Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if you’re the white parent of a mixed race child in the U.K., you should educate yourself about race issues and racism?

237 replies

Yabberwocky · 12/12/2023 21:56

Just that, really. You should make an active and consistent effort to inform yourself, try to understand what your child might be dealing with, recognise microaggressions, that sort of thing.

I’ve been musing about my own childhood and upbringing. Wondered what people thought.

OP posts:
browneyes77 · 14/12/2023 06:14

Yabberwocky · 13/12/2023 22:56

I think they should try to understand what their child will be dealing with and support them to do so. The fact that you don’t seem to recognise that this is what you’ve deathbed your mother as doing is interesting.

I’m also really not seeing the need for the dismissive ‘deep dive into racism’ comment. But, okay.

My mother didn’t specifically go off and learn about what she should do to support me with any racism I may experience. She already knew how to support me as a mother and brought me up to be myself and love myself for who I am.

You suggested that the white parent should ‘educate themselves’.

My point is that some parents don’t need to educate themselves, because they already have common sense, awareness and understanding. They don’t need any further education. That is what I was referring to as a ‘deep dive’.

TheWOKEgiveMeTheBOAK · 14/12/2023 06:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Bature · 14/12/2023 06:02

UnwantedOpinionBelow · 13/12/2023 23:47

I am mixed raced and have experienced some racism from black and white people, however I would say rarely (under 5 times). To be honest, most people idolise me and my skin colour/race, which I find slightly odd. Definitely more compliments received for my race than negative.

I think parents of mixed raced people should take the stance of learning about both sides of their kid's heritage and teaching the kids mainly to be equally proud of their heritages and to love themselves.

The parents should read up on racism and race issues but I wouldn't force this topic too much on the kids, as it could create a chip on their shoulder when they may not have had one otherwise. For the parent it is more important to understand as it will allow the parent to deal with/identify a racist situation, should their kids experience one and they can then have that chat when it is required.

Teaching the kid to love themselves in all ways regardless of others opinions is the key to raising a mixed kid in my mind. My mum did this as I have never felt bad about my race!

To be honest, most people idolise me and my skin colour/race

What does this even mean? And what does being ‘complimented for your race’ mean?

For the parent it is more important to understand as it will allow the parent to deal with/identify a racist situation, should their kids experience one and they can then have that chat when it is required.

That’s literally what this post is about.

Alohapotato · 14/12/2023 05:55

My children are white but I do educate them about racism too and empathy.
I think everybody should learn about it.

Bature · 14/12/2023 05:50

slore · 14/12/2023 02:57

YABU. All people of all races need to understand that other races have different experiences of life to themselves. Nobody can automatically understand what it's like to be an ethnicity other than their own.

It is the responsibility of both parents to be sensitive to the needs of their mixed race child. Not just white parents. Assuming both are full members of their race, neither of them will have the experience of being mixed race either.

All people of all races need to understand that other races have different experiences of life to themselves. Nobody can automatically understand what it's like to be an ethnicity other than their own.

Yes, joy to the world and kumbaya. Not what’s being discussed here. Which is that if you have a child who is going to experience racism, you should learn about racism so you can support them.

It is the responsibility of both parents to be sensitive to the needs of their mixed race child. Not just white parents. Assuming both are full members of their race, neither of them will have the experience of being mixed race either.

The non-white parent will have firsthand experience of racism and being non-white in a white majority country. The white parent will not. You think it’s unreasonable to suggest that the white parent has some additional learning to do in this area?

DeeCeeCherry · 14/12/2023 03:08

Brave post OP.

Mostly you'll get the usual 'I ONLY experienced racism from Black people' aka White people aren't ever racist, just to cloud your point.

I have a good friend in similar position to you who is NC with his White adopted parents. Complicated situation but mainly he felt once he grew older and was no longer 'the cute curly haired child', they didn't even try to understand the racism he experienced and in fact implied if he came across as calm friendly polite smiley blah blah (to racists..!) it would help. They also completely ignored his heritage. Not the 1st time I've known of such things happening so I do get it.

I hope you can come to a peaceful resolution in your mind

slore · 14/12/2023 02:57

YABU. All people of all races need to understand that other races have different experiences of life to themselves. Nobody can automatically understand what it's like to be an ethnicity other than their own.

