Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel deflated after a charity xmas do hearing a paid worker saying it was a 'free lunch' for them?

437 replies

YNK · 11/12/2023 23:45

I had an injury and joined a great charity group a few years ago to meet for coffee once a week and to enjoy activities and support each other.

Some members are in residential care due to the severity of their condition so they are always accompanied by carers, others have fully recovered.
Members pay for activities and weekly meetings and pay happily and willingly for the chance to meet and socialise.

Some members have suffered and been compensated legally for injuries caused and many are now financially secure and if assistance is provided, I feel this 'them and us' divide is hurtful.

After a very nice xmas lunch, as we were leaving a group of paid carers could be heard saying it was at least a decent 'free lunch'

I feel grubby now and I'm thinking of leaving the group - AIBU?

OP posts:
WonderLife · 12/12/2023 13:23

Sounds like the carer was just happy to get a free lunch?

No, they're not there as friends, but it is nice to have their work appreciated and valued by the charity and service users and to be invited for lunch.

Verv · 12/12/2023 13:13

TreacleMines · 12/12/2023 13:07

You are right- it is dehumanising to always be on the receiving end of the relationship. Always be the job, the work, the burden, when you would much rather wipe your own arse and go out to lunch without needing a carer to wash you first.

So it probably would have been a better idea to keep the comments out of earshot of the service users (who after all, are as much screwed over by the shit show that is the ‘care industry’ as the carers are)…

in the same vein as you probably wouldn’t stand chatting to your colleagues about your baby shower at the weekend when you are the sister on a wards of women who have just had miscarriages or still births, and standing next to a patient’s bed.

Undertakers are only there doing undertaking for the money, but they still try to behave in a solemn way when near the family even though they don’t give a shit about the deceased in a personal sense.

Yeah, they should've made certain they were out of earshot for sure.

LadyBird1973 · 12/12/2023 13:13

@inamarina obviously no one has^^ to feel a bond with their clients. I think it's just jarring if you have thought of everyone as part of the group and then realise you are just work for some of the people there.

Years ago, when I was a childminder, I was invited sometimes to children's birthday parties. Yes, looking after them was my job, but still, it was nice to be acknowledged by their parents as important to their children - that's the closest comparison I personally have. I might not have always wanted to go but it would have been rude to say anything remotely negative while at those events.

TomeTome · 12/12/2023 13:13

It’s less about being grateful and more about being polite. Who wants to here someone say stuff like that after spending time with them?

Again being on a low income does not excuse you from being kind or polite.

nothingcomestonothing · 12/12/2023 13:08

I attended in hope we could all enjoy each others contribution as equals.

I thought they were invited to be our friends and not considered as mere dogsbodies.

OP you seem to be upset because the comment you heard forced you to recognise that the carers are not you or your fellow attendees' friends, and you are not at the event as equals. But that's the truth. You want the carers to want to be there, and to see it as a social event rather than a work thing, but it isn't, for them. As PP said, the comment burst your bubble.

You don't like that you are a service user and other see you and your group members as such. It's not up to the carers to pretend that a work function is their chosen social activity, so that you don't have to acknowledge reality. I'm sorry if that sounds harsh, but you don't seem to be taking on board what many posters have tried to say to you.

TreacleMines · 12/12/2023 13:07

Verv · 12/12/2023 12:50

Let me assure you that while you and your friends are not party to their pay and conditions, they will be utterly shit and the renumeration for dealing with personal care is so utterly shit that a "free lunch" is seen as comfort and respite, which is likely why the statement was made.

These people are not your friends, or your servants, or your gracious proletariat, in the exact way that you are not their friends, masters, or charitable providers of food.

The only contract they have with your circle is to provide care those that they are assigned to.
A free lunch is a work perk, and it is how it is viewed across the board.

I realise that it's dehumanising, but it's how the care industry works.

You are right- it is dehumanising to always be on the receiving end of the relationship. Always be the job, the work, the burden, when you would much rather wipe your own arse and go out to lunch without needing a carer to wash you first.

So it probably would have been a better idea to keep the comments out of earshot of the service users (who after all, are as much screwed over by the shit show that is the ‘care industry’ as the carers are)…

in the same vein as you probably wouldn’t stand chatting to your colleagues about your baby shower at the weekend when you are the sister on a wards of women who have just had miscarriages or still births, and standing next to a patient’s bed.

Undertakers are only there doing undertaking for the money, but they still try to behave in a solemn way when near the family even though they don’t give a shit about the deceased in a personal sense.

SweatpantPotato · 12/12/2023 13:04

We have a charity that comes to my work in a offer free hot lunch to anyone who needs it. The charity workers don't judge the circumstances of the folks who take advantage of the meals. Sometimes our staff members will grab one, and I'm glad they do, less waste and you never know who is struggling.

Verv · 12/12/2023 12:50

YNK · 12/12/2023 02:33

I haven't required or needed them.
I was only happy to show appreciation for their care of others, for which they are paid but I'm not party to their terms of pay or conditions, nor are any of our members.

Let me assure you that while you and your friends are not party to their pay and conditions, they will be utterly shit and the renumeration for dealing with personal care is so utterly shit that a "free lunch" is seen as comfort and respite, which is likely why the statement was made.

