Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel deflated after a charity xmas do hearing a paid worker saying it was a 'free lunch' for them?

437 replies

YNK · 11/12/2023 23:45

I had an injury and joined a great charity group a few years ago to meet for coffee once a week and to enjoy activities and support each other.

Some members are in residential care due to the severity of their condition so they are always accompanied by carers, others have fully recovered.
Members pay for activities and weekly meetings and pay happily and willingly for the chance to meet and socialise.

Some members have suffered and been compensated legally for injuries caused and many are now financially secure and if assistance is provided, I feel this 'them and us' divide is hurtful.

After a very nice xmas lunch, as we were leaving a group of paid carers could be heard saying it was at least a decent 'free lunch'

I feel grubby now and I'm thinking of leaving the group - AIBU?

OP posts:
Neriah · 12/12/2023 11:30

You know what? It's kind of interesting reading the OP's various claims. The carers were there working but they weren't there working. They were being paid or they weren't being paid. And my personal favourite, they have never seen this person ever before, but they knew they were a carer even though they weren't working as one. Plus, interesting timing - an insomniac poster.

Hmm. I have an opinion....

user1497207191 · 12/12/2023 11:20

There is nearly always a kind of friction where volunteers and paid staff work together in charities, museums, care homes, hospitals, etc.

At the end of the day, most staff are there because they have to in order to earn a living. That's completely different to volunteers who want to be there to help people or contribute to a good cause etc.

I've been involved in quite a few small/local charities, good causes, etc., as a volunteer, and you just have to get accustomed to the "paid" staff seeing it as just a job, starting/finishing at official working hours, not turning up for evening/weekend "socials".

TreacleMines · 12/12/2023 11:16

SgtBilko · 12/12/2023 10:57

And because it is work it is unprofessional to make comments like that within earshot of the service users. What if your GP said within your earshot, ‘At least I get paid for seeing her?’ I think you would be pretty upset.

It was impolitic of the carer to be overheard- as a manager I would say “next time keep those comments out of ear shot of service users, it’s unprofessional”…

in the same way as I as a social worker might say to my colleague “ffs I’ve got to do a home visit to X family, I hate going, last time there was shit on the sofa… I don’t know if it dog shit or human shit”- but I wouldn’t say it on the families doorstep!

Peach0123 · 12/12/2023 11:04

OP as a carer YABU big time. One of the first thing we are taught in training is that although we may be 'close' in a way to service users, we are NOT friends, a line that shouldn't be crossed. It sounds like you have now worked this out and are disappointed. There could have been many reasons for the comment, you only heard what the man said, not the context. Sounds like he was looking at the positive.

  • annual leave could have been refused in order to attend
  • the event went on longer than planned
  • carer didn't get a break that day
  • carer was called in to cover on a day off
  • They might not have won on tombolla 🤣

I really hope you have only came on here to vent and haven't went to the others in the group stirring them up. That really wouldn't be fair at all on anyone. Also you would look like a trouble maker, one to watch.

Move on from this and enjoy you actual friends, respect the carers a bit more and dont dampen what was a nice lunch for others.

TinkerTiger · 12/12/2023 11:03

YNK · 12/12/2023 01:28

I appreciate all your comments especially those who understand how demeaning this comment felt to me personally but more for my friends who need to accept they need assistance through no fault of theirs.
They are not to blame for needing help and we have all contributed to financing this.
They benefit from paid work and we appreciate their help, which is why we wanted them to have a nice time with us.
If I had a guest in my home I wouldn't invite them back if that was their parting shot at xmas!

It's demeaning working in a challenging job for abysmal pay.

JustAGirlScotland · 12/12/2023 10:59

I think the issue here is that fundamentally life is NOT a Hallmark movie. No matter how much you wish it were it's just not.

SgtBilko · 12/12/2023 10:57

Imagwine · 12/12/2023 09:17

It’s definitely work. A big bonus if you enjoy it and you get a decent free lunch, but at the end if the day I think some would have preferred to have been paid and at home. Not all. Some would enjoy the social occasion for itself, but look at the threads on here, there are an awful lot of unsociable buggers around. For some people it’s a strain to socialise, but it might be more palatable if at least they get a decent free meal.

And because it is work it is unprofessional to make comments like that within earshot of the service users. What if your GP said within your earshot, ‘At least I get paid for seeing her?’ I think you would be pretty upset.

inamarina · 12/12/2023 10:53

LadyBird1973 · 12/12/2023 06:39

I think the OP has expressed herself well.

Being a carer is not quite the same as working in an office and this lunch isn't exactly the same as going to the office work do. The boundaries are not so clearly defined, when one person is helping another with their day to day lives, including social activities. The OP felt that the carers were also a legitimate part of the group, even though being there is part of their paid employment - she values them and wanted them to feel welcomed and included.
That very crass comment made it clear that, to some carers, it literally is just about work and they don't feel bonded to the group at all. That is hurtful.
The group was doing a nice thing and the OP feels that carer was disparaging about it.

