Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Can I get compensation? Assaulted at hospital

354 replies

Plzstopthisstupidity · 11/12/2023 18:28

Good evening Mumsnet

My sister recently announced she is pregnant and it brought back a memory of something I had buried.

5 years ago, I had a C-section. The day after in hospital, when I was recovering, a nurse grabbed me by the neck in a hallway of patients, staff and visitors and threatened me. She verbally and physically assaulted me.

I can’t discuss the reasons behind it but long story short was she verbally abused me in private (my room) and then when she heard me trying to complain, she grabbed me.

The manager of the maternity ward saw this and spoke to me. She apologised and comforted me. I was humiliated, sobbing and traumatised at the time.

I moved on. I still think about it… more so recently.

I was given the nurse’s name and found out that she is still working in the hospital (this was a year ago not sure if she is still there now).

I am starting to feel immensely angry about what happened. Part of me wants to take legal action.

Mumsnet: is there anything I can do? Is it worth even doing anything as it’s been so long since it happened?

just looking for ideas/advice - thank you!!

OP posts:
Plzstopthisstupidity · 11/12/2023 19:54

Whatever medication I was on, a hospital staff member grabbed me at the neck (collar/skin) and swore at me.

For the person who said a slip of paper wouldn’t be given, I literally have it among my baby notes. Did I write that myself and tuck it away? How would I have even known her name?

There must be a record. I am going to ring the hospital tomorrow and chase this up. Forget the money. I am just really angry right now.

OP posts:
Mailista · 11/12/2023 19:54

BTW, I had a severe birth injury and DC1 and I both nearly died. The only compensation that mattered to me was that he and I both survived.

SnowSwan · 11/12/2023 19:54

Oh there are definitely unstable nurses working out there. I was a nurse many years ago and worked with a nurse with a personality disorder. Officially diagnosed. She was absolutely vile at times. Would corner colleagues and threaten them. Held a knife to one of them. She would throw stuff and break equipment. She would scream "FUCK YOU!", walk off the ward and go home.
Our poor ward manager was constantly going to her manager about it, but they just told her there was nothing to be done. She couldn't be touched because she had a disability. But as far as I know she never touched a patient, just other staff.

In your case, I think the ward manager was hoping you would put in a complaint so the higher ups would finally have to take action to remove her. I'm not sure what can be done now, sadly. Contact PALS and see what they say.

TheShellBeach · 11/12/2023 19:52

OP I'm very sorry you're so distressed about this incident. I am a retired midwife and I've worked with many nurses and midwives who had appalling attitudes to patient care.

When I was a patient myself I had some bad experiences with some of them.

Rudeness, withholding pain relief................. yes, I've experienced that.

But not physical violence.

You say that you weren't on strong painkillers, but you'd just given birth and would have had morphine or fentanyl in the anaesthetic.

It does seem likely that an incident of rudeness took place, and you imagined the assault part of it.

If a ward manager witnessed an assault in her department, the police would have been called and the staff member dismissed.

I hope that you can, one day, come to terms with your baby's traumatic birth.
Flowers

SignoraItaliana · 11/12/2023 19:52

What a horrific experience for you. As you have the nurse’s name, report her to the NMC. A datix (incident report) will have been completed at the time, or should have been, so there will be evidence of the assault. I’m a registered nurse and I can confirm there are rogue nurses within the profession. They need to be reported and removed from the register.

Mailista · 11/12/2023 19:52

Just let it lie, OP. Some nurses shouldn't be nursing, but there's no way to know after the event. Get counselling or whatever it takes to help you move on. That's my advice.

(And saying "fuck the Daily Mail" won't make them any more or less likely to filch this thread).

AppleDumplingWithCustard · 11/12/2023 19:52

LIZS · 11/12/2023 18:38

You can make a claim within 3 years of being aware of an incident. Was it formally recorded at the time? However you could complain to the RCN if they are still registered and ask for a debrief with the Head of Midwifery at the hospital.

Nursing & Midwifery Council (NMC) for complaints, not Royal College of Nursing (RCN).

momonpurpose · 11/12/2023 19:52

I'd go to the police

Rocket1982 · 11/12/2023 19:51

For everyone saying the OP is grabby for considering asking for compensation because there as no financial cost to her, I disagree. After previously having no mental health issues I got PTSD after giving birth to DS2. I wasn't physically assaulted but the way I was treated by the midwife refused to talk to me or support me while I was giving birth (tired, end of shift) and I feel this contributed to a severe birth injury. I was too traumatised to engage with the event for over 3 years after it happened so by the time I wrote to the unit, the 3 years had expired and they basically said they would consider the feedback but nothing could happen. I wasn't seeking financial compensation but I wanted to the midwife to know how her behaviour had affected me. She'd left and that didn't happen. I needed a many sessions of counselling to begin to begin to recover which is obviously NOT available on the NHS so trauma induced by medical neglect (or assault in the case of the OP) does incur a cost to the victim. There are too many stories of shit care in maternity units. Really those units need to be prioritised for the best care because of the massive impact that bad care has, not just on the physical health of mothers and babies but down the line on PND and PTSD and the start that children get in life. Better care would make so much difference and actually save costs that individuals and society incur from all the after effects from substandard care for birthing mothers. OP I think you should complain and if they brush you off ask for a meeting.

Icopewhenihope · 11/12/2023 19:50

The title of your post put me off to be honest. Waiting 5 years to suddenly remember this rings bells too. Honestly you have no hope of getting money out of this for therapy. None of it rings true from the tights to the assault in front of loads of witnesses to the sudden memory of this happening 5 years later.

Plzstopthisstupidity · 11/12/2023 19:50

I just want to add, some details have been changed slightly as I have (however briefly) shared this story with people in my life. I actually discussed it slightly at a training event at work even, one about wellbeing etc. So that’s that.

The overall story remains the same. I was, in my full senses, assaulted by a hospital staff member in a hallway in full view of a handful of patients, staff, and the ward manager after I had given birth by C-section.

OP posts:
someonethatyoulovetoomuch · 11/12/2023 19:49

I’ve been a senior NHS midwife for years, I managed a postnatal ward for 4 years. If I witnessed a midwife physically and verbally abuse a patient, that midwife would be suspended, referred to the NMC and struck off. They certainly wouldn’t be moved to another ward for a bit, and I also wouldn’t give you their name on a slip of paper or make you sign anything. I’m not saying it didn’t happen, I’m saying your account of what happened is frankly bizarre. If it is true, you should have reported it at the time. Five years down the line, I’d maybe contact the head of midwifery and take it from there? You won’t get any form of compensation though, if your account is accurate then there isn’t any proof.

And just a pedantic aside, there are no rooms where you heat formula up in a microwave in hospital, that’s a dangerous way of heating baby milk so I’d be reporting that too tbh.

Teder · 11/12/2023 19:49

OP it’s not that people disbelieve that medical staff can assault a patient, it’s the fact that a) it is coming back to you over the course of posting on this thread (if I understood that correctly) and b) that it was witnessed by so many people who did not even report it to PALS. Ignoring the latter part, I do wonder how much your repressed and newly recovered memories are accurate. Nobody here can tel you this. You are clearly traumatised and deserve to seek help.

Blinkityblonk · 11/12/2023 19:48

@CharlotteRose90 perhaps people thought the OP was being restrained for her own good? Who knows? I have certainly seen people manhandled for this reason in hospital, including under 18's on the eating disorder ward who are held down screaming. Not everything is done 'nicely' and perhaps people weren't sure what they saw or thought a nurse would be in control and doing the right thing.

Blinkityblonk · 11/12/2023 19:46

I meant to say I pay £110 a week, it's £55 a session, and that's not the highest, many are charging £70 a session now. Counselling can be good but it is not just some free option people can dip into if they have horrible flashbacks from bad nursing (and some nurses on maternity wards are extremely callous, as well as the kind ones).

Plzstopthisstupidity · 11/12/2023 19:46

I just want to say, I actually asked my partner to take over bed time and I have resigned myself to the front steps because I am
in tears right now. Speaking about this has brought back very difficult feelings and reminded me what a shit time in my life that was. I’m only writing this to let it out, sorry for turning Mumsnet into my personal diary.

Also fuck the DailyMail just in case they decide they want to write a stupid article about medical assaults, the idiots.

taking a breather and then I’ll get back to your comments and to real life.

OP posts:
CharlotteRose90 · 11/12/2023 19:45

This story isn’t believable at all. I’m sorry but if you’re saying there was that many witnesses then either security or the police would have been called. No way would you go back to your room and her carry on working afterwards. Maybe something happened but not what you’re saying.

Blinkityblonk · 11/12/2023 19:45

One thing is bugging me on this post and that's everyone saying get counselling as if it's just a free resource! I pay £55 for both my children to have counselling due to unavoidable trauma a week, it's costing a lot of money and isn't, in a cost of living crisis, just something many people can just stump up for, even with cutting stuff elsewhere. Counselling is not cheap, even the 'discounts' are not free. The only thing the NHS round us offers is 6 weeks of extremely routinized CBT not relevant to any specific problem.

BettyBallerina · 11/12/2023 19:45

Velvian · 11/12/2023 19:40

I believe you @Plzstopthisstupidity . I'm quite disgusted at the PPs that are trying to pick holes. My sister had to wear tights after a C-section.

It is amazing, it doesn't matter how many reviews and inquiries there are into Maternity care in the NHS, women are still not believed!

Cruel treatment (in addition to neglect) happens routinely in hospitals. There are more good staff than bad, but I think you are very lucky if you survive a hospital stay with no incidences of callousness or cruelty.

Agree. And I had compression tights on after both my sections.

I also noticed on both occasions that some of the midwives on the postnatal ward treated the C-section mums differently (they were ignored and spoken to rudely). I’m so sorry this happened to you, OP and I’m sorry that some don’t believe you.

dottycat123 · 11/12/2023 19:44

I have been a nurse for nearly 40 years and even when I started I would have been horrified at such an incident.
I actually think that the managers role in this alleged incident is worth pursuing. As a manager she has failed to follow any standard process for dealing with such an incident. You say she got you to sign something, that should be in your records. The manager has also put her registration on the line which is surprising, there can be no process in the NHS where a nurse manager gets a patient to sign a bit of paper as a reasonable conclusion to the situation described. I would request your medical notes and see what is documented.

Picklemeyellow · 11/12/2023 19:42

This is truly horrific if it genuinely happened op, the only way you’ll know if there are any recordings of this is to contact PALS and start from there.

But don’t discount the power of a reaction to medication, blood loss and exhaustion to completely skew your account of situations. 5 days after giving birth I truly believed my dh had tried to strangle me in my sleep, turned out to be a combination of sleep deprivation and anaemia!

MIL was hospitalised a few years ago and had some kind of reaction to her meds. She rang dh at 2am begging him to
come get her because one of the male nurses was trying to kill her by lethal injection whilst the other nurses were standing just outside her door discussing and arranging a charity concert on her behalf! Two months later and back at home she was still convinced that had all been a genuinely real scenario and no one could ease her mind over it all.

But for piece of mind I’d definitely start with PALS if I were you.

Starryskies1 · 11/12/2023 19:42

I think asking to access your notes may help. To unpick it maybe consider counselling. I would look at getting some advice from a solicitor about your rights. Personally I wouldn’t go for compensation. But I would want to make sure this behaviour isn’t carried on.

HappyHamsters · 11/12/2023 19:42

A midwife can be reported to the NMC who can investigate complaints

SharSharBinks · 11/12/2023 19:41

I think if anxiety/trauma is your concern you'd get more out of counseling than you would a payout.

Velvian · 11/12/2023 19:40

I believe you @Plzstopthisstupidity . I'm quite disgusted at the PPs that are trying to pick holes. My sister had to wear tights after a C-section.

It is amazing, it doesn't matter how many reviews and inquiries there are into Maternity care in the NHS, women are still not believed!

Cruel treatment (in addition to neglect) happens routinely in hospitals. There are more good staff than bad, but I think you are very lucky if you survive a hospital stay with no incidences of callousness or cruelty.

Swipe left for the next trending thread