Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who should pay? Tenant or landlord

107 replies

MirrorBack · 11/12/2023 12:56

Windy here yesterday, not a storm but enough to be noisy and see the trees really moving around.

Tennant opened a fairly high up flat window while cooking.
Window blew open hard, hinges are bent and now it can’t be closed properly.
Window is about 2 metres, opens from the bottom, upvc and otherwise has no issues.

OP posts:
agent765 · 11/12/2023 17:30

Swashbuckled · 11/12/2023 16:15

I think if they’d paid for their own windows, they wouldn’t have opened them in a high wind. In the storm this weekend, I had to open my bedroom window at night to see if a tree had fallen. I opened it a crack, and then used my other hand to grip the edge and keep the opening gap small, so the wind wouldn’t catch it and blow it open and cause damage. ‘Cos I know what it would cost me. (And I’d say it would have to be a strong wind, noisy and seeing the trees moving, to damage the hinges like that.)

Spot on.

I've been a tenant, and am now an owner (well, the bank is technically the owner).

I looked after my rentals as well as I look after my own home. Leaks get fixed ASAP, no wet washing on radiators, windows opened a crack every morning for at least an hour every day no matter how cold it is. Windows wiped down every morning as despite all my counter-measures, I still get condensation on cold days.

However, it was windy in gusts over the weekend and I assumed that a gust could possibly wrench the window open so I only opened the windows on the sheltered side of the house.

I don't understand how hard it is for some people, tenants and owners but particularly tenants, to use their heads and look after their homes.

My friend has rented for the last 25 years. She's left each home in a mess due to negligence (or being a bit daft at times). Each one was pristine when she moved in. I know this because her last but one was the one I'd moved out of directly before she moved in and I'd viewed the others with her.

She won't accept advice. Does everything she shouldn't to keep a house dry and mould-free. The one she moved into after me was covered in black mould in three months. She was using a vented dryer against an inside room wall so even if the house had a hole for a vent it wouldn't have been used. She was trying to heat the house from the heat of her new dryer as she reckoned the steam was warming!

I asked her at the time if it needed a vent but she said it would have come with the machine if it did. I explained that some don't and pointed out the steam coming from the back to no avail. She blamed me for telling her about the "faulty" house and "dodgy" landlord even though I'd lived there 8 years with no problems. She's trying to sue the landlord - a lovely elderly gent who was amazing with us.

I despair. She's well-educated and not stupid but lacks common sense and won't take responsibility for anything. She's lucky to get a rental at all. If potential landlords saw the state of the houses when she left she wouldn't get one. She has a dog and cat but works all day so the carpets are always a mess with dog shit and pee and interior doors are scratched and chewed. She's just rescued a cat despite the current landlord not accepting them due to her allergy to cat flea bites. Apparently, the previous tenant did the same and as she cleans the property between tenants she is unwilling to accept them.

As for window limiters, it depends on the window as some have to open fully as a fire escape.

Notmetoo · 11/12/2023 17:26

Landlord definitely

m00rfarm · 11/12/2023 17:23

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 11/12/2023 17:23

That's not remotely how it works.

Right. Ok.

Tiiredofthiss · 11/12/2023 17:23

Landlord, probably covered by their building insurance anyway.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 11/12/2023 17:23

m00rfarm · 11/12/2023 15:33

Would the damage have been caused had the house been unoccupied? No. So it’s the tenant who caused the damage. And should at least pay towards the costs.

That's not remotely how it works.

Zebedee55 · 11/12/2023 17:16

Landlord. A window should be fit for purpose.

margotrose · 11/12/2023 17:13

Given the tenant's insurance would not cover the building, it is only for the Tenant's possessions and is not mandatory anyway, that would be impossible.

Tenants can get insurance to cover accidental damage to the building. The fact that it's not mandatory is irrelevant, really.

margotrose · 11/12/2023 17:11

Halfemptyhalfling · 11/12/2023 17:10

Unless the landlord has installed a tumble drier, how else should the tenant dry washing in the UK in winter? Drying on a radiator would be quicker than elsewhere in a room?

Heated airers, clothes horse etc.

Halfemptyhalfling · 11/12/2023 17:10

BabaBarrio · 11/12/2023 14:38

Washing on the radiators is also negligence. This tenant needs a crash course in how to live in a cold, damp country.

