Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's unreasonable, me, DH, his ex?

290 replies

onionparker · 12/12/2023 12:01

Me and DH have been married 5 years and together for 7. We share two children and I also have two DSC.

There has been a little bit of tension about this situation recently and wondering who you think is being unreasonable?

For context, I was in an abusive relationship during my teens and early twenties before I met DH, this included physical and financial. Because of this I don't like feeling trapped, which is exactly how I felt at the time (no money to leave), so I have always insisted on separate finances with DH. Not because I think I'll be leaving but it brings me comfort to know that I have my own money.

DH earns okay, I however earn more than he does and also have some inheritance from grandparents that was quite considerable that I used some of to put down a large deposit on our house etc.. for the first time in my life, in the past few years ive felt financially secure and like my hard work has paid off to get where i am with my career.

We split bills proportionately and whilst if something is needed I have no problem paying, I don't want to pool resources and never have. DH always accepted this before.

Anyway, DH always has his two older DC 3 nights a week. He pays maintenance to their mum and this obviously goes off his wage. He'll also give extra as and when he can if needed.

She has mentioned to him recently that she feels she needs more and we should consider paying maintenance based on household salary rather than just his. She has made comments like this in the past I.e. if I have a new car or I pay for us to go away (with DSC), she makes out like she's due something because of our "lifestyle".

DH now seems to think this may be a good idea and I could perhaps contribute more into the family pot so he can pay more or we could work out what it would be on our joint salary and pay that (Which is essentially just me paying maintenance as I'd be subsiding him to do so). I've told him absolutely not.

This is one of the exact kinds of scenarios I wanted to avoid by having separate finances. I don't want to be tied into supporting another household. DSC are his and their mums children and therefore any support should be based of his salary not mine. We obviously have children together than need my support. And I do actually spend a lot on DSC when they are with us and don't care about that at all but I don't want to commit to paying another woman when I don't need to.

So AIBU?

OP posts:
SuspiciousSue · 12/12/2023 14:04

We had this with the ex too. In fact, when DH first started paying, he actually got a message from her saying ‘I need @suspicioussue’s financial details to give to the CMS!!’ This was after she’d screamed in my face the previous week. My response to her was less than favourable, let’s just leave it at that.

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 14:04

notlucreziaborgia · 12/12/2023 13:59

That is the responsibility of their two parents, not OP. If the solution is that he improves his prospects and earns more then sure, but if that happens he also has a responsibility to increase his contribution to his household, and the two children he has with OP.

And perhaps the only way this can be done is if the OP’s young DC spend more time in care than she likes, or she cuts back her hours. All I said is that there will likely be ramifications for her.

How DH allocates any additional earnings is a private matter for him and OP. She has not sought advice on this point

horseyhorsey17 · 12/12/2023 14:04

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 13:48

I hope you can see now that it’s nothing to do with your step parent.

Oh - you know my family and specific circumstances, do you?

harriethoyle · 12/12/2023 14:02

DH's ex tried this when we got serious and was told firmly to bugger right off by DH. Cannot BELIEVE your DH is even entertaining this!

BloodyAdultDC · 12/12/2023 14:01

Babymamamama · 12/12/2023 12:26

I thought CMS look at household income especially when you are married. Why do so many people think this is not the case?

Because it's not the case, that's why...

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 14:00

Crababbles · 12/12/2023 13:47

The dad (and his wife) already pay for everything 3/7. If their mum pays for the same that leaves 4-5 days a month to split. It’s hugely unlikely that their essentials on 2-2.5 days a month cost more than the maintenance he’s paying.

We have no idea about this. We know he pays for their food, shelter, utilities and transport costs 3/7 of the time and a small bit of CM.

MN contains frequent threads from mums explaining that their DC fathers do not pay for school uniforms, sporting and hobby expenses, after school activities, music lessons, presents, driving lessons and even the clothing for the DF residence.

My first post on this seems to have gone unnoticed.

