Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's unreasonable, me, DH, his ex?

290 replies

onionparker · 12/12/2023 12:01

Me and DH have been married 5 years and together for 7. We share two children and I also have two DSC.

There has been a little bit of tension about this situation recently and wondering who you think is being unreasonable?

For context, I was in an abusive relationship during my teens and early twenties before I met DH, this included physical and financial. Because of this I don't like feeling trapped, which is exactly how I felt at the time (no money to leave), so I have always insisted on separate finances with DH. Not because I think I'll be leaving but it brings me comfort to know that I have my own money.

DH earns okay, I however earn more than he does and also have some inheritance from grandparents that was quite considerable that I used some of to put down a large deposit on our house etc.. for the first time in my life, in the past few years ive felt financially secure and like my hard work has paid off to get where i am with my career.

We split bills proportionately and whilst if something is needed I have no problem paying, I don't want to pool resources and never have. DH always accepted this before.

Anyway, DH always has his two older DC 3 nights a week. He pays maintenance to their mum and this obviously goes off his wage. He'll also give extra as and when he can if needed.

She has mentioned to him recently that she feels she needs more and we should consider paying maintenance based on household salary rather than just his. She has made comments like this in the past I.e. if I have a new car or I pay for us to go away (with DSC), she makes out like she's due something because of our "lifestyle".

DH now seems to think this may be a good idea and I could perhaps contribute more into the family pot so he can pay more or we could work out what it would be on our joint salary and pay that (Which is essentially just me paying maintenance as I'd be subsiding him to do so). I've told him absolutely not.

This is one of the exact kinds of scenarios I wanted to avoid by having separate finances. I don't want to be tied into supporting another household. DSC are his and their mums children and therefore any support should be based of his salary not mine. We obviously have children together than need my support. And I do actually spend a lot on DSC when they are with us and don't care about that at all but I don't want to commit to paying another woman when I don't need to.

So AIBU?

OP posts:
Crababbles · 12/12/2023 12:31

Workingmammabear · 12/12/2023 12:28

I am a SM to one DSD. OH and I pool our finances in a joint account. Yet Maintenance IS ONLY calculated on his salary. This has been argued with by the ex on numerous occasions, and we always end up with the same outcome. My salary is not available to her and never will be. I do however treat her daughter a lot and we have her 50/50 so she does get the benefit and isn't missing out.

Edited

If you have her 50/50 why is anyone paying anything?

poetryandwine · 12/12/2023 12:31

Hi, OP -

You sound very generous, and I voted YANBU, but there is always room for misunderstanding on Mumsnet. Like @Octavia64 I would want to confirm that your DH is paying at least the minimum support for a parent who has his DC three nights a week. And also to confirm that you are in a country like England where only the parent’s income is taken into account by the courts.

Then I would want to confirm that your generosity as a household with your DSC really does come close to 3/7 of their basic expenses. It’s great to give them treats and holidays, but are you paying proportionately for school uniforms, after school clubs, school trips, sporting and hobby expenses, presents to be bought, etc? This is the stuff that might be outside your awareness and could really add up. If their mum is absorbing a load of unseen expenses that is not right. Having the children 3/7 of the the time is seen by the courts as a proxy for covering 3/7 of their basic expenses.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 12/12/2023 12:31

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

What's your evidence for saying that the ex is correct?

Or are you just making shit up on the basis of what you think should happen?

Soubriquet · 12/12/2023 12:31

Not being unreasonable. They aren’t your children. They are your dh’s and ex wife’s. They are the ones who should be paying. It’s ok for you to buy things occasionally for the stepchildren but they aren’t your priority

Workingmammabear · 12/12/2023 12:30

@Babymamamama because they don't! They are not interested in my salary, only whether my OH has any other dependents.

Crababbles · 12/12/2023 12:30

Babymamamama · 12/12/2023 12:26

I thought CMS look at household income especially when you are married. Why do so many people think this is not the case?

No idea because it’s completely untrue. CMS is based on the non-resident parent’s income only.

OP, the only correct answer here is to laugh at them both. You’re already subsidising SC’s existence 3/7 days a week, you’re under no obligation to pay for them in their mother’s home.

OnlyFannys · 12/12/2023 12:30

If he wants to pay more he can do so from his own wage. He can absolutely get to fuck. She can also look at improving her own earning potential

bunniesandguineapigs · 12/12/2023 12:29

@Babymamamama because its not! It's calculated on the NRPs wages only - very clear on the CMS website and the calculator only asks for the paying parents income, not household income.

NoNoNanette · 12/12/2023 12:29

@onionparker

DH now seems to think this may be a good idea and I could perhaps contribute more into the family pot so he can pay more or we could work out what it would be on our joint salary and pay that (Which is essentially just me paying maintenance as I'd be subsiding him to do so). I've told him absolutely not.

