Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who should pay? Tenant or landlord

107 replies

MirrorBack · 11/12/2023 12:56

Windy here yesterday, not a storm but enough to be noisy and see the trees really moving around.

Tennant opened a fairly high up flat window while cooking.
Window blew open hard, hinges are bent and now it can’t be closed properly.
Window is about 2 metres, opens from the bottom, upvc and otherwise has no issues.

OP posts:
Zanatdy · 11/12/2023 13:49

Landlord.

Jacfrost · 11/12/2023 13:47

MirrorBack · 11/12/2023 13:23

They have done a lot of stupid things tbh, that they’ve moaned about. Our kids are friends and it’s not the first time she’s called me in to look.. Not reported a crack in the shower that leaked for ages. Flooded with a tap om, snapped things….Tbh they also have awful condensation and they usuallly hate opening windows, so it’s weird. The flat was decorated and a lot of work before they moved in, it’s not crappy. No idea if they’ve paid before. I don’t dislike her, but I’m glad not my tenant!

So they've got condensation and have presumably been told by the landlord to open windows...they open a window and they're negligent 😂

I'm so glad I'm not a tenant anymore.

bigdecisionstomake · 11/12/2023 13:38

It is a landlord responsibility to keep the structure and security of the building intact. The landlord should only try to claim the cost back from the tenant if they can clearly demonstrate tenant has been negligent or not acted in a 'tenant like manner'.

MirrorBack · 11/12/2023 13:34

It’s only £160 to replace hinges, I’m guessing below insurance amounts. The window is otherwise fine. There’s no cheeky request to claim a replacement or anything. So far just a text

OP posts:
Tiredbehyondbelief · 11/12/2023 13:26

Landlord. It's not unreasonable to open a window during cooking. Stormy weather isn't uncommon in the Uk

Tacotortoise · 11/12/2023 13:25

It will be covered by the buildings insurance. The rent should contain an amount to cover wear tear and acts of stupidity by the tenant. If the amount needed to cover "acts of stupidity" gets too high, then that's when you up the rent or lose the tenant.

Sparklesocks · 11/12/2023 13:25

MirrorBack · 11/12/2023 13:20

I’m not sure about weather warnings, but I live on the same road as the tenants (I’m a landlord so they asked me, but not their landlord).
I was tbh leaning towards negligence. I’d closed all my windows and the story seems off. Open a crack as described it looks impossible. Maybe if it was open absolutely full the wind could lift it? The window looks not old and decent.
I kind of saw why the landlord has said negligence, but was wondering other’s opinion before I answered. I said I’d think

Honestly I think things like this are just part of being a landlord. The tenant didn’t deliberately break the window or act in a way that you’d expect would break it. If your friend can’t swallow costs like this then maybe being a landlord isn’t for them.

edit: apologies I misunderstood and thought you knew the landlord, not the tenant

MirrorBack · 11/12/2023 13:23

Trisolaris · 11/12/2023 13:20

I’d pay if it was my tenant. I wouldn’t think badly of them either unless they had a significant history of damaging things.

They have done a lot of stupid things tbh, that they’ve moaned about. Our kids are friends and it’s not the first time she’s called me in to look.. Not reported a crack in the shower that leaked for ages. Flooded with a tap om, snapped things….Tbh they also have awful condensation and they usuallly hate opening windows, so it’s weird. The flat was decorated and a lot of work before they moved in, it’s not crappy. No idea if they’ve paid before. I don’t dislike her, but I’m glad not my tenant!

OP posts:
gnarlynarwhal · 11/12/2023 13:23

*part not pet

gnarlynarwhal · 11/12/2023 13:22

It’s pet and parcel of being a landlord. You pay.

TinkerTiger · 11/12/2023 13:20

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 13:00

I think that the tenant’s insurance should pay.

opening windows during a storm (uk has had 2 storms this weekend) is pretty daft and I don’t see why the landlord should have to pay for their stupidity.

Edited

From the first line of the OP 'not a storm'

MirrorBack · 11/12/2023 13:20

I’m not sure about weather warnings, but I live on the same road as the tenants (I’m a landlord so they asked me, but not their landlord).
I was tbh leaning towards negligence. I’d closed all my windows and the story seems off. Open a crack as described it looks impossible. Maybe if it was open absolutely full the wind could lift it? The window looks not old and decent.
I kind of saw why the landlord has said negligence, but was wondering other’s opinion before I answered. I said I’d think

OP posts:
Dotjones · 11/12/2023 13:20

Landlord. 1) it's an issue with the structure of the property and 2) it's not like the winds were that bad - if a relatively light wind can cause that damage, the structure wasn't very sound.

Trisolaris · 11/12/2023 13:20

I’d pay if it was my tenant. I wouldn’t think badly of them either unless they had a significant history of damaging things.

OhmygodDont · 11/12/2023 13:18

Landlord but I’d also expect the landlord might decide not to renew as common sense say windows wide open and strong winds do not mix well and put a safety catch on the window too.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 13:16

fitforflight · 11/12/2023 13:05

Which tenants insurance are you expecting to pay out? There's nothing a tenant would have that should cover windows.

I’ve not been a tenant since I was a student but back then we all had to have insurance that covered our belongings against loss, theft and accidental damage. It also covered accidental damage to the building and when the property was broken into we each had to use our insurance to sort out the damaged doors to our rooms and the back door that had been damaged as they gained entry.

I assumed tenants would have insurance to cover against damage such as that in the op, it’s not fair for landlords to have to cover the costs where the tenant hasn’t used their common sense.

GinAndJuice99 · 11/12/2023 13:15

Cloudysky81 · 11/12/2023 13:12

Landlord, but I wouldn't be keeping that tenant for long.

You sound nice

Cloudysky81 · 11/12/2023 13:12

Landlord, but I wouldn't be keeping that tenant for long.

KatBurglar · 11/12/2023 13:11

Landlord, and probably covered by the landlord's buildings insurance.

Daisymay2 · 11/12/2023 13:11

I agree with @SnowsFalling , it would be my responsibility but I would be a bit miffed as there were plenty of weather warnings at the week end. I would be approaching the Managing Agent regarding the buildings insurance though.

ladyofshertonabbas · 11/12/2023 13:11

Have been both- the landlord.

saraclara · 11/12/2023 13:10

A window that opens from the bottom wouldn't expect to be damaged by wind. I'd potentially think twice about opening a side hinged window, but there has to have been something wrong for a bottom opening one to be broken by a non- hurricane wind.

This is what landlord's building insurance is for. It's not the tenant's fault, and nor could they insure against such an incident.

FloofCloud · 11/12/2023 13:08

Well I suspect the landlord would have to pay, but the person opening the window needs to consider their stupidity, if it was really windy then keep windows closed if they're the type that swing open in the wind

randomstress · 11/12/2023 13:05

Having been both a landlord and tenant I think this is a landlord issue.
It is quite common to have to open a window when cooking.
It sounds as though the hinges just weren't very good quality rather than the tenant was doing something unexpected.

fitforflight · 11/12/2023 13:05

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 13:00

I think that the tenant’s insurance should pay.

opening windows during a storm (uk has had 2 storms this weekend) is pretty daft and I don’t see why the landlord should have to pay for their stupidity.

Edited

Which tenants insurance are you expecting to pay out? There's nothing a tenant would have that should cover windows.