Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not have children because I can't give them a better or even equal life to mine?

162 replies

eastea · 11/12/2023 21:53

I grew up poor but I was bright, worked hard, went to University, got a first, and then a masters degree. I met and married my DH also the first in his family to go to university and have a professional job. We worked hard but we still have a standard of living roughly equivalent to that of our parents had and that is without us having kids yet. Even our generation as promised so much if only we got a degree but it all turned out to be lies for the most part, these days the debt is even more and the rewards even fewer so what about when babies today grow up?

It feels like in order to actually move up in the world now you can't just work your way there you need to inherit not only wealth but also contacts, a certain confidence and way of being in the world, having a private education for example.

My DH and I do ok but we live a pretty modest lifestyle and when I look at all the things most kids seem to do now like all the various lessons, extra curricular activates, tutoring it seems very out of reach. Not to mention the odd holiday abroad access to cultural activities that would help them to fit in once at university if they went. I know these things do matter because I went to university not having ever been abroad and in many instances though I knew what a word meant I would get the pronunciation wrong because I'd never heard it said aloud prior to being a uni. Those deficits marked me out as different, and I was ridiculed for my accent and I never quite fitted in (perhaps a feature of the university I went to where most were from very wealthy backgrounds).

I've seen other working class, university educated people who don't quite fit in anywhere go on to have kids who also don't quite fit in anywhere and I feel like if I could buy my kids what I didn't have though a private education or some other means then I might think of it but I just feel like its getting harder and harder for people to maintain what they have and that any gaps for meritocracy as closing up.

I just see a very bleak future where few make it and those that will probably have generations of wealth behind them and for those that don't I think life will probably be pretty miserable mired in debt, subscription fees, poor healthcare and little hope of having a secure home or even children of their own. That is even before I consider the environmental disaster that awaits us and future generations.

I just feel sometimes like its kinder not to have them.

OP posts:
BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 15:20

Clytherow · 13/12/2023 15:09

I don't agree, unless you think it's already too late and everyone will be dead in 30 years (which I don't) then we need more people. People concerned about the environment tend to raise other humans concerned about the environment, which is a good thing. Otherwise the only people who procreate are going to be climate change deniers. How is that helpful?

I do think it’s too late. Children being born now will have to live in circumstances that are unbearable by current standards, they’re not going to be dead in 30 years.

Allthatglittersisntart · 13/12/2023 15:18

It sounds like you are more educated than your parents so you can give them an advantage other what you had. Expensive extracurricular activities can be OTT. Children need time to be children. It does depend where you live though. I grew up poor but happy due to ideal location and with a RP accent enforced! Accents are a lot more celebrated these days though!
My DP has done better than me though career wise and he grew up rich when young then very very poor(no food level of poor) due to tragedy.

Clytherow · 13/12/2023 15:09

BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 11:32

Still a good reason not to bring children into the world.

I don't agree, unless you think it's already too late and everyone will be dead in 30 years (which I don't) then we need more people. People concerned about the environment tend to raise other humans concerned about the environment, which is a good thing. Otherwise the only people who procreate are going to be climate change deniers. How is that helpful?

Clytherow · 13/12/2023 15:07

sandragreen · 13/12/2023 10:03

The planet isn’t being destroyed. It’s being altered so it will not support life, certainly not human life anyway.

The planet will be here for millions of years after humans die out.

I think that’s what @Clytherow means?

That's exactly what I meant. The planet is going to be absolutely fine. Humans may not be, but the planet will be.

jonesysy · 13/12/2023 14:59

Thank god my mum never read MN beforeshe had me and got influenced by this nonsense. There will be humans on this planet for thousands more years and those that are will be equally grateful.

Kendodd · 13/12/2023 11:59

Beezknees · 12/12/2023 09:02

Essentially here you are saying that anyone earning minimum wage shouldn't have children. That's a wrong and very dangerous road to go down.

I think you've got this the wrong way around (and points to a more fundamental problem with the society we've made). It's not that people on minimum wage shouldn't have children because they can't afford a decent life for them. People on minimum wage SHOULD be able to afford a decent life so that they can afford children if they want, that's the issue we should be fixing. Plus, if this is fixed it takes away the need for parents to provide driving lessons/house deposits etc because the children can afford to provide for themselves. This isn't some 'we can't afford it' fantasy either, it's perfectly possible and was in the past, we just have to vote for it. A good start would be a massive council house building programme.

And somebody said upthread that money doesn't buy happiness,
true, but poverty absolutely does buy misery.

BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 11:32

jonesysy · 13/12/2023 10:36

its not semantics, you just dont understand the effect of climate change. The planet isn't turning into a burnt arid rock. It will sustain plenty of life even at many degrees warmer than now but many places will experience extreme weather and flooding and become difficult for humans to live in resulting in han migration, famine, wars etc. Deeply unpleasamt for people and the many animals that cannot adapt or migrate amd will become extinct. However as humans suffer and decline, other animals more adaptable than us will begin to thrive and new ecologies will develop

Still a good reason not to bring children into the world.

jonesysy · 13/12/2023 11:24

how many people regret that they were born?

or think that their mothers were selfish to have them?

SparklesInTheCloud · 13/12/2023 10:38

Op you are not wrong and everything you said in your post is an important factor that people should consider. Ironically, this consideration that you are showing even towards your unborn child would make you a very good parent.

Having said that if you want to have children I'd go ahead and do it. We all (except for the few who have been coerced) have children for the purely selfish reason that we want to have a child. The selflessness only starts after birth or maybe after conception. Evolutionary most of us are programmed to have a strong urge to procreate and so we do (not that this is an excuse and good on you for thinking beyond that). What I mean is you wouldn't be the first or the last to make this selfish decision. You'd just be like most of the world.

For millenniums people have been bringing children into a less than perfect world or at times into absolutely terrible conditions and we can't blame them. It's just what pretty much everyone did.

So while morally you are correct from a human point of view I think we can be forgiven for this just as we should be forgiven for other human emotions and needs.

However from an individual child's point of view you can say of course that you don't want your (unborn) child to suffer or that you dont want to follow thr masses and perpetuate the selfishness yourself. I think many young people these days hold that view and I think it's very noble and admirable.

No child requires to be born. If you aren't bothered either way or just aren't that keen on having a child then that's perfectly fine and you would be doing the right thing.

But if you do want a child then I don't think you should deprive yourself. I mean you won't find a good justification to have a child (I didn't and I tried very hard but finally I had to accept thst it was just to satisfy my desire to have a child) but maybe the fact that you want one, that we are kind of programmed through evolution to want one and that everyone else is just doing it does count for something. There's a lot of beauty and happiness still around and who knows we can only hope that the future won't be as bad as it looks right now. I'm very worried for my children as well especially about climate change and I did think very long and hard before I had my first DC. I tried to find a justification but I couldn't and finally had to accept that if I have a child it would be just to satisfy my own very selfish desire to have a child and thst I was knowingly going to subject this potential child of mine to all the suffering and pain they might encounter. It sounds crazy but honestly I can live with that and I don't regret it. In spite of worrying for their future I'm (selfishly) still so happy and relieved that I have my kids and all I can do now is to try and make life as decent for them as I can.

Apologies for rambling!!

jonesysy · 13/12/2023 10:36

its not semantics, you just dont understand the effect of climate change. The planet isn't turning into a burnt arid rock. It will sustain plenty of life even at many degrees warmer than now but many places will experience extreme weather and flooding and become difficult for humans to live in resulting in han migration, famine, wars etc. Deeply unpleasamt for people and the many animals that cannot adapt or migrate amd will become extinct. However as humans suffer and decline, other animals more adaptable than us will begin to thrive and new ecologies will develop

BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 10:16

It’s semantics. It’s a different way of saying the same thing. 🤷‍♀️

sandragreen · 13/12/2023 10:10

Are you saying earth didn’t exist before it cooled down enough to sustain human life?

It will still support other life forms once we are gone. We are just destroying our own future. That’s the message, and I think it’s an important one.

BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 10:06

A beautiful green planet capable of supporting and nurturing life is being transformed into a burnt arid rock. In what sane mind is that not destruction?

sandragreen · 13/12/2023 10:03

The planet isn’t being destroyed. It’s being altered so it will not support life, certainly not human life anyway.