You absolutely MUST stick to this. 'May be a good idea', 'family pot'? JESUS. Tempted to say he saw you coming. This happens such a lot.

I'm sorry if this sounds harsh, but if this was me, it would lead to a very VERY careful evaluation of whether I should be with that man, with a strong presumption that the answer is NO.

Have you got to wear Lidl jeans and shoes and go around in a rusty 1998 Nissan Micra in case ex-wifey kicks up a fuss?

Workingmammabear · 12/12/2023 12:28

I am a SM to one DSD. OH and I pool our finances in a joint account. Yet Maintenance IS ONLY calculated on his salary. This has been argued with by the ex on numerous occasions, and we always end up with the same outcome. My salary is not available to her and never will be. I do however treat her daughter a lot and we have her 50/50 so she does get the benefit and isn't missing out.

Weddingpuzzle · 12/12/2023 12:27

My DH has no children. I have 3DC with two different DF's (I have had a long, complex and colourful past). If I had my children 3 nights per week (I don't I have the youngest two 50:50 so there is no maintenance exchanged) but just say I had them 3 and their father had them 4 - would my DH be expected to contribute to my ex DH? Of course he wouldn't and exDH would be a cheeky fucker to expect that.

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 12/12/2023 12:27

Bloody cheek. If your DH was still with his ex, they would be living off their joint incomes to support their own children. Why do they think your money should come into it for maintenance for children who are not your own?

Babymamamama · 12/12/2023 12:26

I thought CMS look at household income especially when you are married. Why do so many people think this is not the case?

SinnerBoy · 12/12/2023 12:26

She's completely out of order and has absolutely no right to expect you to pay for her kids. As others have pointed out, the kids are with you for almost half the week, perhaps he should be paying less?

Is he a bit of a drip? Has she caused problems in the past, which he thinks he can avoid, by giving in to her?

Catsknowbest · 12/12/2023 12:26

Good God no. What a cheek!!

CombatBarbie · 12/12/2023 12:24

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

I hope your not in UK and telling folk that....

KombuchaKalling · 12/12/2023 12:24

She is majorly being unreasonable by being grabby and entitled. He is unreasonable for feeding into this nonsense. You are being completely reasonable. She doesn’t pay for your children and why should you pay for hers?

I would suggest she learns to manage her money better and / or earn more money. It’s not your problem.

noooooooo · 12/12/2023 12:20

God loves a trier eh. DH should have met that attempt with a big hearty lol. Definitely fucking not.

greencheetah · 12/12/2023 12:19

YANBU

Tell DH and his ex to fuck off

Octavia64 · 12/12/2023 12:19

There is a calculator available that tells you what the government cms service would assess him as needing to pay.

www.gov.uk/calculate-child-maintenance

If I were you I would check this and compare it to how much he pays already.

If he is paying less than the cms amount I would consider upping it (it's generally considered that the amounts from the calculator are low compared to how much children cost).

Otherwise, unless the kids are clearly not fed, no new clothes etc I wouldn't be considering upping it.

NoNoNanette · 12/12/2023 12:18

Agix · 12/12/2023 12:03

YANBU. Maintenance should be based on his salary. Sounds like ex is being grabby and unreasonable, and DH is being unreasonable agreeing with her.

I have seen this a number of times, a man with kids, their mother has custody, man starts relationship with a woman on a good salary, kiddy mother thinks 'we deserve a slice of that'. Or if not deserve, 'I bet I can shame him into it, the wimp'. With dire results if not firmly checked.

Workawayxx · 12/12/2023 12:18

YANBU. CMS does not take into account a partner/spouse's income, only the parent. The DSC are already benefiting (rightly of course) from the home that your inheritance has gone towards and presumably other things that are possible because you pay bills etc proportionately according to salary. The ex can asks for what she likes but your DH should absolutely say it's not possible.

SerenityNowInsanityLater · 12/12/2023 12:17

Heavens, I'd be rethinking my marriage to DH if he's so willing to drag you into his and his ex's responsibility. His ex divorced him, not you two. Cheeky fuckers, the pair of them. YA definitely NOT BU. And what about your children? I feel angry on your behalf. To quote Dave Chappelle, "Boundaries, bitch!"

muchalover · 12/12/2023 12:17

@Keepinmovin I disagree. I don't believe that courts are permitted to charge partners for kids that are literally nothing to do with them.

CombatBarbie · 12/12/2023 12:17

Namerequired · 12/12/2023 12:12

Forget the ex. She’s a cf but irrelevant. How and why does your dh expect you to fund his ex and children? Sure at nearly 50/50 there shouldn’t be much maintenance? Also he should be paying for them when they are with yous too. I hope you have protected your deposit, because it seems he has no issue taking from you.

This!!