Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's unreasonable, me, DH, his ex?

290 replies

onionparker · 12/12/2023 12:01

Me and DH have been married 5 years and together for 7. We share two children and I also have two DSC.

There has been a little bit of tension about this situation recently and wondering who you think is being unreasonable?

For context, I was in an abusive relationship during my teens and early twenties before I met DH, this included physical and financial. Because of this I don't like feeling trapped, which is exactly how I felt at the time (no money to leave), so I have always insisted on separate finances with DH. Not because I think I'll be leaving but it brings me comfort to know that I have my own money.

DH earns okay, I however earn more than he does and also have some inheritance from grandparents that was quite considerable that I used some of to put down a large deposit on our house etc.. for the first time in my life, in the past few years ive felt financially secure and like my hard work has paid off to get where i am with my career.

We split bills proportionately and whilst if something is needed I have no problem paying, I don't want to pool resources and never have. DH always accepted this before.

Anyway, DH always has his two older DC 3 nights a week. He pays maintenance to their mum and this obviously goes off his wage. He'll also give extra as and when he can if needed.

She has mentioned to him recently that she feels she needs more and we should consider paying maintenance based on household salary rather than just his. She has made comments like this in the past I.e. if I have a new car or I pay for us to go away (with DSC), she makes out like she's due something because of our "lifestyle".

DH now seems to think this may be a good idea and I could perhaps contribute more into the family pot so he can pay more or we could work out what it would be on our joint salary and pay that (Which is essentially just me paying maintenance as I'd be subsiding him to do so). I've told him absolutely not.

This is one of the exact kinds of scenarios I wanted to avoid by having separate finances. I don't want to be tied into supporting another household. DSC are his and their mums children and therefore any support should be based of his salary not mine. We obviously have children together than need my support. And I do actually spend a lot on DSC when they are with us and don't care about that at all but I don't want to commit to paying another woman when I don't need to.

So AIBU?

OP posts:
GuinnessBird · 12/12/2023 12:52

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Wrong.

Crababbles · 12/12/2023 12:51

NorthernSpirit · 12/12/2023 12:48

YANBU

If the mother wants more money (as long as the father is paying the correct amount of maintenance) then she needs to go out & earn more.

I’m a SM - my DH’s EW is also grabby and has tried to pull this stunt. It’s the reason I got a pre nup & like you keep our finances separate. While I work my arse off, she chooses to work PT 3 days a week (kids are 15 & 18) but is always demanding more money (my DH pays over £10k a year CM).

Do not pay - they aren’t your children and are not your responsibility.

Pre-nups aren’t legally enforceable in the UK. Your husband’s ex isn’t entitled to your salary regardless.

TomatoSandwiches · 12/12/2023 12:51

Perhaps ops husbands ex watched the same thing as @Keepinmovin and similarly didn't understand.

InefficientProcess · 12/12/2023 12:51

HeddaGarbled · 12/12/2023 12:48

So pretty much a consensus above apart from the poster who was mistaken.

I do think you need to be sensitive here, though.

If you and your husband can afford to take his children on expensive holidays and generally have a much nicer lifestyle, because of your income, I can understand why that would seem unfair to a woman who was struggling financially. And children can be absolute sods about moaning at the parent who can’t treat them like the richer parent does.

That doesn’t mean you should give her any of your income. But maybe think about not making the disparity too obvious.

Why should the ex’s feelings be the determining factor.

Surely she should be pleased that her children get nice holidays and a better lifestyle because their SM is generous enough to provide it.

So what if the ex feels a bit crap? She could use that to motivate herself to improve her own lifestyle.

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 12:51

@ElevenSeven points out that if the mum is assuming too many expenses it is for OP’s DH to make them up. Her point is excellent.

But I am wondering if he has told her that he cannot, or more broadly, if there us a disconnect in communications and OP doesn’t know the full story

ChateauDuMont · 12/12/2023 12:50

He made the decision to get with another woman and have more children so it's up to him to earn enough money to provide for both sets of children.

If his job at the money isn't enough then he has to look for a better paying job, or find an additional income or study whilst working to improve his chances of getting a better job.

The ex is jealous.

funinthesun19 · 12/12/2023 12:50

Catnuzzle · 12/12/2023 12:08

Ask DH what his ex is going to contribute to your DC. They're being ridiculous.

Good point! The only way it would be fair is if she paid you money for your kids if she wants you to pay for her kids.

You owe her/ her household nothing.

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 12:49

SinnerBoy · 12/12/2023 12:48

Thick Tok, surely?

Poster can’t even understand what she is saying, she’s talking about financial orders, not CMS. Honestly, I despair

Crababbles · 12/12/2023 12:49

Keepinmovin · 12/12/2023 12:44

Actually it is I'm afraid. Despite it seems very unfair I agree

https://www.tiktok.com/@thelegalqueen/video/7236850829548948762

You’re really getting guidance from TikTok instead of the government site?

That video says the ex is “entitled to ask” about a new partner’s income. You can ask what you want, doesn’t mean there’s any requirement to answer. Bear in mind this is a solicitor trying to get money.

The CMS calculations, on NRP’s income alone, is used for situations where the dad earns up to about 250k.

