Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who should pay? Tenant or landlord

107 replies

MirrorBack · 11/12/2023 12:56

Windy here yesterday, not a storm but enough to be noisy and see the trees really moving around.

Tennant opened a fairly high up flat window while cooking.
Window blew open hard, hinges are bent and now it can’t be closed properly.
Window is about 2 metres, opens from the bottom, upvc and otherwise has no issues.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
caringcarer · 12/12/2023 00:47

Mabelface · 11/12/2023 13:02

Landlord via their own buildings insurance. Not the tenant.

This, but I'd be telling the tenant not to open the window in a storm again.

Saracen · 12/12/2023 00:39

Landlord. Sure, the tenants could have been a bit more careful, but it isn't outright negligence. It's just one of those things.

If this happens repeatedly, the landlord should consider getting better quality hinges.

Damnloginpopup · 11/12/2023 22:03

Too much drama. You can replace the hinges. They aren't expensive or difficult to source. Crappy job to do but any competent diyer or handyman can do it in ten minutes.

BIossomtoes · 11/12/2023 21:43

The landlord should claim on their buildings insurance. That’s what it’s for.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 21:40

FrippEnos · 11/12/2023 21:21

FYI, its not an apology when you still blame the other person in the "apology"

At no point have I appointed any blame. I have already apologised for any misunderstanding and offence that you may have taken.

Anyway, I think we’ve derailed this thread enough now.

FrippEnos · 11/12/2023 21:21

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 21:00

🙄

FYI, its not an apology when you still blame the other person in the "apology"

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 21:00

FrippEnos · 11/12/2023 20:58

there you go again making assumptions.

Go you.

🙄

FrippEnos · 11/12/2023 20:58

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 20:36

You thought that it was amusing and showed no understanding of how it worked. If you were maintaining it then surely it wouldn’t be amusing as you’d know that it was doing the job that it was there to do perfectly well.

Apologies if you misunderstood my posts, no offence was intended.

there you go again making assumptions.

Go you.

lemmein · 11/12/2023 20:56

This happened to a friend of mine and the housing association tried to charge her for it. I appealed against the charge on her behalf (she'd just lost her child and couldn't be bothered with the hassle) and they dropped it.

I would expect the landlord to claim on the insurance for it, but obviously HA's disagree!

Caswallonthefox · 11/12/2023 20:45

Landlord pays. That's why they have building insurance. Although, in my case, my flat is grade 2 listed, which means the exterior has to look original, so I have ancient sash windows. I found out recently that replacing a glass pane costs £15 and there are 8 separate bits per window.
My landlord only does what he absolutely has to and whatever regulations he has to follow.
Every time I let him know I have a problem he's in France on holiday.

Denimdenimdenim · 11/12/2023 20:37

Landlord

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 20:36

FrippEnos · 11/12/2023 20:29

You decided that on no information that I wasn't maintaining the extractor. That is making stuff up and rude.

You thought that it was amusing and showed no understanding of how it worked. If you were maintaining it then surely it wouldn’t be amusing as you’d know that it was doing the job that it was there to do perfectly well.

Apologies if you misunderstood my posts, no offence was intended.

FrippEnos · 11/12/2023 20:29

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 20:25

You didn’t say anything about moisture and I didn’t say anything rude @FrippEnos

You thought that it was amusing to have an extractor that didn't extract to the outside. It’s very normal to have this type of set up in kitchens and it doesn’t result in moisture problems in the property. I’m glad that you maintained it so that it could do the job that it was designed for.

Edited

You decided that on no information that I wasn't maintaining the extractor. That is making stuff up and rude.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 20:25

You didn’t say anything about moisture and I didn’t say anything rude @FrippEnos

You thought that it was amusing to have an extractor that didn't extract to the outside. It’s very normal to have this type of set up in kitchens and it doesn’t result in moisture problems in the property. I’m glad that you maintained it so that it could do the job that it was designed for.

FrippEnos · 11/12/2023 19:55

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 19:49

@FrippEnos it probably had charcoal filters in it to absorb smells. As you were a tenant I would have expected you to check and maintain them really. Do tenants really not try to maintain the property that they are living in at all?

Did you mean too be so rude?

Yes it did and yes I did.

But it doesn't alter the fact that the extractor didn't extract condensation to the outside, which was the point that I was making. If you could have been bothered to read what I had posted.

Wendyspotatopeeler · 11/12/2023 19:50

Mabelface · 11/12/2023 13:02

Landlord via their own buildings insurance. Not the tenant.

This.
Accidents happen all the time and it would come under buildings in which is covered by Landlord insurance.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 19:49

@FrippEnos it probably had charcoal filters in it to absorb smells. As you were a tenant I would have expected you to check and maintain them really. Do tenants really not try to maintain the property that they are living in at all?

FrippEnos · 11/12/2023 19:46

BabaBarrio · 11/12/2023 14:36

This. There is no need to open a window when cooking, that is what the hood extractor fan is for. The damage occurred due to tenant negligence so they should replace the window.

I had a hood extractor in the last place that I rented.
The amusing thing is that it didn't extract to the outside, it just recirculated the air.
So as much as you seem to have it in for the tenants you don't know the full details.

Passingthethyme · 11/12/2023 18:47

Muchtoomuchtodo · 11/12/2023 13:00

I think that the tenant’s insurance should pay.

opening windows during a storm (uk has had 2 storms this weekend) is pretty daft and I don’t see why the landlord should have to pay for their stupidity.

Edited

I agree with this

margotrose · 11/12/2023 18:43

as a tenant you can’t win. Don’t open the window and get mould and it’s your fault, open the window and it gets damaged by the wind and it’s your fault.

Not opening your window during a storm/strong winds isn't going to give you mould Hmm

WhickDittington · 11/12/2023 18:41

SnowsFalling · 11/12/2023 13:02

Landlord.

But as a landlord I'd be miffed, as although windows are mine to fix, it was the tenant actions that caused the damage.

Edited

Yes, I agree. Landlord to pay (insurance would cover careless tenants), but irritating.

As a landlord I'm sometimes irritated by the damage my tenants do (far more damage than I've ever done, and I'm really not particularly careful), but you have to suck it up. People aren't as thoughtful when it's not their responsibility.

sandletown · 11/12/2023 18:24

Landlord. And I'm a landlord

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/12/2023 17:53

agent765 · 11/12/2023 17:44

Insurance costs rise to stupid amounts if you claim for small things like that.

From what OP says in a later post they sound like idiots. Would you open the window when the trees are visibly being blown around if it were your own house?

I no longer rent but there are fewer houses up for rental than ever before because landlords are selling up due to too many regulations, mortgage interest relief withdrawn and Section 21 at risk. Landlords can afford to be picky.

My LL was great but my friend's new LL is already talking of selling up and she hasn't been there long.

The fact landlords are selling up because they're now being regulated to ensure they provide adequate living conditions to their tenants tells its own story really.

I also love that despite the OP stating in the opening line that it was

"Windy here yesterday, not a storm but enough to be noisy and see the trees really moving around"

Multiple posters have decided to ignore that entire and post on the basis that the tenant opened their windows fully in gale force winds.

agent765 · 11/12/2023 17:44

IveOnlyEverHeardOutwithONHere · 11/12/2023 17:33

Isn’t that what insurance is for?

as a tenant you can’t win. Don’t open the window and get mould and it’s your fault, open the window and it gets damaged by the wind and it’s your fault.

Insurance costs rise to stupid amounts if you claim for small things like that.

From what OP says in a later post they sound like idiots. Would you open the window when the trees are visibly being blown around if it were your own house?

I no longer rent but there are fewer houses up for rental than ever before because landlords are selling up due to too many regulations, mortgage interest relief withdrawn and Section 21 at risk. Landlords can afford to be picky.

My LL was great but my friend's new LL is already talking of selling up and she hasn't been there long.

IveOnlyEverHeardOutwithONHere · 11/12/2023 17:33

Isn’t that what insurance is for?

as a tenant you can’t win. Don’t open the window and get mould and it’s your fault, open the window and it gets damaged by the wind and it’s your fault.