Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed at my mum’s expectations when moving to the Caribbean

262 replies

Ticklemeharder · 11/12/2023 09:46

My mum currently lives about 10 minutes away from me and my two DC’s (age 1 & 3). She’s recently moved in with her partner of 18 months and is very happy and in love. Her partner has had some issues with work in the UK but used to work in the Caribbean and has applied for a number of jobs there which he feels confident securing. They have told us all this in the last week and are planning to relocate in January.

My mum is currently in a huff with me when I expressed concerns over the speed of the move and questioned whether they had thought everything through etc. When asked how long they were planning on living out there I was given a very vague answer of “oh maybe a few years but who knows!”

She just keeps on going on about the white sandy beaches and glorious sunshine and won’t it be a fabulous adventure. Reassuring me that she will still have a relationship with the grandkids due to the invention of FaceTime and we can come out to visit once they are settled over there.

There is also an expectation that I will deal with renting out of both her and her partners properties as they won’t have time before they go. Not to mention my mum’s 8 year old dog who my mum seems to think a family member will just take her because “no-one will see her in a shelter”.

All of this just seems completely out the blue and I’m struggling to be supportive. It’s almost like she’s so focussed on the fantasy that the reality has not even slightly entered in her mind. I’m not sure what to do.

OP posts:
twilightcafe · 11/12/2023 14:40

PPs are correct that a professional letting agent needs to deal with your mother's property while she is away. I would also strongly recommend to her that she does tnot sell up her property, thinking she will be spending the rest of her life in the Caribbean.
I know of several retirees who did sell up and move back to the Caribbean. A big proportion of them realised that the Caribbean wasn't what they thought it would be, would love to move back the UK, but can't because they can no longer afford to buy anything here.

Goingsunny · 11/12/2023 14:29

I understand you're disappointed she's moving so far away, but I do think she should be able live her life. It might be amazing or it might be a mistake but she needs to find that out for herself.
I think you need to be clear that you cannot take on managing two properties. I know you said you would help with hers, but you could say you've looked into it and there's a lot more to it than you realised , and you've got enough on with your small children so they would be better off with a letting agent. You could offer to help by preparing it for rental eg. Helping her clear it out/ helping her hire a skip or removal firm/ storage, so you're not completely going back on this.

She needs to decide what to do with her stuff and look at her budget and how much money she will need to live on once letting fees, storage costs and whatever else will be deducted, although this isn't your problem . She also needs to look into taking the dog with her. They've got a lot to sort out by January. It does seem very quick.

Arggghhhhhhhh · 11/12/2023 14:28

Just. Say. No.

Honestly, I'm sick of reading here about daughters (myself included) run into the ground by ridiculous demands of extended family.

GaryLurcher19 · 11/12/2023 14:26

A bit of general advice about possible romance fraud in this link:

https://www.surrey.police.uk/romancefraud#:~:text=Romance%20Fraud%20is%20a%20serious,Romance%20Fraud%20anonymously%20to%20Scamalytics%20.

Not saying he is a scammer but you can check him out a bit without them knowing or risking upsetting your mum.

occa · 11/12/2023 14:25

Honestly, this scenario varies from being pretty plausible to totally bonkers depending on which part of the Caribbean you're talking about. Where are they thinking of moving to?

PurBal · 11/12/2023 14:19

YouveGotAFastCar · 11/12/2023 09:58

Having lived in the Caribbean for a while; she's not that wrong. Lots of people, especially older people, do just move out there for a while.

I'd be supportive of, and excited about, her move if that's what she wants to do - but I wouldn't be taking on renting out her properties, that's a pain in the arse with everything you need to sort, and two properties is basically a job. There's a reason agents charge decent commission for that.

I also wouldn't necessarily be taking her dog, unless I wanted it.

It's a shame about her grandchildren but she has considered that aspect, she just doesn't deem it a priority vs going to live out in the Caribbean, so that says a lot. You can't force good grandparents.

This.

RantyAnty · 11/12/2023 14:16

After reading this again, can you do a background check on him?

I wonder if him suddenly wanting to relocate is a way of avoiding some type of legal action against him?

NotSayingImBatman · 11/12/2023 14:14

Ticklemeharder · 11/12/2023 11:46

I can’t really divulge much about the DP’s work situation but he is British and high up in a regulated career. He is currently dealing with a dispute which means he is unable to work in his current field until it’s resolved (if ever) and his savings have all been used up in the court case.

Every single part of this screams romance scammer. No doubt once they get out there and she's isolated from everyone, he'll tell her he just needs a contract to come good and she needs to sell her house in the meantime to tide them over.

Dustybarn · 11/12/2023 14:08

Tell your mum it’s too much to take on if you have to rent out both their places and she will have to use an agent. She can take the dog with her! Lots of people emigrate with pets.