These people are not your friends, or your servants, or your gracious proletariat, in the exact way that you are not their friends, masters, or charitable providers of food.

The only contract they have with your circle is to provide care those that they are assigned to.
A free lunch is a work perk, and it is how it is viewed across the board.

I realise that it's dehumanising, but it's how the care industry works.

Holly60 · 12/12/2023 12:49

YNK · 11/12/2023 23:55

Yes it was a fact, and before my injury I had a position where I attended events in a similar capacity but I felt privileged and honoured to be invited, not that it was a compensation.

I really don't feel this was a comment in the xmas spirit at all.

Wasn't the carer there to look after someone? So they were working? They got a free lunch at work and commented that it was nice. I don't get what they've done wrong?

bridgetreilly · 12/12/2023 12:46

OP is massively unreasonable and not interested in what anyone else has to say. I think we can all just be glad we didn’t have to go to lunch with her and pretend it was a huge privilege for us.

TrinityTinselBalls · 12/12/2023 12:36

YNK · 11/12/2023 23:55

Yes it was a fact, and before my injury I had a position where I attended events in a similar capacity but I felt privileged and honoured to be invited, not that it was a compensation.

I really don't feel this was a comment in the xmas spirit at all.

Gosh

CaramelMac · 12/12/2023 12:22

They may have wanted to be there but then had something else come up after they’d accepted the invitation, it could’ve been “I had to miss my child’s nativity to come to this, but at least is was a decent free meal” referencing a previous Christmas meal they’d had that wasn’t nice.

OP you wanted to show your gratitude but you did that in a way that suited you, much like people who buy gifts they themselves would want. You didn’t consider whether the carers would want a group meal out, they may have appreciated your gratitude more if it had been in the form of a supermarket gift card which would always be welcomed by someone on low pay at this time of year.

itsmylife7 · 12/12/2023 12:17

you've got very 'robotic" answers OP.

Another one who sees nothing wrong .

Unless you wanted the carers to be so grateful to be invited to (for them boring )
Christmas lunch.

It's not like they could have few drinks and dance on the tables, as they were in Work Mode !

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 12/12/2023 12:17

mantyzer · 12/12/2023 12:07

Someone saying "at least I get paid for seeing her" within earshot is unprofessional. We all know some people are more difficult than others, but you dont say it to the people you are working with.

In the OP it said the carers said “at least it was a decent free lunch” which I could have been the end of all sorts of sentences talking about things they had to rearrange/miss to be there.

it didn’t say at least I get paid for seeing her, which would be mean if said in earshot of the service user.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 12/12/2023 12:09

It's all about money ! with the OP.

So how much did it cost you for the carers to attend ?

Did you pay £50 for lunch with £2.50 going towards the carer's ' free ' lunch ?

or did the carers' free lunch come out of your annual subscription to the charity i.e. you pay £3 a month and 15p of that went for the carers lunch ?

Thus when the OP left she expected ( and needed ) the carers to stand at the front door in a line doffing their caps and bowing / curtsying saying Thank you Thank you Thank you !

and what is

' Some members have suffered and been compensated legally for injuries caused and many are now financially secure and if assistance is provided, I feel this 'them and us' divide is hurtful. '

all about ?

It reads like the OP is jealous that some of her friends have been so badly injured that they received compensation and with some of that compensation they ( have to ? ) pay for care as opposed to ' free ' care that may be provided by the NHS / Government / Local Authority.
( I have no idea how care is paid for, nor by whom - but it's not free it is paid for somehow, whether from NI contributions / Income Tax / wages or pension etc. )

Or maybe the OP begrudged having to contribute somehow to the carers ' free ' lunch for which they are expected to be grateful for the rest of their lives, when her friends could pay from their huge amounts of compensation and not notice the £2.50 going out of their bank accounts ?

I couldn't be a carer, I now work very part time in a supermarket on the checkouts ( I love it ! sitting on my bottom for a couple of hours or so meeting different people all day ) and I meet lots of carers and their clients and I could not do it.
Not even for £100 an hour, never mind min wage of £10.42

and the OP is pissed off because one carer mentioned that it was a ' decent ' free lunch.

Some wonderful comments on this thread, I wish there was a ' like ' or a ' good comment ' button, as I don't feel the ' thank you ' button is appropriate ?

mantyzer · 12/12/2023 12:07

Someone saying "at least I get paid for seeing her" within earshot is unprofessional. We all know some people are more difficult than others, but you dont say it to the people you are working with.

TreacleMines · 12/12/2023 12:04

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 12/12/2023 11:46

@TreacleMines should a complaint be about actual abuse or feeling unsafe absolutely should be made!
Op wants to complain that the carer made a comment that showed they weren't grateful enough to be 'treated'to lunch at work.

I’m not saying every little complaint should result in the person involved being fired or disciplined, I’m just saying that on principle service users have to be able to complain. The previous poster implied they have some sort of black list of people who have made complaints… that is dodgy territory (although very tempting).