InefficientProcess · 12/12/2023 12:49

That video is for people who are in the middle of getting divorced and agreeing a financial settlement.

It’s not relevant here.

The OP’s income has absolutely no bearing on his maintenance obligations. And the courts are not going to get involved with this.

NorthernSpirit · 12/12/2023 12:48

YANBU

If the mother wants more money (as long as the father is paying the correct amount of maintenance) then she needs to go out & earn more.

I’m a SM - my DH’s EW is also grabby and has tried to pull this stunt. It’s the reason I got a pre nup & like you keep our finances separate. While I work my arse off, she chooses to work PT 3 days a week (kids are 15 & 18) but is always demanding more money (my DH pays over £10k a year CM).

Do not pay - they aren’t your children and are not your responsibility.

SinnerBoy · 12/12/2023 12:48

Thick Tok, surely?

HeddaGarbled · 12/12/2023 12:48

So pretty much a consensus above apart from the poster who was mistaken.

I do think you need to be sensitive here, though.

If you and your husband can afford to take his children on expensive holidays and generally have a much nicer lifestyle, because of your income, I can understand why that would seem unfair to a woman who was struggling financially. And children can be absolute sods about moaning at the parent who can’t treat them like the richer parent does.

That doesn’t mean you should give her any of your income. But maybe think about not making the disparity too obvious.

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 12:47

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Tik tok 🤣🤣🤣🤣.

Keepinmovin · 12/12/2023 12:46

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 12/12/2023 12:46

InefficientProcess · 12/12/2023 12:46

They are already long divorced and have a financial settlement.

So that video is entirely irrelevant. All she’s entitled to now is the basic CMS minimum rate.

Also lol at TikTok ‘evidence’ 🤣🤣🤣

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 12:46

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 12:45

I don’t like the sound of the ex any more than anyone else does and voted YANBU.

But why is no one else open to the possibility that OP’s DH could be ‘letting’ the ex assume an unfair portion of basic expenses for the DSC, and OP is unaware? We see this all the time on other threads.

Because it’s nothing to do with the OP, even if he is. That’s for him to rectify.

InefficientProcess · 12/12/2023 12:46

Keepinmovin · 12/12/2023 12:44

Actually it is I'm afraid. Despite it seems very unfair I agree

https://www.tiktok.com/@thelegalqueen/video/7236850829548948762

They are already long divorced and have a financial settlement.

So that video is entirely irrelevant. All she’s entitled to now is the basic CMS minimum rate.

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 12:45

I don’t like the sound of the ex any more than anyone else does and voted YANBU.

But why is no one else open to the possibility that OP’s DH could be ‘letting’ the ex assume an unfair portion of basic expenses for the DSC, and OP is unaware? We see this all the time on other threads.

Keepinmovin · 12/12/2023 12:44

SecondUsername4me · 12/12/2023 12:17

Unfortunately for you the ex is correct in that the household income is considered which is you plus DH and that you can't just "keep" your money separate

Which country are you in? This isn't the case in England

Actually it is I'm afraid. Despite it seems very unfair I agree

https://www.tiktok.com/@thelegalqueen/video/7236850829548948762

TikTok - Make Your Day

https://www.tiktok.com/@thelegalqueen/video/7236850829548948762

OldTinHat · 12/12/2023 12:44

No. YANBU. Stick to your guns. Your money is yours. Their children are theirs. No way should you be paying.

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 12:44

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 12:31

Hi, OP -

You sound very generous, and I voted YANBU, but there is always room for misunderstanding on Mumsnet. Like @Octavia64 I would want to confirm that your DH is paying at least the minimum support for a parent who has his DC three nights a week. And also to confirm that you are in a country like England where only the parent’s income is taken into account by the courts.

Then I would want to confirm that your generosity as a household with your DSC really does come close to 3/7 of their basic expenses. It’s great to give them treats and holidays, but are you paying proportionately for school uniforms, after school clubs, school trips, sporting and hobby expenses, presents to be bought, etc? This is the stuff that might be outside your awareness and could really add up. If their mum is absorbing a load of unseen expenses that is not right. Having the children 3/7 of the the time is seen by the courts as a proxy for covering 3/7 of their basic expenses.

Even if this were the case, this would be for the DF to make up the difference, never the OP.

notlucreziaborgia · 12/12/2023 12:44

Viviennemary · 12/12/2023 12:39

Up to you. But I can see why his ex feels he should pay more if he has a better standard of living that his children.

he has his children nearly 50% of the time. In that time they are benefiting from said better standard of living. If their mother wants a better standard of living at her house then it’s up to her to improve her situation herself.

InefficientProcess · 12/12/2023 12:42

Viviennemary · 12/12/2023 12:39

Up to you. But I can see why his ex feels he should pay more if he has a better standard of living that his children.

He’s not paying for that lifestyle though.

So his ex would be entirely wrong to feel that way. Indeed, she should be grateful that he’s providing additional maintenance because the OP is picking up the slack and paying more for him.

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 12:42

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 12/12/2023 12:40

WHY??? she could increase her earnings? Why is she so pathetic and ridiculous and entitled she still wants her ex to pay for her her????

bloody hell?

Also, where do people get the fundamentally wrong idea that their income has to somehow be equal or ‘fair’ to their ex?
It doesn’t.