Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect after school club to provide a proper tea?

319 replies

Fummymummy · 11/12/2023 19:09

Genuinely don't know what the norm is here so looking for perspective.

Dd is in reception and goes to wrap around after school.
After she'd come home starving several times, I asked the staff for more info about the tea set up.
They serve tea at 3.30pm, DD says she isn't hungry then so doesn't eat. Fair enough.The food is then taken away and they can have a cracker or a biscuit as snacks later on.
Every single day last week she has had crackers for tea, and today she's had 1 biscuit!
I get that she's offered tea but if she isn't hungry they can't force her to eat, and they have to have a cut off - that's fine, so I asked if they would at least save her plate for later so she at least gets her tea even if it's cold.
She came home yet again today absolutely starving. Doesn't seem like they're keeping her plate back.

We don't get home until about 6pm so she's going from 11.40 (when reception eat) til then.

AIBU to be pissed off that she's living off crackers and biscuits when she's meant to have tea there?
I don't get why it's so early, or why they need to take plates away if some clearly haven't eaten.
Is this normal? Do most kids have to have a second tea at home later? (We usually have bedtime snacks, not a full meal). I know it's not like a nursery where the ratio is lower, but it feels poor that they're letting her go without (bar the crackers).

She's in bed for 7pm so it's a struggle when I'm having to rustle something proper up between getting home, doing her reading and bath/ bedtime.

Am I expecting too much?

OP posts:
Grammarnut · 13/12/2023 08:44

waterrat · 11/12/2023 21:03

god depressingly low standards here for childcare. This is a 4 or 5 year old - they should be allowed and encouraged to eat when hungry!!

My kids were at a childminder and were given proper dinner - our school ASC does spag bol etc proper tea -

And 330 and then no other chance to eat??? For a little reception kid?

This is just bullshit levels of care for children.

Should not eat 'when hungry' but when it is time to eat. Routine is very important to children and also teaching children that they are the centre of the world and should eat when they please is not a good way to bring children up, nor lead to a healthy eating pattern in adulthood.

Ktime · 13/12/2023 08:38

Grammarnut · 13/12/2023 08:22

That's true enough though her job doesn't sound like split shifts at a supermarket. She may have a crippling mortgage or aged parents to help out, we don't know. But DD seems to be in school (reception probably starts at 8.30) from early morning to early evening, which is a long time for a small child. I dislike this idea that everyone has to go out to work and that bringing up one's own children is a waste of a woman's education, qualifications etc so I am rather biased but 8 hours seems a long time to be in school, and then practically straight to bed with a snack at 7pm. At the very least the OP needs to re-organise her thoughts here and think about providing a proper family meal at the end of the day, even if it's pizza and chips and mushy peas (even cack-handed DHs can do that), and a slice of bought apple pie, all sitting at a table together and not watching TV, bustling around getting the child ready for bed.

Hilarious that OP should provide a ‘proper family family’ but cack-handed husbands can get away with pizza and chips.

Beezknees · 13/12/2023 08:33

Grammarnut · 13/12/2023 08:22

That's true enough though her job doesn't sound like split shifts at a supermarket. She may have a crippling mortgage or aged parents to help out, we don't know. But DD seems to be in school (reception probably starts at 8.30) from early morning to early evening, which is a long time for a small child. I dislike this idea that everyone has to go out to work and that bringing up one's own children is a waste of a woman's education, qualifications etc so I am rather biased but 8 hours seems a long time to be in school, and then practically straight to bed with a snack at 7pm. At the very least the OP needs to re-organise her thoughts here and think about providing a proper family meal at the end of the day, even if it's pizza and chips and mushy peas (even cack-handed DHs can do that), and a slice of bought apple pie, all sitting at a table together and not watching TV, bustling around getting the child ready for bed.

But it's absolutely none of your business what other women want to do. It's not your place to tell someone else how they should live their life.

Ktime · 13/12/2023 08:30

If they’re things like sandwiches and sausage rolls, could she put them in a lunch box when they’re served and have them later when she’s Hindu?

Grammarnut · 13/12/2023 08:22

Beezknees · 13/12/2023 07:35

You have no idea of OP's circumstances and it's none of your business what hours she chooses to work, that wasn't what she was asking.

That's true enough though her job doesn't sound like split shifts at a supermarket. She may have a crippling mortgage or aged parents to help out, we don't know. But DD seems to be in school (reception probably starts at 8.30) from early morning to early evening, which is a long time for a small child. I dislike this idea that everyone has to go out to work and that bringing up one's own children is a waste of a woman's education, qualifications etc so I am rather biased but 8 hours seems a long time to be in school, and then practically straight to bed with a snack at 7pm. At the very least the OP needs to re-organise her thoughts here and think about providing a proper family meal at the end of the day, even if it's pizza and chips and mushy peas (even cack-handed DHs can do that), and a slice of bought apple pie, all sitting at a table together and not watching TV, bustling around getting the child ready for bed.

Grammarnut · 13/12/2023 08:15

Beezknees · 13/12/2023 07:34

When DS was at after school club they did things like sandwiches, wraps, pasta, spaghetti hoops on toast, chicken burgers. Not hugely substantial but better than just crackers!

There's no suggestion this after-school club does not do that, it is that the DD won't eat it. Crackers are a light snack later.

Grammarnut · 13/12/2023 08:13

3.30 sounds about right for a light tea, if children have lunch at 11.40. Most will be peckish by then. I'd check your DD is only not eating because she isn't hungry and not because she is upset at not seeing you for what sounds like 8/10 hours and then goes to bed very nearly as soon as she gets home (if you are collecting her and then going straight home). Most families will be sharing an evening meal, before getting their children off to bed (and how will you do later, when DD has evening things to do, e.g. sports clubs, Brownies, music lessons etc?). And YABU to expect an evening meal from an after-school club; they aren't expected (nor being paid by the sounds of it) to provide the evening meal, that's your job. Mine (admittedly a long time ago) went from school (from age 4 and a half for DD, and lunch was at 12.00) to childminder (who picked them up and provided a snack and drinks) to home, where they'd have a light snack (toast, etc.) before dinner, which was a full meal with a pudding, before bed at about eight. Children eat a lot, even though in small amounts at a time, so if your DD is refusing food at 3.30 (over 3 hours since lunch) then something else is going on.

Caterpillarsleftfoot · 13/12/2023 07:58

A cup of tea surely wouldn't be normal for a small child?

LlamaLoopy · 13/12/2023 07:41

Ours used to do early tea because they had 2 pick up slots and that was the only way to accommodate those picked up earlier.

is she actually not hungry or distracted by other activities she could be doing instead of eating? This was always a problem with my son - they started making them all remain at the table for a set time (couldn’t choose to go play instead) and he started eating then as did lots of them!

Beezknees · 13/12/2023 07:35

DragonFly98 · 12/12/2023 23:09

You need to work part time your hours and the lack of proper food are not fair on your dc. You are not a single parent, you have two incomes you don't have to work full time.

You have no idea of OP's circumstances and it's none of your business what hours she chooses to work, that wasn't what she was asking.

Beezknees · 13/12/2023 07:34

When DS was at after school club they did things like sandwiches, wraps, pasta, spaghetti hoops on toast, chicken burgers. Not hugely substantial but better than just crackers!

nononoyesno · 13/12/2023 07:31

No idea why people are giving so much grief to the OP who has asked a question, taken on board responses and seems lovely!
OP - I found the change from nursery to school and wrap around tricky with food. Like your DD mine had an early tea at nursery and was happy with a snack when they got home. This was enough for her.
Our ASC didn't offer a meal so I knew in advance I needed to make dinner when we got in around 6 but it was still HARD! Extra meal planning and batch cooking, and a really hungry little girl who couldn't even wait 10mins for something to be heated. It did get easier as she got bigger, and eventually I was able to move my start time even earlier so we could get home a bit sooner. Now my youngest has just started school and she's also been soooo hungry for tea even when getting in and fed earlier than her sister was. She's adjusting now and I'm looking forward (in some ways!) to bed time getting a bit later so the evening is less of a rush.
Good luck with it all x

LBFseBrom · 13/12/2023 04:10

I wish you and your daughter all the best, op.

pollymere · 13/12/2023 00:28

Mine started needing a full meal in the evenings as school meals and snacks just didn't really do the job. Hopefully as yours gets older, she'll be able to have a simple meal at 6:30 or 7pm and then go to bed around 7:30 or 8pm. Good luck!

Fummymummy · 12/12/2023 23:54

I haven't said I don't want to give her proper food. I've taken on board comments, realised what they provide isn't what I thought, and have since given her tea at home and plan to continue to do so.
And I've made it pretty clear that she's always had something when she's got home - just supper rather than a home cooked hot meal.

I have said several times flexing my hours isn't an option right now but it should be in the new year. No, I can't just afford to go part time "because we have 2 incomes" on what planet are some people on? And not only that, but my job isn't doable on less hours - I wasn't able to drop any after asking my employer. Which is why I can't be available for pick ups.

And to be very clear, I do not give a fuck what time anyone else thinks is appropriate for my child (that you have never met) to go to bed at. She goes to bed at 7. End of.

OP posts:
PuttingDownRoots · 12/12/2023 23:22

What does she get for her school lunch/dinner? Mine only wanted something light like scrambled eggs, cheese on toast, sandwiches, pitta bread with veg sticks each as they had a full meal at lunch time. So most could be prepared in advance so could be produced very quickly if necessary.

And judgemental people... bore off. Its a mother doing their best. It would be lovely if OP could earn a full time wage for school hours work... but thats not how life works. Shes working to pay for food, housing, clothes etc, not going down the pub while her child lingers in an orphanage...

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 12/12/2023 23:17

I think maybe you were a bit spoilt by nursery?

DragonFly98 · 12/12/2023 23:09

Fummymummy · 12/12/2023 21:30

Thank you for this wonderful post! Where are all the normal people like you?
Can't believe someone asked me why I had a child 😂😂😂 honestly!
Yes, it's very sad as another poster says, she's at school for 11 hours. (Well, usually about 10). Well, what else should I do with them while I'm at work?
DH works away for weeks at a time - but of course that's no issue, he's fine to have kids and never see them. (Btw DH is brilliant, pulls his weight at home when he's back too).

May as well update everyone while I'm here, DD had crackers at ASC tonight, apparently she didn't want to eat with everyone else like I asked because tea was hot dogs, and she doesn't like them. So I made her fish fingers, smiley faces and beans for tea when we got home.

Oh and since she had a slightly later bedtime last night due to me taking a while to rustle up food before bed, she was AWFUL this evening. But yes, I should definitely push her bedtime later because it's not already hard enough for her to cope with the super long days, that I never ever feel sad or guilty about because obviously I should never have had children 😅

You need to work part time your hours and the lack of proper food are not fair on your dc. You are not a single parent, you have two incomes you don't have to work full time.

Thedm · 12/12/2023 22:46

Fummymummy · 12/12/2023 21:30

Thank you for this wonderful post! Where are all the normal people like you?
Can't believe someone asked me why I had a child 😂😂😂 honestly!
Yes, it's very sad as another poster says, she's at school for 11 hours. (Well, usually about 10). Well, what else should I do with them while I'm at work?
DH works away for weeks at a time - but of course that's no issue, he's fine to have kids and never see them. (Btw DH is brilliant, pulls his weight at home when he's back too).

May as well update everyone while I'm here, DD had crackers at ASC tonight, apparently she didn't want to eat with everyone else like I asked because tea was hot dogs, and she doesn't like them. So I made her fish fingers, smiley faces and beans for tea when we got home.

Oh and since she had a slightly later bedtime last night due to me taking a while to rustle up food before bed, she was AWFUL this evening. But yes, I should definitely push her bedtime later because it's not already hard enough for her to cope with the super long days, that I never ever feel sad or guilty about because obviously I should never have had children 😅

The bottom line is that she needs to eat proper food. Even if she ate the hot dogs at 3.30, that’s not enough to get her through to the next morning.

You need to find a way to make sure she has dinner, either keeping her up later or picking her up earlier. Or have dinner already cooked (slow cooker) for when she walks in the door. If she cannot stay up late enough to eat dinner with your current work times then you need to find a way to adjust those, or put her to a childminder who will feed her a proper meal instead of ASC.

But you cannot just carry on wither her eating cracker and then just having a slice of toast when she gets home. Her poor diet will be contributing to her tiredness.

I was a single mum to two kids and had to use ASC so I could work. I still fed them. Stop acting like no one else understands. We do. But she needs dinner so you have to change something.

gemma19846 · 12/12/2023 22:32

Why would you rather your child ate cold food than make her proper tea when she gets home?

Noglitterallowed · 12/12/2023 22:28

It’s an after school club not a room service when your child feels like eating unfortunately. She’s being offered food and not wanting it not a lot they can do really. Imagine if every child wanted tea at a different time? How would that even work. It’s like lunch times at school they are set times. Yeah you’re paying but not enough to dictate that they are at your child’s beck and call.

Whatthefnow · 12/12/2023 22:20

You need to cook your kid a dinner.

Cantab54321 · 12/12/2023 22:07

Batch cooking and freezing portions is the way forward. After a few weeks it is second nature and so easy to get a healthy meal on the table quickly.

Wonderfulstuff · 12/12/2023 21:34

OP -my DC goes to a childminder instead of ASC and one of the deciding factors was that she got a proper tea at the childminder. I commute and am rarely home before 7 so there's no chance of us having cosy weekday family dinner times... this is something we only get to enjoy at the weekend. So knowing that she's had a decent nutritious tea is a relief and means that DH can pick up her and get cracking on reading homework and bedtime routine (and yes we are in Yr1 and still do a 7pm bedtime - I didn't think this was weird before this thread!). I do fully appreciate that good Childminders are like gold dust and not all schools have them but if you can find one I would strongly recommend it.

Fummymummy · 12/12/2023 21:30

OlympicProcrastinator · 12/12/2023 09:13

Wraparound care isn’t school. It’s usually in a separate part of the building filled with toys books, games, big sofas and kids from all different ages to play with. The kids can play, relax on a bean bag, whatever. In the summer they play out in a massive playground all to themselves, run in the woods, go to the library, beach (where I am anyway) and absolutely love it.

But here’s the rub. If we relied on benefits to pay for our kids, someone would say “why did you have kids if you couldn’t afford them”

If we work to pay for our kids, and let’s face it for most people one wage isn’t going to be enough, another arsehole will say “why did you bother having kids if you can’t look after them” or awww I feel so sad for them.

Of course only ever said to the women. Literally nobody has ever asked DH why he had kids if he can’t be home by 3pm.

So to all the working mums on here being shamed by (surprise surprise) other women for working full time to provide for your kids, remember, unless someone else is paying your bills they can fuck off with their opinions.

I am sure your kids are as happy, chatty, confident and as thriving as mine are and benefitting from two (or one) parents working hard to provide a decent life in these hard times.

Thank you for this wonderful post! Where are all the normal people like you?
Can't believe someone asked me why I had a child 😂😂😂 honestly!
Yes, it's very sad as another poster says, she's at school for 11 hours. (Well, usually about 10). Well, what else should I do with them while I'm at work?
DH works away for weeks at a time - but of course that's no issue, he's fine to have kids and never see them. (Btw DH is brilliant, pulls his weight at home when he's back too).

May as well update everyone while I'm here, DD had crackers at ASC tonight, apparently she didn't want to eat with everyone else like I asked because tea was hot dogs, and she doesn't like them. So I made her fish fingers, smiley faces and beans for tea when we got home.

Oh and since she had a slightly later bedtime last night due to me taking a while to rustle up food before bed, she was AWFUL this evening. But yes, I should definitely push her bedtime later because it's not already hard enough for her to cope with the super long days, that I never ever feel sad or guilty about because obviously I should never have had children 😅

OP posts: