Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's unreasonable, me, DH, his ex?

290 replies

onionparker · 12/12/2023 12:01

Me and DH have been married 5 years and together for 7. We share two children and I also have two DSC.

There has been a little bit of tension about this situation recently and wondering who you think is being unreasonable?

For context, I was in an abusive relationship during my teens and early twenties before I met DH, this included physical and financial. Because of this I don't like feeling trapped, which is exactly how I felt at the time (no money to leave), so I have always insisted on separate finances with DH. Not because I think I'll be leaving but it brings me comfort to know that I have my own money.

DH earns okay, I however earn more than he does and also have some inheritance from grandparents that was quite considerable that I used some of to put down a large deposit on our house etc.. for the first time in my life, in the past few years ive felt financially secure and like my hard work has paid off to get where i am with my career.

We split bills proportionately and whilst if something is needed I have no problem paying, I don't want to pool resources and never have. DH always accepted this before.

Anyway, DH always has his two older DC 3 nights a week. He pays maintenance to their mum and this obviously goes off his wage. He'll also give extra as and when he can if needed.

She has mentioned to him recently that she feels she needs more and we should consider paying maintenance based on household salary rather than just his. She has made comments like this in the past I.e. if I have a new car or I pay for us to go away (with DSC), she makes out like she's due something because of our "lifestyle".

DH now seems to think this may be a good idea and I could perhaps contribute more into the family pot so he can pay more or we could work out what it would be on our joint salary and pay that (Which is essentially just me paying maintenance as I'd be subsiding him to do so). I've told him absolutely not.

This is one of the exact kinds of scenarios I wanted to avoid by having separate finances. I don't want to be tied into supporting another household. DSC are his and their mums children and therefore any support should be based of his salary not mine. We obviously have children together than need my support. And I do actually spend a lot on DSC when they are with us and don't care about that at all but I don't want to commit to paying another woman when I don't need to.

So AIBU?

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 17:01

notlucreziaborgia · 12/12/2023 16:31

She can expect what she likes, but beyond the maintenance he gives her for the one day a week more she has them, he doesn’t in fact have to give her anything else.

OP doesn’t have to contribute money herself, and nor does she need to agree to him making any changes that would require her input.

This has already been done to death and misses the point of how the goal will be achieved in the real world. OP’s marriage will not thrive unless both partners are doing at least all right. Putting DH in an impossible situation doesn’t ultimately benefit her.

As I’ve said, there is still the possibility that OP and her DH are in fact generous and the mum is a CF. We just don’t know

StaunchMomma · 12/12/2023 16:59

Stick to your guns, OP.

You've worked hard and been sensible with money to get to where you are - not to give it away to another family.

Make it a very firm no and tell them to stop asking.

AllisColm · 12/12/2023 16:55

Your H is trying to take what he thinks is the easy way out by agreeing with his ex.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 12/12/2023 16:53

3 nights out of 7 is nearly 50/50, and the OP's DH is paying maintenance which probably covers the extra day each week.

Yes, there are essential extras like school uniform, holiday childcare etc and I agree with the principle that these costs should be shared equally between both parents but I presume that the mum is in receipt of child benefit that would go some way towards covering these expenses as well, so that should be used first and any additional costs should then be split 50/50.

Optional extras such as hobbies, activities etc need to be negotiated and shared between the parents, and the extent to which these can be afforded will depend on the parents' means, which is the same for children whose parents are still together. If either parent unilaterally decides to send the kids to a particular activity, I don't think it's the other parent's responsibility to contribute to that.

RB68 · 12/12/2023 16:45

so currently he pays less than you for the household based on his salary - do you factor inthe extra children when they are with you - so he pays for their share? (Didn't think so) and how many times a week does ex pop over and do the cleaning or cook tea? Babysit your kids?

I think you need to have a relook at what each of you are paying and make sure it is reflective of true cost with two extra kids on his side and I would be telling him if she is so keen on you paying her to look after her own kids (cos that is what she really wants) then you need to see her cleaning your toilets and contributing to cooking and washing up once in a while.

I would suggest DH goes 50 50 with the children and see how she likes that

x2boys · 12/12/2023 16:43

thesixleggedpsychopathonthetrain · 12/12/2023 16:41

The problem seems to be that your husband has more children than he can comfortably afford. Unless you dragooned him into that situation, it's not your problem to solve.

Bow do you,work that out?

PurpleBugz · 12/12/2023 16:42

Absolutely not unreasonable.

I say this as a parent receiving maintenance who's ex dropped to 3 days a week to pay me less. He lives in her house for free and I presume she pays for all the needs of their joint child. It's her money, she may be an amazing step mum but she's not financially responsible for my children

thesixleggedpsychopathonthetrain · 12/12/2023 16:41

The problem seems to be that your husband has more children than he can comfortably afford. Unless you dragooned him into that situation, it's not your problem to solve.

TrashedSofa · 12/12/2023 16:38

BungleandGeorge · 12/12/2023 16:07

Not quite that simple. They’ve been married for 5 years, presuming this is uk they’re most likely entitled to 50:50 of all assets. One high earner and one low earner paying proportionately the same isn’t necessarily fair as the higher earner will have a lot more disposable income. So the way the split is, is making him intentionally poorer, but he should have more money for his first lot of children. She’s topping him up for luxuries but he’s actually entitled to half her assets.and of course OP hasn’t said how much he is actually paying.. If they weren’t married I’d agree with you.

OP and her DH aren't divorcing though? The typical provisions in respect of asset division on divorce in England and Wales aren't relevant to calculations of maintenance, and being married to someone doesn't entitle you to their income during the marriage. You're talking about things that kick in when the relationship ends.

