Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel deflated after a charity xmas do hearing a paid worker saying it was a 'free lunch' for them?

437 replies

YNK · 11/12/2023 23:45

I had an injury and joined a great charity group a few years ago to meet for coffee once a week and to enjoy activities and support each other.

Some members are in residential care due to the severity of their condition so they are always accompanied by carers, others have fully recovered.
Members pay for activities and weekly meetings and pay happily and willingly for the chance to meet and socialise.

Some members have suffered and been compensated legally for injuries caused and many are now financially secure and if assistance is provided, I feel this 'them and us' divide is hurtful.

After a very nice xmas lunch, as we were leaving a group of paid carers could be heard saying it was at least a decent 'free lunch'

I feel grubby now and I'm thinking of leaving the group - AIBU?

OP posts:
BoohooWoohoo · 12/12/2023 05:57

It’s positive that the charity provides a decent (ie good quality) meal for the carers too. Carers are low paid and presumably forgotten by many charities so including them in the free meal is a good thing for the charity to do.
I don’t think it’s rude to comment on the free decent meal aspect. It’s not rude that the carer saw it as an incentive to attend either. 🤷‍♀️ Caring is a job and it is unreasonable to expect carers to feel the same about the charity as the people with the condition.

oakleaffy · 12/12/2023 05:55

Cupcakekiller · 12/12/2023 00:06

Caring is a tough job and usually underpaid. You'd begrudge them a free Xmas meal?

This in ♠️ spades!

RedHelenB · 12/12/2023 05:51

kittensinthekitchen · 12/12/2023 02:23

This makes no sense.

There's an increasing number of posts on Mumsnet written in the same difficult to follow way. I'd be really interested in whether they are written by the same person/people or if there's a spate of people joining Mumsnet that have very little ability to articulate themselves in an understandable manner.

This. I've a feeling it's the same poster.

GrannypantsMagee · 12/12/2023 05:50

YNK · 12/12/2023 01:42

Sure, I have worked in similar roles and I felt honoured to be invited as a guest at celebrations, particularly if it was part of my paid role.

I hope I made a positive contribution to those events that I participated in and I always thanked my hosts for their appreciation.

@YNK You have worked in 'similar roles' - as a carer, or some kind of other role in the charity or healthcare or legal sector? Unless you were a carer on low/minimum wage I don't think you can compare.

I've been to possibly similar events, charity Xmas events funded or set up partly and via the medicolegal sector. I think you alluded to the fact that some service users will have had major trauma personal injury claims and will be well supported with rehab, care, and compensation, and some won't - due to not having an insurable injury, this creates a huge disparity in how much help they get as it may be state minimum/CICA paid for. This is a terrible fact of life in the UK. The work that charities do is vitally important in helping provide support and community for everyone regardless. However, everyone who is there because they work for the organisation or service users IS there because of their job and may have other things they would rather do. I personally would avoid saying it aloud if I was them, but I bet they more than deserve that free lunch.

terraced · 12/12/2023 05:49

I think you're being over sensitive about it. Keep supporting the charity if you want to.

pictoosh · 12/12/2023 05:35

I think you're taking a common flippant comment too personally.

Zanatdy · 12/12/2023 05:30

I get why their comment was upsetting when you’d all chipped in to include them and weren’t inviting them in their caring capacity. I guess for them though they are still thinking of it as work. Regardless their comment was rude, and they should have been thanking people not making comments like they

BubziOwl · 12/12/2023 05:29

Struggling with the context here, but the comment in of itself just sounds like one of those standard jokey negative comments people make, especially at work. It's just something people with a particularly sense of humour say. I wouldn't read into it at all.

Spencer0220 · 12/12/2023 05:10

YNK · 12/12/2023 01:28

I appreciate all your comments especially those who understand how demeaning this comment felt to me personally but more for my friends who need to accept they need assistance through no fault of theirs.
They are not to blame for needing help and we have all contributed to financing this.
They benefit from paid work and we appreciate their help, which is why we wanted them to have a nice time with us.
If I had a guest in my home I wouldn't invite them back if that was their parting shot at xmas!

Is it possible you misunderstood the comment/context?

Perhaps to their tastes the meal wasn't great. But at least it was also free?

Spencer0220 · 12/12/2023 05:05

sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 12/12/2023 00:51

'invited as friends, as part of paid work' - that doesn't make sense. They're either getting a bit of a bonus outside of work because they're valued, or it's part of work.

This.

You might have thought they were friends, but if it was part of their work to be there, then they might well have seen it the other way.

Whilst I have a friendship with a number of my ex carers, I'm under no illusion that we met for anything other than a contractual obligation.

The carers are free to see it as they like. The only part where it's possible you are not being unreasonable, is that it was wrong of them to say it in earshot of the service users. But that is it.