It is the responsibility of both parents to be sensitive to the needs of their mixed race child. Not just white parents. Assuming both are full members of their race, neither of them will have the experience of being mixed race either.

Reugny · 14/12/2023 00:48

@UnwantedOpinionBelow if you have a mixed race boy, in particular, you cannot just have a "chat" to them for example about the police after they have been stopped and searched.

Depending on their height, so perceived maturity, you need to make them aware from 9 onwards what they shouldn't wear and what rules of yours they need to obey.

Oh and I've had to explain racism to my DD clearly when she was 4 due to a couple of white women's behaviour towards her. Though we've had encounters since she was a baby with all sorts of people. Funnily enough if we go out with friends of certain ethnicities the crap doesn't happen as it seems other people presume they are her parents.

MCOut · 14/12/2023 00:22

@browneyes77 At first glance, your experience doesn’t seem to be far away from what OP is advocating for.

She never said that parents were required to sit their children down and tell them “Your life is going to be horrible because of racism”. Nor did she say that white parents, educating themselves requires going to seminars or reading lots of books. Education that comes from listening to her husband and his family or supporting him when he encountered racism is equally as valid. I imagine what OP is talking about, is having enough of an awareness to not dismiss your feelings when you encountered it, not perpetuate it herself and to participate in both your cultures with you. Some parents and partners ignore race or can participate in racist behaviour.

Bature · 13/12/2023 23:56

UnwantedOpinionBelow · 13/12/2023 23:31

@TinyRebel I am confused, in your post you said you know someone who is racist with a mixed child and then proceeded to state 'It’s appalling, but we can’t challenge it because she can’t possibly be racist as she has a black son!'

Was the child mixed raced or black?! You're pretty ignorant yourself if you are calling a mixed raced person black! Do you not know the difference?😅

I’m fairly certain she was quoting the person in question.

UnwantedOpinionBelow · 13/12/2023 23:47

I am mixed raced and have experienced some racism from black and white people, however I would say rarely (under 5 times). To be honest, most people idolise me and my skin colour/race, which I find slightly odd. Definitely more compliments received for my race than negative.

I think parents of mixed raced people should take the stance of learning about both sides of their kid's heritage and teaching the kids mainly to be equally proud of their heritages and to love themselves.

The parents should read up on racism and race issues but I wouldn't force this topic too much on the kids, as it could create a chip on their shoulder when they may not have had one otherwise. For the parent it is more important to understand as it will allow the parent to deal with/identify a racist situation, should their kids experience one and they can then have that chat when it is required.

Teaching the kid to love themselves in all ways regardless of others opinions is the key to raising a mixed kid in my mind. My mum did this as I have never felt bad about my race!

UnwantedOpinionBelow · 13/12/2023 23:31

@TinyRebel I am confused, in your post you said you know someone who is racist with a mixed child and then proceeded to state 'It’s appalling, but we can’t challenge it because she can’t possibly be racist as she has a black son!'

Was the child mixed raced or black?! You're pretty ignorant yourself if you are calling a mixed raced person black! Do you not know the difference?😅

Yabberwocky · 13/12/2023 22:56

browneyes77 · 13/12/2023 22:40

Perhaps read my post properly.

I am speaking about my personal experience only and why I felt my mother’s approach was the right one.

How other parents choose to approach it is up to them. The point is, it’s not a one size fits all and different approaches also work. Not every white parent has to do a deep dive into racism to support their child, as the OP suggests.

Edited

I think they should try to understand what their child will be dealing with and support them to do so. The fact that you don’t seem to recognise that this is what you’ve deathbed your mother as doing is interesting.

I’m also really not seeing the need for the dismissive ‘deep dive into racism’ comment. But, okay.

OP posts:
browneyes77 · 13/12/2023 22:40

Bature · 13/12/2023 22:17

That’s excellent for you. There are literally mixed race posters (multiple, not just one) on this thread whose white mothers chopped off their ‘wild’ hair because they couldn’t be bothered to learn to do it. Perhaps step outside your experience and recognise that a lot of mixed kids have had a bit of a shit time because their white parent didn’t make the necessary effort.

Perhaps read my post properly.

I am speaking about my personal experience only and why I felt my mother’s approach was the right one.

How other parents choose to approach it is up to them. The point is, it’s not a one size fits all and different approaches also work. Not every white parent has to do a deep dive into racism to support their child, as the OP suggests.

Bature · 13/12/2023 22:17

browneyes77 · 13/12/2023 21:48

I’m mixed race.

My white mom always focussed on pushing me to be myself, stand up for myself and not take any shit. And to understand that people who had any issue with my skin colour, were the ones with the problem and to call them out on it and cut people like that out of my life.

She didn’t need to educate herself further on racism. She knows what racism is. She is in an interracial marriage.

What she did instead, was made sure that I grew up a strong woman who didn’t tolerate any shit, racist or otherwise. She raised me to advocate for myself.

And as far as I’m concerned she did everything right and did a good job.

I’m close to both sides of my family. Understand the heritage of both sides of my family. And am proud of all of my heritage.

Edited

That’s excellent for you. There are literally mixed race posters (multiple, not just one) on this thread whose white mothers chopped off their ‘wild’ hair because they couldn’t be bothered to learn to do it. Perhaps step outside your experience and recognise that a lot of mixed kids have had a bit of a shit time because their white parent didn’t make the necessary effort.

browneyes77 · 13/12/2023 22:16

itsmyp4rty · 13/12/2023 13:25

I would teach them all the positives about their culture and to be proud of it and to feel secure in themselves no matter what others think or say - but to know who they can talk to if they have any problems or are unsure about anything.

For me I think teaching them that they will probably be effected by racism and that they are likely to face prejudice and discrimination because of who they are is just going to make them feel unsafe and like they are already on the back foot, already a victim.

I wouldn't do that to my disabled child despite him facing similar challenges so I wouldn't do it a mixed race child.

I couldn’t agree more.

This is precisely how my parents approached it.

muggart · 13/12/2023 22:05

IncompleteSenten · 13/12/2023 15:40

This is an issue I am very aware of and have spent time thinking about.

But what do you do if your spouse is the one who thinks skin colour is no big deal?

My husband is black. He's Kenyan. Moved to the UK in his 20s.

I have asked him about this more than once and he tells me it would be making an issue where there isn't one and we don't need to train our sons to see racism everywhere.

His words not mine.

Do I, as a white woman, have the right to correct my black husband on racism? To tell him how he sees things is wrong and he has to listen to me? Is that not problematic in itself? A white person telling a black person their lived experience is wrong?

We have two now adult sons. One considers himself mixed and the other considers himself black. I feel my role is to respect that, not to tell one of them he's wrong.

What do you do? I wish I knew.

This is similar to my situation except my DH is Asian and was born and raised in the UK. He has said that he doesn't think racism is a big issue in the UK, that it's never held him back and that he doesn't want our DD to be primed to see herself as a victim. He simply does not care about it as an issue at all and will roll his eyes if it comes up. He's also (affectionately) laughed at me for "white guilt". I can't exactly tell him that he's wrong and that is he oppressed, and that our DD will be oppressed too.

FIL experienced racism as a child in the UK and sees it differently. Ironically, FIL is the only person in the family who makes overtly racist comments (about Muslims and black people).

I have no idea what my DD's experiences will be as she grows up or what she'll make of it all. She seems to be 'white passing' so I doubt she'll experience racism the way other people in this thread have, but I worry she will feel disconnected from her asian heritage as the in laws live abroad, DH isn't teaching her Punjabi and we aren't practicing their religion.

browneyes77 · 13/12/2023 21:48

I’m mixed race.

My white mom always focussed on pushing me to be myself, stand up for myself and not take any shit. And to understand that people who had any issue with my skin colour, were the ones with the problem and to call them out on it and cut people like that out of my life.

She didn’t need to educate herself further on racism. She knows what racism is. She is in an interracial marriage.

What she did instead, was made sure that I grew up a strong woman who didn’t tolerate any shit, racist or otherwise. She raised me to advocate for myself.

And as far as I’m concerned she did everything right and did a good job.

I’m close to both sides of my family. Understand the heritage of both sides of my family. And am proud of all of my heritage.

MCOut · 13/12/2023 21:48

CampsieGlamper · 13/12/2023 20:40

It is invidious and prejudiced to imply that one race alone should be held responsible for tracking race awareness.
The op raises a good point that children of mixed relationships may suffer racism, xenophobia, hate and prejudice. It is the duty of both parents to make their children aware of the threats and dangers as well as what to be aware of, but also what to be around of from both cultures.
It is regrettable that some members of some groups enjoy feeling they are the ultimate victim - this teaches the wrong values and destroys trust, harmony and peaceful coexistence.

Racism, xenophobia and hate exist in the UK. It not unique to the UK, and from countless surveys and evidential investigations there are many many countries where it is far worse.

Yes, some people from some groups really do like feeling like they’re the ultimate victim. It’s regrettable that they can be so fragile they demand minorities stay silent and tolerate injustice so they can live happily with the fiction there is trust, harmony and peaceful coexistence.

Bature · 13/12/2023 20:51

CampsieGlamper · 13/12/2023 20:40

It is invidious and prejudiced to imply that one race alone should be held responsible for tracking race awareness.
The op raises a good point that children of mixed relationships may suffer racism, xenophobia, hate and prejudice. It is the duty of both parents to make their children aware of the threats and dangers as well as what to be aware of, but also what to be around of from both cultures.
It is regrettable that some members of some groups enjoy feeling they are the ultimate victim - this teaches the wrong values and destroys trust, harmony and peaceful coexistence.

Racism, xenophobia and hate exist in the UK. It not unique to the UK, and from countless surveys and evidential investigations there are many many countries where it is far worse.

It is invidious and prejudiced to imply that one race alone should be held responsible for tracking race awareness.

Nobody has said that they should. However, in the context being discussed, the non-white parent already knows about racism, generally first hand. The white parent may not.

Racism, xenophobia and hate exist in the UK. It not unique to the UK, and from countless surveys and evidential investigations there are many many countries where it is far worse.

So what? What’s your point? People experiencing it in the U.K. should count their blessings, as it could be worse?

Autumnalday · 13/12/2023 20:47

I'm mixed race and at school, non-white students were racist towards me. Every race should be educated on racism.

Alwaystired2023 · 13/12/2023 20:46

Yes I really do - and I think that there's some things that a white mum or dad will never be able to understand about their mixed race child's experiences and feelings

CampsieGlamper · 13/12/2023 20:40

It is invidious and prejudiced to imply that one race alone should be held responsible for tracking race awareness.
The op raises a good point that children of mixed relationships may suffer racism, xenophobia, hate and prejudice. It is the duty of both parents to make their children aware of the threats and dangers as well as what to be aware of, but also what to be around of from both cultures.
It is regrettable that some members of some groups enjoy feeling they are the ultimate victim - this teaches the wrong values and destroys trust, harmony and peaceful coexistence.

Racism, xenophobia and hate exist in the UK. It not unique to the UK, and from countless surveys and evidential investigations there are many many countries where it is far worse.

Girasoli · 13/12/2023 20:35

I've tried to talk to DS1 (7) about racism but we've been very fortunate and he's never experienced any that I or he have noticed so I think it's still very abstract for him - a bit like when I try to talk about sexism and he talks about how women couldn't be nurses in the Victorian times (they studied Florence Nightingale recently).

His class is very multicultural and ethnicity only tends to come up in nice ways like "what do you call your grandparents" or who went to what country over the holiday to visit relatives.

Pinkyyogapanties · 13/12/2023 20:26

Neitheronethingnortheother · 13/12/2023 16:31

Same here. I had to have my hair very short as a child because my mum refused to deal with it, and then when I grew it longer as a teenager she refused to take me to a hairdresser to get it trimmed and wouldn't let me buy appropriate products for it. She insisted I used the same products she used for her very fine blonde straight hair.

It took me years as an adult to give myself permission to go to an appropriate hairdresser, to buy the right products, to deal with my hair correctly. Even now if I wear it curly I get negative comments from my family about how it looks every single time.

I have so many similarities to your story.
I wasn’t allowed to go to the hairdresser- my grandma cut my !
’crazy hair ‘.
My brother laughs at my curls and asked me if I was trying to be ‘ a black sister ‘ and laughed!!!!
My husband has had to spend so many hours giving me the confidence to wear my hair curly ! Today I went to an interview with curls ! Absolutely huge for me . I’m month curly and I’m so happy. I’m now buying curly products and am discovering how to look after my curls at 34!

I wanted to say to you that you are beautiful and worthy and May your curls roam free ! Xxx thank you for sharing your experience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread