Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you would choose money or happiness (career wise) ?

81 replies

felttippenguin · 12/12/2023 15:46

I'm at a bit of a cross roads career wise. I currently work in finance while I'm finishing up my degree. My field is charity sector and it's not well paid for how highly educated you have to be, jobs are also somewhat scarce so volunteering etc is expected to gain experience/make connections.

My finance job was a pay the bills jobs up until now. But I've reached a point where I could easily progress within the company and make a career out of it.

My earning potential in finance is higher but I do find it boring. I find the work in my field of education incredibly fulfilling.

I'm trying to think about my life in ten years. Will I regret choosing to work in a job that pays well and funds a good lifestyle but bores me to tears? Or would I regret having less money but an enjoyable job!

I know it's totally individual but I'm not the only one to make this choice and I'd love to hear what people think is more important? Money or happiness?

OP posts:
LumiB · 12/12/2023 20:54

Money! I spend more of my time outside work and want money to fund it so ill put up with 'boring work'. End of the day i work to live so long as I am not miserable i don't care.

NalafromtheLionKing · 12/12/2023 20:53

Go for the money then try to wiggle yourself into a cushy number there once more senior (has worked pretty well for me).

felttippenguin · 12/12/2023 20:51

@user628468523532453 oh I'm definitely not under any illusions that working in my "dream job" would mean I wake up everyday and skip to work!

A pretty key aspect of the job I want in the charity sector (without being too specific) is working with children and families, and connecting them to someone I'm passionate about. I wouldn't be able to get that in any capacity really in finance or banking.

Unfortunately a lot of jobs working with kids are quite low paid which is sad really.

OP posts:
LilyLemonade · 12/12/2023 18:36

Go for happiness at work - it’s where you spend a huge amount of your life.

You can always pivot later into a better paying career, or keep an eye out for opportunities to combine the two. But first give the thing you love your best shot.

Money does matter - it gives you freedom - but it’s important to live in tune with your values, and be able to look back and feel that your long hours at work were invested in things that matter to you.

I also think it’s important to have work that aligns with your identity. When people ask what you do, would you feel that it reflects who you truly are to say ‘I’m a finance specialist’ or would you feel prouder / more yourself if saying ‘I work in [x] charity sector’. You want to feel that you belong in your profession.

user628468523532453 · 12/12/2023 18:28

Undisclosedlocation · 12/12/2023 18:23

If you do a job long enough, even the most fulfilling of jobs will eventually get boring (or at least lose its shine)
I’d always take the lucrative career and fill in the fulfilment void with something meaningful in my spare time. Volunteering in the ‘dream sector’ perhaps?

I was just thinking this.

It's a bit naive to believe that a job that's enjoyable / fulfilling at early career stage when it's all shiny and new will still feel the same ten years later once you've been burnt by the realities of stretched budgets / politics / regulator pressures and being under financial pressure yourself.

Conversely the finance job may become less boring over ten years as you progress and do more varied/challenging work.

Snowpake · 12/12/2023 18:27

Op I’m in an arts based profession, where the earning capacity is low and a lot of people who work in the field have another source of income (inheritance etc).

i love it, but it gets tiring - not so much the low pay, as being surrounded by people who don’t understand what it means to actually live off the salary. IMO the low salaries attract people who can afford to work for less, which in turn means the salaries can remain low because people don’t need to argue for more.

As a result I have become an advocate for better pay and conditions. I’m quite proud of the changes I’ve been able to make for other people. I am amongst the highest earners in my field, and i still have another 20 years to go in my career so I anticipate this rising further - I will just have to make the case.

I have often considered doing a money job and even got quite far down another route - training for a finance role. Problem is, I hated it. I was bored rigid. It made me realise that I love my job, it gives me purpose and meaning. Not everyone feels the same (god knows life would be easier if I didn’t) but if that’s the way you’re wired then money just won’t be enough.

So I’m proposing a third route: forge a new path in the sector you love. You won’t be the only person who wants better pay and conditions

Undisclosedlocation · 12/12/2023 18:23

If you do a job long enough, even the most fulfilling of jobs will eventually get boring (or at least lose its shine)
I’d always take the lucrative career and fill in the fulfilment void with something meaningful in my spare time. Volunteering in the ‘dream sector’ perhaps?

fpqand · 12/12/2023 18:18

I think it's usually not as black and white as that and there is usually a compromise you can make. Ultimately, money affords you the lifestyle you want outside of work which for me is travel, stability, nice home etc so I would never be happy earning a pittance no matter how much I loved my job. Equally, there is no point spending hours and hours a week in a role you despise if you spend all your free time dreading getting back to work. For me the answer was a side step into a slightly more lucrative area of my skillset which bumped up my salary and progression significantly, but my compromise is I am remaining in the public sector due to the interest of the context and the flexibility, I could take my skillset into the financial sector and earn a heck of a lot more but likely at a cost that is not worth it to me, right now at least.

So I would review your skills, potential etc and see if you actually have a middle road option.

user628468523532453 · 12/12/2023 18:17

felttippenguin · 12/12/2023 16:47

No you're right it doesn't have to be a binary choice. I don't really know what else I'd want to do that would be both fulfilling and reasonably well paid though

Your personal life should be fulfilling.

