Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed at my mum’s expectations when moving to the Caribbean

262 replies

Ticklemeharder · 11/12/2023 09:46

My mum currently lives about 10 minutes away from me and my two DC’s (age 1 & 3). She’s recently moved in with her partner of 18 months and is very happy and in love. Her partner has had some issues with work in the UK but used to work in the Caribbean and has applied for a number of jobs there which he feels confident securing. They have told us all this in the last week and are planning to relocate in January.

My mum is currently in a huff with me when I expressed concerns over the speed of the move and questioned whether they had thought everything through etc. When asked how long they were planning on living out there I was given a very vague answer of “oh maybe a few years but who knows!”

She just keeps on going on about the white sandy beaches and glorious sunshine and won’t it be a fabulous adventure. Reassuring me that she will still have a relationship with the grandkids due to the invention of FaceTime and we can come out to visit once they are settled over there.

There is also an expectation that I will deal with renting out of both her and her partners properties as they won’t have time before they go. Not to mention my mum’s 8 year old dog who my mum seems to think a family member will just take her because “no-one will see her in a shelter”.

All of this just seems completely out the blue and I’m struggling to be supportive. It’s almost like she’s so focussed on the fantasy that the reality has not even slightly entered in her mind. I’m not sure what to do.

OP posts:
PremiumRaa · 11/12/2023 10:30

It's a bit rich to tell you that you need to manage her rental! That's ridiculous and rude. She sounds as if she acting in a rash way, does she really care about this dog if she's just assuming someone will take it on and she hasn't made proper enquiries? She's saying no one will see it in a shelter - sounds as if from her behaviour she likely would.

Grandparents aren't obliged to be in their grandkids lives but I would be hurt by her actions. It's her life but let her deal with all the logistics.

Paddleboarder · 11/12/2023 10:29

I wouldn't stand in her way of living wherever she wants. However, I would not take on the task of renting out the property - lots of regulations that I wouldn't want to have to worry about. An agency needs to be doing that. As for the dog - I might eventually take it in as I'd feel sorry for it having to go to a shelter, but it's such a responsibility that I certainly wouldn't make it easy for her.

Dery · 11/12/2023 10:27

I don’t think 18 mths is too soon in a relationship to do this - particularly between older people who have accumulated decades of life experience - given she is keeping her home and will have it to return to. I think it’s an exciting adventure.

But it isn’t right to leave dealing with the dog and the rental properties to other family members so she needs a reality check on those issues and needs to make proper arrangements for them. And I agree that it shows a rather uncaring attitude to her dog and makes me wonder if she’s not a particularly good dog-owner.

Ohtobetwentytwo · 11/12/2023 10:25

I would have one very serious conversation and if she doesnt listen say I'll support her fully. Then id make vaguely agreeable noises about how lovely the beaches will be when she mentions it and be very very very clear that I cannot deal with the fall out like sorting the do it the rentals when she mentions those.

Sera1989 · 11/12/2023 10:24

Don't take on being landlord to two properties! Don't really understand why they have to move away so quickly but your DM is right, that is definitely not enough time to get things sorted and make sure the property is legally safe. It's a headache and even with a lettings agent you will still have to sort things out, make decisions, sometimes find tradesmen as the agent will try to overcharge you etc. etc.

The bit that got me is that she doesn't seem to care about the dog. It sounds like she's not bothered about taking him back when she returns if she's thought about giving him to a shelter. If she isn't really sad about having to give the dog away then I find that pretty strange as most people wouldn't just dump their dog forever to chase a dream

ChannelyourinnerElsa · 11/12/2023 10:23

I’d be pleased for her but I wouldn’t sort her properties.

I don’t know why it’s a problem that she doesn’t know how long she is going for? Nor why you are sure the reality won’t be white sandy beaches? Have you moved out there and lived there yourself?

tachycardigan · 11/12/2023 10:22

emsyj37 · 11/12/2023 10:21

I don't think @Circularargument is projecting at all, there are multiple comments in the replies that suggest OP's mother is a bad grandparent. I interpreted the comments in the same way!

Not one person has suggested OP’s DM is a bad grandparent. You are seeing things that aren’t there.

GreatGateauxsby · 11/12/2023 10:21

Lemonyyy · 11/12/2023 10:11

I wouldn’t be that vague. If you say something like “I wouldn’t know where to start” then that’s a problem she can offer a solution to. The issue is “I don’t want to” which is perfectly valid and needs to be listened to!

😅😅😅😅
That's fair.
I rescind my advice and update it to @Lemonyyys

emsyj37 · 11/12/2023 10:21

I don't think @Circularargument is projecting at all, there are multiple comments in the replies that suggest OP's mother is a bad grandparent. I interpreted the comments in the same way!

tachycardigan · 11/12/2023 10:19

Circularargument · 11/12/2023 10:13

No, they are saying moving abroad makes her a bad grandmother. As if having raised her children, she is now only conditionally allowed a life, because she had to be on hand for theirs. But if they wanted to move, sure as eggs are eggs there'd be sod all sympathy for her and a gang of cheerleaders saying to "help her get over herself"

You are massively projecting Circular. No one has said moving abroad makes her a bad grandmother. It’s the dumping of her pet and home rental responsibilities that people are objecting to.

And then OP is being expected to sort her mum’s boyfriend’s rental property too, OP likely doesn’t even know him well!

BrimfulOfMash · 11/12/2023 10:17

I would breathe a sigh of relief that she isn’t selling her house here and marrying him…

Be excited and supportive for her adventure. But maybe say that organising rental has important legal and financial responsibilities and you think it would be better / safer if an agency did it.

Re dog “oooh, who is going to foster darling Rover? Obviously we can’t take him but we’ll visit him if he goes nearby”

MitchellMummy · 11/12/2023 10:17

Big red flags here ... agree with other posters about letting agents. Being a landlord is a big pain so let a company deal with that. As for the dog - if it's a breed/cross breed then breed rescue could hopefully help (google, e.g. springer spaniel rescue). Maybe start on that so your Mum sees the reality of it (whereas if you have the dog then she'll feel that she can come home to see it at any time). Living in a lovely hot country is a lot different to a two week holiday ... could the partner not move out there first, renting out his house, and she goes for an initial holiday? Has she been to that island before?

Circularargument · 11/12/2023 10:13

ShippingNews · 11/12/2023 10:08

I'd be disappointed in my kids if they felt being a good grandma meant I couldn't go and have some fun .

Iwasafool nobody said OP's mother can't go and have some fun. They are just suggesting that her mother should organise her own home rental and dog situations instead of dumping them on her daughter.

No, they are saying moving abroad makes her a bad grandmother. As if having raised her children, she is now only conditionally allowed a life, because she had to be on hand for theirs. But if they wanted to move, sure as eggs are eggs there'd be sod all sympathy for her and a gang of cheerleaders saying to "help her get over herself"

Lemonyyy · 11/12/2023 10:11

GreatGateauxsby · 11/12/2023 10:10

There is also an expectation that I will deal with renting out of both her and her partners properties as they won’t have time before they go. Not to mention my mum’s 8 year old dog who my mum seems to think a family member will just take her because “no-one will see her in a shelter”.

Its bound to go sideways some point down the line.
just stay at arm's length and let her crack on.

Make it clear you will NOT be taking the dog.

Anything around the rental use the same stock lines.
"Oh gosh..I don't know where to start with that..."
"Ohhhh I'm not really sure how it works"
"I don't think im the right person to help. I wouldn't want to get it wrong."
"What if something happens? I would feel awful if I picked bad tenants that didn't pay rent for 6m and then trashed the place"

Edited

I wouldn’t be that vague. If you say something like “I wouldn’t know where to start” then that’s a problem she can offer a solution to. The issue is “I don’t want to” which is perfectly valid and needs to be listened to!

Tempnamechng · 11/12/2023 10:11

I don't think 18 months is too short a time to be moving overseas with someone. She isn't making it a permanent move as she is keeping her home here. I think good for her to be going on an adventure for a few years, and she is allowed to put herself first now you are grown. The only unreasonable bit is not taking her dog with her. Tell her to use an all inclusive letting agent.

Headband · 11/12/2023 10:11

You can't take on the renting of their properties, they're not yours for a start. Tell them to engage an agent.

Lemonyyy · 11/12/2023 10:10

Your mum will have to move later once the houses are sorted. That’s not your problem or your job.

the dog is harder, I really wouldn’t see a family member’s dog in a shelter personally, but if you don’t want or need a dog in your life then absolutely don’t take him. Is he slowing down or still quite agile? Big dog or small? Loud? These will all make a difference to how easy he is to rehome.

GreatGateauxsby · 11/12/2023 10:10

There is also an expectation that I will deal with renting out of both her and her partners properties as they won’t have time before they go. Not to mention my mum’s 8 year old dog who my mum seems to think a family member will just take her because “no-one will see her in a shelter”.

Its bound to go sideways some point down the line.
just stay at arm's length and let her crack on.

Make it clear you will NOT be taking the dog.

Anything around the rental use the same stock lines.
"Oh gosh..I don't know where to start with that..."
"Ohhhh I'm not really sure how it works"
"I don't think im the right person to help. I wouldn't want to get it wrong."
"What if something happens? I would feel awful if I picked bad tenants that didn't pay rent for 6m and then trashed the place"

ShippingNews · 11/12/2023 10:08

I'd be disappointed in my kids if they felt being a good grandma meant I couldn't go and have some fun .

Iwasafool nobody said OP's mother can't go and have some fun. They are just suggesting that her mother should organise her own home rental and dog situations instead of dumping them on her daughter.

Circularargument · 11/12/2023 10:07

YouveGotAFastCar · 11/12/2023 09:58

Having lived in the Caribbean for a while; she's not that wrong. Lots of people, especially older people, do just move out there for a while.

I'd be supportive of, and excited about, her move if that's what she wants to do - but I wouldn't be taking on renting out her properties, that's a pain in the arse with everything you need to sort, and two properties is basically a job. There's a reason agents charge decent commission for that.

I also wouldn't necessarily be taking her dog, unless I wanted it.

It's a shame about her grandchildren but she has considered that aspect, she just doesn't deem it a priority vs going to live out in the Caribbean, so that says a lot. You can't force good grandparents.

But of course my friend whose grandkids are being moved to Western Australia not just for a few years but forever, a year after she was widowed early just has to suck it up.
She's old (well, 66) and doesnt matter. No-one is allowed to criticise anyone under 50 apparently.

tachycardigan · 11/12/2023 10:06

Iwasafool · 11/12/2023 10:05

Give her a break, I always said when I retired I was having my gap year as they didn't happen when I was young. Didn't happen as I'm DHs carer but I'd be disappointed in my kids if they felt being a good grandma meant I couldn't go and have some fun.

Have fun but don’t leave your responsibilities with your kids to pick up, that’s selfish.

tachycardigan · 11/12/2023 10:05

BarbaraofSeville · 11/12/2023 10:02

Refuse to do anything except make sure the dog isn't neglected. If they want their houses rented out and don't have time to deal with the admin, that's what letting agents are for.

Not sure OP can do that, short of taking the dog in herself.

Iwasafool · 11/12/2023 10:05

YireosDodeAver · 11/12/2023 10:01

You can't make her be a good grandma.

You can certainly decline to adopt a dog you don't want, and so can all other family members.

You can certainly decline an unpaid job as property manager, or charge a reasonable fee for the service

Give her a break, I always said when I retired I was having my gap year as they didn't happen when I was young. Didn't happen as I'm DHs carer but I'd be disappointed in my kids if they felt being a good grandma meant I couldn't go and have some fun.

PickledPurplePickle · 11/12/2023 10:04

You won't change her mind, but you can put your foot down about what you will and won't do

So, tell them now that you won't be dealing with their properties and they will need to get an agent to deal with this

And if you don't want the dog, tell her now, so that she can make other arrangements

tachycardigan · 11/12/2023 10:04

YANBU. Tell her they will both need to see an agency about the tenancies because you won’t be able to help.

And don’t take the dog.

Swipe left for the next trending thread