Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DDs school want me to COVID test her, AIBU to say no?

286 replies

mybossisaprick · 11/12/2023 16:43

Dd, who is in primary school, has got the cold that’s been going round. She’s not too unwell in herself, and is happily playing, but she has a husky voice and a cough. She’s maybe a bit more tired than normal, but nothing that would mean she would need to stay off school. If she was unwell enough to miss school, I’d keep her off.

Her teacher pulled me aside at pickup time and asked me if she’d taken a COVID test. I said no, she hadn’t. Teacher asked me why not, and I explained that she wasn’t unwell enough to miss school, and so there was no point testing her for COVID. Teacher said that I should test her anyway, and if positive she should stay home. I explained that myself and my partner both have to work, we don’t get enough leave as it is, and whilst if DD was actually unwell in herself and couldn’t go to school, one of us could stay off with her, but since she’s not, we really don't have the resources to be taking time off. Also, I don’t have easy access to tests and I’d rather not buy a test when I don’t need to.

AIBU to tell this teacher that I wouldn’t be testing DD?

OP posts:
x2boys · 12/12/2023 08:56

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 12/12/2023 08:19

Well, I imagine that there are some employers here who expect their staff to come in when they are sick too, but maybe the question should be why are UK employers so draconian? Here everyone is entitled to a number of sick days every year, and if you don't use them they accumulate. I thought the UK was supposed to be "world leading" - it's mentioned on here often enough!! Some of your workplace practices sound decidedly old fashioned.

Edited

Clearly we are reading different forums as on all the threads I read on here nobody thinks he UK is world leading in anything and every week we have a thread about how terrible the UK is compared to the rest of he world
I don't think the UK is terrible btw I just think we are four years into the pandemic now we have vaccines and treatment s and we are getting on with Covid now much Like the rest of the world hence why Employers expect their Employees in regardless of whether they have Covid or not assuming they are well enough.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 12/12/2023 08:41

VanityDiesHard · 11/12/2023 22:47

You are still giving Covid way too much importance in your life, to be fair. People do not care any more, and fewer and fewer people are going to care going forward. You can accept that fact, or you can waste precious energy getting upset that the world has moved on.

Wouldn’t you give it more importance if you were in my state?

TrashedSofa · 12/12/2023 08:21

mathanxiety · 11/12/2023 23:03

Your problems with leave/ sick days are not the teacher's or the classmates' to solve.

Equally, the teacher's desire for the OPs child to take a test is not the OPs problem to solve.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 12/12/2023 08:19

x2boys · 12/12/2023 08:16

Well,as you say you are not in the uk so you have no understanding of how some UK employers expect their employees in regardless and many employees will be subject to disciplinary proceedingss if they continually go off sick

Well, I imagine that there are some employers here who expect their staff to come in when they are sick too, but maybe the question should be why are UK employers so draconian? Here everyone is entitled to a number of sick days every year, and if you don't use them they accumulate. I thought the UK was supposed to be "world leading" - it's mentioned on here often enough!! Some of your workplace practices sound decidedly old fashioned.

x2boys · 12/12/2023 08:16

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 12/12/2023 03:57

I'm not in the UK, but thinking back over my working life none of my employers "expected" people to come in when they were sick. People made their own decision about whether they were well enough to work or not, and that was that.

Well,as you say you are not in the uk so you have no understanding of how some UK employers expect their employees in regardless and many employees will be subject to disciplinary proceedingss if they continually go off sick

fiftiesmum · 12/12/2023 08:14

Those of us with memories going back to pre COVID days will know that some colds can be really nasty and some people would go on to get chest, throat, sinus or ear infections - we just have a name and a home test for one of these viruses which start off with sneezing, runny noses and cough.
OP I would not buy a test - if you see teacher today ask them for the test pack or say you have requested one from the nhs but have not received it

SwingTheMonkey · 12/12/2023 07:58

CouchCat · 12/12/2023 07:49

@SwingTheMonkey

Of course it doesn’t make more sense not to spread illness around classrooms. Firstly, as previously mentioned, kids would spend more time at home than at school in the winter months and secondly, do you not remember the awful problem with invasive Strep A last year? Caused by a couple of years of not mixing and spreading normal winter viruses…

Sorry, to clarify, you do want sick kids? Won't that then mean they're at home? Confused

Not necessarily, no. Mine have all had mild colds this week - nothing bad enough to be at home. It’s necessary to have these mild viruses circulating as we found out last year. In fact, my own children haven’t been poorly enough for a single day off this term. A sniffle here and there, sure. But nothing serious.

CouchCat · 12/12/2023 07:49

@SwingTheMonkey

Of course it doesn’t make more sense not to spread illness around classrooms. Firstly, as previously mentioned, kids would spend more time at home than at school in the winter months and secondly, do you not remember the awful problem with invasive Strep A last year? Caused by a couple of years of not mixing and spreading normal winter viruses…

Sorry, to clarify, you do want sick kids? Won't that then mean they're at home? Confused

bellac11 · 12/12/2023 07:29

Friarclose · 11/12/2023 23:56

I tested positive on Tuesday last and only just feeling better now. Aches, headache, terrible sinus pain, loss of taste and smell and was barely able to keep my eyes open.

Covid is NOT just a cold to many.

If you can test and isolate, you should.

Thats how all colds make me, its how my body reacts, always has done. I lose my taste and smell on a regular basis, I have had loss of taste and smell since having a terrible virus a long time ago and have long term impacts from that but no one is interested in that because the virus didnt have a name, its just 'long virus'.

SwingTheMonkey · 12/12/2023 07:02

CouchCat · 12/12/2023 06:42

From the OP: "husky voice and a cough. She’s maybe a bit more tired than normal" and the teacher asked OP to test, so felt it was necessary.

I agree that it does seem sometimes kids are off sick all the time. But doesn't it make more sense not to spread those illnesses around a small, stuffy room full of children and adults, complicating the problem?

I'll note, too, that the OP has only posted once, so this could be all theoretical anyway.

Of course it doesn’t make more sense not to spread illness around classrooms. Firstly, as previously mentioned, kids would spend more time at home than at school in the winter months and secondly, do you not remember the awful problem with invasive Strep A last year? Caused by a couple of years of not mixing and spreading normal winter viruses…

Clutterbugsmum · 12/12/2023 06:54

I wouldn't test, if your child's well enough to go to school then they should.

We need to try to get back to pre Covid and only if we are really ill do we stay at home.

Oh and it's winter there are so many colds as there is every year.

CouchCat · 12/12/2023 06:42

SwingTheMonkey · 12/12/2023 04:06

In the first instance, it doesn't sound like the child should be in school.

@CouchCat Why would a child with a cold mild enough that they are still happily playing, need time off school? If I kept my children off every time they had a cold in the winter months, their attendance would be dire.

From the OP: "husky voice and a cough. She’s maybe a bit more tired than normal" and the teacher asked OP to test, so felt it was necessary.

I agree that it does seem sometimes kids are off sick all the time. But doesn't it make more sense not to spread those illnesses around a small, stuffy room full of children and adults, complicating the problem?

I'll note, too, that the OP has only posted once, so this could be all theoretical anyway.

shearwater2 · 12/12/2023 05:40

StaunchMomma · 11/12/2023 17:03

I think you sound a bit entitled, OP.

Schools don't have to stick to guidance to the letter, they have to look at their situation. If they have eg vulnerable pupils or staff at the school or a current staffing issue due to Covid then I can see why they'd make that request.

They have to think about all kids, not just yours and certainly not your working hours.

Yeah, and if you followed the teachers advice and they tested positive for Covid and the child missed a few days of school, you'd find yourself in an attendance meeting next term.

School policy is usually to get kids in at all times to get 100% attendance which leads to kids going in when they are unwell and spreading all sorts of viruses.

You do what you need to do, OP, for your daughter if she feels fine to go in.

NativityLobsterNumber4 · 12/12/2023 05:22

I think if your child has a cold that is affecting their voice, causing a cough and is more tired, she’d benefit from a couple of days rest staying in the warm. Teachers are used to kids having a bit of a sniffle or cold and don’t mention it, for the teacher to mention it, she must appear poorly in school.

SwingTheMonkey · 12/12/2023 04:06

In the first instance, it doesn't sound like the child should be in school.

@CouchCat Why would a child with a cold mild enough that they are still happily playing, need time off school? If I kept my children off every time they had a cold in the winter months, their attendance would be dire.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 12/12/2023 03:57

x2boys · 12/12/2023 00:52

Yes some do but not all My husband works for the biggest super market Iin the uk they expect their employees in as d does that ittle known service known as the NHS ! You are lucky

I'm not in the UK, but thinking back over my working life none of my employers "expected" people to come in when they were sick. People made their own decision about whether they were well enough to work or not, and that was that.

blackfluffycat · 12/12/2023 01:21

My daughter 13 was sent home today.

At around 8pm she told me the deputy head told her to do a test at home. I don't have any. Where do I get them? Can she not go back until she's done one? 😬😬

x2boys · 12/12/2023 01:14

Againlosinghope · 12/12/2023 01:08

Have they got vulnerable children/child in the school?
I know a school which the staff need to test and stay off if positive. The school tried to encourage parents to test but most don't. It's difficult when their are medically vulnerable children

My child goes to a special school for children with severe and profound learning disabilities some children have multiple and profound disabilities and are extremely vulnerable they are tube fed and are on oxygen I'm still expected to send my son into school regardless of whether he tests positive of Covid if he's well enough

Againlosinghope · 12/12/2023 01:08

Have they got vulnerable children/child in the school?
I know a school which the staff need to test and stay off if positive. The school tried to encourage parents to test but most don't. It's difficult when their are medically vulnerable children

x2boys · 12/12/2023 00:52

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 12/12/2023 00:35

SOME employers expect their employees in regardless. My boss told me to stay at home for four days with a cold (I had done numerous tests). And no, I couldn't work from home.

Not all employers are draconian.

Edited

Yes some do but not all My husband works for the biggest super market Iin the uk they expect their employees in as d does that ittle known service known as the NHS ! You are lucky

CouchCat · 12/12/2023 00:47

@SwingTheMonkey

No, no. Bullying is forcing kids who are perfectly well enough to be at school, to stay at home, further damaging their education, because the mild condition they are experiencing might cause someone else to be more poorly.

Thats bullying.

It isn't bullying. In the first instance, it doesn't sound like the child should be in school. Education won't be damaged by a couple of days at home. And why is it okay for someone else to be made "more poorly"? If another child is more poorly, won't they then be forced into school absence?

Just test as the teacher is requesting. Don't make other people ill.

CouchCat · 12/12/2023 00:40

@VanityDiesHard

There are so many colds and viruses around, Covid is not special. We just have to get on with it. The world stopped for nearly two years! If the panickers had their way we would be locked down to this day.

  • Covid is a novel virus (that means 'new' to everyone's immune system, FYI), and that gives it a different status, yes?
  • No, we would not be still locked down, as we have this wonderful tool now called a 'vaccine'. When we didn't have that and the virus was surging, lockdowns helped tamp down infections. They aren't needed now.

Does that help?

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 12/12/2023 00:35

x2boys · 11/12/2023 17:04

You, realise that, Employers expect their employees in regardless of wether they have covid?
It doesn't matter wether they are happy to be surrounded by people with Covid they have no option.

Edited

SOME employers expect their employees in regardless. My boss told me to stay at home for four days with a cold (I had done numerous tests). And no, I couldn't work from home.

Not all employers are draconian.

x2boys · 12/12/2023 00:01

VeryGoodVeryNice · 11/12/2023 23:57

I’ve just tested positive today and feel absolutely dreadful - I’m planning on isolating until I’m negative just because it’s an asshole thing to do to make other people ill, with what can be quite a nasty virus, so close to Christmas. This is my 4th bout of covid and every time my DC have caught it too, their symptoms have been a lot milder. So just because your DD isn’t too bad doesn’t mean that adults or vulnerable people she passes it on to will be as lucky.

Lovely for you but people are not Arse holes because they need to.work nor are they selfish in fact I would say it was more selfish expecting people to test ,stay at home and potentially lose their job putting their own family at risk ,just in case the pass on a virus to some hypothetical stranger

VeryGoodVeryNice · 11/12/2023 23:57

I’ve just tested positive today and feel absolutely dreadful - I’m planning on isolating until I’m negative just because it’s an asshole thing to do to make other people ill, with what can be quite a nasty virus, so close to Christmas. This is my 4th bout of covid and every time my DC have caught it too, their symptoms have been a lot milder. So just because your DD isn’t too bad doesn’t mean that adults or vulnerable people she passes it on to will be as lucky.