Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not have children because I can't give them a better or even equal life to mine?

162 replies

eastea · 11/12/2023 21:53

I grew up poor but I was bright, worked hard, went to University, got a first, and then a masters degree. I met and married my DH also the first in his family to go to university and have a professional job. We worked hard but we still have a standard of living roughly equivalent to that of our parents had and that is without us having kids yet. Even our generation as promised so much if only we got a degree but it all turned out to be lies for the most part, these days the debt is even more and the rewards even fewer so what about when babies today grow up?

It feels like in order to actually move up in the world now you can't just work your way there you need to inherit not only wealth but also contacts, a certain confidence and way of being in the world, having a private education for example.

My DH and I do ok but we live a pretty modest lifestyle and when I look at all the things most kids seem to do now like all the various lessons, extra curricular activates, tutoring it seems very out of reach. Not to mention the odd holiday abroad access to cultural activities that would help them to fit in once at university if they went. I know these things do matter because I went to university not having ever been abroad and in many instances though I knew what a word meant I would get the pronunciation wrong because I'd never heard it said aloud prior to being a uni. Those deficits marked me out as different, and I was ridiculed for my accent and I never quite fitted in (perhaps a feature of the university I went to where most were from very wealthy backgrounds).

I've seen other working class, university educated people who don't quite fit in anywhere go on to have kids who also don't quite fit in anywhere and I feel like if I could buy my kids what I didn't have though a private education or some other means then I might think of it but I just feel like its getting harder and harder for people to maintain what they have and that any gaps for meritocracy as closing up.

I just see a very bleak future where few make it and those that will probably have generations of wealth behind them and for those that don't I think life will probably be pretty miserable mired in debt, subscription fees, poor healthcare and little hope of having a secure home or even children of their own. That is even before I consider the environmental disaster that awaits us and future generations.

I just feel sometimes like its kinder not to have them.

OP posts:
Pickles2023 · 12/12/2023 06:59

I dont think kids will notice this dilemma unless you taught them to..

I had the opposite, i grew up pretty wealthy. My mum went on a course to retrain and made friends with a single mum trying hard to provide single handedly. I would go over to where they lived (on an estate) i LOVED it.

I didnt notice difference in houses, i mean i went in my friends room and living room, i didnt go around every room to work out how many rooms were upstairs and if they were doubles. I just saw a wonderful homely home, where everything felt loving. I was a bit jealous that she had so many friends on the estate and could go park and play after school. (Living in the big house rurally has no play parks and no other kids around) it was always fun and always things to do and people around.

Now we are grown up, having tutors and opportunities didnt mean a thing. Her mum working hard rubbed off and she is a professional photographer who went to uni..

Its how you raise the kids and the childs personality at the end of the day.

Obviously money can make it easier but it doesnt define who a person is.

(Some of the kids in my private school are bums now dont think thats down to poverty)

Also i didnt go to uni, i did an apprenticeship, no amount of money can make someone suddenly academic if they aren't.

Beezknees · 12/12/2023 06:33

This wouldn't even occur to me.

I find this inferiority complex about not being wealthy so weird. I'm a single mum living in social housing with not a penny to my name and I don't care. Doesn't make me a bad person and I'm secure enough not to care what others think. DS is the same. We don't have a bad life either just because we're not wealthy.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 12/12/2023 06:30

eastea · 11/12/2023 23:36

@HomburgandTrilby Same here, my background was very deprived. I'm not sure if that has a bearing. I don't know how old you are but I think things are getting worse all the time in terms of getting frozen out. My university friends for example tend to live in a certain area now they are married and starting families. Not even they can afford to buy there without considerable family help. Its not an area that we could ever afford to buy in and its not that I care about living there for the sake of it but its just that when you can't move there you just end up excluded, you aren't handy anymore to meet up for a coffee or a drink so you just slip off the radar.

Edited

Sounds like you need new friends.

sunnydayhereandnow · 12/12/2023 05:54

I wonder if the issue here is that you haven't yet found your own social group. Your expectations of what's needed for kids to have a decent life reflect the lifestyle of the top couple of percent, not most people who are graduates from decent universities. I also went to Oxbridge, from a modest background (parents both teachers, father from strongly WC family). At uni I had friends from a lot of backgrounds, but because we all basically lived in the same accommodation and did the same hobbies, it kind of plastered over class differences. After uni it became clearer that a lot of my uni friends were from a totally different social class and now have a totally different income level and lifestyle, and I simply drifted away from them. Now in my mid-40s, I have made new friends from work and various activities, and they are much more similar to me: people who went to good universities, have decent professional jobs, generally pinched and scraped for a few years out of uni with no parental help, and are now comfortable but don't have extra cash to throw around. Most importantly, I don't feel like the odd one out in this group.

The same applies for kids: in my friendship group we have similar values and lifestyles. None of the kids go to private school. They maybe have one lesson or paid activity outside school. Holidays are budget options - camping or maybe a weekend in an airbnb - or swapping houses with friends. Restaurants are an occasional treat. We set an example for our kids by saving for the things that most matter to us and showing that fun and "treats" don't have to be expensive. DC are confident and happy, and so are we :)

NoSquirrels · 12/12/2023 01:00

I’m sorry you feel this way, OP.

Any kids you have will have 2 university-educated parents who (presumably) know enough to teach them all the things you felt you didn’t know growing up.

Where you buy a house doesn’t matter to any potential theoretical children. It matters to you, though, and you should try to get some help unpicking how you can be happier in yourself.

It’s a classic quote for a reason: comparison is the thief of joy.

WandaWonder · 12/12/2023 00:50

Maybe if people put more thought into having kids there would be less constant drama's and social workers, fostering needed

nettie434 · 12/12/2023 00:49

I actually think it's important to think carefully about having children but it's a shame that you seem to be thinking oŃnly about the material side. For instance, you and your husband are good role models for breaking stereotypes abkut who will . As others have said, most children don't have private tutoring and go on exotic holidays. They still live happy and productive lives.

hillyland · 12/12/2023 00:47

I come from a poor background and we are financially very comfortable now so it's not impossible - all of our money has come from DH's salary (I'm a sahm) or investment gains. We've never had any help from family.

We have 2 dc who both enjoy all the things you mention - private school, lots of extracurriculars, regular holidays and trips out. I have to admit I would have taken the same position as you if we weren't comfortably off - I wouldn't have wanted to try to raise dc without a lot of financial slack, because those extras do make a difference to quality of life and it's better not to be constantly stressed about money. You do have time to bring your salaries/capital up to the required level though - we didn't have dcs until late 30s.

I read a lot about the cost of living crisis and the challenges in state schools, and I'm so glad I'm not worrying about that.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 12/12/2023 00:37

I do realise that, but for me, the appearance of success is everything. I dream of having a beautiful daughter who will do ballet as I did as a teen, but actually make a career of it. Or failing that, make some kind of mark in the world. I am a person who cares a lot about material things and appearances, and sometimes I think that is maybe not the best way to bring up a child.

You're right, it would be awful for a child to have a parent with your attitude.

heartbroken22 · 12/12/2023 00:34

It feels like you're overthinking this.

TomeTome · 12/12/2023 00:33

How much do you earn? I can’t imagine two grads from a posh university have tiny household income.

Ofcourseshecan · 12/12/2023 00:32

Ofcourseshecan · 12/12/2023 00:31

OP, I feel for you and I had quite similar experiences growing up. Not so bad in university because the culture was quite egalitarian at mine.
And I’m disappointed by the way privilege and nepotism never did really go away.
But I’d say life for most people in the UK now is immeasurably more affluent than when I was a working-class child in the 1960s. Everyone I knew had a much lower standard of living than now. Treats and outings were special occasions, not everyday events. Parties were just jellies or trifles and games. Everything now is more lavish.
We didn’t feel deprived back then because we didn’t know anything different. Small children living in a future in which things get a big scaled-down won’t compare it with today’s opulence because they won’t remember it. You compare yourself with the people around you, not with others from a different era.
That’s the long way of saying OP, don’t be put off having children because times may be harder and inequality still persists!

things get a bit scaled-down

FlippyFloppyShoe · 12/12/2023 00:32

Btw if you have DC be prepared to constantly question if you are getting it right/wrong, goes with the territory.

Ofcourseshecan · 12/12/2023 00:31

OP, I feel for you and I had quite similar experiences growing up. Not so bad in university because the culture was quite egalitarian at mine.
And I’m disappointed by the way privilege and nepotism never did really go away.
But I’d say life for most people in the UK now is immeasurably more affluent than when I was a working-class child in the 1960s. Everyone I knew had a much lower standard of living than now. Treats and outings were special occasions, not everyday events. Parties were just jellies or trifles and games. Everything now is more lavish.
We didn’t feel deprived back then because we didn’t know anything different. Small children living in a future in which things get a big scaled-down won’t compare it with today’s opulence because they won’t remember it. You compare yourself with the people around you, not with others from a different era.
That’s the long way of saying OP, don’t be put off having children because times may be harder and inequality still persists!