Im a social worker- I’ve lost count of the times people ring up in a rage about all sorts of things (usually shouting, swearing and trying to explain my job to me)… I politely offer to direct them to the official complaints process and let them get on with it. It’s part and parcel of the job.

Lifeasiknowitisout · 12/12/2023 12:03

SgtBilko · 12/12/2023 10:57

And because it is work it is unprofessional to make comments like that within earshot of the service users. What if your GP said within your earshot, ‘At least I get paid for seeing her?’ I think you would be pretty upset.

The GP only does see you because they are paid.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 12/12/2023 12:02

You feel grubby because you listened in to someone else's conversation where they've said they had a 'decent free lunch' and you want to create drama about this?

KvotheTheBloodless · 12/12/2023 12:00

You're asking for more out of the carer/patient relationship than is usual - whilst most carers will care about the people they work with, that doesn't mean they actively want to spend time with them outside of work. I really like my colleagues, but I would always prefer to be home with my DH and DC than out with them. I go to work socials because it's part of the job - it's not disrespecting my colleagues to say that.

Your demand for 'respect' is ridiculous - why on earth do you think that carers, who are usually on minimum wage, should be super-grateful for a free lunch with work colleagues, in their own unpaid time? You're asking for too much, you need to reassess your own behaviour towards paid carers, who are professionals but not your friends.

QueenCamilla · 12/12/2023 11:55

Envy is a great magnifying glass for fault.

Bumblebeestiltskin · 12/12/2023 11:54

YNK · 12/12/2023 01:18

No, they were being paid and attending as the groups guests, in gratitude for their efforts in working for our friends.

Being paid = work.

I'm not sure why you're struggling to grasp this?

Lwrenagain · 12/12/2023 11:47

Hello @YNK I've not read the replies of other posters yet but I've read yours and I understand that you feel insulted, maybe even on behalf of your friends?

I was a carer for many different kinds of people over many different roles for over 20 years. I've cared for everyone from new babys to dying elderly people and everyone in between.

Here is what I can tell you -
Carers are told repeatedly "they're your clients, you're not friends", because historically carers have taken advantage of the power dynamic with their clients and unfortunately, even though most carers are decent, some are horrible people and it's to protect the service users carers are told to not be pals.

You pay peanuts you get monkeys.
I went into care work very young presuming the staff would all be hippies who smelt of incense sticks and grew their own sage, who cared about people and were on a crusade to give the most vulnerable people a wonderful service.
I was wrong, often care staff are people who couldn't be hired anywhere elswe due to lack of qualifications and are literally forced to do this kind of work.
Ive known colleagues be senior carers but unable to get a job in the asda due to lack of qualifications.

The way these carers said this has upset you but something you've said has shone through about money. You've been in a position to donate some (unless I've read wrong in which case I'm very sorry!) But care staff can do 12 / 15 / 24 hours straight no sleep shifts of gruelling physical work, we can wash, dress, toilet, give medicine, assist to feed, support with incidents, deaths, etc over 100 people per day depending on size of place worked, for minimum wage that'll need topping up with universal credit and we're still called benefit scroungers for having the sheer audacity to be on shite pay for a job that most people wouldn't choose to do. So maybe they're just happy about something free when carers are made to feel so undervalued. It may have sounded really grabby and it might have been, but these are people, often women, who may nurse your loved ones into their journey with death in the wee hours of the night and be told you're not allowed to accept a box of milk tray from the family to say thank you.
Maybe it's the novelty?

Maybe they're grabby, shitty people, maybe they're poor and excited they've had something nice at no expense to themselves, either way, don't let this play on your mind too much, you have a lovely group and support network here, don't leave from one flippant comment.

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 12/12/2023 11:46

@TreacleMines should a complaint be about actual abuse or feeling unsafe absolutely should be made!
Op wants to complain that the carer made a comment that showed they weren't grateful enough to be 'treated'to lunch at work.

TreacleMines · 12/12/2023 11:38

Peach0123 · 12/12/2023 11:04

OP as a carer YABU big time. One of the first thing we are taught in training is that although we may be 'close' in a way to service users, we are NOT friends, a line that shouldn't be crossed. It sounds like you have now worked this out and are disappointed. There could have been many reasons for the comment, you only heard what the man said, not the context. Sounds like he was looking at the positive.

  • annual leave could have been refused in order to attend
  • the event went on longer than planned
  • carer didn't get a break that day
  • carer was called in to cover on a day off
  • They might not have won on tombolla 🤣

I really hope you have only came on here to vent and haven't went to the others in the group stirring them up. That really wouldn't be fair at all on anyone. Also you would look like a trouble maker, one to watch.

Move on from this and enjoy you actual friends, respect the carers a bit more and dont dampen what was a nice lunch for others.

Edited

It’s not that they have that attitude, it’s that they were unprofessional in saying it within earshot of service users.

Also, why would you come on here and tell a disabled woman that if she makes a complaint she will be labelled as ‘trouble’ and ‘one to watch’?!

Did you miss the part of your training that (should) have taught you that as a carer there is an enormous power imbalance in your favour when dealing with your service users?! Disabled people have to be able to raise issues without fear of reprisal otherwise abuse can (and does) happen.

Swipe left for the next trending thread