Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if you’re the white parent of a mixed race child in the U.K., you should educate yourself about race issues and racism?

237 replies

Yabberwocky · 12/12/2023 21:56

Just that, really. You should make an active and consistent effort to inform yourself, try to understand what your child might be dealing with, recognise microaggressions, that sort of thing.

I’ve been musing about my own childhood and upbringing. Wondered what people thought.

OP posts:
Yabberwocky · 14/12/2023 16:11

DojaPhat · 14/12/2023 16:03

I think generally mixed people (Black & white) with a Black mother fare quite differently to mixed people with a white mother.

I’d like to start a thread about this, actually. But I don’t think it would go down very well.

OP posts:
Yabberwocky · 14/12/2023 16:10

DojaPhat · 14/12/2023 16:03

I think generally mixed people (Black & white) with a Black mother fare quite differently to mixed people with a white mother.

God, yes. There’ll be outrage at this, but it is SO DIFFERENT! Growing up, the mixed kids with Black mums were always just so much more comfortable in their own skins. They knew about their mum’s culture, ate the food, listened to the music and some of them could speak the languages. The girls’ hair was always on point.

And, in my school/area at least, their parents were way more likely to be together and married.

I was EXTREMELY jealous. Still am. I’m sure you can tell. 🙃

OP posts:
DojaPhat · 14/12/2023 16:03

I think generally mixed people (Black & white) with a Black mother fare quite differently to mixed people with a white mother.

glossylipps · 14/12/2023 15:55

My white English partner (I'm black) took our 8 month old baby to a children's hospital recently for a checkup, he later told me that the Asian Indian doctor was super unfriendly and cold and was purposely seeing other families before my partner and baby even tho they had been waiting for ages,she even had the gall to ask 'are you the father' 'what is the relation to this baby' and words of that affect. I told him that she is lucky I wasn't there as she would end up hating me. And he was like 'yeah your right Indian doctors really don't like seeing white and black mixed children' - sadly this hasn't been our only experience with Asian people in particular- he is very aware of racism especially when it comes to me and the kids, he is more open minded then a lot of white men his age.

Yabberwocky · 14/12/2023 15:31

Angrycat2768 · 14/12/2023 15:20

As añ Asian parent of mixed race children, I feel like this also. Maybe it's different because my children don't look Indian and are often mistaken for Spanish/ South American children. They have experienced "stupidity" racism like people assuming that they and their friend who is mixed race Black and White were brothers because they were the only Brown kids in the class etc. But I don't want my children thinking they can't do something or that they will find something impossible to do because everyone is racist and looking put for microaggressions everywhere they look. And yes, the amount of times me or the kids have had to pull my Indian mother up on frankly racist behaviour or silly comments about Black people, Chinese people etc is ridiculous. She's lived in London for 50 years but only really has friends from her own community. I've never experienced that open racism from white adults, and I live in that Mumsnet racism hotspot " Not London".

Edited

But I don't want my children thinking they can't do something or that they will find something impossible to do because everyone is racist and looking put for microaggressions everywhere they look.

I genuinely don’t understand how anyone read the OP and thinks this is what I’m advocating.

OP posts:
IDidntFloatUpTheLaganInABubble · 14/12/2023 15:25

I am and I do and I have whole heartedly supported them in challenging when they have faced blatant racism or microaggressions.

Westfacing · 14/12/2023 15:23

With little kids it’s fine to give them a very short, practical (boyish) haircut until they are old enough to have a strong opinion (and can do most of the care themselves),

I don't think it's fine for a girl to be given a very short haircut just because a parent doesn't learn how to manage afro hair.

As for shaving a girl's hair... jeez.

Angrycat2768 · 14/12/2023 15:20

itsmyp4rty · 13/12/2023 13:25

I would teach them all the positives about their culture and to be proud of it and to feel secure in themselves no matter what others think or say - but to know who they can talk to if they have any problems or are unsure about anything.

