he will be able to talk to you about it should the need arise. In your situation the best approach might be reactive. Also racism is so rooted in the social I’m assuming they might understand the more insidious aspects better with experience. Maybe from a pre-emptive perspective, focusing on making sure there is an equally positive view of both of their heritages is enough.

Queucumber · 13/12/2023 18:52

Actually, having mixed race friends has been very important to my dd. She is the only mixed race person in our family, and there are aspects of the mixed race/dual heritage experience that neither her dad nor I have experienced directly. We both try to understand, obviously, and I have learnt a great deal from our many conversations on this issue. However, I think dd has found it immensely helpful to have mixed race friends who just "get it" without her needing to explain. I am truly grateful that she has had that.

That makes a lot of sense.

feralunderclass · 13/12/2023 18:43

It's like anything though, if you don't have lived experience about something you often don't think to educate yourself about it. Then again, some parents just cba or don't think it's necessary. One of my dc is deaf and we went to (free) classes, which we were signposted to after the diagnosis. I assumed every parent in this situation would do so, but that is very much not the case. Some just simply don't see the point, or don't feel it is their responsibility as its a 'medical' thing.

Zanatdy · 13/12/2023 18:41

My kids are mixed race (Asian / white) and we have had many conversations about racism. One of my children looks like he is full Asian and the other like you can only just tell she’s not fully white. Thankfully we live in a multi cultural area and no racism of note. My eldest is taking advantage of schemes aimed at mixed race / ethnic minorities for work / interns etc. I mean he qualifies but I think he’s experienced more positivity for being none white than negativity. They do embrace their Asian culture and are close to cousins on dads side too. I think overall being mixed race has been positive for them

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/12/2023 18:36

ThereSnowLimit · 13/12/2023 18:08

I agree, OP. I’m a white parent of mixed race children. I’ve tried really hard (and will always keep trying) to see things through my children’s eyes and educate myself about issues that affect them as mixed race young people (now both teens) and the issues that they care about.

There are some things I’ll never truly be able to understand about their experience, and for that they have their Dad and black and mixed race family and friends. I think it must be very hard for those mixed race kids growing up with their white parent & family only. It must be hard growing up in a white area. My kids have grown up in an area where they are definitely not in the minority. Most of their friends are black or mixed race, so they have peers with a shared experience. My husband came from Jamaica to a majority white area as a kid and it was brutal.

Actually, having mixed race friends has been very important to my dd. She is the only mixed race person in our family, and there are aspects of the mixed race/dual heritage experience that neither her dad nor I have experienced directly. We both try to understand, obviously, and I have learnt a great deal from our many conversations on this issue. However, I think dd has found it immensely helpful to have mixed race friends who just "get it" without her needing to explain. I am truly grateful that she has had that.

Interestingly, she has a couple of friends who are exactly the same mix as she is, and a few who are a completely different mix, and it doesn't seem to matter that much either way...it is the experience of having a foot in two cultures and two ethnicities that seems to be important for her, rather than the specific combination of cultures.

I think things would have been a whole lot harder for her without those friends who share that experience.

Bature · 13/12/2023 18:10

TreadLight · 13/12/2023 17:11

When I educate myself about something, go back to original sources, obtain contemporary data, consider the merits of both sides of an argument and talk about it with different people to get a wide range of view points. I often end up with a view diametrically opposed to the view held by the person who suggested I should "educate myself".

So if you have a view which you strongly hold, and think others should strongly hold it too, educate them. Put forward persuasive, compelling cases why your position is right. If you don't, if you leave it up to them, you could well end up with someone who makes the effort and finds out that it is unquestioningly you that is full of boloney.

How is that a response to my comment?

ThereSnowLimit · 13/12/2023 18:08

I agree, OP. I’m a white parent of mixed race children. I’ve tried really hard (and will always keep trying) to see things through my children’s eyes and educate myself about issues that affect them as mixed race young people (now both teens) and the issues that they care about.

There are some things I’ll never truly be able to understand about their experience, and for that they have their Dad and black and mixed race family and friends. I think it must be very hard for those mixed race kids growing up with their white parent & family only. It must be hard growing up in a white area. My kids have grown up in an area where they are definitely not in the minority. Most of their friends are black or mixed race, so they have peers with a shared experience. My husband came from Jamaica to a majority white area as a kid and it was brutal.

IncompleteSenten · 13/12/2023 18:05

MCOut · 13/12/2023 17:38

@IncompleteSenten what you’ve said so so interesting. I’ve noticed anecdotally that some of us who have formative experience in black majority countries may underestimate the childhood experience of racism and its impacts. I think this is particularly noticeable in people who come from middle class l backgrounds because we know what black achievement looks like, we’ve already formed at least a partial positive black identity and the UK is a developed country, so the immediate assumption (especially in times gone by) is that no matter what it will be better here. Your husband might have a completely different view, but I imagine if it’s somewhat similar to this than knowing your child is also mixed race might make race seem like less of a problem.

It’s also very interesting that your elder son identifies as black and not mixed race but also has said he hasn’t experienced any racism. I would have doubts but that might be true. It might be that what you have done as parents is managed to instil a very positive view of his black Kenyan heritage which is just as important. (Caveat, I am not saying that people who identify as a mixed race do not have a positive sense of their black identity or that it’s in anyway bad to identify as mixed race).

I wonder that too. He's Kikuyu and grew up pretty privileged. A lot of people from other tribes have quite negative feelings about the Kikuyu even today
.
Re my elder son and racism I have wondered if we've let him down and if he thinks racism is only about being called offensive names because we've failed to give him a true and broader understanding if that makes sense.

But my husband has always been completely opposed to doing that, saying like I said that we'll teach them to see racism everywhere.

I am acutely aware of the dangers of white privilege and I worry that if I disrespect my husband's strong views on this that I am acting like I as a white person knows more than he does even though I have benefitted in so many ways all my life from a system set up to benefit some and actively block others. Then I wonder am I doing the just as irritating navel gazing and hand wringing and look at me thing when it's actually not about me or how I feel or how I view things.
Then he tells me see, this is what I'm talking about, you're creating problems.

SemperIdem · 13/12/2023 17:42

I’m surprised by some of the comments here and the yabu %.

I’m white, I don’t have mixed race children, but I think it is important to educate myself and my child on racism, the lived experiences of colleagues, friends, neighbours. I would think it even more important if my child was mixed race and likely to have a different lived experience to me, if not throughout their life consistently, but at certain points, because skin colour is still an issue for many in the society we live in.

As it is, my focus is making sure that my child doesn’t become the child who robs another of their childhood innocence because they have said something racist.

MCOut · 13/12/2023 17:38

@IncompleteSenten what you’ve said so so interesting. I’ve noticed anecdotally that some of us who have formative experience in black majority countries may underestimate the childhood experience of racism and its impacts. I think this is particularly noticeable in people who come from middle class l backgrounds because we know what black achievement looks like, we’ve already formed at least a partial positive black identity and the UK is a developed country, so the immediate assumption (especially in times gone by) is that no matter what it will be better here. Your husband might have a completely different view, but I imagine if it’s somewhat similar to this than knowing your child is also mixed race might make race seem like less of a problem.

It’s also very interesting that your elder son identifies as black and not mixed race but also has said he hasn’t experienced any racism. I would have doubts but that might be true. It might be that what you have done as parents is managed to instil a very positive view of his black Kenyan heritage which is just as important. (Caveat, I am not saying that people who identify as a mixed race do not have a positive sense of their black identity or that it’s in anyway bad to identify as mixed race).

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/12/2023 17:37

As the white mum of a mixed race child, I'm frankly astonished and appalled that 40% of people think you're being unreasonable.

Surely this is just basic common sense that, as the parent of a child who may sadly experience racism, you should be equipped with a reasonable understanding of the issues so that you can support your child effectively and advocate for them appropriately?

Of course, there will be elements of your child's experience that you will never fully understand, and it's entirely possible that the child's other parent won't either. Being mixed has its own challenges as well as many positives. I have had to constantly educate myself as my dd has grown up and worked through her feelings about various aspects of her identity, and I have had to be really open to learning about her perspectives on race and ethnicity - even when they have been hard to hear! - rather than simply presuming that my own assumptions and perspectives are correct. I don't have her lived experience, but I can certainly try to understand it and to support her as well as I can. And I can also learn from others by reading more widely on the subject and listening to the experiences of people who know a lot more about this subject than I do.

I'm sorry if one or both of your parents disappointed you, OP. You deserved better.i don't doubt that I probably get things wrong myself sometimes, but I hope that dd will at least recognise that I have acknowledged the challenges and done my very best to educate myself about them in order to support her as well as I can.

TreadLight · 13/12/2023 17:11

Bature · 13/12/2023 15:10

I would really like more of the 40% who find ‘if you’re the white parent of a mixed race child in the U.K., you should educate yourself about race issues and racism’ to BU to explain why.

When I educate myself about something, go back to original sources, obtain contemporary data, consider the merits of both sides of an argument and talk about it with different people to get a wide range of view points. I often end up with a view diametrically opposed to the view held by the person who suggested I should "educate myself".

So if you have a view which you strongly hold, and think others should strongly hold it too, educate them. Put forward persuasive, compelling cases why your position is right. If you don't, if you leave it up to them, you could well end up with someone who makes the effort and finds out that it is unquestioningly you that is full of boloney.

IncompleteSenten · 13/12/2023 17:00

Yabberwocky · 13/12/2023 16:12

@IncompleteSenten It sounds to me like you’re pretty on the ball with all of this, tbh. Even the manner in which you’re expressing your doubts indicates the amount of thought you’ve put into it. They’re lucky to have you.

Thank you so much. That means a lot to me.

Reugny · 13/12/2023 17:00

@Sugarsun this:

(or that men have it more difficult than women)

depends on the area in society you are talking about.

MCOut · 13/12/2023 16:59

Carrotmouse · 13/12/2023 13:17

This isn’t true ime. Mixed people are usually treated as mixed, which might have its own issues.

My point was not that all people of colour are treated the same, or that there aren’t nuances which depend on ethnicity. Surely, if you are being treated as though you are mixed logically you are not being treated as though you are white? Or did you mean you feel there is a fluidity in the way that you are treated?

Sugarsun · 13/12/2023 16:56

I’m not sure why you’ve had such dickish responses on here.

Some posters get instantly triggered when someone mentions race and they try and deny there’s any such thing as racism.

I would expect any parent, especially white patents, to understand racism and how it affects their child and how their child is going to be negatively affected.

This could be direct racism, or more systemic and deep rooted like with many employers, landlords, police etc are going to subconsciously treat you differently than a white person.

I would also expect 2 dads or a single parent dad to understand the difficulties that a female may face throughout her life too.

And although there will be people who deny the sexes are often treated differently (or that men have it more difficult than women), they are wrong because of deep rooted subconscious bias/stereotypes that people have.

FrippEnos · 13/12/2023 16:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Except that Power+ prejudice= racism is a new concept.
Both black and white people (and others) can be racist.

Neitheronethingnortheother · 13/12/2023 16:31

Pinkyyogapanties · 13/12/2023 15:56

My mum ( white ) cut off my long hair when I ( mixed race ) was 7. I had a bob because she didn’t know to cope with my ‘crazy hair ‘.
after straightening my hair everyday for 16 years - I stopped a month ago . I feel so sad I was told I had unmanageable hair . I have beautiful curls ! That’s super random but I feel so sad looking back . I was so shamed of myself and my hair .

Same here. I had to have my hair very short as a child because my mum refused to deal with it, and then when I grew it longer as a teenager she refused to take me to a hairdresser to get it trimmed and wouldn't let me buy appropriate products for it. She insisted I used the same products she used for her very fine blonde straight hair.

It took me years as an adult to give myself permission to go to an appropriate hairdresser, to buy the right products, to deal with my hair correctly. Even now if I wear it curly I get negative comments from my family about how it looks every single time.

Yabberwocky · 13/12/2023 16:12

@IncompleteSenten It sounds to me like you’re pretty on the ball with all of this, tbh. Even the manner in which you’re expressing your doubts indicates the amount of thought you’ve put into it. They’re lucky to have you.

OP posts:
Yabberwocky · 13/12/2023 16:10

@Pinkyyogapanties I’m so sorry.

OP posts:
Pinkyyogapanties · 13/12/2023 15:58

i grew up in a very white area . My brother and I were the black kids in the town . I hated my mum for years for taking us to this town. I have so many issues from being bullied .

Pinkyyogapanties · 13/12/2023 15:56

My mum ( white ) cut off my long hair when I ( mixed race ) was 7. I had a bob because she didn’t know to cope with my ‘crazy hair ‘.
after straightening my hair everyday for 16 years - I stopped a month ago . I feel so sad I was told I had unmanageable hair . I have beautiful curls ! That’s super random but I feel so sad looking back . I was so shamed of myself and my hair .

Swipe left for the next trending thread