Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if you’re the white parent of a mixed race child in the U.K., you should educate yourself about race issues and racism?

237 replies

Yabberwocky · 12/12/2023 21:56

Just that, really. You should make an active and consistent effort to inform yourself, try to understand what your child might be dealing with, recognise microaggressions, that sort of thing.

I’ve been musing about my own childhood and upbringing. Wondered what people thought.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hubblebubble · 16/12/2023 09:42

Sorry, that was a ramble. But I wonder if PPs meant their mothers learnt from lived experience? As there wasn't the same access to information in previous generations.

Hubblebubble · 16/12/2023 09:30

I do think that theres knowing about something and then theres experiencing it. Before I had my DS I knew that racial microagressions were a thing, but they'd never happened to me. But if I'd never even heard the term, I'd have learnt what they were soon enough after having him. Now I get are you his mother? When out and about alone with my child, not in a group of women. And sometimes visible shock when I say yes, even though this is the 21st century and mixed race is the fastest growing ethnicity in the UK. Theres also a lot of wheres his father from, which gets right up my nose. Nobody would ask this if my kid was white, even though his father could easily be Russian, American or European and theres been black people in the UK since the Roman times. As it is, his dad isnt British and we met when we were both working abroad, but these are strangers asking and for all they know his dad could've been from Hull. Not to mention people complimenting him on his lovely light skin using those words (he would be equally gorgeous if he was as dark as his dad aaa).

Reugny · 16/12/2023 06:17

DojaPhat · 15/12/2023 22:48

The white parent of a mixed child should be aware of issues surrounding race specifically because like it or not they are actually in the most advantageous position to advocate for their child if and when racism rears its ugly head. I'd go so far as to say they're in a better position to advocate than the Black parent of a mixed race child.

In some cases but not all cases.

DojaPhat · 15/12/2023 22:48

The white parent of a mixed child should be aware of issues surrounding race specifically because like it or not they are actually in the most advantageous position to advocate for their child if and when racism rears its ugly head. I'd go so far as to say they're in a better position to advocate than the Black parent of a mixed race child.

Sayearlgrey · 15/12/2023 22:36

OP, this has been a helpful thread. Thanks for starting it.

I do my best to get things right for my DC but I'm always aware that me being both white and separated from their father for many years doesn't always put them in an advantageous position when it comes to seeking advice etc. I have found it interesting to hear the different perspectives raised.

Neitheronethingnortheother · 15/12/2023 20:53

In the same way that many of us may not have experienced the loss of parent. We don’t need to educate ourselves on that or experience it, to have an understanding of the emotions and feelings that would create for someone going through it.

Nevertheless parents of a child who has lost a parent might want to do a little research on how that impacts a child and the best way to support them. Like a parent of a disabled child might do some learning around that, or the parent of an adopted child is expected to do courses on issues that child might encounter before adopting.

I mean most parents go to antenatal classes at least so the concept of a parent having to learn something about parenting is hardly a new thing

Bature · 15/12/2023 20:48

browneyes77 · 15/12/2023 20:38

Nothing she wasn’t already aware of by the time she’d met him.

She didn’t live her life with her head in the sand.

You can witness things throughout life that all manner of people experience and be able to gain understanding from that.

You don’t need to specifically go out and make a conscious effort to educate yourself on something (as the OP suggested) to gain an understanding. Which is my point. That seems to constantly be missed 🙄

I’m actually done with this thread now to be honest.

Your mother knew so much about racism that there was nothing left to be learnt from her Black partner? She had learnt everything there was to know about it before she met him? That’s quite a feat.

It’s also interesting as your first comment on the thread specifically credited her knowledge to her having married interracially: She didn’t need to educate herself further on racism. She knows what racism is. She is in an interracial marriage.

You keep saying ‘go out’ or ‘go off’ and educate yourself. Nobody has said that. However they do it, whenever they do it. If they’ve done so naturally and consistently throughout their lives, then that’s great. This has been explained to you, quite comprehensively, more than once. You’re refusing to take it in, for reasons clear only to you.

You're free to be done. Nobody is asking you to keep coming back.

browneyes77 · 15/12/2023 20:38

Bature · 15/12/2023 20:25

So, your mother learnt nothing about racism from your father? Either directly or by observation?

Nothing she wasn’t already aware of by the time she’d met him.

She didn’t live her life with her head in the sand.

You can witness things throughout life that all manner of people experience and be able to gain understanding from that.

You don’t need to specifically go out and make a conscious effort to educate yourself on something (as the OP suggested) to gain an understanding. Which is my point. That seems to constantly be missed 🙄

I’m actually done with this thread now to be honest.

Bature · 15/12/2023 20:25

browneyes77 · 15/12/2023 20:17

She didn’t need to educate herself on it to understand how it affects people. It’s called emotional intelligence.

In the same way that many of us may not have experienced the loss of parent. We don’t need to educate ourselves on that or experience it, to have an understanding of the emotions and feelings that would create for someone going through it.

I find it strange that you’re arguing with me about MY mother who you don’t know and are therefore not in a position to determine how she has the understanding of racism that she has.

So, your mother learnt nothing about racism from your father? Either directly or by observation?

browneyes77 · 15/12/2023 20:17

Yabberwocky · 14/12/2023 08:22

My mother didn’t specifically go off and learn about what she should do to support me with any racism I may experience. She already knew how to support me as a mother and brought me up to be myself and love myself for who I am.

She learnt at some point, did she not? She wasn’t born with innate knowledge of racism and she didn’t learn through experiencing it. So, she did inform herself. Whether she learnt from observing things that happened to your father, speaking to your father or reading books, yes she did educate herself. Which is what I’m saying parents should do.

I find it very strange that you are arguing otherwise.

She didn’t need to educate herself on it to understand how it affects people. It’s called emotional intelligence.

In the same way that many of us may not have experienced the loss of parent. We don’t need to educate ourselves on that or experience it, to have an understanding of the emotions and feelings that would create for someone going through it.

I find it strange that you’re arguing with me about MY mother who you don’t know and are therefore not in a position to determine how she has the understanding of racism that she has.

MCOut · 15/12/2023 18:07

@ThereSnowLimit I think you have completely misunderstood what was said. When previous posters and myself suggested there are some conversations that should take place in a safe space it was not to suggest that white parents of mixed children shouldn’t comment on the topic. It wasn’t really a response to anything anyone else has said at all.

It’s more that we know when we have criticisms of our own communities there are certain elements who will co-op these in a wholly negative and unhelpful way to attack poc. Therefore, sometimes it’s better to limit these conversations to members of our communities and others who we know will have these discussions in good faith rather than leave ourselves open to that. An open forum doesn’t meet that requirement.

Reugny · 15/12/2023 16:44

ThereSnowLimit · 15/12/2023 16:28

I don’t think you really wanted to discuss this with white parents of mixed race children. You don’t appear to like the answers.

And please don’t make out I’m saying you’re being aggressive. I don’t hold with the old aggressive black woman trope and I would never use it or intimate it.

If you want to have a discussion for and among black and mixed race people only, you’re right - this ain’t the place to do it, and the thread title was probably a bit misleading.

The OP hasn't had issues with other clearly white posters on this thread who have mixed raced children.

So maybe it is how you engage with posters discussing an issue that is at fault.

Sushi4Dins · 15/12/2023 16:41

ThereSnowLimit · 15/12/2023 16:28

I don’t think you really wanted to discuss this with white parents of mixed race children. You don’t appear to like the answers.

And please don’t make out I’m saying you’re being aggressive. I don’t hold with the old aggressive black woman trope and I would never use it or intimate it.

If you want to have a discussion for and among black and mixed race people only, you’re right - this ain’t the place to do it, and the thread title was probably a bit misleading.

You cannot be serious. What answers? You didn’t answer a single one of her questions. She responded to what you were saying in good faith, you didn’t like her answers and refused to actually engage with what she was saying, then accused her of spoiling for a fight (so, yes, you essentially called her aggressive) with absolutely no basis.

You clearly aren’t able to have a conversation where you don’t like what’s being said. Where is your self awareness?

ThereSnowLimit · 15/12/2023 16:28

I don’t think you really wanted to discuss this with white parents of mixed race children. You don’t appear to like the answers.

And please don’t make out I’m saying you’re being aggressive. I don’t hold with the old aggressive black woman trope and I would never use it or intimate it.

If you want to have a discussion for and among black and mixed race people only, you’re right - this ain’t the place to do it, and the thread title was probably a bit misleading.

DeeCeeCherry · 14/12/2023 23:06

Bature

ThereSnowLimit
I think there may be something about black women perceiving children of black mothers/white fathers as ‘better off’. Black men might view it differently. I don’t know. I’m not trying to be controversial, I just wonder if there is something there

Are you including mixed race women in ‘Black women’?
@Bature I wondered this

BW/WM pairings are better off financially than WW/BM. It’s not perception, they literally have more money. Possibly because white men statistically earn more than Black men. They also have higher levels of educational attainment, their kids have better outcomes and their relationships are more likely to last. The only interracial pairing with better overall outcomes is white men and Asian women. There’s a study that I’ll try to find and link for you. It’s paywalled, but you’ll get the gist

True. BW/WM relationships tend to be far more stable. Normally both partners are working smart, and raise their family well

Black men, in general (this doesn’t apply to everyone, obviously) don’t like ‘their women’ to ‘date out’. They think it’s fine when they do it, but object when BW date or marry non Black men. Also, BW are the most ‘race loyal’ demographic and tend to only want to date BM

Exactly. DB's partner is White, 3 mixed race DCs & he is adamant he does not want his daughter dating White men. His sons can date as they please. Most Black men I know with White partners feel similar; although mostly they don't tell their partner this, they find a Black Woman be she sister, other female relative, friend, work colleague etc and try to bend our ears about it then are annoyed we aren't interested. I mean, what am I supposed to say? None of my business and I don't care. Nor do swathes of us, despite what group think seems to be, over-concern ourselves with who Black men who aren't our partners, are dating. We get a lot of flak via skewered perceptions.

