Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Had enough with excuses for bad behaviour

64 replies

Ribenaberry12 · 12/12/2023 19:50

I work in a secondary school and have done for a long time (20 odd years). I currently work in a pastoral support role and part of my job is contacting parents to let them know when their child has been placed in detention/isolation. I reckon that, in the last term, 9/10 parents have argued with me and/or tried to excuse their child’s behaviour. Even when the situation is 100% clear cut - think caught vaping or heard swearing. I’m getting sick of it and thinking about jacking it in.

I’m a patient person, I’m good at my job and my school is really good - we have lots of support strategies that we offer but I’m just sick of the lack of accountability from parents. Honestly, some of the excuses I’ve been given are unbelievable.

I used to phone parents and they’d apologise for their kid’s behaviour and we’d work together to support them and we’d make sure it didn’t happen again. The bond you’d get with kids and their families when the kids turned it around was fantastic and it was great to see their successes. Now I cannot remember the last time a parent admitted that their kid was in the wrong and didn’t argue the toss - sometimes aggressively, sometimes pinging off countless emails at all hours of the day and night. Sometimes personally attacking staff who have pulled their kids up. It’s so time consuming and draining. I see the teachers and SLT so drained by it too. It’s never been this bad.

AIBU?
YABU - it’s your job, suck it up
YANBU - there’s a lack of accountability and it sucks

OP posts:
Violinist64 · 12/12/2023 22:46

NightmareGirl · 12/12/2023 22:20

Swearing isn’t a good way for someone to talk but detention is harsh. They just need to be told not to talk like that. It’s not deliberate misbehaviour. It’s someone’s speech being shaped by their peers.

Edited

For goodness’ sake. Of course they know better. “Someone’s speech being shaped by their peers” indeed. It is usually deliberate - they know exactly what they are saying and doing. If a four or five year old comes out with an unfortunate word that they have overheard or come from a background where swearing is a normal form of communication, you might then say “that’s not a nice word and I don’t want to hear it again.” By the time they reach secondary school, they know exactly what they are saying and l suspect that many children that age know more swear words than l do (l never swear). When children of this age use bad language, they are deliberately misbehaving and a detention is an appropriate punishment. When l was at school, a boy used the word b…dy at a teacher, so not one of the worst words but still unacceptable. The punishment he received was the cane. We do not cane children these days and I am not going to argue for or against it but he certainly never did it again and it acted as a deterrent to others. Swearing is horrible and should be punished. A detention can make the pupil reflect on why they are there and what they have done.

Ronaldoronalda · 12/12/2023 22:37

I have been shocked by some of the behaviour my daughter reports and I think it must be very hard to navigate as staff.

However schools are not always right. My daughter has never so much as had a negative point on her app in all her years at high school but a couple of years ago, out of the blue, I was phoned by her head of year to say that she had assaulted another child. I was surprised but supportive of the school taking action.

When I went to pick her up I was cross with her. Then I saw she was sobbing and had several obvious marks on her skin.

The year head had reported the incident the wrong way around to the parents. I still feel awful for how I simply accepted what the school had said without challenge and that when my daughter needed my love and support the most, I was cross with her.

We never heard from the school again other than in the form of a somewhat surly email to say that after investigation they had decided not to take any action as regarded her on the matter. I can only hope what they meant was ‘sorry‘.

NightmareGirl · 12/12/2023 22:20

Swearing isn’t a good way for someone to talk but detention is harsh. They just need to be told not to talk like that. It’s not deliberate misbehaviour. It’s someone’s speech being shaped by their peers.

TheWalkingDeadly · 12/12/2023 22:20

Lol Titus! All i wrote and you take it im the problem, despite it being school making the errors?

Overall i think the better behaved kids are paying the price for larger schools and classes, more sen students etc. But it impacts the sen kids even more.

There is also a lot more control of what subjects kids have to take at gcse.

TrixieFatell · 12/12/2023 22:17

Overall I don't think yabu, I know plenty of parents who don't understand why their little darlings are always in trouble and think it's because the teachers are picking on them (and then I hear from my child the real story).

However the school has gone ridiculously draconian this year with isolations being handed out for asking a question too many about the work, putting head on arms etc. if they get punished for such trivial things I can see why parents get annoyed.

I also had to argue one because my daughter was given a detention for not doing homework that was due in a week later. She was devastated as she's never been in trouble before but her homework log clearly stated a different date from the one the teacher was saying. She didn't do the detention but it took ages to get it off her record.

I have also argued about primary school child missing break because other people in their class wouldn't stop talking. I hate collective punishment, it's lazy.

I am that parent 🤣🤣

Nanny0gg · 12/12/2023 22:13

Cicciabella · 12/12/2023 22:03

Yesi agree, I work in a secondary its horrendous, a day doesn't pass without assaults or verbal abuse. The parents are just as bad, we've banned several as they verbally abuse staff.

How about when other children are victims of the above and the school don't protect them and the other kid has no consequences at all?

Coyoacan · 12/12/2023 22:04

Fionaville · 12/12/2023 21:16

I think some high schools have taken it too far with the uniform policy, putting kids into isolation for minor infringements and not letting them go to the toilet etc. Some of the reasons for being put into isolation are ridiculous and I just dont agree with it as a punishment for anything but the worst behaviours. So I think from that point of view, relations between parents and staff are at an all time low.
I know my school never had to contact my parents over anything, because these harsh rules weren't in place when I was at school. So if they had received a call about me, it would have been taken seriously.

I think I am older than you but I was always in trouble at school but it was not the culture in those days to call parents about punishments. I think my mother was only called in when they were thinking of expelling me

Cicciabella · 12/12/2023 22:03

Yesi agree, I work in a secondary its horrendous, a day doesn't pass without assaults or verbal abuse. The parents are just as bad, we've banned several as they verbally abuse staff.

MumofSpud · 12/12/2023 22:02

I got told today by a Year 9 that it was MY fault he was in detention
Ummm no !
No personal responsibility anymore.

Bluevelvetsofa · 12/12/2023 21:54

I retired some years ago, but it was certainly going that way then.

Parents who would defend their child, despite not knowing the circumstances and being unaware 99% of the time, what their child was doing.

Being sworn at, kicked, wrestled to the crowd, ignored, shouted and screamed at, are all par for the course and it’s exhausting as well as unfair. I really think it will get to the point of collapse.

IHS · 12/12/2023 21:52

I think people lack any humility now and simply can't admit when they or their children are in the wrong. They can't admit it and just apologise. Is this because society is more unforgiving now? The people that I know that can't admit they're in the wrong have a tendancy towards being very self absorbed and thinking too highly of themselves.

A lot of parents believe that their children won't love them anymore if they discipline them. They prefer to be their friends rather than their parents.

GreyhpundGirl · 12/12/2023 21:46

MPY24 · 12/12/2023 21:36

I thought the op was mainly talking about the parents though not the kids. Covid may or may not have affected kids behaviours. But the point here is that the parents are arguing why things aren't the kids faults etc rather than why the kids are behaving like they are.

I think there's been a disaffection with schools/ education as a result of covid— you only had to look at social media to see what people thought of us, lazy teachers and the useless education system.

Vuurhoutjies · 12/12/2023 21:41

I really hate these threads that are all about how awful children are today etc etc... but I have to admit, I think the issues with discipline at school are a bit odd. I have a few friends who I consider to be broadly similar in parenting style to me, but who are weirdly twitchy if their child gets a detention or similar at school.

But I agree with a PP that the kids whose parents respond this way, probably have bigger problems at home. DS got into a situation at the beginning of year 7. The teacher implied that my response - which was to accept the school's judgement etc, was unusual. I know one of the other parents and she's a woman who has behaved so crazily in the past she had a reputation at our primary school (I won't go into details as it would actually be outing her behaviour was SOOOO batshit). Her child started the issue in this case - fully confirmed by the school following its investigation, and DS' punishment was significantly less as a result - but I am 100% certain she is one of the parents OP is talking about and a friend overheard her bitching about my DS on the school run which just made me laugh.

MPY24 · 12/12/2023 21:36

GreyhpundGirl · 12/12/2023 20:38

I have worked as a secondary school teacher for 20+ years. Covid has had an enormous impact, especially on the younger ones. Colleagues who work in different places say the same.

Edited

I thought the op was mainly talking about the parents though not the kids. Covid may or may not have affected kids behaviours. But the point here is that the parents are arguing why things aren't the kids faults etc rather than why the kids are behaving like they are.

Flufferblub · 12/12/2023 21:35

I must say, I don't remember the school ever calling my parents. But then, I was absolutely terrified of teachers, and would never talk back to them.

When the schools call me about my dc's behaviour, I always support the school and try to work with them to turn things around. I know that my dc's are no angels. Things have been a bit better lately behaviour wise touch wood, but I'm currently trying to kick my 15 year old up the arse to study for his GCSEs.

If they play up at school, get into fights, swear at the teachers, then yes they're going to have to face the consequences. I remember my ds crying to his dad (we're separated) because he'd been sent out for swearing at a teacher. His dad was going to go to the school and tell them they were out of order... He never went. I went to a meeting with the school and told them I supported them 100%, and it was absolutely unacceptable behaviour from my ds.

I tell the schools that I am happy to be contacted if anything goes on. I won't have it, it's completely unacceptable, and they can't go through life like that. They need to learn to solve their problems in appropriate ways, to be held responsible and accountable for their actions and self control. They need to face their consequences and make amends for the wrong they have done. They can't go through life swearing at people, being violent and disrespectful.

Kids will try to come out with all excuses. Everyone else was doing it.... Someone talked to me so I talked back....They made me angry ... Blah blah blah. It's always someone else's fault. I have to bring them back on track and say We're talking about you and your behaviour here. The rules still apply to you, even if (insert lame excuse here)...

I make mine say or write down I was wrong. Not even an apology. I'm sorry. Who cares? You don't mean it. You need to write it down I was wrong. Next time I will do this instead. Writing it down gives them a sense of completion.

BCBird · 12/12/2023 21:32

I bee teachin nearly 30 years in a secondary school. I hear you op.

TitusMoan · 12/12/2023 21:27

TheWalkingDeadly · 12/12/2023 21:07

Completely dosagree with violinist64. You can impact a child somewhat, but they are their own person. Some will intentionally do stuff no matter how strict you are or how much you explain. Or sometimes they just dont realise.

Also in terms of schools having parents arguing, sometimes it will be because schools have things wrong (which seems to happen a lot more than when I was at school). Plus detentions are dished out much more easily.
Dc1 y7 one teacher has dc confused with another. Then another member of staff has also confused them. Luckily its not punishment, but dc has missed out on at least 2 'positives'. Then also dc moved classes and so was behind (which teacher would have known..) Got told off and told may have to move back -- when it was all due to a school error. Dc didnt seem to know when subject test would be and it wasnt shown on online system. And has set homework for a day they dont see the teacher.

I dont agree with isolation except for say swearing at teacher or violence etc. As the kid will just get behind and increase distruption.

Dc class are getting a lot of being sent to behaviour support and it seems to be escalating. The process doesnt seem to be being followed.

But i think setting for more subjects would have helped as there are kids getting 0% in with those getting 100%.

You’re part of the problem, then.

jimbort · 12/12/2023 21:27

My son was recently suspended for 2 days for vaping cannabis and I was totally apologetic to the school. They just wanted to support him. I was happy for them to report him to the police as he needs to answer for his own actions. The parents of the other boy were happy to sweep it under the carpet and I was very shocked. Like if he never takes responsibility and is honest then he will be a monstrous adult. YANBU at all. I don't understand what goes through some parents heads.

Fionaville · 12/12/2023 21:16

I think some high schools have taken it too far with the uniform policy, putting kids into isolation for minor infringements and not letting them go to the toilet etc. Some of the reasons for being put into isolation are ridiculous and I just dont agree with it as a punishment for anything but the worst behaviours. So I think from that point of view, relations between parents and staff are at an all time low.
I know my school never had to contact my parents over anything, because these harsh rules weren't in place when I was at school. So if they had received a call about me, it would have been taken seriously.

TheWalkingDeadly · 12/12/2023 21:07

Completely dosagree with violinist64. You can impact a child somewhat, but they are their own person. Some will intentionally do stuff no matter how strict you are or how much you explain. Or sometimes they just dont realise.

