Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DDs school want me to COVID test her, AIBU to say no?

286 replies

mybossisaprick · 11/12/2023 16:43

Dd, who is in primary school, has got the cold that’s been going round. She’s not too unwell in herself, and is happily playing, but she has a husky voice and a cough. She’s maybe a bit more tired than normal, but nothing that would mean she would need to stay off school. If she was unwell enough to miss school, I’d keep her off.

Her teacher pulled me aside at pickup time and asked me if she’d taken a COVID test. I said no, she hadn’t. Teacher asked me why not, and I explained that she wasn’t unwell enough to miss school, and so there was no point testing her for COVID. Teacher said that I should test her anyway, and if positive she should stay home. I explained that myself and my partner both have to work, we don’t get enough leave as it is, and whilst if DD was actually unwell in herself and couldn’t go to school, one of us could stay off with her, but since she’s not, we really don't have the resources to be taking time off. Also, I don’t have easy access to tests and I’d rather not buy a test when I don’t need to.

AIBU to tell this teacher that I wouldn’t be testing DD?

OP posts:
Inastatus · 14/12/2023 08:36

@Grimchmas - no, we don’t call it long cold or long flu or long anything other than covid. I’m sure in time it will drop the specific label.

LorlieS · 14/12/2023 00:50

@Grimchmas But when do we draw the line? Surely we won't keep testing ad infinitum? I'm a primary teacher and most definitely don't test; I'd never be in work!!

Grimchmas · 14/12/2023 00:45

Inastatus · 13/12/2023 22:57

@DaizyDee - I’m truly sorry that you’ve been affected by long covid but you must know that chronic post viral illness is caused by lots of different viruses. The fact is that covid is now a very mild illness for the vast majority of people, especially if vaccinated, and you cannot expect people to isolate themselves anymore. Not forgetting the obvious fact that you are contagious before you have symptoms and that you could be positive and completely symptomless.

It would help if people stopped saying it's just like a cold then. Because as far as I'm aware people don't get Long Colds.

I have ME from a different virus. Covid deserves more respect than the average cough or cold.

cardibach · 14/12/2023 00:33

eastegg · 13/12/2023 16:50

II’m sorry but the pp this post was responding to did sound like they were asking for special treatment. And accordingly got lots of replies similar to MonsteraMama’s. Something very much along the lines of ‘would you be happy surrounded by potentially Covid positive people every day, because that’s what’s expected of the teacher’. Highly unsurprising that got lots of replies saying that teachers are no different in this respect to hordes of other workers/professionals. The pp really did ask for it.

What you are failing to grasp is that nobody should be in that position. That’s the whole point. Not special treatment for teachers. The same - better - treatment for everyone.

Inastatus · 13/12/2023 22:57

@DaizyDee - I’m truly sorry that you’ve been affected by long covid but you must know that chronic post viral illness is caused by lots of different viruses. The fact is that covid is now a very mild illness for the vast majority of people, especially if vaccinated, and you cannot expect people to isolate themselves anymore. Not forgetting the obvious fact that you are contagious before you have symptoms and that you could be positive and completely symptomless.

TeaWithASplashOfMilk · 13/12/2023 21:41

MyCatIsPlotting · 11/12/2023 17:15

My understanding is that the NHS say you shouldn’t actually test children and babies unless advised by a medical professional. Have you asked her whether school has a Covid policy and, if so, why it differs from NHS guidance?

I remember seeing this too about medical professional. Daft wasn't it?Looks like it's changed now.

www.nhs.uk/conditions/covid-19/covid-19-symptoms-and-what-to-do/

eastegg · 13/12/2023 16:50

cardibach · 11/12/2023 17:31

Where did you jump to ‘special treatment’. People on here really hate teachers don’t they?
Nobidy should have to have that experience. The nurse saying it what she has to do is shocking. Has everyone forgotten that people do die from it, or get long Covid?

II’m sorry but the pp this post was responding to did sound like they were asking for special treatment. And accordingly got lots of replies similar to MonsteraMama’s. Something very much along the lines of ‘would you be happy surrounded by potentially Covid positive people every day, because that’s what’s expected of the teacher’. Highly unsurprising that got lots of replies saying that teachers are no different in this respect to hordes of other workers/professionals. The pp really did ask for it.

TeaWithASplashOfMilk · 13/12/2023 16:01

DaizyDee · 13/12/2023 13:57

This is a depressing thread to read. Covid has disabled me and ruined my life. There are 2 million of us in the UK alone and many of them are kids, their lives changed because of the Government's policy of letting it rip. You're following the guidelines but the guidelines are unsustainable. Schools are struggling with teachers with repeated infections, kids off sick more and more frequently. No testing = more infections. Covid has not become a cold, it is still disabling people, ignoring it isn't making it go away.

Agree with this. I'm sorry you have long covid. It's fucked my life too.

The most bizarre thing out of all this is as time has gone on, an increasing amount of research has shown how damaging covid is.

We are deliberately hurting kids - their education, mental health, ability to learn, their immune systems, their organs, their teachers, their families, their life chances and the economy.

I guess the same people that used the rationale that covid can jump species, but not spread between kids, will deny the impact of covid on them too. Doesn't matter as they'll be paying for it.

And no, I don't think we should lock down or that we can eliminate all risk of catching covid, but I don't think we should be maximising it either. That we have effectively stuck our fingers up at those who are vulnerable is abhorrent.

The idea that there weren't people who were affected by lockdowns and by covid infections as well is crackers, as is the idea that everyone who doesn't support the current overtly extreme policy of maximising infections is somehow more extreme for wanting a less harmful policy. There are plenty of people who isolate and don't get paid (I was one, and yes, I know not everyone is in that position - also wrong). There are those that would want to isolate, even unpaid, but are told to go in anyway - some of these people work with vulnerable clients - it is fucked up.

Someone mentioned treatments - there are no approved treatments for long covid.

Bit of a rant. DS was sick yesterday and has covid. I could be a complete shit and send him to school, or I could save another kid having a shitty weekend, or another parent's job, or even just someone's Christmas - quite possibly one of the ones taking the piss out of those who bother to do that.

DaizyDee · 13/12/2023 14:08

Loverofoldfilms · 11/12/2023 20:29

Check out the website long covid kids and then cry about how cruel and ill informed you are. I am so upset. You have no idea what you are talking about. I could despair at the cruelty and ignorance.

I'm despairing too. Long Covid is dismissed and mocked more than ever. Why are people so cruel?

DaizyDee · 13/12/2023 14:06

VanityDiesHard · 11/12/2023 22:42

That can't be good for your mental health at all. Being in a constant state of anxiety and high alert is probably worse for the body than Covid, particularly as mild as it has got now. I had Covid twice and it was a slight inconvenience, I can't fathom getting so het up about it.

Having Long Covid is not good for your mental health. What a surprise. Being chronically ill isn't a barrel of laughs. What would you suggest we do about it? Mind over matter doesn't fix heart problems, inability to walk or breathing difficulties

DaizyDee · 13/12/2023 14:04

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 11/12/2023 22:37

Well l am.

Long covid is kind of shit really. And l don’t want to get covid on top of long covid really. You know, because I’m so incredibly unwell now…..

So yeah, I’m fucking worried all the time.

I also have Long Covid and I'm so sad to see the dismissive, uncaring replies on here. You are not alone, even though it must feel like that. I hope you're on the Long Covid FB support group? It's a good place to get moral support and can be a lifeline.

DaizyDee · 13/12/2023 13:57

This is a depressing thread to read. Covid has disabled me and ruined my life. There are 2 million of us in the UK alone and many of them are kids, their lives changed because of the Government's policy of letting it rip. You're following the guidelines but the guidelines are unsustainable. Schools are struggling with teachers with repeated infections, kids off sick more and more frequently. No testing = more infections. Covid has not become a cold, it is still disabling people, ignoring it isn't making it go away.

Lainey0930 · 13/12/2023 08:10

Well said!

gemma19846 · 12/12/2023 22:45

Good God 🤣🤣🤣

gemma19846 · 12/12/2023 22:43

Yes. Why do teachers think theyre any different than anyone else who works, or goes shopping or leaves the house every day. Get a grip

gemma19846 · 12/12/2023 22:41

Oh is this covid nonsense making a "come back"? Tell teacher shes your child and no you wont be sticking things up her nose and down her throat for absolutely no reason. Its a cold she will be fine. Our children have suffered enough with this covid BS

TrashedSofa · 12/12/2023 18:55

Even in 2020 @Pickingmyselfup there was no legal requirement for the government to fund isolation. SSP only, so there were people who were priced out of isolation whilst also being threatened with legal sanctions if they didn't do it. Otherwise I broadly agree.

VanityDiesHard · 12/12/2023 18:55

Pickingmyselfup · 12/12/2023 18:44

I wouldn't test because it wouldn't change my view. I don't get paid if I don't go to work so I try and go in as much as possible but because I have 2 kids my odds of not making it in are higher.

If they are genuinely ill then me and my husband take it in turns to stay at home. Neither of our employers would be happy if we turned around and said we couldn't make it in because our child wasn't ill but covid positive considering there are no rules anymore.

I know this seems to be a mind blowing concept to some but neither of us can work from home, we can't afford for either of us to piss our employers off unnecessarily, we like being able to afford to pay the bills. Both of our employers are actually pretty good about us needing time off for sickness but there is only so much they will accept and that's totally understandable. Us not being there has negative impacts on them and when it can't be helped it can't be helped but this isn't one of those.

Now I do think there can be a lot of unfairness around sickness, presenteeism in the workplace and in school. I've worked in many places where its assumed someone is faking if they call in sick and too many absences require a meeting. As you can imagine it's not conductive to taking time off because of a sore throat or a sniffle plus at the end of the day if we all took time off because we were tired/only feeling 95% we would never be in work.

If we are expected to ground to a halt because of covid we need to go back to 2020, pay for isolation of yourself or a child, free tests and government backed isolation policies because otherwise we will crack on as usual because we have to come first and that's the way of life. Nobody else is going to put a roof over my head or feed us.

I agree with every word of this. Some Mumsnetters really do live in Never Never land.

Pickingmyselfup · 12/12/2023 18:44

I wouldn't test because it wouldn't change my view. I don't get paid if I don't go to work so I try and go in as much as possible but because I have 2 kids my odds of not making it in are higher.

If they are genuinely ill then me and my husband take it in turns to stay at home. Neither of our employers would be happy if we turned around and said we couldn't make it in because our child wasn't ill but covid positive considering there are no rules anymore.

I know this seems to be a mind blowing concept to some but neither of us can work from home, we can't afford for either of us to piss our employers off unnecessarily, we like being able to afford to pay the bills. Both of our employers are actually pretty good about us needing time off for sickness but there is only so much they will accept and that's totally understandable. Us not being there has negative impacts on them and when it can't be helped it can't be helped but this isn't one of those.

Now I do think there can be a lot of unfairness around sickness, presenteeism in the workplace and in school. I've worked in many places where its assumed someone is faking if they call in sick and too many absences require a meeting. As you can imagine it's not conductive to taking time off because of a sore throat or a sniffle plus at the end of the day if we all took time off because we were tired/only feeling 95% we would never be in work.

If we are expected to ground to a halt because of covid we need to go back to 2020, pay for isolation of yourself or a child, free tests and government backed isolation policies because otherwise we will crack on as usual because we have to come first and that's the way of life. Nobody else is going to put a roof over my head or feed us.

Manthide · 12/12/2023 17:48

StripyHorse · 11/12/2023 16:57

Everyone saying OP is not being unreasonable... would you be happy to be surrounded by covid positive co-workers (some of whom won't cover their mouths when coughing /sneezing) so close to Christmas? That is essentially what you are expecting of the teacher.

I work in a zero hours minimum wage job in a warehouse. Of course people come in if they are ill as otherwise they don't get paid. Some are more considerate than others as to their basic hygiene but generally there are lots of germs around. Occasionally someone rocks in with a face mask but I'm never sure if that means they have covid or are protecting themselves from it.

Lainey0930 · 12/12/2023 15:13

You aren’t being unreasonable. I’d tell them no too! I think the teacher should mind her own bloody business.

Megifer · 12/12/2023 11:25

But if you do know the answers to my questions that would be great 🤣

Megifer · 12/12/2023 11:25

SwingTheMonkey · 12/12/2023 11:22

My response was sarcastic. I wouldn’t test for Covid, or flu.

It was in response to someone saying they only test for Covid, not flu because ‘you’d know if you had the flu’. Which is ridiculous imo - flu is just as likely to make someone seriously ill as Covid is.

Oh fgs I'm a dick, ignore me 😩

SwingTheMonkey · 12/12/2023 11:23

Yesididntdothat · 12/12/2023 11:14

I really can't be doing with the "ha ha blood on your hands" comments. Probably depends a bit on whether you had anyone you knew die from covid. Or just general self interest, perhaps.

My grandad died from the flu. Probably caught it from someone who insists on testing for Covid but would happily carry on as normal if they got that negative Covid test result.

SwingTheMonkey · 12/12/2023 11:22

Megifer · 12/12/2023 11:05

I have a cold at the minute, only mild, as do my DC. Flu tests are £20 on Amazon. Do we need to stay in until we can test? Do we test every day until its clear? Where can I claim the £20-£100 back?

My response was sarcastic. I wouldn’t test for Covid, or flu.

It was in response to someone saying they only test for Covid, not flu because ‘you’d know if you had the flu’. Which is ridiculous imo - flu is just as likely to make someone seriously ill as Covid is.