Upon reflection, I’m not sure if this is a conversation I should be having on MN

Agree, I wouldnt go into it in any deep way here.

Reugny · 14/12/2023 22:15

glossylipps · 14/12/2023 15:55

My white English partner (I'm black) took our 8 month old baby to a children's hospital recently for a checkup, he later told me that the Asian Indian doctor was super unfriendly and cold and was purposely seeing other families before my partner and baby even tho they had been waiting for ages,she even had the gall to ask 'are you the father' 'what is the relation to this baby' and words of that affect. I told him that she is lucky I wasn't there as she would end up hating me. And he was like 'yeah your right Indian doctors really don't like seeing white and black mixed children' - sadly this hasn't been our only experience with Asian people in particular- he is very aware of racism especially when it comes to me and the kids, he is more open minded then a lot of white men his age.

Every father I know who has taken their kids under 5 to medical appointments alone in the last few years gets shit.

However the ones with mixed raced kids get more shit.

My own DP has been asked like the other dads I know if he has permission to take our DD to our DD to the appointment/hospital and why can't mum take the kid, when they are the ones who are looking after their child or even children on their own at that time.

In addition my DP has been repeatedly by different medical staff who he is in connection to our DD and then them making up our DD's ethnicity. My DP knows this this part isn't normal. Incidentally the medical staff weren't all Asian.

I've had shit over my DD and so has one of our black relatives who takes her out on trips, but not in medical settings.

Ketzele · 14/12/2023 21:54

I agree, OP, and would add that it's a very challenging thing to do well. Even if, like me, you live in London and already have lots of mixed race family.

I completely understand how difficult your childhood must have been. My grandmother had eight mixed race children in the 50s, and moved them out of London. They were the only POC at their school, in the village, but it definitely felt like a taboo subject at home. I've still never heard them talk about it, though the grandchildren are more forthright.

Britneyfan · 14/12/2023 21:29

I’m a white mother of a mixed race child in the U.K. and I do agree we need to educate ourselves about race issues.

I will say that the general thinking about race issues in terms of what was the anti racist “ideal” was very different in the 80s, even the 90s when color-blindness was really promoted as the height of being anti-racist. And so I can see how OP may have had a mother who didn’t recognise the importance of micro-aggressions etc.

I now feel that in retrospect, this pervasive view at the time was problematic, and I have been on a long anti-racist journey from the days where I would listen to Michale Jackson’s Black or White and En Vogue’s Free Your Mind as a teenager.

Along the way I have had to accept that I still had to learn and grow in this area myself, I remember for example an argument with my ex over the existence of the BET channel and MOBO awards, with my initially feeling that they were inherently racist against white people, but I do now understand and recognise that they carved out a place for talented black artists precisely because they were being overlooked elsewhere, and you can’t just cut out the historical context of oppressor and oppressed when thinking about these things.

DojaPhat · 14/12/2023 21:10

@MCOut 100%!! r.e. my comment on the range to speak about this issue was exactly referring to that! I have a lot of criticisms and views about this, especially the different ways in which mixed children develop the lens with which they view society and their position within it as adults.

MCOut · 14/12/2023 21:06

JamSandle · 14/12/2023 18:53

What about if you're Indian with a child of half Black parentage or another race?

Tbh the few people of this mix that I know are fully integrated into both their cultures and didn’t seem (caveat they might just not have spoken about it) to have these problems with their parents.

MCOut · 14/12/2023 20:55

@ThereSnowLimit When that phrase was used I was talking about financially. In my experience, there’s less couples this way round but most tend to be quite well off and it’s not usually just the man.

@DojaPhat now you’ve said it and I’ve thought about it, I do agree. That’s more a conversation for black and mixed people to have in black and mixed race spaces. I do have some criticism but it’s nuanced and inevitably it will get taken out of context and be used to attack us.

Bature · 14/12/2023 20:54

ThereSnowLimit · 14/12/2023 20:43

What question? I feel like you’re itching for a fight rather than open to discussion, so I’m out.

I asked, perfectly reasonably, what other measures of ‘doing better’ there might be. That’s me ‘itching for a fight’?

So, basically, you don’t have a response to my question and you reckon the way to get round that is to claim you’re being aggressed. Okay, then.

ThereSnowLimit · 14/12/2023 20:43

What question? I feel like you’re itching for a fight rather than open to discussion, so I’m out.

Bature · 14/12/2023 20:11

ThereSnowLimit · 14/12/2023 19:51

I think ‘measuring ‘emotional’ outcomes is a grey area.

Not really. People state their emotional state and it’s possible to track factors like mental health.

You haven’t answered my question.

PricklePop · 14/12/2023 20:08

Mostly you'll get the usual 'I ONLY experienced racism from Black people' aka White people aren't ever racist, just to cloud your point.

This has been my experience. It doesn't mean who're people are never racist.