Also in terms of schools having parents arguing, sometimes it will be because schools have things wrong (which seems to happen a lot more than when I was at school). Plus detentions are dished out much more easily.
Dc1 y7 one teacher has dc confused with another. Then another member of staff has also confused them. Luckily its not punishment, but dc has missed out on at least 2 'positives'. Then also dc moved classes and so was behind (which teacher would have known..) Got told off and told may have to move back -- when it was all due to a school error. Dc didnt seem to know when subject test would be and it wasnt shown on online system. And has set homework for a day they dont see the teacher.

I dont agree with isolation except for say swearing at teacher or violence etc. As the kid will just get behind and increase distruption.

Dc class are getting a lot of being sent to behaviour support and it seems to be escalating. The process doesnt seem to be being followed.

But i think setting for more subjects would have helped as there are kids getting 0% in with those getting 100%.

TomatoSandwiches · 12/12/2023 20:45

YANBU

I've told mine before they start secondary that any detentions dolled out will not be contested by myself or their father but if they have a genuine issue with something we would support them dealing with it maturely.
DS got a few in Yr 8 for talking in class, he tried to blame another boy who started it first but we weren't having that and made him take responsibility for choosing to take part and talk back.

You know which ones are going to have parents like this though from the start, they all seem to have an issue understanding the uniform code ( that they agreed to upon accepting the school place! ) on the parents group, they take no personal accountability and think the rules shouldn't apply to their children.

bellac11 · 12/12/2023 20:45

ghostyslovesheets · 12/12/2023 19:59

I hear you - but maybe those kids behave that way because they go home to parents who don't give a shit, don't set boundaries, don't care - often kids act up with people and in places they feel safe

I think thats the point of the OP isnt it, that there are no boundaries because the parents are crap and make excuses and dont parent, so its pretty much a given the child doesnt have good parenting at home

It can sometimes be the case that children act out more with people they feel safe with but thats not usually the relationship with teachers, its more likely to be that way if the child comes into care. Sometimes children act the way they do because they are modelling behavour they see around them at home, its all they know, theres no 'acting out' in fact, its just how the whole family behave and interact with the world and they will repeat this with their own children

Not all bad behaviour is 'communication' as is said so often on here, sometimes its just bad behaviour because they can.

GreyhpundGirl · 12/12/2023 20:38

BingoWings85 · 12/12/2023 20:10

What do you think has caused the change?

I have worked as a secondary school teacher for 20+ years. Covid has had an enormous impact, especially on the younger ones. Colleagues who work in different places say the same.

Violinist64 · 12/12/2023 20:36

*respect not respect’s.

Violinist64 · 12/12/2023 20:34

There are several threads on here that confirm exactly what you are saying. The one that immediately springs to mind is the one where a year seven boy was disrupting a school play and given a day in isolation as his punishment. His mother felt it was too harsh as he had only been a bit silly and, furthermore, had been egged on by another boy. Most posters, including me, pointed out that her precious son had behaved very badly indeed and deserved his punishment and, if she worked with the school rather than against it, it would help him to take responsibility for his own actions and grow up. However, a few posters had some very “interesting” views. The most eye watering was the one who said that children and adults were equals, that teachers needed to earn their respect's and all that was needed was an apology! Another stated that we needed the free thinkers who didn’t obey the rules because they were our future artists and musicians. I have been a musician all my life and can assure this lady that conformity is very much part of the musical education and much self-discipline, hard work and acceptance of criticism is required. Then special needs are trotted out. I have two adult children at different ends of the autism spectrum. We made sure that they knew how to behave (although my daughter instinctively knew in any case). It is hard work. I realise ADHD can be be particularly difficult, but it means that parents have to work extra hard to make sure they behave appropriately. Of course there is a need for understanding but special needs cannot be an excuse for bad behaviour. When my children were teenagers, I was often told that I was “lucky” to have three well-behaved youngsters. There was no luck involved - they knew how to behave because we had put in the very hard work of parenting them. Unfortunately, many parents these days seem to abdicate their responsibility in this respect. You have my sympathies.