Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel deflated after a charity xmas do hearing a paid worker saying it was a 'free lunch' for them?

437 replies

YNK · 11/12/2023 23:45

I had an injury and joined a great charity group a few years ago to meet for coffee once a week and to enjoy activities and support each other.

Some members are in residential care due to the severity of their condition so they are always accompanied by carers, others have fully recovered.
Members pay for activities and weekly meetings and pay happily and willingly for the chance to meet and socialise.

Some members have suffered and been compensated legally for injuries caused and many are now financially secure and if assistance is provided, I feel this 'them and us' divide is hurtful.

After a very nice xmas lunch, as we were leaving a group of paid carers could be heard saying it was at least a decent 'free lunch'

I feel grubby now and I'm thinking of leaving the group - AIBU?

OP posts:
WhereIsBebèsChambre · 12/12/2023 15:40

1990thatsme · 12/12/2023 15:23

Well I imagine 99% of us would say something like “I don’t blame you, I don’t know how you do it!”

You would actually be offended? You think people should look after your children for the privilege?

Of course! And give thanks each day at their luck of employment! Sticking to childcare example is it not more like teachers going to the panto with the kids and saying 'at least we got free tickets'?

KatBurglar · 12/12/2023 15:29

Roughly 1250 people so far have voted that you are unreasonable and you still keep doubling down.

Why even post in AIBU if you’re that entrenched in your position?

sandragreen · 12/12/2023 15:25

furtivetussling · 12/12/2023 15:13

Of all the AIBU threads I have ever read on MN, this one really has to take the prize for being the most unreasonable of all time.

I take it you haven’t seen the DIL who’s about to go NC with all her in-laws because they forgot her wedding anniversary?😂😂😂

1990thatsme · 12/12/2023 15:23

mantyzer · 12/12/2023 15:20

@Lifeasiknowitisout I know they are doing it for money. But can you imagine if a parent overheard a worker say well glad that its over and I can go home now.

Well I imagine 99% of us would say something like “I don’t blame you, I don’t know how you do it!”

You would actually be offended? You think people should look after your children for the privilege?

mantyzer · 12/12/2023 15:20

@Lifeasiknowitisout I know they are doing it for money. But can you imagine if a parent overheard a worker say well glad that its over and I can go home now.

furtivetussling · 12/12/2023 15:13

Of all the AIBU threads I have ever read on MN, this one really has to take the prize for being the most unreasonable of all time.

chocolatemademefat · 12/12/2023 15:03

I was my husbands unpaid carer - wasn’t eligible for carers allowance because of our ages. I had to take him to things like lunches or he wouldn’t have been able to attend. I was never asked to pay for my meal and didn’t for one minute think someone would object. If you’re there as a carer most of the time you’re doing just that - toilet trips and feeding my husband was my first priority.

Your post makes me sad - I never for one moment thought I was freeloading but some people obviously see it that way. Maybe walk a mile in our shoes.

novhange · 12/12/2023 14:55

PlacidPenelope · 12/12/2023 14:49

No, the Op has not explained herself well at all but if you think so perhaps you can enlighten us as to the meaning of this:

Some members have suffered and been compensated legally for injuries caused and many are now financially secure and if assistance is provided, I feel this 'them and us' divide is hurtful.

How are you understanding that?

If you are talking about the nuances in the kind of relationship between carers and the cared for then how does the OP understand them being as the OP is neither of those things.

I would say the OP's idea of carers and how they should be is the problem, it comes across from the OP as We paid for your lunch you ungrateful wretches.

Some members have suffered and been compensated legally for injuries caused and many are now financially secure and if assistance is provided, I feel this 'them and us' divide is hurtful.

This really confused me too.

Is she saying some members have a lot of money and those providing assistance (i.e. the carers) do not and she finds the divide hurtful?

As in carers should be grateful the members have money?

Lifeasiknowitisout · 12/12/2023 14:49

mantyzer · 12/12/2023 14:08

It is similar to a parent overhearing a nursery worker saying a comment that made it clear they just saw looking after their child as work. Lots of parents would feel upset about that.

This situation with OP is common in care situations. Because paid staff and those they are caring for do bond if they spend a lot of time together. It is a difficult situation that has lots of issues that are rarely recognised in public.

A childcare worker providing childcare is only doing it because it’s paid work.