GaryLurcher19 · 11/12/2023 14:06

Katbum · 11/12/2023 13:45

Reading your updates this guy sounds extremely dodgy and I would be surprised if half what he has told you is true. I’d have words with your mum about the possibility he is lying and scamming her. Moving to the Caribbean sounds lovely, but it also means he has her isolated and far away.

I have to say I agree with the PPs saying he sounds dodgy. A little bit of background checking wouldn't go amiss, just for peace of mind.

thecatneuterer · 11/12/2023 14:03

Spottywombat · 11/12/2023 09:55

As a landlord of many years, renting out houses isn't that easy.

Will need electrical & has checks. Plus tenancy deposit scheme, insurance, mortgage needs to be compliant, yadda, yadda.

Swerve that, it's a complete ballache.

Completely agree. Refuse to get involved. She can deal with an agency.

Katbum · 11/12/2023 13:45

Reading your updates this guy sounds extremely dodgy and I would be surprised if half what he has told you is true. I’d have words with your mum about the possibility he is lying and scamming her. Moving to the Caribbean sounds lovely, but it also means he has her isolated and far away.

TadpolesInPool · 11/12/2023 13:44

I recently moved to the Caribbean and would NOT recommend it for anyone in financial difficulty. It is horrendously expensive: rent, food, clothes, furniture, electronics... plus travel on the island (you really need a car), between islands and to go back home.

Depending on the island there is also the healthcare aspect. I'm on a French island and although it's no more expensive than in France it's VERY difficult to access. We visit dentist, optometrist etc. when we go back to visit family. My kids have SN and for their meds we do video calls with their Dr in Paris...

Talk things like this through with your mum. What's her plan? I spent months researching this before agreeing to the move.

kitsuneghost · 11/12/2023 13:43

Don't do anything !!
Let her go, its her life. But I wouldn't be dealing with any life admin she leaves behind
She can get professionals to deal with the houses and dog if she is in too much of a hurry to get it sorted.

Katbum · 11/12/2023 13:42

‘Mum moving to Caribbean sounds a really exciting adventure - can’t wait to see what you get up to. Just to be clear though, I have a lot on with the kids and my own stuff, so I’m not able to help sort your house or take on any responsibility for it or the dog while you are away.’

BungleandGeorge · 11/12/2023 13:42

Your mum is an adult, be happy for her that she’s found an adventure and is brave enough to do this. You don’t have to agree to take on any of the work though, they can get an agent for the rentals and I don’t see there’s a reason she can’t take the dog with her?

StickyProblem · 11/12/2023 13:41

This, from @OlderandwiserMaybe

"With this update and the length of your Mums relationship I'd be seriously concerned that the mother is in the middle of a relationship scammer.

Setting aside the issue of who should be responsible for the dog and renting the house out.

I think I;d be more interested in what the partners motives are and his background TBH.

These scams develop over years - and especially with talk of a "secret" wedding before they leave for Caribbean I'd be wanting to protect my mothers assets (not for my own benefit but for the protection of the mother). A friend of mine works in finance and he's currently trying to help a client who has lost their entire life's savings to a scan that involved plans to move abroad - spoiler alert the "couple" never moved and the scammer has vanished with all the money."

It's a classic scam pattern. The guy claims to be high up, important, had a great career, used to being wealthy yada yada yada to build your DM's confidence in him, he just doesn't have any money NOW. Next thing is "good news, I won £££ in the court case but can you lend me £10k while it clears".

If he's worked in an industry for years but now he's involved in an expensive work-related court case, he's financially dodgy even if he's genuine.

Why would being in an intelligence-related field (claimed often by scammers as an excuse for secrecy) mean he's involved in an expensive work-related court case? If work goes wrong in intelligence and you are physically safe, you go to prison (breaching secrets act) or you retire/quit. An expensive court case would be more related to commercial work. He's got his stories confused.

Do everything you can to get your mum to stay here, not marry him, take a little longer to decide, and be alert for him asking to sign money or legal power over to him.

Keepinmovin · 11/12/2023 13:36

housethatbuiltme · 11/12/2023 13:20

She is moving WITH her partner though.

She doesn't have to give up her life forever to be near her grand kids... I know plenty of kids who packed up the grand kids and fucked off away from parents they never get shit.

I do actually have friends that I can talk to, they just all live HOURS away from me because we grew up, moved away and live our own lives.

Not sure what to say. I am sorry if I implied you had no friends. I was just responding to your point about being lonely on a warm beach.

I have actually upped sticks and moved half way across the world. I have lots of friends in the UK but it was hard without a support network where I moved to, time differences and all that also made it harder to chat. Despite having a DP there. I had a great time in the end and managed to make friends but it was not easy and I came back after 3 years.

My mother also lives in a different country from where she was born and she found it hard also when she moved with her DP into what used to be their holiday cottage. It was totally different to being there on holiday.

I'm not trying to pick fights with you. I am trying to help the OP. I agree with the OP that moving abroad, no matter how lovely the destination, is hard. But her mother can't be told this by the OP, she'll probably need to find out the hard way.

thing47 · 11/12/2023 13:29

It's an aside, admittedly, but the 'Caribbean' isn't really an amorphous whole when you're talking about living there rather than visiting on holiday. The islands are different sizes and face different issues, whether that's political, import/export or violence and drugs problems. It would help to know where your DM's partner is planning to live @Ticklemeharder

Spottywombat · 11/12/2023 13:28

^A large proportion of current landlords who are abreast of the proposed changes are selling up.

Taxation is on turnover, not profit so it's possible to pay taxes on loss making rentals.

Plus you clear her stuff to where?

Clearing a house can take a long time. Not a job yiu want if you have little dc, they are enough work on their own. .

This really has a whiff of a Walter Mitty scenario. I would be stalking the shit out of his previous life (es).

BarmyFotheringay · 11/12/2023 13:26

Rental and dog aside I would be very concerned about this man. You say "He is British and high up in a regulated career. He is currently dealing with a dispute which means he is unable to work in his current field until it’s resolved (if ever) and his savings have all been used up in the court case."

Could he possibly be facing a criminal conviction? He can work in another field. Why would the dispute may not ever be resolved? Do you only have his word for it that the savings have all been used up? Why the Caribbean and not nearer i.e. Europe? No disrespect to your mum but why would somebody in a 'high up' job want to marry a woman who is unable to work and has a 'modest' house.

You may not be interested in any inheritance and just want your mum to enjoy herself but you may feel differently if she is fleeced, 'modest' house and all, by this man.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 11/12/2023 13:23

Iwasafool · 11/12/2023 10:03

I never did any of that, paid an agent and it was all done for me.

I agree a good agent can take most of burden from you. Expect to pay 12% for a very good one

dont go with a cheap agent: caught out by that when exh decid3d to save money. Agents took no responsibility to deal with difficult and problematic renters who, steered in right direction, could have been ok. As it was agents did not intervene with mass condensation issues form drying washing inside over radiators and we were left with enormous bill to completely treat and redecorate the house.

even with agents, it is still not “no work”, there’s stuff to do annually, your mum will need to do her tax returns etc. if you have great tenants tab at stay for a few years it can be easy. Poor tenants can make your life hell, stressful in same way as poor landlords can make tenants lives hell

also mum needs to know laws are changing rapidly, if she needs to come home in a hurry she won’t just be able to turf tenant out, it could be months to regain her property. In Scotland it’s even more difficult now.

personally it’s a mugs game I’d certainly not take on for anyone else. Wouldn’t want responsisiblty if stuff goes wrong. Homes are emotional

PlanningTowns · 11/12/2023 13:22

Ticklemeharder · 11/12/2023 11:46

I can’t really divulge much about the DP’s work situation but he is British and high up in a regulated career. He is currently dealing with a dispute which means he is unable to work in his current field until it’s resolved (if ever) and his savings have all been used up in the court case.

Aside from everything else this is a huge red flag. Hopefully you know more about this situation and are confident what you have said here is accurate. Is he running away from something???

you can’t stop your mum, but the hiding of a wedding from you as her child when you otherwise have a good relationship and she expects you to tidy up after her is just not right. I would raise it with her.

i think you need to be braver and kick back about helping with sorting the rentals.

also has she ever been to the Caribbean? Like most tourist places the living there is very different to visiting. Has she checked health care provision is she has medical conditions?

realistically she is an adult and can well adult, but you don’t need to facilitate it all because they can’t be arsed.

housethatbuiltme · 11/12/2023 13:20

Keepinmovin · 11/12/2023 12:19

OK sure but not sure that's the case with OP Mother who has a DP and grandkids and seems to gave friends as she's spoken to them about the move.
So I'm trying to respond to the OP situation

She is moving WITH her partner though.

She doesn't have to give up her life forever to be near her grand kids... I know plenty of kids who packed up the grand kids and fucked off away from parents they never get shit.

I do actually have friends that I can talk to, they just all live HOURS away from me because we grew up, moved away and live our own lives.

ruby1957 · 11/12/2023 13:18

Her partner has had some issues with work in the UK but used to work in the Caribbean and has applied for a number of jobs there which he feels confident securing.

This would ring alarm bells for me - it is all happening within the next month. They should see how things go re visas etc before involving all the rest of the family. He should sort everything since he knows the country. Hope it is all on the level and your Mum gets to enjoy the sunshine and white beaches for a while if that is what she wants.