Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Married 2 years. DHs family forgot our anniversary. Mine remembered.

564 replies

crossroads1 · 12/12/2023 13:45

DH's family forgot our anniversary, only been married 2 years. They remember all other important dates. But no effort for us. My family all remembered first thing in the morning and sent us both messages.

Should i bring this up to DH? I just want to tell my in laws where to stick it!!

Could this be my chance to distance myself from them? My get out of jail free card? I never liked them from the beginning.

OP posts:
crossroads1 · 12/12/2023 23:04

Bernardmanning · 12/12/2023 22:49

"My SIL used to send DH a list of unprompted present suggestions for her daughter 'just in case he wanted to buy her something!' INSANE."

So his sister sends him a list of birthday/Christmas ideas for her daughter, while prefacing that he doesn't have to buy her anything?! How absolutely terrible. How dare she try and come up with any helpful suggestions for him, when I'm sure that, he is perfectly capable of picking out the latest Barbie or Lol doll himself or picking up something from his local b&q. Particularly coming from such a close knit family who seemingly celebrate every time someone farts.
Honestly OP, you sound as though you are jealous of the entire family and expect to be put on some sort of pedestal. It's as though you are permanently looking to find fault and looking to drive a wedge between your DH and his family. You are already sewing seeds of doubt in his mind.
Look, you don't have to like his family. But that is pretty low to try and impact his relationships with them. One day, if you have children, when they are grown up, you may find yourself on the same position as your in-laws.

Yes this is the niece who is a spoilt brat. You're passing judgement when you only know a snippet of the story. You dont know half the stuff SIL does. Be objective.

And the suggestion list isnt anything for her birthday or christmas, its a 'just because' present. She went as far as to ask DH to buy daughter diamond earrings one year.. these are not small presents from Superdrug.

OP posts:
PTSDBarbiegirl · 12/12/2023 23:02

Personally I don't get the fuss around celebrating other people's anniversaries. I used to find it very odd when my ex MIL would be asking her children what everyone would be doing for their anniversary. Why do you expect anyone else to acknowledge it, some people don't really go in for that choosing to celebrate with their partner instead.

ConsuelaHammock · 12/12/2023 23:01

No one cares about other people’s wedding anniversaries. 25th, 40th perhaps but 2nd??? You will sound unhinged if you say anything. Perhaps your family remembered because YOU reminded them ??

crossroads1 · 12/12/2023 23:01

Chickenkeev · 12/12/2023 22:42

I wasn't bitching! And ruminating is indeed a far better word! But it does no good at the end of the day. So personally, i'd just let it go. Have no expectations. Sometimes people just let you down, so there's no point in having expectations of them. You're setting yourself up for failure that way really. I do get that it hurts though.

Oh i didnt mean you were bitching! Its the other comments ive had on this thread

OP posts:
Bernardmanning · 12/12/2023 23:00

I'm assuming of course that this is the same niece that you dislike, having previously run her down on another thread.

crossroads1 · 12/12/2023 23:00

MrsAllsorts · 12/12/2023 22:39

We have never had an anniversary card from anyone and we don’t send them either. All the couples I know just send cards to their spouse, and vice versa, and sometimes they don’t all do that.

I wasn't expecting a card. Just a message as everyone else in the family gets one.

OP posts:
Noglitterallowed · 12/12/2023 22:59

Bernardmanning · 12/12/2023 22:49

"My SIL used to send DH a list of unprompted present suggestions for her daughter 'just in case he wanted to buy her something!' INSANE."

So his sister sends him a list of birthday/Christmas ideas for her daughter, while prefacing that he doesn't have to buy her anything?! How absolutely terrible. How dare she try and come up with any helpful suggestions for him, when I'm sure that, he is perfectly capable of picking out the latest Barbie or Lol doll himself or picking up something from his local b&q. Particularly coming from such a close knit family who seemingly celebrate every time someone farts.
Honestly OP, you sound as though you are jealous of the entire family and expect to be put on some sort of pedestal. It's as though you are permanently looking to find fault and looking to drive a wedge between your DH and his family. You are already sewing seeds of doubt in his mind.
Look, you don't have to like his family. But that is pretty low to try and impact his relationships with them. One day, if you have children, when they are grown up, you may find yourself on the same position as your in-laws.

Exactly this!!!

Bernardmanning · 12/12/2023 22:49

"My SIL used to send DH a list of unprompted present suggestions for her daughter 'just in case he wanted to buy her something!' INSANE."

So his sister sends him a list of birthday/Christmas ideas for her daughter, while prefacing that he doesn't have to buy her anything?! How absolutely terrible. How dare she try and come up with any helpful suggestions for him, when I'm sure that, he is perfectly capable of picking out the latest Barbie or Lol doll himself or picking up something from his local b&q. Particularly coming from such a close knit family who seemingly celebrate every time someone farts.
Honestly OP, you sound as though you are jealous of the entire family and expect to be put on some sort of pedestal. It's as though you are permanently looking to find fault and looking to drive a wedge between your DH and his family. You are already sewing seeds of doubt in his mind.
Look, you don't have to like his family. But that is pretty low to try and impact his relationships with them. One day, if you have children, when they are grown up, you may find yourself on the same position as your in-laws.

CantFindTheBeat · 12/12/2023 22:49

I get you, OP.

What changes do you think you & DH might make because of this?

(Stepping back is a gradual thing - maybe this is the move to the first step?).

Frasers · 12/12/2023 22:45

Really your husband is “shocked”. I guess like attracts like and you’re both the same, If he’s not just humouring you, but god that would give me the ick.

Chickenkeev · 12/12/2023 22:42

crossroads1 · 12/12/2023 22:36

Agree - ruminating is not the way, this is an open forum where i wanted to gauge the opinion of others as well as letting off steam in (What i thought was) a safe place.

Lesson learnt.

I wasn't bitching! And ruminating is indeed a far better word! But it does no good at the end of the day. So personally, i'd just let it go. Have no expectations. Sometimes people just let you down, so there's no point in having expectations of them. You're setting yourself up for failure that way really. I do get that it hurts though.

MrsAllsorts · 12/12/2023 22:39

We have never had an anniversary card from anyone and we don’t send them either. All the couples I know just send cards to their spouse, and vice versa, and sometimes they don’t all do that.

crossroads1 · 12/12/2023 22:37

TowerRaven7 · 12/12/2023 20:37

My in-laws always make a big song and dance about their anniversary and I sent them cards for maybe eight years. They have never, ever sent us one and we’re bordering on 24 years! I stopped sending them one and have never looked back. When they mention it I say, “happy anniversary”.

wow you kept that up for eight years?! youre a better woman than me. this has been 2 and ive quickly realised they are 'give an inch, take a mile' kind of people

OP posts:
crossroads1 · 12/12/2023 22:36

Chickenkeev · 12/12/2023 22:34

Basically, you're both just stewing. It's pointless. It upsets you both and doesn't change the outcome.You dislike the inlaws so let them off and get on with your own life. Stewing is unhealthy.

Agree - ruminating is not the way, this is an open forum where i wanted to gauge the opinion of others as well as letting off steam in (What i thought was) a safe place.

Lesson learnt.

OP posts:
Chickenkeev · 12/12/2023 22:34

crossroads1 · 12/12/2023 19:04

This is not about 'remembering our anniversary.'

It's about being treated differently to the rest of the family. My other SIL (married into the family) has had full blown arguments with MIL, yet, even she still gets a birthday and anniversary message.

I have never had an argument with any of them - i have always bitten my tongue, I internally get fed up but outwardsly i have always been respectful. Me and DH have spoken about lack of effort on his familys part many times before. and even he ackowledges this.

Basically, you're both just stewing. It's pointless. It upsets you both and doesn't change the outcome.You dislike the inlaws so let them off and get on with your own life. Stewing is unhealthy.

crossroads1 · 12/12/2023 22:34

Mirrormeback · 12/12/2023 21:17

It's not particularly normal for anyone other than the actual wife or husband to remember their own anniversary

The entire point is for my DH's family they do remember. They all talk daily (or at least every other day).

UPDATE: this eve DH brought this up himself - he was shocked and dissapointed that no-one remembered. Verbatim "we always send eachother happy insert birthday/anniversary/special occasion messages" and even said how much effort the two of us make for everyone else.

Would also like to add DH does a lot for his family and it's only up til last year that i started speaking up. My SIL used to send DH a list of unprompted present suggestions for her daughter 'just in case he wanted to buy her something!' INSANE. He is the only brother and dad is not around. Alot of dynamics with my in-laws.

The majority of ppl on this thread did not understand what was at the core of my annoyance - my DH gets taken advantage of and is finally seeing this himself. Because of this thread I kept schtum to him not saying a word about how they all forgot. He willing brought this up himself. I can actually say thanks for all those who became really nasty with their words - because of that I was able to occupy myself here instead of ranting to him, and in the end I didnt have to say a word for him to realise it wasnt right.

OP posts:
Mirrormeback · 12/12/2023 21:17

It's not particularly normal for anyone other than the actual wife or husband to remember their own anniversary

TowerRaven7 · 12/12/2023 20:37

My in-laws always make a big song and dance about their anniversary and I sent them cards for maybe eight years. They have never, ever sent us one and we’re bordering on 24 years! I stopped sending them one and have never looked back. When they mention it I say, “happy anniversary”.

WeightoftheWorld · 12/12/2023 20:32

Gosh, we just about remember our own wedding anniversary. I certainly don't know a single other person's with the exception of my own DPs and that's only because DC1 was born on the same date!

Chill.

Hankunamatata · 12/12/2023 20:29

Leave the what's app group. Avoid the drama

FreckledWhelp · 12/12/2023 20:26

We’ve never had a card or anything from anyone for our anniversary. I’ve never sent one either! Just about remember our own tbh.

NaughtybutNice77 · 12/12/2023 20:19

tescocreditcard · 12/12/2023 13:52

Go round their house and beat the crap out of them

Oh yes, as a minimum for such a henious crime

Itwasafterallallaboutme · 12/12/2023 20:19

pinkfonies · 12/12/2023 15:40

@Itwasafterallallaboutme - It's comments like this that I hate on mumsnet - what a passive aggressive response!

I hate the way mumsnet has a habit of people responding so harshly to a post where the OP is offended and usually quite rightly offended, or they have a point at least....

I remember ages ago someone was offended that their SIL never got them a birthday present, when they always helped their DH buy SIL's birthday present. Everyone jumped on her, made her feel really stupid when she already felt quite hurt. Where is the sympathy on mumsnet sometimes?

Sorry @pinkfonies it wasn't meant to be at all "passive". Actually it wasn't Actually meant to be aggressive either. I was, and am, annoyed and frustrated by @crossroads1 OP, I wouldn't expect anyone over the age of 8 to get upset by such a small unimportant thing. But then it was never a thing to send other people an Anniversary Card in my or my DH's family.

My response to the OP was merely an honest one on my part. I really think that the reason the OP's in-laws might have singled out her and her DH from getting an anniversary card, could very well be because they are very much aware of how much "cross" hates them. I think it is very much in the OP's interest to try and think about how her behaviour can cause corresponding behaviours in others. I think that that would be a very valuble lesson to learn. For goodness sake, she asked almost gleefully, and definitely hopefully, if their lack of good wishes meant that she could use it as an excuse to not spend time with them.

She really does need to start growing up now, and she threw herself in the depend when deciding to start on Mumsnet! I also hate all this hatred and harshness on MN 'pink', including yours towards me, but I will shrug it off because I am an adult, and because anyone who makes a comment, or even starts a thread, is opening themselves up to other peoples thoughts etc - even when it is not in the AIBU section. If 'cross' has been upset by thinking strangers on MN are being horrible to her, then maybe it will make her think about whether she is being horrible to anyone herself?

My biggest hope on this thread, is that the OP will learn to be nicer to other people if she wants it reciprocated, and to not "sweat the small stuff", because like most of the rest of us have experienced at one time or another, she will probably have much more serious things in her life to deal with than this... I do, of course, wish her well for the future, as I am sure most other Mumsnetters do as well.

NaughtybutNice77 · 12/12/2023 20:18

I really don't think anyone should need to remember or celebrate a wedding anniversary other than the two spouses. Possibly a first anniversary and milestone celebrations if you're throwing a party/going out for a family meal etc.
I don't think they forgot as much as didn't bother...which is fine. Do you celebrate their anniversary?

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 12/12/2023 20:14

Oh for goodness sake!! It's your anniversary - the only person other than yourself who needs to remember is your DH.

You are being totally ridiculous.

Swipe left for the next trending thread