Your work life should fund your fulfilling personal life.

Trying to meet all your needs from a job is a recipe for misery. You will always be disposable to your employer, which means your fulfilment can be vaporised with a redundancy or dismissal.

Trisolaris · 12/12/2023 18:14

Money unless I hated my job or it stressed my unduly.

Money will pay for me to do the things I want in life outside work and give me greater happiness than a job I love.

Gettingbysomehow · 12/12/2023 18:13

Why choose? I have both.

Zuve · 12/12/2023 18:11

Well I was bored at work once. Then I decided to get studying etc to make it fulfilling. Now, years later I am still in the same job and my advice is always ask for. I turned a dull job into an adventure and the money is really good

Iceache · 12/12/2023 17:55

Money. I chose a degree-level job with a salary ceiling of £43k (unless I go for promotions / management positions) and I regret not choosing differently when I had chance. I like my job, but I find it frustrating to earn so little. My husband in contrast found himself in an industry by chance when he was younger, realised he was very good at a particular sector of it and worked his way up. He now earns six figures which has given me a certain amount of freedom in my own job - which I think cushions my frustration at my own salary, but if it weren’t for him, I’d have moved industry a few years back to increase my earning potential.

Onthetipofmytonguetoo · 12/12/2023 17:46

I did some freelance marketing work for a pretty big and we’ll know charity a couple of summers ago. It was a three month contract and I stated my day rate and, because they were super short staffed, I got it. But when I realised what those far superior who had been working for the company for 10+ years were getting…I was earning that sum as someone more junior at a or agency back in 2007. It annoys me that so many charity sector organisations pay such a poor wage when they’re pretty well off in a lot of cases. There is no way I would take the long hours the permanent staff were working or the pressures or the tedious meeting to decide everything (teams meetings were taking up at third of my day) for the pittance they were paying their employees. Until then I’d always fancied working for a charity - it tight me the grass definitely isn’t always greener.

ticktickticktickBOOM · 12/12/2023 17:36

I would stick with the well paid job for say - 4/5 years, build up a cash cushion, whilst also keeping my hand in at my dream vocation by keeping up to speed with the charity sector, volunteering a few hours per week, carry on skill/knowledge building so you can go into it at a slightly higher level?

Charity sector are keen to have people with a finance mind so your few years on a higher wage could pay in both ways.

eurochick · 12/12/2023 17:20

Money to get to the point where you can pay the bills, a pension and have some left over for savings and spending. Then if you could choose to make more money or having a happier work life it is a trickier choice.

declutteringmymind · 12/12/2023 17:11

Money.

RedHelenB · 12/12/2023 17:05

I'd go for the job you enjoy as long as it covers the bills with sone spare " choosing money".

nutsnutspistachionuts · 12/12/2023 17:04

If you’re at the start of your career you may not have seen the variety of jobs in the charity sector yet. If finance is your skill-set then you should read up about emerging fields like microfinance and social impact investment. There are lots of fields that cross over between the two and charities always want people that understand funding.

Also look at jobs at funders, grant-making bodies, trusts and foundations who fund the charities. Or local govt.

Alternatively, cut your teeth in the private sector with a view to moving over to the charity sector at a higher level. If you want kids, charity jobs are often more family friendly and you might reach a point where £40-50k and flexi-time is better than £90k but you never go home.

MereDintofPandiculation · 12/12/2023 17:02

Not having enough money leads to unhappiness. But once you reach a certain level, more money doesn't bring greater happiness.

Nevermind31 · 12/12/2023 17:01

felttippenguin · 12/12/2023 16:31

Definitely. I've been paying into a help to buy isa since I was a 18

Money then… st least until you have a decent deposit

Lakeyloo · 12/12/2023 17:01

I think there's a balance, but money for me (as long as you aren't dreading going to work each day and it's not affecting your mental health)
Work to live, not live to work.
I can get through a boring or stressful working day if I know I've got nice things to look forward to outside of work.

Ultravox · 12/12/2023 17:00

I had a similar dilema 20years ago and went for the money. It took me some time to come to terms with not loving my job, however I don’t hate it and the lifestyle it has allowed for me and my family more than makes up for it. I find my fulfilment in life through personal things.

Nepmarthiturn · 12/12/2023 16:55

I'd focus on that. Write a list of the things about the not-very-well-paid job that attract you to it, and another of your skills, and go to see a careers adviser (a good one). There are so many jobs and careers that many of us aren't even aware of. Try to identify on that has what you will find fulfilling AND with decent earning potential then it's a matter of working out the stepping stones to get there. It's worth the extra effort even if it takes a bit longer than either route you've identified: many people don't figure out the best career for them until much later (if at all!) so don't be afraid to take a risk and change tack, with a good plan in place.

felttippenguin · 12/12/2023 16:47

Nepmarthiturn · 12/12/2023 16:38

Does it have to be this binary choice, though? If you have found things that appeal to you in your sector, do you have transferrable skills where you can take steps towards a similar but better paid role like that in another sector? You don't have to be bound in by what you have done to date and exclude other options that might require a few smart sideways career moves but get you to a career path that you find fulfilling and has a better earning potential.

No you're right it doesn't have to be a binary choice. I don't really know what else I'd want to do that would be both fulfilling and reasonably well paid though

OP posts: