Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not have children because I can't give them a better or even equal life to mine?

162 replies

eastea · 11/12/2023 21:53

I grew up poor but I was bright, worked hard, went to University, got a first, and then a masters degree. I met and married my DH also the first in his family to go to university and have a professional job. We worked hard but we still have a standard of living roughly equivalent to that of our parents had and that is without us having kids yet. Even our generation as promised so much if only we got a degree but it all turned out to be lies for the most part, these days the debt is even more and the rewards even fewer so what about when babies today grow up?

It feels like in order to actually move up in the world now you can't just work your way there you need to inherit not only wealth but also contacts, a certain confidence and way of being in the world, having a private education for example.

My DH and I do ok but we live a pretty modest lifestyle and when I look at all the things most kids seem to do now like all the various lessons, extra curricular activates, tutoring it seems very out of reach. Not to mention the odd holiday abroad access to cultural activities that would help them to fit in once at university if they went. I know these things do matter because I went to university not having ever been abroad and in many instances though I knew what a word meant I would get the pronunciation wrong because I'd never heard it said aloud prior to being a uni. Those deficits marked me out as different, and I was ridiculed for my accent and I never quite fitted in (perhaps a feature of the university I went to where most were from very wealthy backgrounds).

I've seen other working class, university educated people who don't quite fit in anywhere go on to have kids who also don't quite fit in anywhere and I feel like if I could buy my kids what I didn't have though a private education or some other means then I might think of it but I just feel like its getting harder and harder for people to maintain what they have and that any gaps for meritocracy as closing up.

I just see a very bleak future where few make it and those that will probably have generations of wealth behind them and for those that don't I think life will probably be pretty miserable mired in debt, subscription fees, poor healthcare and little hope of having a secure home or even children of their own. That is even before I consider the environmental disaster that awaits us and future generations.

I just feel sometimes like its kinder not to have them.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
smallhousewonders · 20/03/2024 12:05

I hear you. I always thought there would be a natural progression through the generations. Doesn’t seem like it now. I agree about contacts and networks. I didn’t have those either. My kids are getting by because they’re bright but it’s much more of a struggle for them. I feel sad that someone with your achievements feels parenthood is ill advised. Your future children would make an important contribution to a balanced, safer society.

Clytherow · 14/12/2023 12:24

BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 19:30

That’s all very lovely but it’s all a bit too new age for my taste. I’m a cynic.

sounds like a joyful way to live, and if you're right, well you won't end up any more or less doomed than the rest of us for being cynical.

Flickersy · 14/12/2023 10:46

It's true there is a vast difference between the expectations we were brought up with and the reality we now live in.

I remember when I was growing up my dad would say to me "if you work hard and do well at school and get good results in your exams and go to university and get a good job, you won't have to live in a house like that" (pointing to some rougher areas as we drove past).

His snobbery aside, I did all of the above (incurring the corresponding university debt) and houses like "that" are all I can afford to live in - as part of a house share!!

When you're told all your life "do this and you'll be fine" and then you're not fine, it is a depressing prospect because to be fine is out of your reach through circumstances beyond your control.

Ortila · 14/12/2023 10:20

You sound quite depressed.

Don't be intimidated by the middle classes. And don't chase them, thinking you have to have everything they have in order to thrive. Most of them are chasing each other.

That list of must haves, put it to one side. It's not a recipe for happiness, not for you or any children you might have. It's just what you've put together from observing the bourgeoisie. It's not meaningful.

You already have a lot - education, a professional job, a steady marriage. Build on that however you please. Who cares where you fit in? Pretty much every one of those people you're looking at and wanting to fit in with are all anxious about losing fit themselves through some economic or social disaster which at some level they fear they are one step away from. It's all an appearance, an illusion. If you don't/can't match an appearance, does that matter a damn?

Enjoy your life, have kids or not as you please, concentrate on the people you love and don't measure yourself against some shifting and amorphous view of success.

LikeTheMorningDew · 14/12/2023 07:28

I hear you OP. I definitely wish I could have had 3+ kids, but the economic outlook is so bleak that it wouldn't be fair.

OutsideLookingOut · 14/12/2023 07:22

VanityDiesHard · 13/12/2023 20:05

I didn't say it was 'a good' reason. I said that it was MY reason. When it comes to not having children, any reason is valid as it is not actually compulsory. Have you ever read any of those Buzzfeed threads about people who were ambivalent about having children and then went ahead and had them anyway, because they felt it was somehow expected of them? Bit of an eye opener. These people (90% of them women) felt trapped, resentful of their kids and the loss of their freedom, and impoverished. I would feel the same unless I had enough money for a LOT of care, a good boarding school, and a lot of extras as well. People have different priorities in life and that's ok. People who constantly say 'it's the simple things that count' are annoying IMO. They should speak for themselves, not for everyone else.

Yeah I kind of agree though not with a boarding school unless they are teens who want to go.

Patenting looks way easier with enough money and opportunities for the children.

OutsideLookingOut · 14/12/2023 07:20

HomburgandTrilby · 13/12/2023 18:03

Sure, there are people who wish they hadn’t been born, but as parents can’t time travel to check this ahead of time before conceiving, I’m not sure what the point is — don’t ever have a child in case that child has an unhappy life?

Maybe think about what kind of life your prospective child might have. To be realistic, money makes even bad situations easier. A lot of these people experienced ACEs, trauma, etc etc. Even then you can’t guarantee your child will be happy or healthy, it is just something to consider before bringing another human into the world.

naughtynine · 13/12/2023 21:19

It’s a sorry state of affairs but I think lots feel like the OP hence the birth rates.

Beezknees · 13/12/2023 21:04

VanityDiesHard · 13/12/2023 20:05

I didn't say it was 'a good' reason. I said that it was MY reason. When it comes to not having children, any reason is valid as it is not actually compulsory. Have you ever read any of those Buzzfeed threads about people who were ambivalent about having children and then went ahead and had them anyway, because they felt it was somehow expected of them? Bit of an eye opener. These people (90% of them women) felt trapped, resentful of their kids and the loss of their freedom, and impoverished. I would feel the same unless I had enough money for a LOT of care, a good boarding school, and a lot of extras as well. People have different priorities in life and that's ok. People who constantly say 'it's the simple things that count' are annoying IMO. They should speak for themselves, not for everyone else.

You absolutely have every right to not want kids for whatever reason but the boarding school bit threw me - you know most kids wouldn't even want to go to boarding school??

Sallybegood · 13/12/2023 20:57

VanityDiesHard · 13/12/2023 20:05

I didn't say it was 'a good' reason. I said that it was MY reason. When it comes to not having children, any reason is valid as it is not actually compulsory. Have you ever read any of those Buzzfeed threads about people who were ambivalent about having children and then went ahead and had them anyway, because they felt it was somehow expected of them? Bit of an eye opener. These people (90% of them women) felt trapped, resentful of their kids and the loss of their freedom, and impoverished. I would feel the same unless I had enough money for a LOT of care, a good boarding school, and a lot of extras as well. People have different priorities in life and that's ok. People who constantly say 'it's the simple things that count' are annoying IMO. They should speak for themselves, not for everyone else.

I know having kids isn’t compulsory (I don’t have them), and if your point is that you wouldn’t want to have them without the money to outsource a lot of the care to other people, then fair enough. But your original post didn’t say that, it seemed more to do with feeling inadequate due to not having met a very specific and unusual set of standards. Of course that’s your prerogative, and I’m sorry if it comes across as patronising or self-righteous or whatever to say that seems to me a shame, that’s not how I mean it. FWIW I wouldn’t say ‘it’s the simple things that count’ because I didn’t feel like leaving London etc had to do with focusing on simple things, it was more like having more space and freedom to think about complex things once 50% of my brain wasn’t being taken up with worry about insane property prices, and the ES magazine telling me to spend £2,000 on a new jacket on the tube ride home, and etc. But that’s me, and if different things are important to you then different things are important. I guess all I’m trying to say is that, for me, a change of context made me realise that what was important to me wasn’t necessarily what I had thought it was. YMMV.

VanityDiesHard · 13/12/2023 20:05

Sallybegood · 13/12/2023 19:58

I strongly disagree that not being part of the 1% is a valid reason not to have children.

In the case of some of these posts I think you might benefit from moving to a different and possibly cheaper city (particularly if you live in London) and finding a different set of friends who are less materialistic and didn’t all go to Oxbridge (which I assume is what we’re talking about). I’ve been in that bubble and I know it can make people feel very inadequate and unhappy, but there’s a whole fulfilling world out there if you step outside it.

I didn't say it was 'a good' reason. I said that it was MY reason. When it comes to not having children, any reason is valid as it is not actually compulsory. Have you ever read any of those Buzzfeed threads about people who were ambivalent about having children and then went ahead and had them anyway, because they felt it was somehow expected of them? Bit of an eye opener. These people (90% of them women) felt trapped, resentful of their kids and the loss of their freedom, and impoverished. I would feel the same unless I had enough money for a LOT of care, a good boarding school, and a lot of extras as well. People have different priorities in life and that's ok. People who constantly say 'it's the simple things that count' are annoying IMO. They should speak for themselves, not for everyone else.

Sallybegood · 13/12/2023 19:58

VanityDiesHard · 11/12/2023 22:40

I can get where the OP is coming from, though. I think that there is a sense of inferiority that comes from not being wealthy. I come from a middle class background and am privately educated, but I feel I am a failure because I am not 1%, and I am intelligent but not as successful as I ought to be. I wouldn't have children for the same reason, and also because I just know I would want my kids to do so much better than me, and that pressure isn't fair.

I strongly disagree that not being part of the 1% is a valid reason not to have children.

In the case of some of these posts I think you might benefit from moving to a different and possibly cheaper city (particularly if you live in London) and finding a different set of friends who are less materialistic and didn’t all go to Oxbridge (which I assume is what we’re talking about). I’ve been in that bubble and I know it can make people feel very inadequate and unhappy, but there’s a whole fulfilling world out there if you step outside it.

BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 19:30

jonesysy · 13/12/2023 18:07

All of us lucky enough to be born have got those unknown number of years on this planet to experience life to witness it, to discover it, to be a part of it and to find their place in it. To be a friend, to make a difference. People in different times and places have always lived through hard times and though we don't know all their names we know that many people struggled, suffered and gave their lives to causes that were greater than themselves. We need those people more than ever and I hope my children and their children are those sorts of people and one day a new spring for humanity arrives after people realise what selfishness cost them

That’s all very lovely but it’s all a bit too new age for my taste. I’m a cynic.

jonesysy · 13/12/2023 18:07

All of us lucky enough to be born have got those unknown number of years on this planet to experience life to witness it, to discover it, to be a part of it and to find their place in it. To be a friend, to make a difference. People in different times and places have always lived through hard times and though we don't know all their names we know that many people struggled, suffered and gave their lives to causes that were greater than themselves. We need those people more than ever and I hope my children and their children are those sorts of people and one day a new spring for humanity arrives after people realise what selfishness cost them

JaneyGee · 13/12/2023 18:03

"I'd say life for most people in the UK is now immeasurably more affluent than when I was a working class child in the '60s"

Possibly. It depends how you measure wealth. Yes, we have more stuff, and more cheap electronic goods, and so on, but our quality of life is much worse than it was in the '60s. For a start, there's just no flippin room. You can't move. Not only are there far too many people, the pace of life is speeding up. I'm in the south east, and at times I feel like I'm suffocating. The traffic is awful. So bad, in fact, that I hardly bother going out. My local woods have been hacked down to make way for a new housing estate, and a second massive estate is being built at the other end of the village that is more like a new town.

In 1960, there were three billion humans. Today there are eight billion, and we're heading for ten. I know someone will say that the birth rate is dropping, but that's only true in Europe. Africa's birth rate is so high their population is going to double by 2050. Plus, of course, people are living longer. Add climate change into that mix, and you've got a disaster on your hands. I'd swap DVD players and microwaves and central heating for more space and silence and green fields.

HomburgandTrilby · 13/12/2023 18:03

OutsideLookingOut · 13/12/2023 17:30

It is quite taboo to admit to this but there are a minority who would say they would rather not be born (and maybe more who have been tranquilised out of the feeling with antidepressants). Just look up anti natalists.

Sure, there are people who wish they hadn’t been born, but as parents can’t time travel to check this ahead of time before conceiving, I’m not sure what the point is — don’t ever have a child in case that child has an unhappy life?

OutsideLookingOut · 13/12/2023 17:30

jonesysy · 13/12/2023 16:21

Theres a difference between not having kids because the world is overpopulated and not having them because you think their lives will be unbearably bad. But both reasons are flawed. The first because whetheror not you have kids makes as much difference as a mosquitos fart in a hurricane. The second reason is flawed because you're infantilising your offspring. They are future humans, able to make the best of their circumstances just like every other person who has ever lived. Sure many of those people suffered, but did they not also find times of joy, times they laughed, loved, cared and helped each other? When did any of those people, even in their darkest hours say that they wished they had never been born?

It is quite taboo to admit to this but there are a minority who would say they would rather not be born (and maybe more who have been tranquilised out of the feeling with antidepressants). Just look up anti natalists.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/12/2023 17:28

When did any of those people, even in their darkest hours say that they wished they had never been born?

When they were 14, almost certainly Grin

Clytherow · 13/12/2023 17:06

BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 15:35

If it makes them think twice about the most damaging thing they could possibly do, ie add to the population, it’s a very good one. The world’s population is constantly rising, the last thing we need is more people.

Right, so then all hope is NOT lost, right, because if it was it really wouldn't matter how many children people had as it wouldn't make a blind bit of difference anyway.

If I was planning kids - I'm not - and I read something like that I'd think, well, whatever, if humanity is doomed anyway what does it matter?

jonesysy · 13/12/2023 16:21

Theres a difference between not having kids because the world is overpopulated and not having them because you think their lives will be unbearably bad. But both reasons are flawed. The first because whetheror not you have kids makes as much difference as a mosquitos fart in a hurricane. The second reason is flawed because you're infantilising your offspring. They are future humans, able to make the best of their circumstances just like every other person who has ever lived. Sure many of those people suffered, but did they not also find times of joy, times they laughed, loved, cared and helped each other? When did any of those people, even in their darkest hours say that they wished they had never been born?

eastea · 13/12/2023 15:59

Clytherow · 13/12/2023 15:24

I'm not sure I agree with this either if I'm honest. "Unbearable by current standards" - I mean - in that case, how would they know better? Human beings are amazingly resilient and adaptable, and even in terrible, awful situations there is still humanity, kindness and laughter.

However I still don't think that children in the developed world are likely to be living in "unbearable" circumstances in 30 years' time.

Its convenient to think that though, not that I hope you aren't right I hope you are but its human nature to think things will work out and be fine but if you actually look at what the modelling shows it isn't all fine and many even think the modelling is too optimistic as its almost impossible to take into account the cumulative effect of all the various feedback loops and tipping points we are already seeing occur. If I were already a parent I'd want to look on the bright side to.

OP posts:
BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 15:35

If it makes them think twice about the most damaging thing they could possibly do, ie add to the population, it’s a very good one. The world’s population is constantly rising, the last thing we need is more people.

Clytherow · 13/12/2023 15:31

BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 15:28

It’s you who’s set an arbitrary 30 year limit, some of us take a long term view. The developed world is already seeing unprecedented levels of immigration, as parts of the world close to the equator continue to heat up this will increase. I’m sick of climate change deniers trivialising its effects which are already impacting on us.

Excuse me, I am not a climate change denier. Not thinking humanity is utterly doomed in the short term (and by the short term in mean within the next 100 years) - which, btw, many well respected climate scientists agree with, including Michael Mann - does not equal "climate change denial".

Telling people everyone is doomed and there is no hope is, as a strategy to evoke action, not a great one.

BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 15:28

It’s you who’s set an arbitrary 30 year limit, some of us take a long term view. The developed world is already seeing unprecedented levels of immigration, as parts of the world close to the equator continue to heat up this will increase. I’m sick of climate change deniers trivialising its effects which are already impacting on us.

Clytherow · 13/12/2023 15:24

BIossomtoes · 13/12/2023 15:20

I do think it’s too late. Children being born now will have to live in circumstances that are unbearable by current standards, they’re not going to be dead in 30 years.

I'm not sure I agree with this either if I'm honest. "Unbearable by current standards" - I mean - in that case, how would they know better? Human beings are amazingly resilient and adaptable, and even in terrible, awful situations there is still humanity, kindness and laughter.

However I still don't think that children in the developed world are likely to be living in "unbearable" circumstances in 30 years' time.