The planet will be here for millions of years after humans die out.

I think that’s what @Clytherow means?

BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 09:49

Clytherow · 13/12/2023 08:29

The "planet" is not on the verge of extinction. The "planet" will be just fine. It's humanity that's threatened, and even then I think the likelihood of all humanity being totally wiped out is pretty slim.

Why the inverted commas around planet? We live on a planet which humankind is systematically destroying. Have you been asleep for the last 40 years?

LapwingDove · 13/12/2023 08:49

You’re not unreasonable to take into account your personal circumstances when deciding whether to have children. We have one DD but didn’t have a second primarily because of our age and finances (which are absolutely fine but would’ve been stretched by a second).

Where we differ is your bleak, pessimistic outlook on the future generally. I’m sure someone having a child in the midst of the Second World War or the Great Depression would’ve probably had the same view of the future.

Clytherow · 13/12/2023 08:29

BIossomtoes · 12/12/2023 14:26

When was the planet last on the verge of extinction?

The "planet" is not on the verge of extinction. The "planet" will be just fine. It's humanity that's threatened, and even then I think the likelihood of all humanity being totally wiped out is pretty slim.

KTheGrey · 12/12/2023 17:04

This is quite sad to read. Do you live in London? Is there no way to train upwards for either of you? Career alteration?

Inkyblue123 · 12/12/2023 16:56

It sounds more like you are disappointed in your own life. maybe it’s time to count your blessings.

titchy · 12/12/2023 16:49

The vast majority of kids don't have the things you claim are essential to a happy life - but they're happy. So it's reasonable to assume you don't need private schooling, tons of extra curriculars and foreign holidays to have a happy life. So if that genuinely is your only reason for not having kids then it's a very flawed reason - perhaps talking to someone would help you work out why those are things you regard as essential to be happy.

If that's just an excuse and you just don't like the idea of having kids that's a perfectly valid reason - own it!

5128gap · 12/12/2023 16:46

There is no reason at all why, provided you're in good health, two educated adults should not be able to offer children a comfortable life. You may not be able to live that life in the most expensive areas of the UK , or in your dream house, or spend a fortune on consumer goods, but a good life nonetheless. As for your children, why should things be worse for them? If you can feed, clothe and educate them, they can go on to build a comfortable life for themselves too. Plenty of us come from WC backgrounds, have to watch our budget and will inherit nothing, but our lives and those of our children still have value, meaning and joy.

Beezknees · 12/12/2023 16:43

VanityDiesHard · 12/12/2023 12:10

Why? Why is it ridiculous? Having children is a luxury, not a right.

Because the majority of people cannot afford to help their children with house deposits and things like that. It's ridiculous to suggest that you shouldn't have children if you can't do that.

I also disagree that having children is a "luxury" and think that's an incredibly sad way of just saying that poor people should just accept their place in life and not demand anything better. Snobby, appalling attitude.

XelaM · 12/12/2023 16:42

My family have zero contacts and live abroad. I work for one of the top law firms in the City and honestly I have absolutely no clue which school any of my colleagues went to 🤷‍♀️ it actually never comes up in any conversation. (I went to state school btw but abroad if it matters.)

Orangeandgold · 12/12/2023 16:32

My DD was a “surprise” pregnancy in my late teens. I think if I didn’t get pregnant that way I would not plan to have children, not right now in my life anyway - it just feels like we are on an ongoing treadmill. I do have an ideal scenario in mind to bring children in - that never happened - but I am also ambitious and resilient and will drop anything for my daughter and she is one of the best people I know.

What I have learned about parenting is that you are raising another human that will have their ups and downs. They will need to go through life and learn. No matter what the external looks like, it’s all about raising people to learn to be grateful and how to handle the world when it’s their turn to do it alone. We build memories for them - for some it’s travelling and for others it’s talking walks in their cities because that is what is nearby.

The world right now is awful! It really is. We have a generation of people growing up knowing this - and I’m sure a few will be in positions when they are older to do their part to make it better.

We are humans, we procreate. If you don’t want children, don’t have them. If you do - it’s not the end of the world.

jonesysy · 12/12/2023 15:30

"Our generation was promised so much but it was lies"
😂