I guess maybe it's comparable to the situation in other workplaces where some people feel their colleagues have also become their friends and then finding out that the colleague views them as just someone they work with. The colleague has a right to feel that way, but it's still a hurtful thing to hear and a crass thing to say out loud.

OP, try not to let this ruin the group for you - your friends are still your friends and this one person's rude behaviour doesn't necessarily reflect how other carers feel.

But isn’t it too much to expect the carers to bond with the group?
Each one of them is in charge of one of the service users, that’s their job.
That doesn’t mean they have to see them as friends.
Isn’t it difficult enough to get people into care work? It’s a hard job, usually not very well paid - and that’s without the expectation that they should see it as more than ‘just work’.

novhange · 12/12/2023 10:45

YNK · 12/12/2023 02:28

Yes I feel my boundaries have been disrespected and more to the point those who are forced to be passive recipients of this disrespect.
They were not forced or obliged to accept our invitation.

Our work Christmas lunch is in a very fancy restaurant, all paid for by our company. I don't want to attend as I feel I'm over worked and underpaid and I don't want to validate the senior staff by celebrating with them. Whilst technically I could opt out, in practice this would mean offending my boss and pushing back my chances of a pay rise even further.

So there is often is an obligation on employees to attend.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 12/12/2023 10:28

Carer works in care home. Manager “do you mind supporting X to attend their charity event? You’ll need to finish a bit later but Lunch will be included” Carer “sure, but I’ll have to find someone to pick the kids up from school/pay for after school club”.

at the lunch, carer to another carer “it’s been a bit of a pain as mum couldn’t pick the kids up so I’ve had to pay for after school club, but at least we got a nice free lunch”.

OP over hears and is offended.

it’s their job OP. I’m sure they’re fond enough of those they support, but they’re still at work and may well have to sort life out around it.

Catsmere · 12/12/2023 10:22

Dontbeme · 12/12/2023 10:14

Person A: Are you okay, you look very tired?
Person B: Today was supposed to be my day off but the boss insisted I come to this lunch. Had to rearrange childcare and get two buses to the venue in the pissing rain. But as least it was a nice free lunch.
OP: Earwigging someone else's conversation "The ungrateful peasants, how dare they".

But more seriously, maybe this person was tired and running on empty, maybe they are the ungrateful sort and a bit rude. Whichever it was please don't let one careless comment ruin your enjoyment of the time spent with this group and maybe give the poor overworked underpaid carers a break. I have family that work in various caring roles and they never seen to be "off", they are always getting one quick question or request outside of working hours.

Yes, as you said, OP was eavesdropping on someone else's conversation. The bloke's comment was none of her business.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 12/12/2023 10:20

Apologies as I haven't RTFT but do you mind if I ask what your injury was, OP?

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 12/12/2023 10:17

I’m sure they’re happy enough supporting people to attend events, but for them it is work. They are at work and who doesn’t love a free lunch when working. I think you’re over reacting OP.

Dontbeme · 12/12/2023 10:14

Person A: Are you okay, you look very tired?
Person B: Today was supposed to be my day off but the boss insisted I come to this lunch. Had to rearrange childcare and get two buses to the venue in the pissing rain. But as least it was a nice free lunch.
OP: Earwigging someone else's conversation "The ungrateful peasants, how dare they".

But more seriously, maybe this person was tired and running on empty, maybe they are the ungrateful sort and a bit rude. Whichever it was please don't let one careless comment ruin your enjoyment of the time spent with this group and maybe give the poor overworked underpaid carers a break. I have family that work in various caring roles and they never seen to be "off", they are always getting one quick question or request outside of working hours.

Workworkandmoreworknow · 12/12/2023 10:13

did you expect them to pay for their lunch? you do understand that they are at work and doing whatever it is their client wants them to? so why would you expect them to pay for their lunch?

BIossomtoes · 12/12/2023 10:13

I thought they were invited to be our friends and not considered as mere dogsbodies.

This is astonishingly naive. They were paid to be there because it’s part of their job.

Catsmere · 12/12/2023 10:11

PuzzledObserver · 12/12/2023 09:58

I’m a volunteer driver with a community car scheme. I ferry older and disabled people to and from appointments. Some have very poor mobility and need assistance getting in and out of the car or carrying things. It’s not the same as being a carer, but there are similarities:

However friendly and chatty I may be, clients are not my friends. Some tell me quite a bit about their life. That’s their choice, and it’s kept in confidence - but I have no obligation to tell them anything about my life. I’m also under no obligation to do anything for them beyond transport and carrying things if needed, and certainly not to do things for/with them at other times.

The vast majority of clients understand this. The odd one pushes the boundary, asking me to attend social events with them or take them shopping. My response is always - if you need transport to go to X, please book it with the office.

Some may think I should do more…… I disagree. I give what I have decided to give.

Yes, this.