It makes all the difference

notlucreziaborgia · 12/12/2023 13:59

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 13:39

@notlucreziaborgia I don’t care whether it is hard on the DSC’s mum. I do care whether it is hard on the DSC. Including CM their DF should be paying half their necessary expenses. This doesn’t include treats such as holidays abroad. Other very expensive optionals shouldn’t count either as they don’t replace necessities.

If DF cannot do this, then what? One option is to earn more, another is to turn to his DW. Any solution is likely to have ramifications for OP.

That is the responsibility of their two parents, not OP. If the solution is that he improves his prospects and earns more then sure, but if that happens he also has a responsibility to increase his contribution to his household, and the two children he has with OP.

tachetastic · 12/12/2023 13:59

onionparker · 12/12/2023 12:01

Me and DH have been married 5 years and together for 7. We share two children and I also have two DSC.

There has been a little bit of tension about this situation recently and wondering who you think is being unreasonable?

For context, I was in an abusive relationship during my teens and early twenties before I met DH, this included physical and financial. Because of this I don't like feeling trapped, which is exactly how I felt at the time (no money to leave), so I have always insisted on separate finances with DH. Not because I think I'll be leaving but it brings me comfort to know that I have my own money.

DH earns okay, I however earn more than he does and also have some inheritance from grandparents that was quite considerable that I used some of to put down a large deposit on our house etc.. for the first time in my life, in the past few years ive felt financially secure and like my hard work has paid off to get where i am with my career.

We split bills proportionately and whilst if something is needed I have no problem paying, I don't want to pool resources and never have. DH always accepted this before.

Anyway, DH always has his two older DC 3 nights a week. He pays maintenance to their mum and this obviously goes off his wage. He'll also give extra as and when he can if needed.

She has mentioned to him recently that she feels she needs more and we should consider paying maintenance based on household salary rather than just his. She has made comments like this in the past I.e. if I have a new car or I pay for us to go away (with DSC), she makes out like she's due something because of our "lifestyle".

DH now seems to think this may be a good idea and I could perhaps contribute more into the family pot so he can pay more or we could work out what it would be on our joint salary and pay that (Which is essentially just me paying maintenance as I'd be subsiding him to do so). I've told him absolutely not.

This is one of the exact kinds of scenarios I wanted to avoid by having separate finances. I don't want to be tied into supporting another household. DSC are his and their mums children and therefore any support should be based of his salary not mine. We obviously have children together than need my support. And I do actually spend a lot on DSC when they are with us and don't care about that at all but I don't want to commit to paying another woman when I don't need to.

So AIBU?

Who is being unreasonable? It's the man in the situation, obviously. This is Mumsnet!!! 😂

And in this case that is right. The ex is looking out for her DC's interests. It's your DH expecting you to pay maintenance so that his ex's lifestyle is more like yours that is madness. Tell them both absolutely no way, and don't give in on this one.

Also watch out for stealth tactics where he sends the extra cash without telling you and then expects you to pay for the shopping or petrol or meals out because he's "a bit short this month".

Lubilu02 · 12/12/2023 13:57

Not your job at all.

If he thinks his children should be getting more, then he can take a leaf out of your book to aim higher and get a better paid job.

Certainly not feed off of you!

BaconMassive · 12/12/2023 13:53

I would imagine these ground rules would have been discussed previously? Like before getting married to someone with children.

If the mother of the children's circumstances changed to have significantly more income to yours, would she contribute to your household? Therein lies the answer.

Coconutter24 · 12/12/2023 13:48

Babymamamama · 12/12/2023 12:26

I thought CMS look at household income especially when you are married. Why do so many people think this is not the case?

It isn’t the case. It goes on the parents earnings

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 13:48

horseyhorsey17 · 12/12/2023 13:45

Oh, all the adults involved! I am 48 now and it still rankles. But that's another story for another thread, it's not exactly the same as the OP's.

I hope you can see now that it’s nothing to do with your step parent.

Crababbles · 12/12/2023 13:47

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 13:39

@notlucreziaborgia I don’t care whether it is hard on the DSC’s mum. I do care whether it is hard on the DSC. Including CM their DF should be paying half their necessary expenses. This doesn’t include treats such as holidays abroad. Other very expensive optionals shouldn’t count either as they don’t replace necessities.

If DF cannot do this, then what? One option is to earn more, another is to turn to his DW. Any solution is likely to have ramifications for OP.

The dad (and his wife) already pay for everything 3/7. If their mum pays for the same that leaves 4-5 days a month to split. It’s hugely unlikely that their essentials on 2-2.5 days a month cost more than the maintenance he’s paying.

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 13:47

Including CM their DF should be paying half their necessary expenses

What necessary expenses are you talking about? This isn’t anything he has to provide, he can if he is able and wants to. If he can’t, there’s absolutely nothing binding on the OP or anyone else to mitigate this.

horseyhorsey17 · 12/12/2023 13:45

Crababbles · 12/12/2023 13:25

Who did you resent, and how do you feel about it now?

Oh, all the adults involved! I am 48 now and it still rankles. But that's another story for another thread, it's not exactly the same as the OP's.

Merseymum1980 · 12/12/2023 13:45

Child maintenance take our full household income into account

ActDottie · 12/12/2023 13:43

They’re both cheeky fuckers! I’m so shocked they even have the balls to suggest it. Stand firm and say no.

viques · 12/12/2023 13:43

While you are not contributing directly to the SC they are benefitting from the financial and other inputs you make into your own household which they benefit from directly. Why would you also contribute to another persons household?

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 12/12/2023 13:41

Definitely should be on his salary alone unless he is doing reduced hours to look after your joint children/enable you to work and earn more in which case I think it’s fair to partially incorporate yours.

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 13:39

@notlucreziaborgia I don’t care whether it is hard on the DSC’s mum. I do care whether it is hard on the DSC. Including CM their DF should be paying half their necessary expenses. This doesn’t include treats such as holidays abroad. Other very expensive optionals shouldn’t count either as they don’t replace necessities.

If DF cannot do this, then what? One option is to earn more, another is to turn to his DW. Any solution is likely to have ramifications for OP.

19lottie82 · 12/12/2023 13:38

If his ex moved in a new partner, would she suggest that maintenance is reduced? Thought not.

TrashedSofa · 12/12/2023 13:35

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 13:18

Actually,@ElevenSeven , while you are correct that DH is the one who should step up if he is not paying his fair half of full expenses, I suspect it is hard on the DSC’s mum if her DC are getting treats and travel instead of basic necessities from OP and her DH.

Not to say the mum should directly get more, but if this is the case then perhaps OP could ask herself why she is willing to give her DSC the one but not the other? Mind, we don’t know that this is the case - but we have seen it a lot on MN. As her own DC are younger OP probably hasn’t thought much about the type of expense I listed upthread.

If DH is contributing fairly to DSC the woman is just a CF.

Seems fairly obvious it's the formalisation and expectation that are the problem for OP, which doesn't surprise me in someone who's been financially abused in the past. The limitation on her independence.

That said, if DH wants to pay more from his own income, it might be appropriate for OP to support him by reframing family spending to facilitate that. So if eg he pays 1/3 of holiday costs and her 2/3, she could agree they go away for 1 week instead of 2, they could jointly agree to cut down on takeaways etc. There are ways she could help without taking on an additional financial commitment herself.

Andthereyougo · 12/12/2023 13:35

Totally, 100% no.
You and DH have the children 3 nights a week and she wants more money? I’d be telling her where to go. Grabby cow.
Stand your ground.

Nicole1111 · 12/12/2023 13:34

The audacity of her (and him for going along with it).

Scottishskifun · 12/12/2023 13:32

Your DH ex is being a cf and if nearly 50/50 then why is he paying maintenance rather then getting them what they need for being with you?!

It's not for you to subsidise her household and its not for your DH to demand you to. Given they are with you 3 days a week you are already indirectly contributing anyway via food shop, energy bills, clothing, petrol if they need running about etc etc etc.

Would just be clear to your DH you already are contributing by these extra costs (teenagers are not cheap to feed!) And you won't be giving over extra cash because his ex wants more money!