Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not have children because I can't give them a better or even equal life to mine?

162 replies

eastea · 11/12/2023 21:53

I grew up poor but I was bright, worked hard, went to University, got a first, and then a masters degree. I met and married my DH also the first in his family to go to university and have a professional job. We worked hard but we still have a standard of living roughly equivalent to that of our parents had and that is without us having kids yet. Even our generation as promised so much if only we got a degree but it all turned out to be lies for the most part, these days the debt is even more and the rewards even fewer so what about when babies today grow up?

It feels like in order to actually move up in the world now you can't just work your way there you need to inherit not only wealth but also contacts, a certain confidence and way of being in the world, having a private education for example.

My DH and I do ok but we live a pretty modest lifestyle and when I look at all the things most kids seem to do now like all the various lessons, extra curricular activates, tutoring it seems very out of reach. Not to mention the odd holiday abroad access to cultural activities that would help them to fit in once at university if they went. I know these things do matter because I went to university not having ever been abroad and in many instances though I knew what a word meant I would get the pronunciation wrong because I'd never heard it said aloud prior to being a uni. Those deficits marked me out as different, and I was ridiculed for my accent and I never quite fitted in (perhaps a feature of the university I went to where most were from very wealthy backgrounds).

I've seen other working class, university educated people who don't quite fit in anywhere go on to have kids who also don't quite fit in anywhere and I feel like if I could buy my kids what I didn't have though a private education or some other means then I might think of it but I just feel like its getting harder and harder for people to maintain what they have and that any gaps for meritocracy as closing up.

I just see a very bleak future where few make it and those that will probably have generations of wealth behind them and for those that don't I think life will probably be pretty miserable mired in debt, subscription fees, poor healthcare and little hope of having a secure home or even children of their own. That is even before I consider the environmental disaster that awaits us and future generations.

I just feel sometimes like its kinder not to have them.

OP posts:
Ohnanawhatsyourname · 12/12/2023 10:39

Hi OP - same boat as you 👋 same background too!

For us it’s because we can’t give them a better life financially AND we’d have scant/no family support (tbh we’re close to our families but they arent very emotionally available and if something happened to us I don’t know what would happen to the pretend kids).

I think if you have either of those - money or family - then it’s more a secure thing. Very much feel as you do on this.

Carrotmouse · 12/12/2023 10:32

If you are able to raise children in a stable and loving environment, they will have an enormous advantage compared to the many children (including wealthy ones) who are raised by parents with difficulties in providing this environment.

I do understand your feelings on not fitting in, but I think finding your place in the world sometimes includes understanding that you are one of those people without a tribe. I stick out for class and cultural reasons, so I have friends who are diverse in terms of age, class, life stage, values etc. I think this is great but I also envy people who just slot into an easy community.

If you want a child, I would think more about yourself and your relationship than about finances (provided you can afford to feed, clothe and house the child). Are you psychologically healthy? Can you put another person’s needs first? Do you and your partner communicate well? Those are without doubt the most important things and if you have them, you will be giving your child a leg-up.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 12/12/2023 10:29

We'll you are being a bit ridiculous obviously. But if you really, really, truly feel that you shouldn't have children because you won't be able to send them abroad to a range of countries to ensure that they never pronounce a word wrong then...okay, you do what you feel is right.

But if you and your husband have professional jobs and are living the same standard of life that you had when you "grew up poor" then you are making some odd decisions. Most of us have average jobs and we are getting by just fine.

WillowCraft · 12/12/2023 10:26

FlowerBarrow · 12/12/2023 10:08

Hmm working half a day once a week to pay for your own driving lessons (especially if a licence isnt actually needed) is absolutely not “struggling”, it’s normal life and has great value in many other ways.

Yes.. if parents just buy you everything you don't value it or have any understanding of how other people live.

I would definitely expect a child to at least contribute, they could have some lessons for Christmas as a main present, or pay half of each lesson if the whole lot seems a bit much.

It's beneficial to instill values, resilience, work ethic and confidence in your children. Making their life so easy because they just get given everything they want is not going to do them any good when they are adults and is actually a really selfish thing to do IMO.

WillowCraft · 12/12/2023 10:22

I think you're conflating two things here. Finances and a feeling of social worth that, for you, is related to wealth.

Wealth does not buy happiness. Yes you need a secure home that is warm and enough food and clothes, a few luxuries are nice too, but children absolutely do not need to live in luxury to be happy. What they need most is to feel secure with loving parents.

Social worth does not have to depend on wealth at all. I was brought up to value culture, reading, music, history, art, the outdoors, all of which are freely available or at fairly low cost. If you were brought up to value having material things then money may seem really important but it doesn't have to be that way.

I think it's really normal for people who were the first in the family to go to university to feel a bit lost in the world. I don't think that is due to wealth though. It's more to do with being different from what they've culturally grown up with, feeling different to their parents and wider family, moving away to a new area perhaps. There's a conflict there.

If you really want to earn more, then do more training or retrain. While you're young and have no kids is the ideal time to do that. Or alternatively mentally readjust to be happy with your lot.

Nosleepforthismum · 12/12/2023 10:17

OP if you want to have kids, go for it! I promise you they will adore you and they will make their own way in the world. I think a lot of what you’ve said in your original post is frankly nonsense. Kids don’t need a private education or even a university degree to be successful. There are loads of areas in the UK where it is affordable to buy property outside of London.

Unfortunately, being highly educated doesn’t always equate to being wealthy. My DSIS earns a very average salary despite her first class degree, masters and PHD. She also has huge student loans to pay off. My DH is a builder and earns substantially more with no debts to pay off. Only anecdotal I know, but there is more than one route to success.

Bireadwhatiread · 12/12/2023 10:13

You are thinking of the negatives. You might have blissfuly happy children growing up in a meritocracy who make lots of friends of all classes and races. More than ever class, gender and race lines are merging and there is more opportunity now than ever before .

Most families scrimp and save. Most go without. Will your kids notice or care? No!

Clytherow · 12/12/2023 10:12

FlowerBarrow · 12/12/2023 10:08

Hmm working half a day once a week to pay for your own driving lessons (especially if a licence isnt actually needed) is absolutely not “struggling”, it’s normal life and has great value in many other ways.

This. People who think they're doing their kids favours by not making them pay for anything at all are deluded. The opposite is true.

Autumnalday · 12/12/2023 10:11

VanityDiesHard · 12/12/2023 09:54

I think it is irresponsible to have children if you aren't able or willing to help them with these things.

Irresponsible parents are those that don't work to support their family and don't feed, clothe or show affection towards their children. Many wealthy parents don't spend much time with their children. The children spend most of their time with a paid nanny. My parents worked hard but also spent time with us too, playing with us, teaching us, buying us books, and taking us to places to broaden our minds. They took an interest in our interests.

FlowerBarrow · 12/12/2023 10:08

Hmm working half a day once a week to pay for your own driving lessons (especially if a licence isnt actually needed) is absolutely not “struggling”, it’s normal life and has great value in many other ways.

user14699084785 · 12/12/2023 10:03

Autumnalday · 12/12/2023 09:53

@user14699084785 young adults don't have family help with big stuff, driving lessons, first car, uni costs, house deposits, eventual inheritance, its a very harsh world

My siblings and I are in our 20s and teens and I think it is very entitled to expect your parents to pay for your driving lessons, car and house deposits. We haven't received any of these and why should we? I mainly relied on my student loan but had occasional help from my parents. I have lots of fond memories of day trips with my parents. As a result of my upbringing, I'm probably a lot more cultured and read more books than many middle class young adults.

It wouldn’t sit right with DH and I to have £££ in the bank, and then our 17yr old having to pay for driving lessons at £35 a go when their part time job pays £7 an hour (on very limited hours as A levels are priority.)
Each to their own.

And I can’t wait for them to pass and buy them a car as we live very rurally, and I’m fed up of being taxi service!
We can afford to make their lives easy, so we will, and why we only had two so we could afford to.
Why would I want them to struggle?

Clytherow · 12/12/2023 10:01

user14699084785 · 12/12/2023 09:20

I agree with all you’ve said.
You see it all the time on here - babies don’t cost much, can have hand-me-downs, no need for expensive presents etc, encouraging people to go on, have a third! …but I think the reality now is that if young adults don't have family help with big stuff, driving lessons, first car, uni costs, house deposits, eventual inheritance, its a very harsh world and I’m very glad we have the means to make our twos lives a bit easier as they become adults.

We were fortunate that my parents helped us massively financially when we were in our 20’s and we fully intend to do the same for ours. Money should run downwards!

I didn't have any help from my parents and nor did DH. We wouldn't have expected it either. We're mid thirties and there is no family money or inheritance - DH first person in his family to go to uni and my parents went to uni but don't have much money. Both of us earn a good wage, we live in a nice house in a nice area. I paid for my own driving lessons, for my own car, and we saved for our own deposit.

Frankly even though we have the money to give our children help with these things I certainly won't be impressed with them if the expectation is that we definitely will. A friend's child is currently at uni but refuses to get a part-time job to help with costs because they are "aiming" for a first. I got a first and still managed to work part-time, and thank goodness I did because I found it infinitely easier to find post-university work than my friends who couldn't be arsed working part time.

FlowerBarrow · 12/12/2023 09:58

I think the problem here @eastea is your personal definition of “thrive”. This is what’s holding you back from enjoying what you have. My guess would be that your feelings about this don’t just affect how you feel about having children, but spill over into other parts of your life.

Clytherow · 12/12/2023 09:55

CalistoNoSolo · 12/12/2023 08:51

Way too many people have way too many children without any thought at all of the financial aspect. I disagree that love, food and shelter is enough. Imo, that's the bare minimum and if you don't have the money to give your child a reasonable upbringing (with very good education and mind opening experiences) you shouldn't have children.

Are you saying you shouldn't have children if you can't afford to have them privately educated?

What if you could afford to have them privately educated but choose not to on the grounds you're morally opposed to private education?

VanityDiesHard · 12/12/2023 09:54

Autumnalday · 12/12/2023 09:53

@user14699084785 young adults don't have family help with big stuff, driving lessons, first car, uni costs, house deposits, eventual inheritance, its a very harsh world

My siblings and I are in our 20s and teens and I think it is very entitled to expect your parents to pay for your driving lessons, car and house deposits. We haven't received any of these and why should we? I mainly relied on my student loan but had occasional help from my parents. I have lots of fond memories of day trips with my parents. As a result of my upbringing, I'm probably a lot more cultured and read more books than many middle class young adults.

I think it is irresponsible to have children if you aren't able or willing to help them with these things.

Autumnalday · 12/12/2023 09:53

@user14699084785 young adults don't have family help with big stuff, driving lessons, first car, uni costs, house deposits, eventual inheritance, its a very harsh world

My siblings and I are in our 20s and teens and I think it is very entitled to expect your parents to pay for your driving lessons, car and house deposits. We haven't received any of these and why should we? I mainly relied on my student loan but had occasional help from my parents. I have lots of fond memories of day trips with my parents. As a result of my upbringing, I'm probably a lot more cultured and read more books than many middle class young adults.

DiscerningDiana · 12/12/2023 09:52

Would you ever consider moving to another country OP, any chance your qualifications would make it easy to get a job somewhere else? Cost of living not so bad everywhere and even where it is the class divisions you experienced are not so pronounced.

KatBurglar · 12/12/2023 09:46

You're not unreasonable at all, OP.

My adult child has decided against having children because he thinks with the climate crisis, he'll be bringing them up to face a pretty bleak world over the next 60+ years and he doesn't want that.

It's a perfectly valid point of view - I feel rather guilty that my children's world is much harsher than mine was as a young adult, with housing and cost of living and the endless negative repercussions of Brexit, plus wars in Ukraine and the middle east and the climate. It was so much more optimistic in the 90s.

Your reasons for or agaist having children are perfectly valid, don't let anyone put pressure on you in either direction.

Autumnalday · 12/12/2023 09:44

I also grew up working class and was the first in my family to go to university. Children don't need private education, expensive hobbies or holidays abroad (I didn't go on many holidays abroad as a child). I've never had issues with pronunciation because I've always had a wide range of vocabulary (being working class doesn't mean you have poor vocabulary). You can take your children to museums, art galleries etc and read books for culture.

Your last line and paragraph before that are incredibly depressing and melodramatic.

LadyHester · 12/12/2023 09:40

I think we overrate the importance of material comfort to happiness. We also very often think that happiness is within our control.
I see so many people around me (including myself) who are financially well off but whose lives are being torn apart by things completely out of their control: serious illness, divorce, worry about elderly parents, children’s mental health crises, (in one case) house burning down…
As I stumble my way through middle age I have come to realise how much we are at the mercy of random events and how insignificant are so many of the so called trappings of success.
I do realise that financial security helps to make these things more tolerable, but - if I’ve read the OP correctly - I think she was focused on something rather more than that.

FiveShelties · 12/12/2023 09:39

@eastea does your husband have the same view?

Beezknees · 12/12/2023 09:32

Also what is "decent?" Everyone will have a different opinion on what is decent.

Beezknees · 12/12/2023 09:31

CalistoNoSolo · 12/12/2023 09:28

No, we're saying unless you can provide a decent life for your children you shouldn't have any.

The person I responded to was talking about house deposits and inheritance. That's just not a reality for most people and a ridiculous expectation.

HomburgandTrilby · 12/12/2023 09:30

CalistoNoSolo · 12/12/2023 09:28

No, we're saying unless you can provide a decent life for your children you shouldn't have any.

But ‘decent’ is deeply subjective.

fpqand · 12/12/2023 09:30

I'm confused, you say you had a very deprived upbringing but even after uni and masters and a professional job you have the same standard of living as when you were growing up? What is your household income?