It's basically a more involved and intimate form of customer service.

TreacleMines · 12/12/2023 10:08

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 12/12/2023 10:03

I'm wondering if there was an expectation that the carers would do a toast or speech of thanks at the end of the meal for being 'treated' to the lunch, and rather than that op overhead what she did?

I think it’s more likely that the op has internalised some of the ‘disabled people are lesser’ attitudes that as disabled people we deal with all the time- and it has become a sore spot for her and made her very sensitive to any perceived slight.

It can be a hard transition to go from moving through the world independently with everyone seeing you as basically their equal, to suddenly being a ‘job’ for someone… it’s understandable that some people want to see their carers as friends who want to spend time with them rather than just because they are being paid.

It isn’t a lot of fun to rely heavily on someone you know doesn’t really care in a personal way…

it’s a bit like therapists- they only listen to your problems because they are paid to, and only care in a professional way- except disabled people can be stuck with that kind of relationship as their primary relationship in most areas of their life.

threecupsofteaminimum · 12/12/2023 10:07

You're being ridiculous, it was probably said tongue in cheek and even if it's wasn't it's hardly a terrible thing you need to start bitching about online Hmm

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 12/12/2023 10:03

I'm wondering if there was an expectation that the carers would do a toast or speech of thanks at the end of the meal for being 'treated' to the lunch, and rather than that op overhead what she did?

PuzzledObserver · 12/12/2023 09:58

I’m a volunteer driver with a community car scheme. I ferry older and disabled people to and from appointments. Some have very poor mobility and need assistance getting in and out of the car or carrying things. It’s not the same as being a carer, but there are similarities:

However friendly and chatty I may be, clients are not my friends. Some tell me quite a bit about their life. That’s their choice, and it’s kept in confidence - but I have no obligation to tell them anything about my life. I’m also under no obligation to do anything for them beyond transport and carrying things if needed, and certainly not to do things for/with them at other times.

The vast majority of clients understand this. The odd one pushes the boundary, asking me to attend social events with them or take them shopping. My response is always - if you need transport to go to X, please book it with the office.

Some may think I should do more…… I disagree. I give what I have decided to give.

Mirabai · 12/12/2023 09:56

You seem very preoccupied with money - who’s paid what and to whom. And reference a “hurtful” divide between those who have received compensation and are now “financially secure” (although presumably very badly injured!)

You say you don’t want to “hear your friends being patronised”, but aren’t you patronising the carers for not doing a good enough of pretending to be your friends and reminding you this is is paid work for them?

TreacleMines · 12/12/2023 09:51

YNK · 12/12/2023 01:35

Not at all!
I have made significant financial contribution to the charity as have most of my friends and I attended in hope we could all enjoy each others contribution as equals.
We are all just an accident away from needing that help.

@YNK I think this is where the problem lies- you wanted to have a party with friends with whom you have an equal relationship- but these people are carers, not friends. Your relationship isn’t equal.

The fact is that for them, spending time with the service users is work. They don’t do it out of friendship (even if they happen to like the people they support)- they do it because they need the job for the money.

So if they didn’t have to for work reasons, they wouldn’t have come to your party, and given the choice they would rather have been somewhere else.

Thats no reflection on anyone in your group, it’s just the nature of the relationship between disabled service users and paid carers.

Rachie1973 · 12/12/2023 09:49

YNK · 12/12/2023 02:33

I haven't required or needed them.
I was only happy to show appreciation for their care of others, for which they are paid but I'm not party to their terms of pay or conditions, nor are any of our members.

As a career I’ll tell you, we’re not ‘allowed’ to be friends with our clients.

Yes, clients. A ‘friendship’ crosses professional boundaries and leaves people open to all sorts of problems. We can be chatty and friendly and even have some type of banter with certain clients we know well. We cannot be their friend though. We cannot really accept gifts beyond an odd bottle of wine or box of chocs. We cannot nip to the pub for a quick pint with them. We can’t lend them a tenner or run them to their Mums. Those are things that ‘friends’ do.

Your invite to a Christmas meal would have been seen as an extension of work. Just coming shows a respect that you seem to think is missing.

SnowSwan · 12/12/2023 09:47

I do think you have an unrealistic impression of what a carer and service user relationship looks like. It is just work. Poorly paid work at that. Most carers are not in the job because they actually care and those that do care eventually become jaded like the rest over time because of how awful they are treated. Expecting them to be very grateful for a meal is a bit...glory seeking, or something. "Look how kind we are to you poor carers."

It's like in any job where you're treated like shit and management comes to you and says "WE have decided to treat you all to a free cupcake as a way of saying thank you!" and then pat themselves on the back thinking about what kind and generous people they are to their workers. When what workers really want is to be treated better by their employers and to be paid a wage that reflects their hard work.

Your Xmas dinner is that free cupcake. But saying that, that carer who you overheard was an idiot to voice his feelings openly like that. Very unprofessional.

Swipe left for the next trending thread