Wallflower3 · 12/12/2023 16:38

Coconutter24 · 12/12/2023 13:48

It isn’t the case. It goes on the parents earnings

It’s not the case and nor should it be. Your step children are not your financial burden. I make more than my DH and his ex combined and I asked the solicitor before I married him if my salary and assets would ever be taken into account when married and he assured me absolutely not.

notlucreziaborgia · 12/12/2023 16:31

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 16:07

No the ex should not expect the OP’s cash but she should expect her children’s father to shoulder half the load. If that means he needs to step up financially or otherwise it is very likely to affect the OP’s life.

How OP and her DH work this out is a private matter

She can expect what she likes, but beyond the maintenance he gives her for the one day a week more she has them, he doesn’t in fact have to give her anything else.

OP doesn’t have to contribute money herself, and nor does she need to agree to him making any changes that would require her input.

notlucreziaborgia · 12/12/2023 16:29

BungleandGeorge · 12/12/2023 16:07

Not quite that simple. They’ve been married for 5 years, presuming this is uk they’re most likely entitled to 50:50 of all assets. One high earner and one low earner paying proportionately the same isn’t necessarily fair as the higher earner will have a lot more disposable income. So the way the split is, is making him intentionally poorer, but he should have more money for his first lot of children. She’s topping him up for luxuries but he’s actually entitled to half her assets.and of course OP hasn’t said how much he is actually paying.. If they weren’t married I’d agree with you.

Depends on whether she took measures to protect her assets prior to the marriage. Considering how concerned OP clearly is about her financial independence, I would suspect that she did.

There’s also the issue of the kids they share. He isn’t just responsible for his first two, but for his younger children as well.

tachycardigan · 12/12/2023 16:28

OP, are you coming back?

Pinkypup · 12/12/2023 16:27

If the kids are with you 3 nights a week, shouldn’t his payment go down and not up? She’s being a CF and you are 💯 not being unreasonable.

Zoreos · 12/12/2023 16:25

YANBU. Put your foot down Op and tell them both to get fucked the absolute pair of cheeky bastards. There shouldn’t be hardly any maintenance being paid as that’s nearly 50/50. Id ask how he’s going to expect to pay maintenance to your step kids and your shared kids if you leave him? I’d be leaving him if my husband was that grabby and inattentive to your needs. Talk about disrespecting the effort you put in to working for your wage. Suggest he gets a better job if he wants to pay more for maintenance but your shared children should get the same benefit.

Iloveacurry · 12/12/2023 16:13

What did he say when you said no?

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 16:12

BungleandGeorge · 12/12/2023 16:07

Not quite that simple. They’ve been married for 5 years, presuming this is uk they’re most likely entitled to 50:50 of all assets. One high earner and one low earner paying proportionately the same isn’t necessarily fair as the higher earner will have a lot more disposable income. So the way the split is, is making him intentionally poorer, but he should have more money for his first lot of children. She’s topping him up for luxuries but he’s actually entitled to half her assets.and of course OP hasn’t said how much he is actually paying.. If they weren’t married I’d agree with you.

CMS is only rated on the NRP’s salary. The household income, and how they split living costs in their home isn’t relevant, neither is remarriage

LolaSmiles · 12/12/2023 16:10

The problem when people, such as ex partners, often start going on about fairness, it's often in situations where their nose is out of joint that their ex has formed a relationship with someone earning a good salary. Conveniently, you don't see threads saying "my ex is living in a house share whilst I'm doing ok for myself, do you think I ought to top his bank balance up each week so it's fair for the children to have two nice homes?"

Children have a mother and a father. Setting aside situations where one parent fucks off or where the father is deliberately kept in the dark, they have two parents responsible for them financially. New partners don't need to be subsidising ex partners.

The same sort of thing happens in blended families when exes get their nose out of joint that their ex treats all his kids the same, but new partner is able to treat their children to more. Ex is usually furious.
In the world of the ex:
Their children: financially provided for by mother, father and generous top up from step mother
New partner's children: only get things from mother and father, and should have less from their mother because new partner should subsidise their step children (usually whilst screaming "but you chose a man with kids!!!")

BungleandGeorge · 12/12/2023 16:07

Not quite that simple. They’ve been married for 5 years, presuming this is uk they’re most likely entitled to 50:50 of all assets. One high earner and one low earner paying proportionately the same isn’t necessarily fair as the higher earner will have a lot more disposable income. So the way the split is, is making him intentionally poorer, but he should have more money for his first lot of children. She’s topping him up for luxuries but he’s actually entitled to half her assets.and of course OP hasn’t said how much he is actually paying.. If they weren’t married I’d agree with you.

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 16:07

No the ex should not expect the OP’s cash but she should expect her children’s father to shoulder half the load. If that means he needs to step up financially or otherwise it is very likely to affect the OP’s life.

How OP and her DH work this out is a private matter

Icantbedoingwithit · 12/12/2023 16:01

God no! Not a chance!

Museum10665 · 12/12/2023 16:00

@19lottie82 the question to ask your dh, would be if his ex were richer would they pay extra maintance ?

Treesinmygarden · 12/12/2023 15:57

No no no no no!!

Not your monkeys, not your circus,

Not sure why he's paying maintenance either, as they're practically 50-50.

This is a dealbreaker.

ElevenSeven · 12/12/2023 15:57

BungleandGeorge · 12/12/2023 15:50

For anyone to know whether this is fair you really need to say what he is paying for, for his first children? And what days is he looking after them? Is he doing a fair share of Monday to Friday?

None of this has any relevance to the OP being asked to contribute.

It’s not about making the children’s lives fair. It’s about who is responsible for who.

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 15:55

Thank you, @BungleandGeorge