Unless the landlord has installed a tumble drier, how else should the tenant dry washing in the UK in winter? Drying on a radiator would be quicker than elsewhere in a room?

SamphiretheTervosaurReturneth · 11/12/2023 17:05

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 13:00

I think that the tenant’s insurance should pay.

opening windows during a storm (uk has had 2 storms this weekend) is pretty daft and I don’t see why the landlord should have to pay for their stupidity.

Edited

Given the tenant's insurance would not cover the building, it is only for the Tenant's possessions and is not mandatory anyway, that would be impossible.

The landlord should claim on their insurance, which does cover the building and is mandatory!

The landlord can also take further step, like limiters on the windows to prevent a recurrence or a Section 21 notice.

honoldbrist · 11/12/2023 16:59

Tenant. Totally irresponsible to open a window during a storm. Must have been opened wide to catch like that too. I only open the vents in bad weather.

My window smashed as a child during a storm. Because I had propped it open as far as it would go. My dad put a new one in and told me not to open the window so wide again!

Haydenn · 11/12/2023 16:38

Landlord, but I’d be then putting limiters on the windows to stop them not being opened too far. I probably wouldn’t renew the tenancy or put the rent up when able for such a careless tenant.

Vinrouge4 · 11/12/2023 16:30

They sound right pain in the arse tenants.

monsteramunch · 11/12/2023 16:28

m00rfarm · 11/12/2023 15:33

Would the damage have been caused had the house been unoccupied? No. So it’s the tenant who caused the damage. And should at least pay towards the costs.

This isn't at all how tenancy contracts work!

margotrose · 11/12/2023 16:23

It sounds to me like the landlord is getting sick of them, to be quite honest.

The tenants should be insured against accidental damage really - we had insurance like that when we rented to cover things like this.

Swashbuckled · 11/12/2023 16:15

I think if they’d paid for their own windows, they wouldn’t have opened them in a high wind. In the storm this weekend, I had to open my bedroom window at night to see if a tree had fallen. I opened it a crack, and then used my other hand to grip the edge and keep the opening gap small, so the wind wouldn’t catch it and blow it open and cause damage. ‘Cos I know what it would cost me. (And I’d say it would have to be a strong wind, noisy and seeing the trees moving, to damage the hinges like that.)

FuckingHellAdele · 11/12/2023 16:12

MumPod · 11/12/2023 15:45

I am a landlord and tenants, in my experience, don't think or worry about damage to the property as they expect the landlord to pay. However, opening a window to let smoke out was a stupid thing to do whilst there's a storm but the tenant won't pay so I would just take it on the chin and sort and make them aware in writing, any future storms... don't open the effing windows so they get damaged 🤣 I have had nothing but issues with my rental properties so I'm perhaps a little bitter 🫣

What storm? The storm that OP says didn't happen, in the first line of the OP?

Landlord pays, and files it under Shit Happens

Houseplanter · 11/12/2023 16:09

Are tenants ever responsible for their actions?

Opening a window wide in bad weather sounds bizarre to me.

Skyisbluegrassisgreen · 11/12/2023 16:07

No, they sound like people who don’t like throwing their money away because of somebody else’s stupidity and thoughtlessness.

m00rfarm · 11/12/2023 16:05

randomstress · 11/12/2023 15:38

This isn't how it works.
As a landlord you have to cover basic wear and tear.

It isn’t wear and tear.

ActDottie · 11/12/2023 16:03

Technically landlord should pay but the tenant was a bit of an idiot!

Ghentsummer · 11/12/2023 16:00

Landlord but if I were them I would be looking to get the tenants out given they seem to be causing damage on multiple occasions. And the tenants shouldn't be complaining about condensation when they are the ones causing it by constantly hanging lots of washing over radiators.

Friendfoe1 · 11/12/2023 15:50

Landlord, the damage wasn’t malicious by the tennant.

DragonFly98 · 11/12/2023 15:45

Definitely landlord, no ambiguity.

MumPod · 11/12/2023 15:45

I am a landlord and tenants, in my experience, don't think or worry about damage to the property as they expect the landlord to pay. However, opening a window to let smoke out was a stupid thing to do whilst there's a storm but the tenant won't pay so I would just take it on the chin and sort and make them aware in writing, any future storms... don't open the effing windows so they get damaged 🤣 I have had nothing but issues with my rental properties so I'm perhaps a little bitter 🫣