BehemothWatermelon · 12/12/2023 05:00

I think I both do and don't get this.
I worked in supported living as a carer for people with leaning disabilities and autism for 6 years, doing 14 hour shifts on minimum wage. The residents had a lot more disposable income than the staff, due to their reduced living costs. They liked to socialise, go out for drinks and meals. Staff got subsidised if we went out with them, £2.50 for lunch, £5 for evening meal. This was never enough to cover our own costs. We weren't able to take our own food in to restaurants obviously. So everytime we took someone out, to McDonald's (a favourite place), Wetherspoons, a Chinese buffet, anywhere, it cost us money to eat with them. We ate with them so they enjoyed it it more, and didn't feel singled out and different. Also sometimes we were out for 8 hours and needed to eat! I'd take snacks, and sometimes order something small, but it still cost me to do my job, to eat out way more often than I would in my personal life. We were on minimum wage and I sometimes felt frustrated by it. i loved my job and liked and respected the people I worked with, but it cost me to work there.
Occasionally, family members would take out the resident, we would need to go, and sometimes they would pay for our full meal! This was very generous and I was always grateful and expressed that. I wouldn't have said "decent free meal" but I would have thought it and felt lucky!
OP I wouldn't feel hurt by this or let it devalue what you get from this group.

3luckystars · 12/12/2023 04:46

I am finding it so hard to understand all of this. Apologies if I’m wrong but it feels like, when someone does something to me, ok I’ll get over it, but if it is to my child, it’s a different pain and I have a totally different reaction. Is that what is happening, you think they have hurt others feelings and you are angry on their behalf?

If so, then why would YOU leaving the group help? Surely it needs MORE people like you? People say stupid things sometimes. The carers might be hurt people too, don’t let it get to you.

Think about why this triggered you so much and definitely don’t leave the group.

Catsmere · 12/12/2023 04:39

FiveShelties · 12/12/2023 04:34

Or..................... the whole thread is a wind up?

Another distinct possibility!

At least it's unlikely to be AI ... they're less confusing/contradictory.

FiveShelties · 12/12/2023 04:34

Catsmere · 12/12/2023 02:32

I'm beginning to wonder if the fellow who made the remark has heard of OP and was doing a subtle wind-up ... if he was, it worked!

Or..................... the whole thread is a wind up?

Lifeasiknowitisout · 12/12/2023 04:30

They are working because they are being paid while they are there.

They aren’t going to get the same sense of community that you do out of it, because they are carers. Not the people who this injury has happened to.

Leaving a group you care about and enjoy going to, because you feel that people who work as carers should have got the same sense of community that you did, is an odd reaction.

They didn’t patronise anyone. But not do they have to feel that they got a lot out of it. Not the same as you.

Besides which, ‘at least we got a free meal’ is the sort of comment people make without attaching much meaning to it. You are reading too much into at for some reason are going to stop attending a group you enjoy and get a lot out of because of that.

thesixleggedpsychopathonthetrain · 12/12/2023 04:21

YNK · 12/12/2023 01:45

It wasn't a gift or a perk from their employer.
No one expects them to be close friends, just being friendly would do.

Isn't it exasperating when servants don't know their place?

SemperIdem · 12/12/2023 04:19

You are being wildly over sensitive.

thesixleggedpsychopathonthetrain · 12/12/2023 04:12

Anybody who does that job deserves all the free lunches they can get.

chappoi · 12/12/2023 04:04

Toddlerteaplease · 12/12/2023 04:00

For the carers it's part of their working day. As a PP said. They don't have to care about the charity. If I was a carer, I would also be pleased it was a free lunch. But wouldn't say it out loud.

I agree don't say it out loud. But if they're being paid to be there then could they even decline. Caring is a job and if someone is paying them to be there then they should act respectful

Toddlerteaplease · 12/12/2023 04:00

For the carers it's part of their working day. As a PP said. They don't have to care about the charity. If I was a carer, I would also be pleased it was a free lunch. But wouldn't say it out loud.

Bigcat25 · 12/12/2023 03:57

OP, I understand where you're coming from to an extent, ie, when you quoted the person who said she would pretend to enjoy herself as a carer at lunch but wouldn't actually, or people who are only working bc they are being paid.

Lets be real, almost everyone would do something else with their time if they weren't being paid, or at least work a much less demanding schedule if they found their work rewarding. It is ideal to think that people might find some fulfilment in their work and a genuine connection to those they help. I'm sure many do, but it's not an all day thing. Carer's will have moments where they think their clients are lovely, and times when they're exhausted, the day is rough, stressful, colleages/clients are difficult and maybe they're operating on almost no sleep. it doesn't mean they don't respect their clients, but that their job is demanding and they're human.

Perks are rare and someone made a semi flippant remark. Please don't leave the group you love over it.

Fivepigeons · 12/12/2023 03:51

I think you are being very precious tbh. Very ott to leave a group because of this. Just because someone didn't seem as grateful or friendly as you thought they should be. There seems to be a blurring of boundaries. And a miscommunication of expectations... are they friends or paid care workers? You can't offer some minimum wage workers a free meal then resent it because they came for the free meal and not out of the spirit of friendship. I think that's a very odd attitude.

GreenWheat · 12/12/2023 03:48

Last night I was at a dinner hosted by one of our clients as a thank you for the work we do for them. I would much rather have been at home sorting out Christmas stuff. I wasn't even paid for it as it was out of hours. It was a nice evening and at least the free food was good.
Expecting me to feel honoured to attend is just unrealistic. I had to go as part of my job. It was pleasant enough but I only went because I had to really. I think you are patronising and deluded if you think people attending events as part of their jobs should also be thrilled to attend.

Catsmere · 12/12/2023 03:47

Tilllly · 12/12/2023 03:42

@therealcookiemonster
Only if it's for charity
And not as fast as police, you can't

😆😆😆

fruitypancake · 12/12/2023 03:44

She doesn't earn very much , why shouldn't she be pleased with a free lunch !?