Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not have children because I can't give them a better or even equal life to mine?

162 replies

eastea · 11/12/2023 21:53

I grew up poor but I was bright, worked hard, went to University, got a first, and then a masters degree. I met and married my DH also the first in his family to go to university and have a professional job. We worked hard but we still have a standard of living roughly equivalent to that of our parents had and that is without us having kids yet. Even our generation as promised so much if only we got a degree but it all turned out to be lies for the most part, these days the debt is even more and the rewards even fewer so what about when babies today grow up?

It feels like in order to actually move up in the world now you can't just work your way there you need to inherit not only wealth but also contacts, a certain confidence and way of being in the world, having a private education for example.

My DH and I do ok but we live a pretty modest lifestyle and when I look at all the things most kids seem to do now like all the various lessons, extra curricular activates, tutoring it seems very out of reach. Not to mention the odd holiday abroad access to cultural activities that would help them to fit in once at university if they went. I know these things do matter because I went to university not having ever been abroad and in many instances though I knew what a word meant I would get the pronunciation wrong because I'd never heard it said aloud prior to being a uni. Those deficits marked me out as different, and I was ridiculed for my accent and I never quite fitted in (perhaps a feature of the university I went to where most were from very wealthy backgrounds).

I've seen other working class, university educated people who don't quite fit in anywhere go on to have kids who also don't quite fit in anywhere and I feel like if I could buy my kids what I didn't have though a private education or some other means then I might think of it but I just feel like its getting harder and harder for people to maintain what they have and that any gaps for meritocracy as closing up.

I just see a very bleak future where few make it and those that will probably have generations of wealth behind them and for those that don't I think life will probably be pretty miserable mired in debt, subscription fees, poor healthcare and little hope of having a secure home or even children of their own. That is even before I consider the environmental disaster that awaits us and future generations.

I just feel sometimes like its kinder not to have them.

OP posts:
CalistoNoSolo · 12/12/2023 09:28

Beezknees · 12/12/2023 09:23

I'm 34 and never received financial help from my parents, nor did my parents from their parents. Most working class families do not have that kind of privilege and we all manage. Essentially you are saying only the middle class comfortable should have kids. Quite disgusting.

No, we're saying unless you can provide a decent life for your children you shouldn't have any.

user14699084785 · 12/12/2023 09:26

Beezknees · 12/12/2023 09:23

I'm 34 and never received financial help from my parents, nor did my parents from their parents. Most working class families do not have that kind of privilege and we all manage. Essentially you are saying only the middle class comfortable should have kids. Quite disgusting.

I can promise you we are all from very solid WC stock here…we are admittedly now fairly comfortable financially, partly through bloody hard work, but no one would describe us as middle class!

VanityDiesHard · 12/12/2023 09:25

user14699084785 · 12/12/2023 09:20

I agree with all you’ve said.
You see it all the time on here - babies don’t cost much, can have hand-me-downs, no need for expensive presents etc, encouraging people to go on, have a third! …but I think the reality now is that if young adults don't have family help with big stuff, driving lessons, first car, uni costs, house deposits, eventual inheritance, its a very harsh world and I’m very glad we have the means to make our twos lives a bit easier as they become adults.

We were fortunate that my parents helped us massively financially when we were in our 20’s and we fully intend to do the same for ours. Money should run downwards!

Totally. Plus with the NHS going down the toilet (I fully expect to see its end in the next ten years or so) medical expenses will become a reality. Why bring children into that unless you have a real cushion?

CalistoNoSolo · 12/12/2023 09:24

Beezknees · 12/12/2023 09:02

Essentially here you are saying that anyone earning minimum wage shouldn't have children. That's a wrong and very dangerous road to go down.

Not at all. It is possible to value education and ensure your children are educated and have open minds without private school. Libraries and museums are free, getting your child into the best possible state school, teaching your child to love learning and broaden their minds and interests is within the reach of the vast majority of people in this country. But if you can barely afford to put food on the table, then no, I think choosing to bring children into poverty is irresponsible, selfish and short sighted.

Beezknees · 12/12/2023 09:23

user14699084785 · 12/12/2023 09:20

I agree with all you’ve said.
You see it all the time on here - babies don’t cost much, can have hand-me-downs, no need for expensive presents etc, encouraging people to go on, have a third! …but I think the reality now is that if young adults don't have family help with big stuff, driving lessons, first car, uni costs, house deposits, eventual inheritance, its a very harsh world and I’m very glad we have the means to make our twos lives a bit easier as they become adults.

We were fortunate that my parents helped us massively financially when we were in our 20’s and we fully intend to do the same for ours. Money should run downwards!

I'm 34 and never received financial help from my parents, nor did my parents from their parents. Most working class families do not have that kind of privilege and we all manage. Essentially you are saying only the middle class comfortable should have kids. Quite disgusting.

user14699084785 · 12/12/2023 09:20

CalistoNoSolo · 12/12/2023 08:51

Way too many people have way too many children without any thought at all of the financial aspect. I disagree that love, food and shelter is enough. Imo, that's the bare minimum and if you don't have the money to give your child a reasonable upbringing (with very good education and mind opening experiences) you shouldn't have children.

I agree with all you’ve said.
You see it all the time on here - babies don’t cost much, can have hand-me-downs, no need for expensive presents etc, encouraging people to go on, have a third! …but I think the reality now is that if young adults don't have family help with big stuff, driving lessons, first car, uni costs, house deposits, eventual inheritance, its a very harsh world and I’m very glad we have the means to make our twos lives a bit easier as they become adults.

We were fortunate that my parents helped us massively financially when we were in our 20’s and we fully intend to do the same for ours. Money should run downwards!

HollyLondoner · 12/12/2023 09:14

I think it really depends on how stable you feel your finances are. I come from a very deprived area with a regional accent whose parents died young so I have been financing myself since 18.

I went to a good university, worked abroad as a way to see the world then worked my way up at a big corporate in London. I'd say we're comfortable in our 30s with a small 2 bed house with a baby and dog.

My best advice would be to not compare yourself to others and you don't need the whole world to be happy. I feel very content in my small house with few possessions but savings in the bank to help mat leave.

If you really want kids, you will have them.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 12/12/2023 09:06

CalistoNoSolo · 12/12/2023 08:51

Way too many people have way too many children without any thought at all of the financial aspect. I disagree that love, food and shelter is enough. Imo, that's the bare minimum and if you don't have the money to give your child a reasonable upbringing (with very good education and mind opening experiences) you shouldn't have children.

Only the wealthy having children then...

hydriotaphia · 12/12/2023 09:03

It is commendable that you are thinking about this stuff but at the same timeholidays abroad/tutoring are not at all necessary and at the most important cultural enrichments you can give them (whatever your income) are going to the library, reading with them, drawing, going over schoolwork a bit, playing, going to the park and just generally spending time with them. Life is obviously a lot easier if you don't have scary money worries and have the luxury of time to spend with your kids. And it is better if you can afford the odd extra-curricular activity, day trip etc - stuff which does indeed cost money. However you don't have to be minted to give kids a good childhood. I would be surprised if two uni grads literally couldn't afford to give their kids a happy and positive childhood that sets them up for life.

DanceMumTaxi · 12/12/2023 09:03

But a very good education doesn’t have to mean private school. And mind opening experiences don’t have to cost the earth. There is definitely a middle ground between super wealthy and abject poverty. This is where the majority of British people are. Yes, people need to be able to provide for their children but most people are doing this very well without being in the top few percent of earners.

Beezknees · 12/12/2023 09:02

CalistoNoSolo · 12/12/2023 08:51

Way too many people have way too many children without any thought at all of the financial aspect. I disagree that love, food and shelter is enough. Imo, that's the bare minimum and if you don't have the money to give your child a reasonable upbringing (with very good education and mind opening experiences) you shouldn't have children.

Essentially here you are saying that anyone earning minimum wage shouldn't have children. That's a wrong and very dangerous road to go down.

VanityDiesHard · 12/12/2023 08:56

CalistoNoSolo · 12/12/2023 08:51

Way too many people have way too many children without any thought at all of the financial aspect. I disagree that love, food and shelter is enough. Imo, that's the bare minimum and if you don't have the money to give your child a reasonable upbringing (with very good education and mind opening experiences) you shouldn't have children.

Totally agree with this. Finally someone speaks sense.

Rabiz · 12/12/2023 08:52

Kids don’t need private school. If you didn’t have enough money to feed them, then that would be something to think about. But only 6 % of the UK population go to private school. Do you really think 94% of British children are living bleak and worthless lives?

No. You have a good education and you value cultural capital. You can take them to museums and libraries and forests and historic churches and teach them about the world without spending lots of money.

CalistoNoSolo · 12/12/2023 08:51

Way too many people have way too many children without any thought at all of the financial aspect. I disagree that love, food and shelter is enough. Imo, that's the bare minimum and if you don't have the money to give your child a reasonable upbringing (with very good education and mind opening experiences) you shouldn't have children.

MyEyesMyThighs · 12/12/2023 08:43

You are obviously surrounded by people who have private school, travel and all the trimmings but there are plenty of happy people with less.

My DDs class has everything: small flats to massive houses, single parents on carers allowance, two doctor families, two families from Ukraine staying in spare rooms and the families with the spare rooms. The friendships have nothing to do with money and status, neither does how happy these kids are.

It's a perfectly valid choice not to have children, but it is sad to make a decision you might regret based on a false premise that might not be true. Look about a bit more, there are more ways to live than the bubble you grew up in and the one you're in now.

Spendonsend · 12/12/2023 08:15

Noone has to have children and your reasons as good as any

But even in my expensive bit of surrey there are plenty of children who have never been abroad, dont have tutoring, and their extra curriculars are cheap like cubs, or the local brass band is free. They are living full happy lives.

University isnt compulsory. For some people its a great return on investment - it opens up a career they find rewarding and sometimes one that pays better. But there are other options.

bibliomania · 12/12/2023 08:08

Agree that it's fine not to have dc - more people should make that choice.

I disagree that you need a set level of material wealth to have joie de vivre . Yesterday teen dd and I wandered around Aldi after school, cooked and watched TV together, so nothing special, but we talked and joked and were perfectly happy just being ordinary. You don't need to always fling money at life.

TheGrimm · 12/12/2023 07:53

Move to a more affordable area (they do exist) and there are nice areas all over the UK which are affordable. Make new friends. Then reassess. You are living your life wishing it was different. It can be. You have to change your life to achieve this. Then decide if children are for you.

Life has always been unfair and each generation thinks theirs has had it the worst.

MilkChocolateCookie · 12/12/2023 07:34

OP, it's fine not to have kids for any reason you like, including worrying about whether you'll be able to give them the life you'd like to give them.

Noicant · 12/12/2023 07:33

I grew up skint so did DH, DD goes to a nice private school, the idea that you have to inherit wealth is ridiculous. Yes of course it makes your life easier but it’s not the be all and end all. Plus we are ethnic minorities so y’know a little bit harder.

Dh works with someone who must be earning multiples of what he does (think close to six figures net) and he grew up on a rough estate (he wasn’t a nerd either, he is just very good at something specific and works hard) It’s utterly defeatist to think you can only progress if you went to private school, most of us didn’t most of the people your hypothetical child would meet wouldn’t have either.

I keep ending up talking to people who are going skiing for some reason, no I don’t ski and I don’t feel bad about it. Whats to feel ashamed of, we had different life experiences. I don’t feel inferior at all.

You can choose to not have kids for any reason at all but this sounds like perfectionism to me. I won’t do it if it’s not perfect. As someone with an actual child nothing is ever perfect, mainly it’s lumbering from one problem to another or one thing on a giant list of things to do to another.

DanceMumTaxi · 12/12/2023 07:26

What is it you do for a job? Surely with a masters degree you have to potential to advance in your career and earn more if that is all that’s holding you back? Could you move to a cheaper part of the country if housing costs are particularly high where you are?

Loubelle70 · 12/12/2023 07:26

I kinda feel the same..i am also from working class background, went to uni when older, got masters. Im in a good job, i luckily had my child (now 32) .. when i was 17. I don't think i would have had any children if i waited later in life. I love children but see poverty, injustice for people in poverty, how people have to fight for everything, bringing children up in such an uncaring selfish world etc...but...my daughter is well rounded, always worked and now has her own kids. I class myself as very lucky no matter my odd negativity 😊

Derb · 12/12/2023 07:22

I think your overthinking things and letting your experience cloud your judgement here.

Very exact same background here except with single parent. My main goal for my own family is stability and security in a strong and stable marriage because I didn't have that. It's the biggest privilege you can give your children.

All that other stuff I don't think is an issue. I was the first in my family to go to uni and have a very northern accent, I didn't find it an issue. My DH was the same. Anyways we live in a different area now so the kids have different accents.

We haven't and won't inherit any wealth but have and are continuing to build successful careers and financially comfortable now. But apart from extra curricular activities like swimming lessons and scouts, we don't have the need for private tutors etc. There is nothing wrong with a family staycation rather than abroad. We've done this lots.

We did wait until we were in our 30s to have DV however so we could afford a large enough house, maternity leave etc.

Benibidibici · 12/12/2023 07:22

A lot of things you can do to enrich a child's life can be done without spending a lot. You are university educated yourself, you'll have a wealth of skills and experience to pass on and are starting from a better base than many.

Your mindset is quite negative.

Sometimes you need to reframe your own experience. For our grandparents generation even remaining in education until 16 arguably should have put them far ahead of their parents, the reality is the change was across the whole population so the relative impact is not there. University education is the same for children of the 80s, it has become so widespread its lost its value adding capacity.

It feels like you expected more/faster social mobility from your experience. In reality social mobility only really occurs when you rise relative to the rest of your generational cohort and generally its a) rare, b) slow, and happens over several generations.

Passingthethyme · 12/12/2023 07:17

I think it's commendable that you're thinking of these things. I don't think money is everything but I do wish people would actually think about various aspects when choosing to have children, rather than just because they want to. Having children is inherently selfish