Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think dentists just count teeth at an nhs checkup?

58 replies

Oucht · 12/12/2023 09:28

After the checkup I had yesterday - told something was looking ok just for the pain to become agonising during the day.. it got me thinking that NHS checkup is merely counting teeth. Is that the same for everyone who has an NHS dentist?

The teeth are not checked for problems unless you mention them. I said an old filling was catching food.. turns out the tooth next to it needs a filling.

The one that's hurting at the back.. second in molar.. is next to a large filling where I have bone loss which has always been a bit achey.. dentist said that all looked fine.. pain got worse.. now I'm having to go back tomorrow because when I look with a mirror at the back of my tooth it has a big crack through it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Reugny · 13/12/2023 15:19

TheMiddleLight · 12/12/2023 13:04

They get paid a set, shitty amount for each NHS appointment.
...

It’s the private work that pays the bills, the wages etc, and means that they can still offer some form of NHS treatment, because god knows that without the private work, there would be zero chance of them making a wage.

You must be a dentist or related to one, judging by your entire post?

Anyway, the bolded is most likely why some of them are shit with NHS patients. I bet they aren't that way with private ones.

Lots of NHS practices do a mixture of NHS and private work.

Mine does.

So it isn't in any dentists interest to be shitty to patients as don't know from how people are dressed who will be able to pay for a particular piece of private work.

XenoBitch · 13/12/2023 02:41

YANBU
Most of my friends have NHS dentists, and they just get the most basic of checks.
During a checkup, my NHS dentist told the nurse I had a shadow over one of my teeth (and said it could be a something sinister), and a few cavities. She just told me to come back in 6 months.
It has been the same with a lot of people I know.. they have a check up but know they will need a filling etc. But nothing gets done.
Saying that, out of desperation, I went private and had the same experience. Had a tooth removed due to infection, but everything else ignored.

MrsFezziwig · 13/12/2023 02:29

What is the position with X-rays? Years ago I used to have X-rays once every 3-4 years purely as a checkup, but have never had them with my current dentist (who is relatively young). As a former radiographer I assumed this was because it’s no longer encouraged (in general) to use X-rays as a screening tool where avoidable, but it seems that’s not the case?

Ludoole · 13/12/2023 02:08

My dentist spent a few minutes looking, then said I needed to make an appointment with the hygienist. I can't afford to keep seeing the hygienist on top of paying for my actual dentist to look in my mouth briefly...

TheFormidableMrsC · 13/12/2023 00:31

My dentist is great. Yes he counts but he also checks each tooth and checks all round my mouth and under my tongue for anything dodgy. He gives them a descale too if they need it. Yours dentist just sounds shit.

Violinist64 · 13/12/2023 00:27

My lovely NHS dentist, who is a similar age to me, has recently retired. We have also moved to a different part of the country and have arranged to have a private dentist while on the waiting list for an NHS dentist at the same practice. I have annual checkups and am usually fine. My dentist was always very thorough and l had x-rays and a scale and polish. Occasionally, the need for treatment would arise and she was always extremely caring and understanding. I had part of a tooth break earlier this year and she told me there was no decay and she built it up with glass isonomer, telling me that, as we get older, our teeth have been working very hard and that it is not unusual to have the odd problem here and there. I am in my (very) late fifties and, apart from the teeth that were removed during orthodontic work because of overcrowding, have all my teeth and plan to keep them for the rest of my life. I do have some fillings, as does nearly everyone my age but on the whole my teeth are strong and I thank my wonderful NHS dentists for helping me to keep them that way.

Circularargument · 13/12/2023 00:03

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 12/12/2023 09:44

They used to do a scale and polish at a check up. Thats stopped now.

Mine still does

DontGoGran · 12/12/2023 23:46

We get judged for DD having a dummy, and then the Dentist quickly checks us both over and is seemingly disappointed that there is absolutely nothing wrong with my teeth and I've never had a filling, gum disease or required any treatment other than the extensive orthodontic work I had as a child to correct overcrowding.

She seems to want to find fault, then sighs and tells me my teeth are fine! But I'm not complaining because at least we're NHS patients so if I do need treatment I'd actually be able to afford it in the future.

ThreeTreeHill · 12/12/2023 23:40

HandyLittleGadget · 12/12/2023 10:53

I went to the dentist recently, after not having a check-up for 2 years. The dentist asked me a few questions (I haven't had toothache or any problems), counted my teeth, said all is fine and she'll see me in a year. I asked if they do a scrape and polish or if that'd be extra. "Oh, we can do that now, if you like", she said - and she did, but I had to ask for that. £25.70 in total, for 5 minutes "work". They're making a fortune.

The £25.70 doesn't go to the dentist, it goes straight back into the NHS. The NHS sells a contract to the practice to carry out a certain amount of work and pays the practice a lump sum to carry out that amount of worm. The dentist will get paid per unit of work, this fee is set by the practice and is different dentist to dentist but is no where near £25.70

Patients fees don't go to the practice.

For a scale and polish and a proper check up £25.70 is a bargain. If your scale and polish took less than 5 minutes you didn't need it, and the dentist was essentially doing you a favour.

ThreeTreeHill · 12/12/2023 23:36

Obviously the dentist doesn't just count teeth. The number of your teeth is unlikely to change check up to check up, you call it the number of the tooth once you have examined it so the nurse knows where you are on the exam

Also a 'huge crack' doesn't mean anything. Could be a deep fissure, could be staining. Could be cracked that's perfectly fine to leave.

hogangogs · 12/12/2023 23:22

@Tacotortoise I’m not excusing shitty dentists. There are shit dentists who charge private fees and there are shit dentists who take on NHS contracts. neither of those things are okay. my point was that i don’t think people realise how dentists are paid. and it’s comments / patients’ attitudes like “they get paid to count teeth” that mean that lots of dentists retire very early. fewer dentists = fewer nhs dentists.

Oucht · 12/12/2023 13:50

No xrays here, or cleaning, or checking the jaw or under the tongue. Only looking at certain teeth if mentioned that something is wrong...
9am yesterday it didn't hurt and now it's agony. They're gonna think I'm crazy despite the huge crack they can't miss... again.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 12/12/2023 13:45

RedHelenB · 12/12/2023 10:26

Ours still.do. And xrays

Mine too.

caringcarer · 12/12/2023 13:44

Mine calls out numbers, then checks gums, then gives me a scale and polish and an occasional X-ray. If they don't offer a scale and polish I ask for one. It's NHS dentist but DH and I pay. FS is 17 so still free but I have noticed he's in and out in about 1-2 minutes.

Oucht · 12/12/2023 13:40

The pain is unbearable right now.
I know tomorrow if they agree something needs doing ... which it does.. hubby has looked and can clearly see the tooth is cracked all the way through the back.. that I am going to have to wait until the new year at least.

OP posts:
Tacotortoise · 12/12/2023 13:37

hogangogs · 12/12/2023 12:37

to the PP saying “i wonder how much they got paid for that?” - the answer is barely anything. Dentists don’t get a salary from the NHS like most doctors do. They get paid a set, shitty amount for each NHS appointment. This amount is nothing compared to all the overheads they have, which is why most also take on private patients. It’s the private work that pays the bills, the wages etc, and means that they can still offer some form of NHS treatment, because god knows that without the private work, there would be zero chance of them making a wage.

People love to complain about dentists - if all they do is count teeth and get paid a shit load for doing it, there wouldn’t be a shortage of them now would there?

OK but either accept the fee and do a competent job or dont accept it at all - that's unethical. My last nhs dentist didn't do enough to justify even a shitty fee. Prior to 2010 though I had years of good NHS dental treatment.

Hibbs126 · 12/12/2023 13:17

At my last appointment they did a quick check of my teeth and gums and then asked if I had any problems. I said it felt like I had holes in 2 of my teeth and they asked where then agreed I had holes and needed fillings so can't have done a very good initial check! However, that will be my last nhs appointment as the practice is stopping nhs treatment in January so need to start saving so I can afford private treatment but won't be paying to see the same dentist that's for sure!

Crooklodge · 12/12/2023 13:08

Mine checks every single tooth, along under the jaw up to the joint, scale & polish and yearly x-ray. He's the only decent nhs dentist I've met in my 37years.

TheMiddleLight · 12/12/2023 13:04

They get paid a set, shitty amount for each NHS appointment.
...

It’s the private work that pays the bills, the wages etc, and means that they can still offer some form of NHS treatment, because god knows that without the private work, there would be zero chance of them making a wage.

You must be a dentist or related to one, judging by your entire post?

Anyway, the bolded is most likely why some of them are shit with NHS patients. I bet they aren't that way with private ones.

TheMiddleLight · 12/12/2023 13:00

I had an NHS dentist who was wonderful. Each visit was as some pp described with their good dentists. Unfortunately, we had to move and I haven't found good enough NHS dentists ever since. Worse is that since Covid, it's been in and out like the OP and some pp have described.

I just mainly pay to go to the hygienist now. If she sees any problem, then I'll go for a checkup with the dentist. The dentist is awful, always in a hurry and distant, bordering on rude, but the hygienist is lovely.

hogangogs · 12/12/2023 12:37

to the PP saying “i wonder how much they got paid for that?” - the answer is barely anything. Dentists don’t get a salary from the NHS like most doctors do. They get paid a set, shitty amount for each NHS appointment. This amount is nothing compared to all the overheads they have, which is why most also take on private patients. It’s the private work that pays the bills, the wages etc, and means that they can still offer some form of NHS treatment, because god knows that without the private work, there would be zero chance of them making a wage.

People love to complain about dentists - if all they do is count teeth and get paid a shit load for doing it, there wouldn’t be a shortage of them now would there?

ChangeNameLikeIChangeSocks · 12/12/2023 12:32

I'm so sorry to heap a bit of bitterness onto your thread, but here goes, at least you have an nhs dentist 😪

Ethelburgha · 12/12/2023 12:28

Mukey · 12/12/2023 12:21

As I've said I work in dentistry and have in the past worked in NHS dentistry as a dental nurse. I am the first to admit there are terrible dentists out there not doing their job properly. I've seen it with my own eyes and some of them should not be practicing.
But i do just want to say that in SOME cases (not all) peoples version of 5 mins is very off.
Even now as a Hygienist I have people telling me that the previous Hygienist they saw only cleaned their teeth for 5 minutes. But they have forgotten that I was their previous Hygienist and I most certainly did not only spend 5 mins. The quickest I can manage cleaning someone's full mouth is 15 mins. And that's because I either have to rush because they've arrived late or something. Unless the person has 3 teeth left its impossible to do it in 5 mins.
I cannot comment on what an individual dentist has or has not done obviously. Just that what people experience as 5 mins is often inaccurate and its been more like 15.
NHS check ups are usually booked for 15 mins in a busy practice. (30 if the dentist is generous). But in that 15 mins it includes checking your medical history and asking if you have any issues. Charting what teeth you have and any issues. Taking an x ray if required. Then treatment planning anything and possibly a scale and polish if clinically necessary. As well as cleaning up the surgery after. That's actually a lot to do in 15 mins.
Do some dentists skip lots of this? I'm sure they do. And they shouldn't.
The other issue is scale and polish. Under band one these days it's only if clinically necessary. So removing some tea staining for example they do not have to do.
What I do find a lot is dentists telling patients to see the Hygienist as they have gum disease or lots of plaque. This they should not be doing. If they have gum disease or lots of plaque meaning the patient cannot clean well then this should be offered under the NHS as it IS clinically necessary.

I go to the dentist with my 11 yr old son and I time the amount of time he gets in the chair at his NHS check up and it is definitely less than five minutes by my iPhone’s stopwatch.

Glad to hear that your practice is less stingy with its time.

Ethelburgha · 12/12/2023 12:26

YANBU. I asked my dentist if he could scrape a bit of stubborn plaque off. He said you’ll need to pay for that as you “only get the basic clean on the NHS”.

I said but if I’m supposed to get a basic clean on the NHS how come I never get any clean at all at these check ups?

He looked guilty and grudgingly scraped off the plaque but yanbu.

Mukey · 12/12/2023 12:21

As I've said I work in dentistry and have in the past worked in NHS dentistry as a dental nurse. I am the first to admit there are terrible dentists out there not doing their job properly. I've seen it with my own eyes and some of them should not be practicing.
But i do just want to say that in SOME cases (not all) peoples version of 5 mins is very off.
Even now as a Hygienist I have people telling me that the previous Hygienist they saw only cleaned their teeth for 5 minutes. But they have forgotten that I was their previous Hygienist and I most certainly did not only spend 5 mins. The quickest I can manage cleaning someone's full mouth is 15 mins. And that's because I either have to rush because they've arrived late or something. Unless the person has 3 teeth left its impossible to do it in 5 mins.
I cannot comment on what an individual dentist has or has not done obviously. Just that what people experience as 5 mins is often inaccurate and its been more like 15.
NHS check ups are usually booked for 15 mins in a busy practice. (30 if the dentist is generous). But in that 15 mins it includes checking your medical history and asking if you have any issues. Charting what teeth you have and any issues. Taking an x ray if required. Then treatment planning anything and possibly a scale and polish if clinically necessary. As well as cleaning up the surgery after. That's actually a lot to do in 15 mins.
Do some dentists skip lots of this? I'm sure they do. And they shouldn't.
The other issue is scale and polish. Under band one these days it's only if clinically necessary. So removing some tea staining for example they do not have to do.
What I do find a lot is dentists telling patients to see the Hygienist as they have gum disease or lots of plaque. This they should not be doing. If they have gum disease or lots of plaque meaning the patient cannot clean well then this should be offered under the NHS as it IS clinically necessary.

Swipe left for the next trending thread