Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's unreasonable, me, DH, his ex?

290 replies

onionparker · 12/12/2023 12:01

Me and DH have been married 5 years and together for 7. We share two children and I also have two DSC.

There has been a little bit of tension about this situation recently and wondering who you think is being unreasonable?

For context, I was in an abusive relationship during my teens and early twenties before I met DH, this included physical and financial. Because of this I don't like feeling trapped, which is exactly how I felt at the time (no money to leave), so I have always insisted on separate finances with DH. Not because I think I'll be leaving but it brings me comfort to know that I have my own money.

DH earns okay, I however earn more than he does and also have some inheritance from grandparents that was quite considerable that I used some of to put down a large deposit on our house etc.. for the first time in my life, in the past few years ive felt financially secure and like my hard work has paid off to get where i am with my career.

We split bills proportionately and whilst if something is needed I have no problem paying, I don't want to pool resources and never have. DH always accepted this before.

Anyway, DH always has his two older DC 3 nights a week. He pays maintenance to their mum and this obviously goes off his wage. He'll also give extra as and when he can if needed.

She has mentioned to him recently that she feels she needs more and we should consider paying maintenance based on household salary rather than just his. She has made comments like this in the past I.e. if I have a new car or I pay for us to go away (with DSC), she makes out like she's due something because of our "lifestyle".

DH now seems to think this may be a good idea and I could perhaps contribute more into the family pot so he can pay more or we could work out what it would be on our joint salary and pay that (Which is essentially just me paying maintenance as I'd be subsiding him to do so). I've told him absolutely not.

This is one of the exact kinds of scenarios I wanted to avoid by having separate finances. I don't want to be tied into supporting another household. DSC are his and their mums children and therefore any support should be based of his salary not mine. We obviously have children together than need my support. And I do actually spend a lot on DSC when they are with us and don't care about that at all but I don't want to commit to paying another woman when I don't need to.

So AIBU?

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 12/12/2023 15:55

BungleandGeorge · 12/12/2023 15:50

For anyone to know whether this is fair you really need to say what he is paying for, for his first children? And what days is he looking after them? Is he doing a fair share of Monday to Friday?

That doesn’t remotely matter.

The OPs salary is nothing to do with any of that.

if his ex has an issue with what he’s paying or doing she should address that. Not expect the Op’s cash.

BungleandGeorge · 12/12/2023 15:50

For anyone to know whether this is fair you really need to say what he is paying for, for his first children? And what days is he looking after them? Is he doing a fair share of Monday to Friday?

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 15:45

x2boys · 12/12/2023 15:36

Does the mother?

All is a mystery, @x2boys

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 15:43

x2boys · 12/12/2023 15:26

He has them half the week and pays maintenance I think you are projecting here
If the Ex wants to improve her situation she could get a better paid job

Happily this situation has nothing to do with my life, now or earlier. But if you are an MN regular you will readily recognise it.

Gymnopedie · 12/12/2023 15:43

Tacotortoise · 12/12/2023 15:33

Yes and I'm sure if he flipped it and provided fully for his first two kids and only partially for his younger two she'd be delighted.

But he's not providing fully for his younger two is he? Because OP pays for them too.

OP you have NO financial responsibility for the children he has with his ex. You already pay for them indirectly if they're with you three days a week, with higher bills and more food. then you pay for them directly by buying them things when they're with you for nearly half the week.

You need to explain to him that if he ups his contribution to pay her more and that means you have to pay more into the household, you might as well cut out the middle man (him) and give your money directly to her. Would he think that was reasonable? For children who are not related to you and not your responsibilty?

Then he needs to explain to his ex that you don't share finances, that anything you have for yourself comes out of your money and is nothing to do with the relationship between his and ex.

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 15:37

Tacotortoise · 12/12/2023 15:33

Yes and I'm sure if he flipped it and provided fully for his first two kids and only partially for his younger two she'd be delighted.

Well she could always ask his ex to help pay, that seems to be how it works?

x2boys · 12/12/2023 15:36

Tacotortoise · 12/12/2023 15:29

But how much maintenance is he paying? Does he pay 3/7 of the cost of clothing, any medical stuff, school trips etc?

Does the mother?

x2boys · 12/12/2023 15:35

Tacotortoise · 12/12/2023 15:33

Yes and I'm sure if he flipped it and provided fully for his first two kids and only partially for his younger two she'd be delighted.

Projecting much?
Seriously some posters twist everything to make out the mothers are reasonable even when they are very unreasonable🙄

Tacotortoise · 12/12/2023 15:33

Yes and I'm sure if he flipped it and provided fully for his first two kids and only partially for his younger two she'd be delighted.

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 15:31

Tacotortoise · 12/12/2023 15:29

But how much maintenance is he paying? Does he pay 3/7 of the cost of clothing, any medical stuff, school trips etc?

Nothing 👏 to 👏 do 👏 with 👏 OP.

Not her job to top it up if he isn’t. That’s for him to sort with his ex.

Tacotortoise · 12/12/2023 15:29

But how much maintenance is he paying? Does he pay 3/7 of the cost of clothing, any medical stuff, school trips etc?

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 15:29

Tacotortoise · 12/12/2023 15:22

Do you really think your stepchildren live on twice the money your dh pays for them, or does their mother contribute the vast majority of the time and money it costs to bring them up? I'd argue that, when you agreed to have children with a man who already has children, you committed to at least allowing him to provide adequately for them.

