Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect after school club to provide a proper tea?

319 replies

Fummymummy · 11/12/2023 19:09

Genuinely don't know what the norm is here so looking for perspective.

Dd is in reception and goes to wrap around after school.
After she'd come home starving several times, I asked the staff for more info about the tea set up.
They serve tea at 3.30pm, DD says she isn't hungry then so doesn't eat. Fair enough.The food is then taken away and they can have a cracker or a biscuit as snacks later on.
Every single day last week she has had crackers for tea, and today she's had 1 biscuit!
I get that she's offered tea but if she isn't hungry they can't force her to eat, and they have to have a cut off - that's fine, so I asked if they would at least save her plate for later so she at least gets her tea even if it's cold.
She came home yet again today absolutely starving. Doesn't seem like they're keeping her plate back.

We don't get home until about 6pm so she's going from 11.40 (when reception eat) til then.

AIBU to be pissed off that she's living off crackers and biscuits when she's meant to have tea there?
I don't get why it's so early, or why they need to take plates away if some clearly haven't eaten.
Is this normal? Do most kids have to have a second tea at home later? (We usually have bedtime snacks, not a full meal). I know it's not like a nursery where the ratio is lower, but it feels poor that they're letting her go without (bar the crackers).

She's in bed for 7pm so it's a struggle when I'm having to rustle something proper up between getting home, doing her reading and bath/ bedtime.

Am I expecting too much?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Clettercletterthatsbetter · 13/12/2023 20:45

Another YABU I’m afraid. Our ASC is £10 and they get a piece of toast.

CasperGutman · 13/12/2023 20:24

Presumably they feed them early because the children are all picked up at different times. If they fed them later, some of the kids would be mid-meal when their parents turned up. I've never personally encountered an ASC that provided an actual meal, though. Ours just get a snack and eat at home later.

LBFseBrom · 13/12/2023 19:54

However, I must add that I only worked part-time when mine was small and my husband did something called a 'nine day fortnight' which meant he had days off at times, also had flexitime. That changed of course, I increased my hours and gradually built up to full time, husband had a complete career change, but that was a few years later and we were prepared to not be very well off/hard up for a while.

We were casual about bedtimes and our offspring did not get tired early. We'd get him ready for bed, clean and pyjamas, etc, but he'd stay downstairs with us until he was tired.

The op's situation is different plus we are living in a different era to the 1980s, so there isn't much point in making comparisons. She has to work things out as best she can for herself and her family. Good luck to her.

LBFseBrom · 13/12/2023 19:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I think that is true for most people, Week54, or something like. I know when mine was small and came home from school he was always hungry, despite having a decent school lunch. He had whatever snack he chose, sometimes cheese on toast or a sandwich and maybe a bit of cake. Then we had dinner/supper at around 7pm, all together. It was nice. On the days I worked my in-laws did pick up and the routine was much the same. However, it is said that boys are generally more hungry and eat more than girls :-).

UsingChangeofName · 13/12/2023 17:31

Caterpillarsleftfoot · 13/12/2023 07:58

A cup of tea surely wouldn't be normal for a small child?

Don't be obtuse.

You could try reading the thread if your understanding is that limited, you could even have learned something.

UsingChangeofName · 13/12/2023 17:27

DragonFly98 · 12/12/2023 23:09

You need to work part time your hours and the lack of proper food are not fair on your dc. You are not a single parent, you have two incomes you don't have to work full time.

WOW! There are some rude people on this thread.

How in the world do you know what the OPs finances are like, or what her job entails ? Hmm

How incredible rude you are being.

No idea why people are giving so much grief to the OP who has asked a question, taken on board responses and seems lovely!

This ^
It was a simple question, which the OP has taken on board all the response, and the OP has also explained why she was somewhat misled - although I'm sure not everyone has bothered to read any of that pretty useful information.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/12/2023 16:44

spriots · 13/12/2023 13:45

Well, I think this because my school's ASC says that they provide a full cooked evening meal...

And they do - they get a full hot meal and pudding.

I understand not everywhere is the same (though apparently not everyone is able to understand this)

OK but I think this is quite rare, or at least you wouldn’t expect it unless it was specifically set out.

I thought it was implicit in what I said that there would of course be exceptions.

But I also agree with @LBFseBrom that there’s value in a family sitting down to dinner together- or at least one of the parents having dinner together with the child. A debrief time.

LBFseBrom · 13/12/2023 15:09

spriots · 13/12/2023 13:45

Well, I think this because my school's ASC says that they provide a full cooked evening meal...

And they do - they get a full hot meal and pudding.

I understand not everywhere is the same (though apparently not everyone is able to understand this)

That is great, spriots, I am pleased for you that a proper dinner is provided for your child. However, as you and others have said, it doesn't happen universally.

I'd have thought the family, ie parents and child or children (however young), sitting around the table early evening and tucking into a nice meal would be the norm for most people. It's cosy, comforting and social, doesn't have to be a big or 'posh' dinner, something pre-cooked from fridge or freezer would be fine as long as all enjoyed and each could eat what they wanted. We always did that. However, it seems that is also not the norm for many.

People do what they have to do, we can't judge. I'm not sure this thread has done the op much good, frankly.

spriots · 13/12/2023 13:45

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/12/2023 13:16

I understand there’s confusion re the fact people use the word “tea” to mean different things, but I’m really surprised anyone thought after school club would provide a child’s main evening meal. And that the parents therefore wouldn’t be cooking them an evening meal in the week.

Well, I think this because my school's ASC says that they provide a full cooked evening meal...

And they do - they get a full hot meal and pudding.

I understand not everywhere is the same (though apparently not everyone is able to understand this)

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/12/2023 13:19

Thedm · 12/12/2023 22:46

The bottom line is that she needs to eat proper food. Even if she ate the hot dogs at 3.30, that’s not enough to get her through to the next morning.

You need to find a way to make sure she has dinner, either keeping her up later or picking her up earlier. Or have dinner already cooked (slow cooker) for when she walks in the door. If she cannot stay up late enough to eat dinner with your current work times then you need to find a way to adjust those, or put her to a childminder who will feed her a proper meal instead of ASC.

But you cannot just carry on wither her eating cracker and then just having a slice of toast when she gets home. Her poor diet will be contributing to her tiredness.

I was a single mum to two kids and had to use ASC so I could work. I still fed them. Stop acting like no one else understands. We do. But she needs dinner so you have to change something.

I agree with this - the obvious answer is batch cooking so the food can be defrosting during the day and ready to eat within a couple of minutes of her getting in.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/12/2023 13:16

I understand there’s confusion re the fact people use the word “tea” to mean different things, but I’m really surprised anyone thought after school club would provide a child’s main evening meal. And that the parents therefore wouldn’t be cooking them an evening meal in the week.

Fizbosshoes · 13/12/2023 13:16

My DS went to an ASC in years 3-5 (so he was 8-10 years old), they used to offer a cooked meal at 4.30pm. I picked him up at 6pm and he often had a 2nd tea when I cooked at about 7pm....but obviously being older, there was time for that as he went to bed later

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/12/2023 13:13

I wouldn’t expect ASC to provide their main evening meal, whatever time that is and whatever they call it. I’d expect a snack to tide them over til you get them home and give them their meal.

Hellokelly · 13/12/2023 13:09

Dinner/evening meal to most Northerners haha

Hellokelly · 13/12/2023 13:01

I actually run a before and after school club myself and the ‘tea’ we provide is a high tea/snack and I make it very clear to parents that it is not intended to be their full evening meal.

We are attached to a nursery and the chefs plan the menu, we have a variety of things such as sandwiches, soup etc but it is only a small portion - we get the same amount for every child whether they are in reception or year 6, so would definitely not be enough for any child for their dinner/tea.

We have several children who will refuse whatever the high tea is, we offer them a piece of toast or bread and butter as an alternative as this is all we really have as an option. Some will still refuse and we would not overly encourage them to eat if they don’t want to as we do expect them to have at least a small evening meal at home.

I understand it must be a rush when you get home to cook before bedtime but unfortunately this is necessary for a lot of parents. Our chefs go home and the kitchen is closed by 4:30pm, so no option to have our high tea any later (ours is 3:30pm too) unfortunately x

Beezknees · 13/12/2023 12:02

And working does not disadvantage women in any way, having my own money and being able to support myself is an advantage. I did not work when my DS was a baby and I split up from his dad and we ended up homeless and living in a hostel, that would not have happened if I had my own job and money. Never again.

Beezknees · 13/12/2023 11:58

Grammarnut · 13/12/2023 11:46

She asked for advice so I gave some. I am not criticising her, but society that makes women go out to work full-time when they have small children, which does not seem to me either women-friendly or a feminist stance I support. When I had no children I thought 24-hour nurseries and off-loading the children on relatives so I could work was a good thing, but really, they are just ways of making women act like men, rather than women, and disparage everything that makes us different from men. A society where women were truly equal would value motherhood, would understand and cope with the biology of women, and their life arc being completely different from men's, and work out ways to allow women to have a career and rear children without outsourcing childcare or losing promotion prospects. Our current method only values making money, so a woman going out to work provides work (less well-paid and with less status) for other women who look after her children, which makes money for someone and supports a capitalist system which values nothing but profit and the ability to make profit. I don't like it and it disadvantages all women - and all men.

You do know that some women actually WANT to work, don't you? Why are you assuming that it's all forced? I would absolutely hate to rely on my partner for money, I don't judge others who do but that's not a life I want.

Crikeyalmighty · 13/12/2023 11:50

@Fummymummy and by the way I don't want to tell you that you are doing it wrong- because I don't know your child- just suggesting what worked for me. I was you for many years!!

Week54 · 13/12/2023 11:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Grammarnut · 13/12/2023 11:46

Beezknees · 13/12/2023 08:33

But it's absolutely none of your business what other women want to do. It's not your place to tell someone else how they should live their life.

She asked for advice so I gave some. I am not criticising her, but society that makes women go out to work full-time when they have small children, which does not seem to me either women-friendly or a feminist stance I support. When I had no children I thought 24-hour nurseries and off-loading the children on relatives so I could work was a good thing, but really, they are just ways of making women act like men, rather than women, and disparage everything that makes us different from men. A society where women were truly equal would value motherhood, would understand and cope with the biology of women, and their life arc being completely different from men's, and work out ways to allow women to have a career and rear children without outsourcing childcare or losing promotion prospects. Our current method only values making money, so a woman going out to work provides work (less well-paid and with less status) for other women who look after her children, which makes money for someone and supports a capitalist system which values nothing but profit and the ability to make profit. I don't like it and it disadvantages all women - and all men.

OlympicProcrastinator · 13/12/2023 09:57

I didn’t quote properly I don’t know how to. When i press ‘reply’ it doesn’t quote for me. How do you do it please fellow MN?

OlympicProcrastinator · 13/12/2023 09:49

That's true enough though her job doesn't sound like split shifts at a supermarket. She may have a crippling mortgage or aged parents to help out, we don't know. But DD seems to be in school (reception probably starts at 8.30) from early morning to early evening, which is a long time for a small child. I dislike this idea that everyone has to go out to work and that bringing up one's own children is a waste of a woman's education, qualifications etc so I am rather biased but 8 hours seems a long time to be in school, and then practically straight to bed with a snack at 7pm. At the very least the OP needs to re-organise her thoughts here and think about providing a proper family meal at the end of the day, even if it's pizza and chips and mushy peas (even cack-handed DHs can do that), and a slice of bought apple pie, all sitting at a table together and not watching TV, bustling around getting the child ready for bed

You can ‘dislike the idea’ all you like but the reality is people more often than not need two incomes to support their family. To tell someone they don’t need to work full time is the height of condescending. You know nothing and she didn’t ask.

The op doesn’t need to ‘reorganise her thoughts’ for fuck sake. She is already taking action to get her child to eat properly by seeking advice on here (Brave lady.) No suggestion the father should ‘reorganise’ his thoughts or working hours?

And for the record, working mothers are still parenting their child when they are at work. They are providing for them, they are being positive role models, they are making the money that buys the food, the activities, the family days out and the decent standard of living that so many children lack.

Teder · 13/12/2023 09:15

Grammarnut · 13/12/2023 08:22

That's true enough though her job doesn't sound like split shifts at a supermarket. She may have a crippling mortgage or aged parents to help out, we don't know. But DD seems to be in school (reception probably starts at 8.30) from early morning to early evening, which is a long time for a small child. I dislike this idea that everyone has to go out to work and that bringing up one's own children is a waste of a woman's education, qualifications etc so I am rather biased but 8 hours seems a long time to be in school, and then practically straight to bed with a snack at 7pm. At the very least the OP needs to re-organise her thoughts here and think about providing a proper family meal at the end of the day, even if it's pizza and chips and mushy peas (even cack-handed DHs can do that), and a slice of bought apple pie, all sitting at a table together and not watching TV, bustling around getting the child ready for bed.

Offensive and sexist - these are the only words than spring to mind.
If you’d bothered to read, the OP took on board the suggestions (even the rude ones!) and is now offering a bigger meal after ASC.

Sirzy · 13/12/2023 09:09

Can you throw something in the slow cooker on days you’re picking up later so it’s ready when you get in? Or leftovers you can quickly microwave?

Crikeyalmighty · 13/12/2023 08:57

@Mummymummy89 I totally agree. Bed time at 7.45- tea at 6.45 - and you don't have to eat then although it's better for socialisation if you do sometimes. If you are getting in at 6 - then I wouldn't expect to have a child bathed, bed and fed by 7pm.

Use a slow cooker or batchcook and heat up curries, bolognese or chilli etc when you get in or if you can afford to do it - get some great quality ready meals and just add some extra veg or a salad on the table. We ate an awful lot of M&S and Cook meals when we were in this situation and lived to tell the tale.

If you don't want to eat as early as that then use an airfryer and bang in some breaded/battered fish portions or sausages, quiche , pie or good chicken nuggets and a jacket potato or waffle and add beans or cook a bit of frozen veg etc
Other options my son used to like were pasta pesto with some cooked chicken and peas added, an omelette with tomato's and cucumber and toast, crumpets with cheese on top and a side salad, pre done meatballs added to good quality pasta sauce on spaghetti with added peas , cooked breakfast type thing sausage, bacon (done in airfryer) plus an egg and tinned tomatoes and bread

Honestly I think they will adjust to a slightly later bedtime - my friend got into the habit of a 6.45 bedtime with her little one because her partner was bad tempered when he got home from work and more so if the little one was messing around- sad I know.