Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree with Nigel Farage?

284 replies

nds241 · 11/12/2023 09:12

I expect to be completely flamed here!

But I find myself agreeing with him. I've been watching TV this morning and have seen him do a couple of interviews following his exit from the jungle.

I voted Remain back in 2016 and have always voted Labour. So in the past I've obviously had very different political views from him m, but everything he said this morning about a population crisis, there being no real leader of the opposition and the Conservative Party being in a complete shambles made sense. I think he does speak a lot of what maybe others would be afraid to say. I honestly feel confused as to why I find myself agreeing with him.

Tell me I'm being unreasonable!

OP posts:
StoodySmithereens · 11/12/2023 12:04

I heard him in the jungle saying that we can’t get a Dr appointment because of immigrants. He did it to hit a nerve with the people. But I must admit that I’ve thought that for a long time now.

leilani83 · 11/12/2023 12:03

NoCloudsAllowed · 11/12/2023 10:53

He's very good at politics. The things you mentioned have objective truth at the heart (ageing population and falling birthrate, tories are a mess, starmer isn't exactly firing up the nation)

However he then discreetly leads people to a cause of the problem and a solution that don't make sense.

Eg immigration. Maybe it's been too high, that was a calculated decision by politicians who could have restricted it under eu rules. Farage heaped up everything on immigration and blamed it for housing crisis, difficulty seeing a gp etc. Proposed brexit as a solution. Brexit means France now under no obligation to stop refugees heading to UK so volume of refugees arriving goes up. Need a new foreign bogeyman so they pick on echr. Really we just need sensible rules, competent government and international collaboration.

They're all about getting people riled up with a sense of being hard done by but they never have positive solutions. It's all about getting rid of regulations and authorities to let corporations do whatever they want. They make it sound like it's about individual freedom but before you know it, you're on a zero hours minimum wage contract, the waterways are full of shit and etc. They don't believe in civil society.

Farage was in the national front and flirted with nazi stuff at school - he's the same person, he's just found a respectable mask to wear.

This.

Southpoint · 11/12/2023 11:59

I am glad to hear people are opening to sensible discussions. Facts are facts and overwhelming immigration is not good for the country. It brings poverty if it is mainly low skilled people is much worse. Farage was always right on immigration issues. I never dislike him or dismiss his concerns. Now may be too late. The government lets be honest has walkedon egg shells as the people just shout racist when this is discussed. You want the benefits of a first world country. You need to control who comes here.

TheThingIsYeah · 11/12/2023 11:56

I love the "what population crisis?" replies on here. Are people really that naive? Sure, if you are the average MNetter (£200k salary, house in a naice area) it might not affect you....yet. But it will, and when the penny drops that migration levels of 700,000+ pa are unsustainable, I'm afraid it's all going to be too late. Nigel did warn you.

LongDarkTeatime · 11/12/2023 11:51

Out of interest, when people speak about feeling there are problems with migration, which type of migration are they speaking about?

  • Is it the majority which is rest-of-the-world migration which is now increased and written into trade agreements (to plug massively reduced trading with EU)?
  • Is it the proportionally very small number of people who arrive on boats (but is disproportionately focused on by this Gov)?
  • Or is it the thousands of asylum seekers waiting disproportionate lengths of time to have their requests reviewed? Remember the queue is only so long as civil servants who addressed this were moved to deal with Brexit. Plus they aren’t allowed to support themselves by working.
Comedycook · 11/12/2023 11:49

NoCloudsAllowed · 11/12/2023 11:45

My sister is a teacher. She says having Eastern European kids in class actually usually improves results because their parents have a much more no-nonsense approach to discipline and homework. Less of the 'how dare you tell off my little angel' mentality. More of a sense of wanting to make the very most of the opportunity to learn and build a life here.

You know very well that not many British people emigrate to Poland, Latvia or Lithuania. Part of the reason is that we left them to Stalin after WWII in a pact that the people of those countries had no real say about. Lots of Poles fought within the British army in WWII then had their country handed over to a Communist dictatorship for their troubles.

Quite a lot of people from former USSR and Soviet bloc countries might have an interesting perpective for you.

My grandfather was polish actually and my grandmother from the former Soviet union.

I have nothing against people from EE. And like British kids, some are well behaved and some are badly behaved. That's irrelevant.

My point was that freedom of movement is only a good idea if the countries are economically comparable...f.o.m between the UK and Germany or France is much of a muchness. Between The UK and EE, it was very much one way.

Dadstheworld · 11/12/2023 11:49

Farage is great at sounding pretty sensible to the man on the street, much of what he states is fairly sane, however I've never heard come up with any practical solutions.

Peablockfeathers · 11/12/2023 11:47

alkinetyh · 11/12/2023 11:37

I think you know full well that is not what @BIossomtoes was suggesting. The point that we have massive gaps in our workforce and big groups of people queuing up wanting to work legally is a pretty simple one to understand.

Social care of course isn’t the only gap which is causing huge issues in our economy. We’re lacking many many skills, and have an ageing population to support from a tax perspective which our current birthrate from british nationals cannot sustain.

Are there many people queuing up though? Lots of (wonderful) nurses that come to work for the NHS from abroad now use it as a springboard to other better paid countries with better working conditions- Australia, Canada etc. Can't blame them! We are a low wage economy now with crumbling public services and social care sector; hardly aspirational for many when there are global shortages of many of these occupations.

Nelliemellie · 11/12/2023 11:47

He was campaigning for Brexit, which has made immigration worse. The Europeans were virtually kicked out.

NoCloudsAllowed · 11/12/2023 11:45

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 11:33

30/31...why even have a limit hey?

During the 2000s, the number of immigrants from EE was incredibly high. My dcs class was 15% children from EE. That is not insignificant. Were there any schools in Latvia/Lithuania/Poland etc which had such a high percentage of British kids in them?

My sister is a teacher. She says having Eastern European kids in class actually usually improves results because their parents have a much more no-nonsense approach to discipline and homework. Less of the 'how dare you tell off my little angel' mentality. More of a sense of wanting to make the very most of the opportunity to learn and build a life here.

You know very well that not many British people emigrate to Poland, Latvia or Lithuania. Part of the reason is that we left them to Stalin after WWII in a pact that the people of those countries had no real say about. Lots of Poles fought within the British army in WWII then had their country handed over to a Communist dictatorship for their troubles.

Quite a lot of people from former USSR and Soviet bloc countries might have an interesting perpective for you.

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 11:45

LongDarkTeatime · 11/12/2023 11:41

A vicar moved to our Church and his kids joined the Church school pushing multiple class numbers above 30. Does that mean we should stop movement of clerics too?

Edited

Ridiculous comparison. Are you proposing freedom of movement between the UK and the entire world or do you think immigration needs some form of control?

okthenwhat · 11/12/2023 11:43

I don't think he's right and saying what people are "afraid to say".

It's a mix of the bloody obvious (Tory party are a shambles), outright lie (there's no real leader of the opposition - disagree strongly, Corbyn and Starmer and ANY leader of the opposition have to fight an uphill battle against the right-wing leaning media), and deliberately unsubtle takes on rather more nuanced issues (immigration).

I refuse it to frame it as I agree with what he has to say. He, on some obvious issues, come to the same conclusion as anyone with an ounce of common sense.

He's wrong as fuck on everything else mind.

Asiatoyork · 11/12/2023 11:43

But that's not what happened - about 6 million people who came here via free movement have applied for and been granted leave to remain.
Whatever your views on the rights and wrongs of that (and Brexit) it does seem that a significant number of EU migrants were staying

Yes, lots have (although I don’t think 6million applications means that many individuals weirdly according to an article I just read).

I think we would not have known exact numbers before using freedom of movement, so maybe it’s about the same number but just it’s now showing in the stats. and from different countries. Not sure how many outflows to Europe there were in the time free movement was operating however, and the recent immigration numbers are net so it’s not comparing apples with apples.

Porridgeislife · 11/12/2023 11:43

alkinetyh · 11/12/2023 11:37

I think you know full well that is not what @BIossomtoes was suggesting. The point that we have massive gaps in our workforce and big groups of people queuing up wanting to work legally is a pretty simple one to understand.

Social care of course isn’t the only gap which is causing huge issues in our economy. We’re lacking many many skills, and have an ageing population to support from a tax perspective which our current birthrate from british nationals cannot sustain.

The key word is skilled workers. And in the case of social care workers (and many other sectors), a background that can be verified.

Undocumented young men with few language or work skills won’t solve the workforce gap. You also may as well ditch border force if an unresolved asylum claim is the threshold for legal work.

BIossomtoes · 11/12/2023 11:42

Thanks @alkinetyh. You made my point much more clearly.

LongDarkTeatime · 11/12/2023 11:41

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 11:18

Can you describe an example of how migration has negatively effected you?

Yes. My dcs reception class ten years ago...at capacity of 30. Halfway through the term goes up to 31 because a child has arrived from Easter Europe and there's no space in primary schools in area. An extra child in a class at capacity isn't enhancing my dcs education. At secondary school age, we didn't get into our nearest school..less than a mile away

A vicar moved to our Church and his kids joined the Church school pushing multiple class numbers above 30. Does that mean we should stop movement of clerics too?

alkinetyh · 11/12/2023 11:37

Porridgeislife · 11/12/2023 09:54

Brilliant idea. Undocumented migrants will almost certainly pass enhanced DBS checks essential for working with vulnerable adults 👍

I think you know full well that is not what @BIossomtoes was suggesting. The point that we have massive gaps in our workforce and big groups of people queuing up wanting to work legally is a pretty simple one to understand.

Social care of course isn’t the only gap which is causing huge issues in our economy. We’re lacking many many skills, and have an ageing population to support from a tax perspective which our current birthrate from british nationals cannot sustain.

SerendipityJane · 11/12/2023 11:36

Hitler said some sensible things. As did Stalin. And Henry VIII

Not quite sure what the point here is ?

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 11:33

RafaistheKingofClay · 11/12/2023 11:29

The difference between 30 and 31 is negligible. And part of the reason schools became hugely oversubscribed was because when the birth rate was falling in the 90s they reduced the number of school places and were very slow to or didn’t bother to increase places back up to where they were.

Like many things, the problem wasn’t the immigration which we needed but lack of government planning for it.

30/31...why even have a limit hey?

During the 2000s, the number of immigrants from EE was incredibly high. My dcs class was 15% children from EE. That is not insignificant. Were there any schools in Latvia/Lithuania/Poland etc which had such a high percentage of British kids in them?

NoCloudsAllowed · 11/12/2023 11:31

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 11:18

Can you describe an example of how migration has negatively effected you?

Yes. My dcs reception class ten years ago...at capacity of 30. Halfway through the term goes up to 31 because a child has arrived from Easter Europe and there's no space in primary schools in area. An extra child in a class at capacity isn't enhancing my dcs education. At secondary school age, we didn't get into our nearest school..less than a mile away

There's pressure on schools in my city and my particular area. It's due to Londoners moving out, gentrification and general population shift. I don't think you can blame immigrants.

NoCloudsAllowed · 11/12/2023 11:29

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 11:09

Brexit means France now under no obligation to stop refugees heading to UK so volume of refugees arriving goes up

The people coming over in boats are virtually irrelevant in the immigration debate despite what we're led to believe. Legal net migration is 3/4 million a year currently. The small number of people coming over in boats is nothing compared to the huge levels of migration the government is in charge of.

Well, yes but they're what gets press coverage.

Less publicity for non-EU nationals coming over because every country we've done these much-vaunted post-Brexit deals that deliver about as much GDP as a jumble sale have clauses requiring x number of worker visas per year. I don't think many Brexit voters wanted to replace French and Polish workers with Indian or Brazilian ones.

RafaistheKingofClay · 11/12/2023 11:29

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 11:18

Can you describe an example of how migration has negatively effected you?

Yes. My dcs reception class ten years ago...at capacity of 30. Halfway through the term goes up to 31 because a child has arrived from Easter Europe and there's no space in primary schools in area. An extra child in a class at capacity isn't enhancing my dcs education. At secondary school age, we didn't get into our nearest school..less than a mile away

The difference between 30 and 31 is negligible. And part of the reason schools became hugely oversubscribed was because when the birth rate was falling in the 90s they reduced the number of school places and were very slow to or didn’t bother to increase places back up to where they were.

Like many things, the problem wasn’t the immigration which we needed but lack of government planning for it.

NoCloudsAllowed · 11/12/2023 11:26

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 11/12/2023 11:20

But that's not what happened - about 6 million people who came here via free movement have applied for and been granted leave to remain.
Whatever your views on the rights and wrongs of that (and Brexit) it does seem that a significant number of EU migrants were staying.

Under EU rules we could have required people to return if they weren't earning a living. It was free movement of WORKERS not people. If you didn't get work within three months or something, the state was not required to support you or pay benefits.

We couldn't be arsed with reforming our benefits system or all the admin involved so we just let people come and claim benefits on the same level as citizens. This attracted more migrants from the poorer EU countries (because why wouldn't you?)

Skilled migrants tend to come and then head back home when it comes to having a family or you just miss home. Because why wouldn't you?

And the flow went the other way too. Many UK citizens took up residence in EU countries.

LongDarkTeatime · 11/12/2023 11:23

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 11/12/2023 11:20

But that's not what happened - about 6 million people who came here via free movement have applied for and been granted leave to remain.
Whatever your views on the rights and wrongs of that (and Brexit) it does seem that a significant number of EU migrants were staying.

Where does the figure of 6 million come from?
How does this compare to the pre-Brexit outward FoM migration from UK to EU?(which has now been stopped)

Echobelly · 11/12/2023 11:22

Low birth rate is a problem, but none of the people talking about it ever seem to propose what is needed to address it - namely making daily life cheaper, affordable childcare, better financial and social support for working and stay at home parents and so on.

They suggest stupid bullshit like giving people a piffling sum of money or a telegram from the King for having a 3rd child!

Swipe left for the next trending thread