For me I think teaching them that they will probably be effected by racism and that they are likely to face prejudice and discrimination because of who they are is just going to make them feel unsafe and like they are already on the back foot, already a victim.

I wouldn't do that to my disabled child despite him facing similar challenges so I wouldn't do it a mixed race child.

As añ Asian parent of mixed race children, I feel like this also. Maybe it's different because my children don't look Indian and are often mistaken for Spanish/ South American children. They have experienced "stupidity" racism like people assuming that they and their friend who is mixed race Black and White were brothers because they were the only Brown kids in the class etc. But I don't want my children thinking they can't do something or that they will find something impossible to do because everyone is racist and looking put for microaggressions everywhere they look. And yes, the amount of times me or the kids have had to pull my Indian mother up on frankly racist behaviour or silly comments about Black people, Chinese people etc is ridiculous. She's lived in London for 50 years but only really has friends from her own community. I've never experienced that open racism from white adults, and I live in that Mumsnet racism hotspot " Not London".

Bature · 14/12/2023 15:20

Carrotmouse · 14/12/2023 15:04

I don’t think anyone has a human right to ‘products’ and I think blocking a teenager from going to the hairdresser is extremely odd and possibly racist (ie not in the category of white mothers who just need a bit of education).

With little kids it’s fine to give them a very short, practical (boyish) haircut until they are old enough to have a strong opinion (and can do most of the care themselves), but I’d probably draw the line at a fully shaved head. This is what people did with girls in the 1970/80s.

In the examples given, a teenager was blocked, her hair was chopped off well after she was able to have a strong opinion and she’s still being made fun of by her family about her hair. But, according to you, this isn’t a big deal.

Bature · 14/12/2023 15:16

wjpa · 14/12/2023 14:56

Cutting the hair of a little kid is very different to not assisting a teenager to do what they want with their hair and using the appropriate products/hairdresser though, isn't it?

The same parent did both things. You then rocked up with ‘I’m uncomfortable with parents being judged’ and ‘I cut my kid’s hair, too’.

If you recognise that the situations are dissimilar, then you’ve answered your own questions.

Carrotmouse · 14/12/2023 15:04

I don’t think anyone has a human right to ‘products’ and I think blocking a teenager from going to the hairdresser is extremely odd and possibly racist (ie not in the category of white mothers who just need a bit of education).

With little kids it’s fine to give them a very short, practical (boyish) haircut until they are old enough to have a strong opinion (and can do most of the care themselves), but I’d probably draw the line at a fully shaved head. This is what people did with girls in the 1970/80s.

wjpa · 14/12/2023 14:56

Cutting the hair of a little kid is very different to not assisting a teenager to do what they want with their hair and using the appropriate products/hairdresser though, isn't it?

Yabberwocky · 14/12/2023 14:45

wjpa · 14/12/2023 14:24

That was my point - my dd's straight brown hair is the same as mine and does not present any particular difficulty/need special treatment. I still kept it short because I valued practicality - no clips, bands, not in eyes and not in food. Are mothers of kids with Afro hair not allowed to do similar to what I did to be practical?

If this is similar to what you’re doing to your daughter, then it’s not ‘allowed’ for either you or mothers of kids with afro hair. It’s awful and traumatic.

If it’s not similar, then stop trying to draw false parallels. It’s whataboutery and profoundly disrespectful to the women who have shared their experiences.

I had to have my hair very short as a child because my mum refused to deal with it, and then when I grew it longer as a teenager she refused to take me to a hairdresser to get it trimmed and wouldn't let me buy appropriate products for it. She insisted I used the same products she used for her very fine blonde straight hair.

It took me years as an adult to give myself permission to go to an appropriate hairdresser, to buy the right products, to deal with my hair correctly. Even now if I wear it curly I get negative comments from my family about how it looks every single time.

OP posts:
wjpa · 14/12/2023 14:24

Reugny · 14/12/2023 13:13

As a parent you will always be judged whether people including your own children think, in general, you are a good parent or not.

I doubt the posters stating their mothers' cutting their hair have straight brown hair. Afro and very curly hair acts differently from straight brown hair.

That was my point - my dd's straight brown hair is the same as mine and does not present any particular difficulty/need special treatment. I still kept it short because I valued practicality - no clips, bands, not in eyes and not in food. Are mothers of kids with Afro hair not allowed to do similar to what I did to be practical?

ThereSnowLimit · 14/12/2023 13:16

Reugny · 14/12/2023 00:48

@UnwantedOpinionBelow if you have a mixed race boy, in particular, you cannot just have a "chat" to them for example about the police after they have been stopped and searched.

Depending on their height, so perceived maturity, you need to make them aware from 9 onwards what they shouldn't wear and what rules of yours they need to obey.

Oh and I've had to explain racism to my DD clearly when she was 4 due to a couple of white women's behaviour towards her. Though we've had encounters since she was a baby with all sorts of people. Funnily enough if we go out with friends of certain ethnicities the crap doesn't happen as it seems other people presume they are her parents.

100% this.

My son has been 6’4 since he was 14. He is a teddy bear, but he has always looked mature for his age and we already know the adultification of black & mixed race children is real. My husband had ‘the police conversation’ with him in year 6, when he was getting ready to go to secondary school, and then again several times over the years. I joined in, but it was led by his Dad. I suppose if I was a single parent I would have had to have it on my own to prepare him.

On the ‘positive reactions’ to being mixed race noted by another poster above…by you often find that they also come from a place of dodgy ideas about race? My DD (now 15) does a massive eye roll at people who gush about her ‘exotic looks’ and want to touch her ‘gorgeous curls’. She gives a pass to old ladies, but otherwise she isn’t going to be happy and feel complimented by it. She actively avoids boys who ‘like light skin or mixed girls’.

Reugny · 14/12/2023 13:13

wjpa · 14/12/2023 13:00

I’m uncomfortable with parents being judged. Most are just doing their best.

my dd is white with straight brown hair. Nothing challenging about it. However, when she was little, I had it cut really short because I didn’t want it going in her eyes or her food and didn’t want to spend time with clips or bands or anything. Sometimes hair is just practicality, not a lack of education.

As a parent you will always be judged whether people including your own children think, in general, you are a good parent or not.

I doubt the posters stating their mothers' cutting their hair have straight brown hair. Afro and very curly hair acts differently from straight brown hair.

Yabberwocky · 14/12/2023 13:06

wjpa · 14/12/2023 13:00

I’m uncomfortable with parents being judged. Most are just doing their best.

my dd is white with straight brown hair. Nothing challenging about it. However, when she was little, I had it cut really short because I didn’t want it going in her eyes or her food and didn’t want to spend time with clips or bands or anything. Sometimes hair is just practicality, not a lack of education.

Not all parents do their best and some parents’ best simply wasn’t very good. Either in its entirety, or with regards to specific things. Their kids are entitled to recognise and address that.

OP posts:
Yabberwocky · 14/12/2023 13:02

AnonnyMouseDave · 14/12/2023 12:53

Is there an argument you are looking at this the wrong way?

If you are white is there not an argument that you should not get into a mixed-race relationship because you can NEVER fully empathize with or support your future child and you should be aware enough about race to know that.

To be clear - obviously I have no problem with mixed sex relationships, but I do think that it is absolutely 100% inevitable that a white parent will always be somewhat unable to fully support their mixed race child, but obviously many make an effort to learn and do a much better job than those who don't.

Is there an argument you are looking at this the wrong way?

What way is that?

If you are white is there not an argument that you should not get into a mixed-race relationship because you can NEVER fully empathize with or support your future child and you should be aware enough about race to know that.

Not being able to fully empathise doesn’t mean you are incapable of educating yourself about racism and racial issues, which is what I think should happen.

but obviously many make an effort to learn and do a much better job than those who don't.

Precisely. So what is it you’re disagreeing with?

OP posts:
wjpa · 14/12/2023 13:00

I’m uncomfortable with parents being judged. Most are just doing their best.

my dd is white with straight brown hair. Nothing challenging about it. However, when she was little, I had it cut really short because I didn’t want it going in her eyes or her food and didn’t want to spend time with clips or bands or anything. Sometimes hair is just practicality, not a lack of education.

Jennifer89 · 14/12/2023 12:59

As a mixed race child with a white parent I agree. My white mother has said doesn't see colour, whilst that sounds sweet it also doesn't really acknowledge racism. I felt awkward to turn to my mum about racism as a child and I shouldn't have felt like that.

Yabberwocky · 14/12/2023 12:57

Carrotmouse · 14/12/2023 12:39

I don’t think the hair thing is a big deal tbh. Plenty of mothers are bad at managing their kids hair and it’s common practice in Nigeria and other places for girls to have shaved heads. I don’t think you can criticise people for making their own choices about how to manage their own kids.

If a white female child had her hair shaved because her mum couldn’t be bothered to manage it, would you think it was a big deal?

And the people criticising are the people whose heads were shaved. I think they have every right to an opinion on their own childhoods and upbringing. Parents aren’t absolved from criticism of how they manage ‘their own kids’.

OP posts:
AnonnyMouseDave · 14/12/2023 12:53

Yabberwocky · 12/12/2023 21:56

Just that, really. You should make an active and consistent effort to inform yourself, try to understand what your child might be dealing with, recognise microaggressions, that sort of thing.

I’ve been musing about my own childhood and upbringing. Wondered what people thought.

Is there an argument you are looking at this the wrong way?

If you are white is there not an argument that you should not get into a mixed-race relationship because you can NEVER fully empathize with or support your future child and you should be aware enough about race to know that.

To be clear - obviously I have no problem with mixed sex relationships, but I do think that it is absolutely 100% inevitable that a white parent will always be somewhat unable to fully support their mixed race child, but obviously many make an effort to learn and do a much better job than those who don't.

Reugny · 14/12/2023 12:50

Carrotmouse · 14/12/2023 12:39

I don’t think the hair thing is a big deal tbh. Plenty of mothers are bad at managing their kids hair and it’s common practice in Nigeria and other places for girls to have shaved heads. I don’t think you can criticise people for making their own choices about how to manage their own kids.

In the UK it isn't and hasn't been common for little girls including those with afro hair to have shaved heads.

This is why the hair thing is a big deal in the UK.

It is also why the posters whose white mothers shaved their hair are upset.

It is also different when you are teen or older, and responsible for your own hair.

Carrotmouse · 14/12/2023 12:39

I don’t think the hair thing is a big deal tbh. Plenty of mothers are bad at managing their kids hair and it’s common practice in Nigeria and other places for girls to have shaved heads. I don’t think you can criticise people for making their own choices about how to manage their own kids.

Yabberwocky · 14/12/2023 08:22

browneyes77 · 14/12/2023 06:14

My mother didn’t specifically go off and learn about what she should do to support me with any racism I may experience. She already knew how to support me as a mother and brought me up to be myself and love myself for who I am.

You suggested that the white parent should ‘educate themselves’.

My point is that some parents don’t need to educate themselves, because they already have common sense, awareness and understanding. They don’t need any further education. That is what I was referring to as a ‘deep dive’.

My mother didn’t specifically go off and learn about what she should do to support me with any racism I may experience. She already knew how to support me as a mother and brought me up to be myself and love myself for who I am.

She learnt at some point, did she not? She wasn’t born with innate knowledge of racism and she didn’t learn through experiencing it. So, she did inform herself. Whether she learnt from observing things that happened to your father, speaking to your father or reading books, yes she did educate herself. Which is what I’m saying parents should do.

I find it very strange that you are arguing otherwise.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread