Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DDs school want me to COVID test her, AIBU to say no?

286 replies

mybossisaprick · 11/12/2023 16:43

Dd, who is in primary school, has got the cold that’s been going round. She’s not too unwell in herself, and is happily playing, but she has a husky voice and a cough. She’s maybe a bit more tired than normal, but nothing that would mean she would need to stay off school. If she was unwell enough to miss school, I’d keep her off.

Her teacher pulled me aside at pickup time and asked me if she’d taken a COVID test. I said no, she hadn’t. Teacher asked me why not, and I explained that she wasn’t unwell enough to miss school, and so there was no point testing her for COVID. Teacher said that I should test her anyway, and if positive she should stay home. I explained that myself and my partner both have to work, we don’t get enough leave as it is, and whilst if DD was actually unwell in herself and couldn’t go to school, one of us could stay off with her, but since she’s not, we really don't have the resources to be taking time off. Also, I don’t have easy access to tests and I’d rather not buy a test when I don’t need to.

AIBU to tell this teacher that I wouldn’t be testing DD?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Feralgremlin · 14/12/2023 19:09

Riverstep · 14/12/2023 18:28

You can get them free from pharmacies if you are eligible for Covid treatments.

None of our local pharmacies have “signed up to the scheme” as such, nearest one is 30+ min drive away so it was easier to just buy them from the local pharmacy down the road.

Riverstep · 14/12/2023 18:28

Feralgremlin · 14/12/2023 17:18

Because for those of us who need them, you can’t access covid treatments without a positive test 🤷🏻‍♀️

You can get them free from pharmacies if you are eligible for Covid treatments.

eastegg · 14/12/2023 17:38

VanityDiesHard · 14/12/2023 15:28

You don't know that the stroke was caused by Covid, that is post hoc ergo propter hoc.

I imagine Technonan is well aware that it can’t be proved that the stroke was caused by Covid and that’s why they have just stated the facts. It has been shown however that Covid attacks the vascular system, and stroke is a vascular event.

Feralgremlin · 14/12/2023 17:18

Riverstep · 12/12/2023 10:06

Are people buying covid tests now then? As an nhs worker, I’ve not been provided with any since the end of 2022. Do people also buy flu tests? If you test for Covid but not for flu, why?

Because for those of us who need them, you can’t access covid treatments without a positive test 🤷🏻‍♀️

Feralgremlin · 14/12/2023 17:09

Ehhh I see it from both sides.

Im at high risk from Covid, DS brought it home from school and passed it on to us which has led to a hospital trip plus covid treatment infusion. We have all been knocked on our bums with it this time around, it’s been horrendous and the added fear that I would end up hospitalised and very seriously ill has been an added stress. We have all stayed home since testing positive, we wouldn’t have been well enough to work anyway, but haven’t been to shops, seen people etc because I wouldn’t want to risk passing this on to another vulnerable person.

Having said that, I am also fully aware of the cost of living crisis, the new govt guidelines, and that lots of people don’t have the privilege of being able to just “stay home” or keep their children off school. Ultimately, bills need to be paid, food needs to be put on the table, and for probably the majority of the country, that is their priority, and rightly so.

I think what doesn’t help is the snarking at either side of the debate. I hold no ill-will to those out and about with covid, going to work and school etc, it’s a necessity for most, but equally I don’t feel that those like myself who do test, who do still choose to isolate, deserve to be ridiculed and patronised because “covid is just a common cold now”, or because we are perceived to be oblivious to our privilege and the difficulties others may face.

TeaWithASplashOfMilk · 14/12/2023 16:35

@VanityDiesHard is there anything you think IS linked to covid infections, apart from hypochondria, or deciding to use a wheelchair for fun of course?

VanityDiesHard · 14/12/2023 15:28

Technonan · 14/12/2023 13:05

Covid is not an illness to be relaxed about. It can cause long term damage, and the more times you get it, the more likely this is to happen. I have two previously healthy friends with heart damage from Covid (one is only in her 30s). I had a totally unexpected stroke - my risk factors are very low - after a mild case of Covid.

There's very little to be done. There are high levels of infection currently and the death rate is going up, but no one is making a big noise about it because of the potential damage to the economy. My advice would be to wear a mask if you're out and about. I'd also test my child because I'd want to know.

You don't know that the stroke was caused by Covid, that is post hoc ergo propter hoc.

TeaWithASplashOfMilk · 14/12/2023 15:27

'but no one is making a big noise about it because of the potential damage to the economy'

There is this, except that implies current policy is not having a big impact on the economy. Economists have been flagging up the financial burden for a while. We are giving kids a multiple whammy - again.

Technonan · 14/12/2023 13:05

Covid is not an illness to be relaxed about. It can cause long term damage, and the more times you get it, the more likely this is to happen. I have two previously healthy friends with heart damage from Covid (one is only in her 30s). I had a totally unexpected stroke - my risk factors are very low - after a mild case of Covid.

There's very little to be done. There are high levels of infection currently and the death rate is going up, but no one is making a big noise about it because of the potential damage to the economy. My advice would be to wear a mask if you're out and about. I'd also test my child because I'd want to know.

TrashedSofa · 14/12/2023 12:58

LuckySantangelo35 · 14/12/2023 12:27

@mybossisaprick

why wouldn’t you just test her op? Like what is your issue with it really?

Out of interest, do you think OP should keep DD off if the hypothetical test is positive? If yes, then it's not a 'just' and OP has explained why that would be a problem. If no, then there's no reason to think there'd be any real point?

LuckySantangelo35 · 14/12/2023 12:27

@mybossisaprick

why wouldn’t you just test her op? Like what is your issue with it really?

Anothnamechang · 14/12/2023 12:19

I’ve just tested positive today and I feel absolutely awful! This is my 5th rodeo with it, last time I had long Covid whilst pregnant. I have a baby who’s oxygen reliant so I am incredibly cautious with any bugs/infections. Although I don’t restrict my other children mixing but if they do fall unwell they are kept off of school regardless.

TeaWithASplashOfMilk · 14/12/2023 12:15

There are lots of viruses that can appear mild in the initial stage - polio for example. It's such a senseless rationale. If someone can show me a piece of robust evidence showing covid is like the common cold now, rather than just saying it, that would be great. For a parenting site, the way we are treating kids is shameful.

DaizyDee · 14/12/2023 11:32

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow At least MN deleted the worst posts by VanityDiesHard calling LC "bollocks" and saying we're "grifters". One day ableism will be viewed with as much abhorrence as racism but we're very far from that atm

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 14/12/2023 11:27

I have to use a wheelchair too.

So much gaslighting, ableism and stubborn ignorance on this thread.

DaizyDee · 14/12/2023 10:56

Inastatus · 13/12/2023 22:57

@DaizyDee - I’m truly sorry that you’ve been affected by long covid but you must know that chronic post viral illness is caused by lots of different viruses. The fact is that covid is now a very mild illness for the vast majority of people, especially if vaccinated, and you cannot expect people to isolate themselves anymore. Not forgetting the obvious fact that you are contagious before you have symptoms and that you could be positive and completely symptomless.

@Inastatus however mild Covid might appear, it's still doing damage. Numerous studies show brain damage in varying degrees after even asymptomatic cases. And the mildest of cases can go on to cause Long Covid, which is taking people out of the workforce and causing misery for hundreds of thousands. Chronic illness is caused by lots of different viruses, yes, but the scale of Covid and Long Covid is another level. There are no mitigations in schools (HEPA fillers/ ventilation) and no policy for avoiding infection (testing/ sensible stay at home policy). It's madness. Thousands of children now have Long Covid from infections picked up at school. Meanwhile people are calling us grifters and saying it's "bollocks", even our ex PM. I have to use a bloody wheelchair and people on this thread are telling me it's in my head? It's ableism pure and simple.
Why should any teacher (or any public servant or any working person) be forced into risking a lifetime of disability?

DyslexicPoster · 14/12/2023 10:05

Shoot me, but I'd smile, say yes, then do nothing. How would they know? Covid us everywhere, my sisters had it 4 weeks apart. You can't stop catching it anymore. It's the new common cold in some ways.

TrashedSofa · 14/12/2023 10:04

Movinghouseatlast · 14/12/2023 09:56

It's a very difficult one.

I had Covid recently. I was very ill for 5 weeks, couldn't work, felt absolutely appalling. I really would have preferred not to go through that.

But the advice is to carry on as normal so this is leading to these moral conundrums and arguments

I think regardless of what the advice was, these conundrums would be there.