FlippyFloppyShoe · 12/12/2023 00:27

I'm a single parent, although I wasn't when I had DC and it's not the life I would have wished for them. Having said that, they are lucky and they are well loved by all their family and whilst we don't have oodles of cash, I do take them places on a budget, but would rather do that and them get experiences than spend a lot and do less. I have siblings whose DC have more opportunities than mine because their household income is more than mine, so they can do more expensive school trips and more expensive family holidays, but even so I've paid for tutoring when required and music lessons and my DC have done some awesome things primarily because i refuse to sit back and let their childhood pass by without trying to see what sparks their interest and that is the example that my parents set me.
Having said that, I can totally understand anyone choosing not to have children for whatever reason. The only person who can make the decision is you, as you can't send them back once they arrive and it is the biggest undertaking you will ever make.

saoirse31 · 12/12/2023 00:06

But eastea, you can't guarantee how your childs life will go in respect of not struggling to get a home and having a happy life. You couldnt guarantee that even if you lived in the suburb you wanted to. You just can't.

What you can hope to provide them with is the best start that you and your partner can give them. And by how you describe your current life that sounds like a really good start.

No one would have a child if they had to be sure of their childs future and how there life would be.

Tacotortoise · 11/12/2023 23:57

We all want that for our children but the truth is, life is a struggle. It was for you, it will be for them. And yes, with climate change etc there'll be plenty of struggle to be had.

eastea · 11/12/2023 23:50

@SweetFemaleAttitude I wouldn't care what they did as long as they didn't have to struggle to have a home and a happy life.

OP posts:
SweetFemaleAttitude · 11/12/2023 23:48

I think that there is a sense of inferiority that comes from not being wealthy

I think that you are talking out of your arse! How rude to assume people feel inferior if they aren't wealthy.

Some people may think money is the be all and end all. But please do not assume everyone does.

I grew up poor, didn't go to uni, but grafted and I've ended up on a decent position. Same with my husband.

We have a nice home in a nice area of our home town, and we have 1 child who wants for nothing.

What would you do OP if your child isn't academic?

Would you think their life was pointless?

You need to work on your self esteem issues and not equate everything in terms of money.

eastea · 11/12/2023 23:47

Kendodd · 11/12/2023 23:38

I have a theory about why people do or don't have kids and it's not about a bleak few of the world, people in Gaza and Sudan have loads of kids. It's all about the money and which direction it flows in. In the countries/areas I just mentioned, and in working class communities in the UK until more recent years, the expectation was that when kids grow up, they start giving money to their parents and young adults feel huge pressure to provide for them. In much of the world, including here, money flows down the generations, so each kid costs an absolute fortune, no money flows back up the generations, so suddenly we decide we don't want to have kids anymore.

Its not that I want my prospective children to give me money or that I would grudge giving them all I have its that I feel like these days I could do all that and they would still struggle to thrive in the world as it is now.

OP posts:
Kendodd · 11/12/2023 23:38

I have a theory about why people do or don't have kids and it's not about a bleak few of the world, people in Gaza and Sudan have loads of kids. It's all about the money and which direction it flows in. In the countries/areas I just mentioned, and in working class communities in the UK until more recent years, the expectation was that when kids grow up, they start giving money to their parents and young adults feel huge pressure to provide for them. In much of the world, including here, money flows down the generations, so each kid costs an absolute fortune, no money flows back up the generations, so suddenly we decide we don't want to have kids anymore.

eastea · 11/12/2023 23:37

Tacotortoise · 11/12/2023 23:24

Well if you feel like that, best not. You'd resent them terribly.

Excuse me? I wouldn't resent them at all I'd just feel like I was letting them down. I think some on here just enjoy sticking the boot in and twisting the knife. I might feeling bleak but at least I am not nasty just for the sake of it.

OP posts:
eastea · 11/12/2023 23:36

@HomburgandTrilby Same here, my background was very deprived. I'm not sure if that has a bearing. I don't know how old you are but I think things are getting worse all the time in terms of getting frozen out. My university friends for example tend to live in a certain area now they are married and starting families. Not even they can afford to buy there without considerable family help. Its not an area that we could ever afford to buy in and its not that I care about living there for the sake of it but its just that when you can't move there you just end up excluded, you aren't handy anymore to meet up for a coffee or a drink so you just slip off the radar.

OP posts:
JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 11/12/2023 23:28

waves from the childfree board

Come over and join us, plenty of us identify

Tacotortoise · 11/12/2023 23:24

Well if you feel like that, best not. You'd resent them terribly.