Ding ding! We have a bingo winner at last

x2boys · 12/12/2023 15:28

Tacotortoise · 12/12/2023 15:22

Do you really think your stepchildren live on twice the money your dh pays for them, or does their mother contribute the vast majority of the time and money it costs to bring them up? I'd argue that, when you agreed to have children with a man who already has children, you committed to at least allowing him to provide adequately for them.

You can argue what you its irrelevant the the dad is already paying maintenance and having the kids three nights a week

x2boys · 12/12/2023 15:26

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 13:39

@notlucreziaborgia I don’t care whether it is hard on the DSC’s mum. I do care whether it is hard on the DSC. Including CM their DF should be paying half their necessary expenses. This doesn’t include treats such as holidays abroad. Other very expensive optionals shouldn’t count either as they don’t replace necessities.

If DF cannot do this, then what? One option is to earn more, another is to turn to his DW. Any solution is likely to have ramifications for OP.

He has them half the week and pays maintenance I think you are projecting here
If the Ex wants to improve her situation she could get a better paid job

Tacotortoise · 12/12/2023 15:22

Do you really think your stepchildren live on twice the money your dh pays for them, or does their mother contribute the vast majority of the time and money it costs to bring them up? I'd argue that, when you agreed to have children with a man who already has children, you committed to at least allowing him to provide adequately for them.

Delphinium20 · 12/12/2023 15:14

YANBU. She's trying to push to see how much more she can squeeze from you. Protect your money!!!

x2boys · 12/12/2023 15:11

ChateauDuMont · 12/12/2023 12:50

He made the decision to get with another woman and have more children so it's up to him to earn enough money to provide for both sets of children.

If his job at the money isn't enough then he has to look for a better paying job, or find an additional income or study whilst working to improve his chances of getting a better job.

The ex is jealous.

Whilst the Ex sits on her arse doing fuck all too improve her situation?
The Father pays maintenance and has the kids three days a week why does he need to earn more why can't the Ex ?

JoyeuxNarwhal · 12/12/2023 15:10

If they were still together they'd manage on his and her salaries, why does she expect it to be different now? Does she have a partner that she can sponge off can help her out if she really needs it? Or does she just want nice things because you have them? If so, tell her she can earn them herself like you do!

If that's not clear - YANBU!

SunCreamQueenie · 12/12/2023 15:09

Absolutely 💯 you're not being unreasonable. If she went through CMS she'd realise your income is not expected to be included. She shouldn't be asking based on what she thinks you have, and he shouldn't have gone along with her nonsense! Stand firm @onionparker xx

ChristmasMadnessCountdownHell · 12/12/2023 15:02

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 14:41

Hope the cheeky fucker ex-wife comes across the thread and reads what people think of her

If only!

eardefender · 12/12/2023 15:01

op if he has them 3 nights a week then surely the amount he is paying in maintenance is very small, they practically have shared custody.
why not just have a shared 50/50 arrangement and not pay any maintenance any more and just share costs for clothes etc with his ex. Sounds like she is doing very well out of the arrangement and this isn't financially fair to your ex.

LadyBird1973 · 12/12/2023 14:59

If I were you I'd see a solicitor about legally ring fencing the house you bought with your inheritance. If it's the marital home, your dh could have a claim should you divorce, regardless of whether it's bought with your own money from inheritance, even though usually inheritance isn't considered part of the marital pot.
That he's taking her side on this would make me very wary and inclined to pull back further on what I'm willing to pay towards.

I must admit I've heard that courts can decide he has a high family income and therefore force him to pay higher maintenance, on the basis that he wouldn't be financially disadvantaged due to your income. While not the exact same as making you directly responsible for his child support, it does in an indirect way. I don't know what would happen if you were to tell a court all finances are separate.
But get legal advice - if you die before him or separate, is his ex going to have an eye on your house, for her kids inheritance? Would your dh expect all kids to inherit equally? These are things you need to iron out.

Loubelou14 · 12/12/2023 14:57

If they didn't get a financial order at the time of their divorce could she be entitled to this....I think she might so although I am in your corner I think there's a chance she could claim this.

SleepingStandingUp · 12/12/2023 14:57

He has the kids a fraction under 50%, surely he isn't paying tons? Splitting uniform costs, school trips is extra but as hoc. Absolutely no reason if he wants to give her more money, baring in mind he has them 3/7s of the time, he should use your money for it.

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 14:52

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 14:38

I pay for DSC to come on holiday, and for food/clothing/meals out when they are with us etc. Most of these things are far nicer standard than what they have with their DM as she is on minimum wage (she is paid full, maximum rate of CMS but myself and DH are high earners). If I was told to stop doing this and start giving them money directly so they could have stuff at their DM’s house I’d simply stop paying at all.

NB - CMS is not aimed at ‘evening things up’. It’s purely based on the salary of the NRP, nothing else. What the RP earns or doesn’t earn isn’t relevant. So, like everyone else, they have to cut their cloth according to what they have.

Again, none of the above is anything to do with the OP. She doesn’t have to think how it comes across, how the DSC might feel, how the DM feels, how the optics are. It’s nothing to do with her. And they are massively CF’s to have even considered demanded it might.

Edited

This post contains many irrelevancies. No one has suggested that most of what you address is at issue