We had a situation where for nearly 2 years, people had a legal obligation to isolate if covid positive but there was no corresponding duty from the state to provide them with enough to live on. SSP only, and just for those who were eligible. That was a problem in 2020-22, Indy SAGE had some interesting stuff about how people were being priced out of isolation, but it was one that was somewhat swept under the carpet. And that was even before the cost of living crisis. It's an inevitability when there isn't the structural backup for testing and isolation, regardless of what the government of the time might be saying.

Movinghouseatlast · 14/12/2023 10:01

Inastatus · 13/12/2023 22:57

@DaizyDee - I’m truly sorry that you’ve been affected by long covid but you must know that chronic post viral illness is caused by lots of different viruses. The fact is that covid is now a very mild illness for the vast majority of people, especially if vaccinated, and you cannot expect people to isolate themselves anymore. Not forgetting the obvious fact that you are contagious before you have symptoms and that you could be positive and completely symptomless.

The vaccines have worn off now, unless you are eligible for a booster.

Believe me, symptoms are not mild. I've just been in bed for 5 weeks with it. I have no risk factors but it knocked me off my feet.

TrashedSofa · 14/12/2023 09:59

eastegg · 14/12/2023 09:55

We never had the public at large testing routinely as far as I recall. And definitely not schoolchildren, which is what the OP is about. It would be a massive shift to go back to symptomatic testing and some form of isolation after a positive test, let alone asymptomatic testing.

I agree, there are very significant barriers in the way of such a policy. Cannot see the public agreeing. But it's what would have to happen for nobody to be in the position of being constantly exposed to people with covid at work.

Movinghouseatlast · 14/12/2023 09:56

It's a very difficult one.

I had Covid recently. I was very ill for 5 weeks, couldn't work, felt absolutely appalling. I really would have preferred not to go through that.

But the advice is to carry on as normal so this is leading to these moral conundrums and arguments

eastegg · 14/12/2023 09:55

TrashedSofa · 14/12/2023 09:47

I don't think that's what it can mean. Covid is still so common, and can be transmitted asymptomatically or by people who will shortly have symptoms but don't yet, so simply not being around coughing and snot wouldn't achieve that. It would have to be a reintroduction of attempts to get people to test routinely, rather than just when they're showing symptoms.

We never had the public at large testing routinely as far as I recall. And definitely not schoolchildren, which is what the OP is about. It would be a massive shift to go back to symptomatic testing and some form of isolation after a positive test, let alone asymptomatic testing.

TrashedSofa · 14/12/2023 09:47

I don't think that's what it can mean. Covid is still so common, and can be transmitted asymptomatically or by people who will shortly have symptoms but don't yet, so simply not being around coughing and snot wouldn't achieve that. It would have to be a reintroduction of attempts to get people to test routinely, rather than just when they're showing symptoms.

eastegg · 14/12/2023 09:39

cardibach · 14/12/2023 00:33

What you are failing to grasp is that nobody should be in that position. That’s the whole point. Not special treatment for teachers. The same - better - treatment for everyone.

I’m not failing to grasp that, but that’s a different point. The point I was making was that saying ‘how would you like to be face to face with the public every day like teachers are?’ really does smack of suggesting that not many people on the thread are in that position. It does. A pp said that sounded like asking for special consideration. You said that shows hatred for teachers. I’m saying the earlier post was asking for special consideration, and pointing that out does not show hatred for teachers.

I’m all for better treatment for public servants. All of them. I say that as someone who worked at the coalface of the criminal justice system for 20 years, including in 2020. But in this context, I’m not sure what you mean by ‘nobody should be in that position’. Nobody should be coming into face to face contact with someone who is snotty and coughing while doing their public-facing job? I’m not sure I can agree with that.

TrashedSofa · 14/12/2023 09:19

Why wouldn't we be able to get post viral symptoms from colds? Colds are viruses. Some of them are even coronaviruses.

I know we aren't likely to have good stats on it, since we all know the issues with post viral conditions being swept under the table and not very well researched. But can't see how anyone could rule out the concept of no 'long' version of some incredibly common viruses.

I agree it's unhelpful saying covid is or isn't like a cold or flu. No good ever comes from that, particularly as so many people seem to think cold and flu are descriptions of severity of symptoms (hence the whole 'real flu' bollocks). But not on the basis of long term side effects.