Do you really believe they would look after peppels
children for free?

PlacidPenelope · 12/12/2023 14:49

mantyzer · 12/12/2023 14:23

I think the OP has explained herself well. I think those saying she has not are failing to understand the nuances in this kind of relationship.

No, the Op has not explained herself well at all but if you think so perhaps you can enlighten us as to the meaning of this:

Some members have suffered and been compensated legally for injuries caused and many are now financially secure and if assistance is provided, I feel this 'them and us' divide is hurtful.

How are you understanding that?

If you are talking about the nuances in the kind of relationship between carers and the cared for then how does the OP understand them being as the OP is neither of those things.

I would say the OP's idea of carers and how they should be is the problem, it comes across from the OP as We paid for your lunch you ungrateful wretches.

ThreeTreeHill · 12/12/2023 14:27

I'm not sure I understand why carers who OP doesn't know would feel honored to be invited to this lunch?

And why when one carer makes a remark, the OP is then thinking of leaving the group, even though this carer isn't affiliated in anyway with the group and OP hasn't even seen them before?

And why OP is expecting these carers, who again she doesn't know, to be invited as friends. They aren't even her carers

It's a bit of an odd set up. The carers are nothing to do with the group and are there to support their client. It's a nice gesture to invite them but it's still a work lunch. It's a bit patronising to think a carer would be honored to be treated to a free lunch with essentially a load of people they don't know.

honoldbrist · 12/12/2023 14:25

Some people have got no tact. I'm not surprised it made you feel like that. Just try and remember they were there to support the people that the charity supports rather than being the subject of the support. I don't suppose that the carers free lunch is what the charity supporters thought they were donating to but if they facilitated the actual beneficaries of the charity being there then I guess that is an incidental cost. Very rude even true.

mantyzer · 12/12/2023 14:23

I think the OP has explained herself well. I think those saying she has not are failing to understand the nuances in this kind of relationship.

PlacidPenelope · 12/12/2023 14:19

Given that the OP hasn't explained the situation entirely, & frequently contradicted herself (they were paid, they weren't paid, it was a group of them, it was one man she'd never seen before, it was a treat, it was work, there's a them vs us mentality, we're all so close, this one comment has dissolved the glue of friendship, I never said anything about glue, etc.) I think we may term her an unreliable narrator, and charitably suggest her interpretation of what actually happened may not chime with others present.

Agree.

I have asked the OP to explain what this part of her opening post means, and as yet no response:

Some members have suffered and been compensated legally for injuries caused and many are now financially secure and if assistance is provided, I feel this 'them and us' divide is hurtful.

One overheard comment which the OP has no idea what it was in response to or any of the context in which it was said and yet has jumped to a damning judgement of the person who said it and why they said it.

MrsVeryTired · 12/12/2023 14:18

I get it OP, having worked in care. It was a comment that shouldn't have been said in earshot of anyone other than other care staff. It may be true but a bit crass to hear.

Chuckiee · 12/12/2023 14:14

I can't even work out where you are finding the offense in what they said.

mantyzer · 12/12/2023 14:14

I do feel sorry for carers. It is an important job and ideally they should be super professional. But in reality they are paid less than people working in supermarkets.

sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 12/12/2023 14:11

TomeTome · 12/12/2023 13:13

It’s less about being grateful and more about being polite. Who wants to here someone say stuff like that after spending time with them?

Again being on a low income does not excuse you from being kind or polite.

Given that the OP hasn't explained the situation entirely, & frequently contradicted herself (they were paid, they weren't paid, it was a group of them, it was one man she'd never seen before, it was a treat, it was work, there's a them vs us mentality, we're all so close, this one comment has dissolved the glue of friendship, I never said anything about glue, etc.) I think we may term her an unreliable narrator, and charitably suggest her interpretation of what actually happened may not chime with others present.

mantyzer · 12/12/2023 14:08

It is similar to a parent overhearing a nursery worker saying a comment that made it clear they just saw looking after their child as work. Lots of parents would feel upset about that.

This situation with OP is common in care situations. Because paid staff and those they are caring for do bond if they spend a lot of time together. It is a difficult situation that has lots of issues that are rarely recognised in public.

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 12/12/2023 14:07

novhange · 12/12/2023 13:54

Someone can correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't carers some of the most poorly paid workers in the country?

Why would you expect them to feel bonded to the group?

Yes, I think you're right, and it's a job I certainly wouldn't be capable of doing well, if at all, even if it suddenly became extremely highly paid. I'm afraid I'm missing the point as to why it was rude of someone attending the lunch to say to presumably a fellow carer, that it was at least a decent free lunch, when they were being overheard out of context.

BIossomtoes · 12/12/2023 13:59

novhange · 12/12/2023 13:54

Someone can correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't carers some of the most poorly paid workers in the country?

Why would you expect them to feel bonded to the group?

Yes. And there’s a huge shortage of them. Wonder why.

novhange · 12/12/2023 13:54

LadyBird1973 · 12/12/2023 06:39

I think the OP has expressed herself well.

Being a carer is not quite the same as working in an office and this lunch isn't exactly the same as going to the office work do. The boundaries are not so clearly defined, when one person is helping another with their day to day lives, including social activities. The OP felt that the carers were also a legitimate part of the group, even though being there is part of their paid employment - she values them and wanted them to feel welcomed and included.
That very crass comment made it clear that, to some carers, it literally is just about work and they don't feel bonded to the group at all. That is hurtful.
The group was doing a nice thing and the OP feels that carer was disparaging about it.

I guess maybe it's comparable to the situation in other workplaces where some people feel their colleagues have also become their friends and then finding out that the colleague views them as just someone they work with. The colleague has a right to feel that way, but it's still a hurtful thing to hear and a crass thing to say out loud.

OP, try not to let this ruin the group for you - your friends are still your friends and this one person's rude behaviour doesn't necessarily reflect how other carers feel.

Someone can correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't carers some of the most poorly paid workers in the country?

Why would you expect them to feel bonded to the group?

HeckyPeck · 12/12/2023 13:50

TomeTome · 12/12/2023 13:13

It’s less about being grateful and more about being polite. Who wants to here someone say stuff like that after spending time with them?

Again being on a low income does not excuse you from being kind or polite.

This.

My Nan always took her carer out for a Christmas lunch (& paid her time too so she wasn't missing out on hours) to show her appreciation for making her life so much easier.

Her carer was lovely and wouldn't have dreamed of being rude about a kind gesture from someone who was really grateful for her support.

Ramalangadingdong · 12/12/2023 13:33

Verv · 12/12/2023 13:13

Yeah, they should've made certain they were out of earshot for sure.

Thank you both. Nice posts on a thread that is overly harsh towards op.

Lifeasiknowitisout · 12/12/2023 13:30

TreacleMines · 12/12/2023 13:07

You are right- it is dehumanising to always be on the receiving end of the relationship. Always be the job, the work, the burden, when you would much rather wipe your own arse and go out to lunch without needing a carer to wash you first.

So it probably would have been a better idea to keep the comments out of earshot of the service users (who after all, are as much screwed over by the shit show that is the ‘care industry’ as the carers are)…

in the same vein as you probably wouldn’t stand chatting to your colleagues about your baby shower at the weekend when you are the sister on a wards of women who have just had miscarriages or still births, and standing next to a patient’s bed.

Undertakers are only there doing undertaking for the money, but they still try to behave in a solemn way when near the family even though they don’t give a shit about the deceased in a personal sense.

We don’t know the context.

Person A ‘I have to get caught up on xyz’
Person B ‘yeah this afternoon will be busy but it’s been nice and at least we got a decent free lunch’

its just colleagues chitchat of which op heard a small portion and assumed it was derogatory.

Op wanted them to attend as friends. They aren’t friends. But she is then upset because they haven’t acted as though they are being paid to attend and professional.

I didn’t invite the undertaker to my mums post funeral wake as a friend of the family then complain he didn’t act like an undertaker at the wake.

A Sister on a ward who had a baby shower would be obviously pregnant. Do they not allow that? They wouldn’t have to mention a baby shower. But again, the sister wouldn’t haven’t been invited to the patients bedside as a friend.

This is the issue. Op (and possibly the company) have blurred boundaries. She believes that because people the charity supports have bonded (though her op suggests they haven’t) doesn’t make the carers friends.

Op wanted them to attend as friends. But is jumping at ‘well it’s unprofessional to say that’ in which case she is viewing them as working.

Swipe left for the next trending thread