Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree with Nigel Farage?

284 replies

nds241 · 11/12/2023 09:12

I expect to be completely flamed here!

But I find myself agreeing with him. I've been watching TV this morning and have seen him do a couple of interviews following his exit from the jungle.

I voted Remain back in 2016 and have always voted Labour. So in the past I've obviously had very different political views from him m, but everything he said this morning about a population crisis, there being no real leader of the opposition and the Conservative Party being in a complete shambles made sense. I think he does speak a lot of what maybe others would be afraid to say. I honestly feel confused as to why I find myself agreeing with him.

Tell me I'm being unreasonable!

OP posts:
LongDarkTeatime · 11/12/2023 13:00

@TodayInahurry you don’t speak for those outside London.
Me, my family and friends, ‘up North’ know the benefits of immigration. We also recognise the dangers of popularism and right-wing rhetoric (long family history of family fighting for this country against fascism).
Please don’t insult us by grouping us into your worries.

Wolvesart · 11/12/2023 13:00

He has charisma which makes his views seem more acceptable than they are. If Labour want to be effective they need a better leader as it’s unbelievable that people aren’t flocking to them given the state of the Tories

Whataretheodds · 11/12/2023 12:57

Megifer · 11/12/2023 09:22

I agree with him in that there is absolutely a population crisis and, as eye rolly as it sounds, I am 100% certain the reason my gp in particular is struggling is the increase in immigration - only have to spend 10 minutes in there to see that tbh, if you manage to get in that is.

BUT I blame the government for not having the infrastructure in place to deal with it, especially as the population was increasing anyway and people are living longer etc. I have no ill feeling whatsoever towards immigrants, I have no doubt I'd do the same for my family if I had to. I'm lucky I don't.

Really, @Megifer ?

The one reason is immigration? Not the massive loss of skilled human resource from the NHS (partly because of the hostile environment), a decade of system underfunding, a widening gap between rich and poor, an ageing population with inadequate social care for many of the reasons above?

LongDarkTeatime · 11/12/2023 12:56

Tracker1234 · 11/12/2023 10:26

So the car washes working for cash, the often Vientnamese people working in nail bars which are often rammed. I have alwyas wondered why they arent raided every day. The one near me only takes cash... they are not contributing towards the economy. They are sending money back home but in the meantime where are they living what health service are they using (that they havent contributed to)?

Farage is a distruptor. Watch him in the next few months. With the Tories making error after error Labour almost need to do nothing (Starmer sitting on the fence time and time again). Put Farage back in and see what happens!

He is speaking to the Red Wall, man/women in the street. Imagine living where your local authoirty has no money to improve your area. They are almost bankrupt.

Yes, I do agree adult social care is a mess. We are living so much longer and not necessarily in a good way. My parents have had to pay £££ to live in care homes. Luckily they had houses with equity in them but who is paying the £1200 PER WEEK to look after the elderly who for one reason or another dont have savings? I support some sort of tax that we pay for individually to support us in old age. Compulsory for all. Yes, you might not need care but its to support the wider population. Yes, even the self employed need to pay.

Wouldn’t it be more sensible if, like other countries, we let asylum seekers work legally while waiting in out hugely backlogged system. If I was in their shoes I’d be trying to earn to pay for myself too. We don’t need to ask already over-stretch police to intervene, just some common sense from Government would do(rather than rabble rousing and scaremongering as usual).

AnnieKayTee · 11/12/2023 12:53

Just to add my tuppence worth. My husband works in construction. There's many workers from countries in Eastern Europe who yes, come here to work. They all live together, sometimes 10 to a house, sending all of their money home. Where they are building their own homes so they can leave. They aren't adding anything to the economy here other than working for lower rates then what is affordable for us to live on.

Also, on the social care side. I've applied for numerous jobs in adult social care, all sorts of hours, nights, bank staff, laundry roles. Have not even had a reply from any of them.

oldwhyno · 11/12/2023 12:52

"population crisis" is a really unhelpful term, and people need to stop using it.

What we are experiencing are the many challenges of demographic change.

Some of that demographic change is slow and predictable (the aging population), some is fast and appears to many to be out of control (net migration).

To a significant extent, high net migration is a defense against an aging population. But it doesn't come without challenges. The 1m+ incoming migrants are largely far less well off economically than those emigrating out of the UK. So there's a significant socioeconomic shift. There's also a racial, ethnic and religious shift, and an imbalance in where in the country these new arrivals are trying to create their new lives, compared to where people emigrate from.

BIossomtoes · 11/12/2023 12:46

TodayInahurry · 11/12/2023 12:36

He tells the truth. Outside of London people with their luxury beliefs, people are absolutely furious about immigration at 745,000 let alone the dinghy invaders. They are also beyond furious about the intimidation marches in London and other cities. I believe in France they use water cannons on them

Nobody’s furious here and it’s not London.

Crikeyalmighty · 11/12/2023 12:43

@TodayInahurry that's incredibly simplistic- plenty of places all over the UK be it south west, midlands, up north are doing perfectly ok and have 'luxury beliefs' (what are these by the way- anyone who doesn't have to shop at Aldi or chooses not to?? I've got several friends in midlands who retired at 55 , pensions kicked in, fully paid up house, seem to go on about 8 holidays abroad a year , and yet literally no one I know in either London or south west is in that position- they might have a fair few holidays but all still have mortgages and are working full time mid 50s.

anotherside · 11/12/2023 12:40

@Comedycook

Net migration was 3/4 million last year...and yet all our problems with social care and filling vacancies etc are still with us. How many more people do we need?

But you posed a fairly pointless rhetorical question at the end of it. Obviously right now we still need a high number - circa the half million mark (which includes a a significant number of overseas students). The fact that you have high profile Tory MPs saying “enough is enough” when they’ve been the ones in government for 14 years ought to alert people to the fact that its a charade. They want to give the impression of being “tough” on would be immigrants while simultaneously relying on this same group to maintain a (barely) functioning society.

Clavinova · 11/12/2023 12:37

NoCloudsAllowed
Brexit means France now under no obligation to stop refugees heading to UK so volume of refugees arriving goes up

Yes they do - we're paying them. We've had separate bilateral agreements and treaties with France for many years;

https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-9681/ 

Why don't Southern and Eastern European countries have an obligation to stop the onward progression of refugees to countries such as Germany and the Netherlands?

TodayInahurry · 11/12/2023 12:36

He tells the truth. Outside of London people with their luxury beliefs, people are absolutely furious about immigration at 745,000 let alone the dinghy invaders. They are also beyond furious about the intimidation marches in London and other cities. I believe in France they use water cannons on them

Flamingbow · 11/12/2023 12:35

I dislike NF and disagree with a lot of what he says, but he hasn't ever said we shouldn't have any immigration. Lots going about health workers etc are purposefully misconstuing that.

TheThingIsYeah · 11/12/2023 12:32

@Southpoint you'll need more and more since the country is run as a giant Ponzi scheme. But no worries, we're told everyone is a net contributor to HM Treasury's coffers so nothing to see here.

Lampzade · 11/12/2023 12:30

anotherside · 11/12/2023 12:21

Immigration is too high when measured against public services ability to cope and house availability BUT we need immigration to be high because immigrants are now filling (or partly filling) massive shortages in mainly public sector professions - healthcare, doctors/nurses, teaching, care work…

The public can’t or won’t do these jobs as the Tories have been complicit in creating a cost of living crisis AND in making public sector jobs badly paid and a toxic/overbearing environment.

Immigration isn’t still high for jokes - it’s because the country will collapse without it. So with their current rhetoric the Tories are having their cake and eating it all the while taking the public for mugs. Which, to be fair, many of them are.

Absolutely this

Crikeyalmighty · 11/12/2023 12:29

@NoCloudsAllowed and it's a big difference- in recent years pre withdrawal agreement it was mainly younger single people, not whole large families who will undoubtedly stay put.

When we lived in Denmark the Danish system policed hugely the 'workers' aspect and again no right to benefits - in the UK the gvt simply couldn't be arsed with setting up departments to do this and that's the problem with the UK- it has CBA syndrome - and hence people take advantage of it- it was the same for many years with the NHS too and non EU residents. And as for the non EU migration in Denmark they had whole teams out constantly looking for black market workers . That's why some of the 'non legal' migration try and chance their arm here- we have been much more lax on such things.

Southpoint · 11/12/2023 12:25

Exactly we have masses numbers in the last two years and still people are calling for more. When will it stop. How many do we need?

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 12:24

anotherside · 11/12/2023 12:23

@Comedycook

Net migration was 3/4 million last year...and yet all our problems with social care and filling vacancies etc are still with us. How many more people do we need?

The whole country is massively reliant on a steady stream of immigrants. You can slowly turn off the tap IF other measures are in place (which until now the Tories have shown no interest in doing). But you can’t just suddenly turn it off.

I didn't say we need to stop all immigration.

And this is the problem...when you express any concern at all, it is assumed you're against all immigration.

This is why we can't have a sensible debate.

It's so tiresome

anotherside · 11/12/2023 12:23

@Comedycook

Net migration was 3/4 million last year...and yet all our problems with social care and filling vacancies etc are still with us. How many more people do we need?

The whole country is massively reliant on a steady stream of immigrants. You can slowly turn off the tap IF other measures are in place (which until now the Tories have shown no interest in doing). But you can’t just suddenly turn it off.

Southpoint · 11/12/2023 12:23

@GrammarTeacher part of the problem is to deny and shut people when trying to debate this.

anotherside · 11/12/2023 12:21

Immigration is too high when measured against public services ability to cope and house availability BUT we need immigration to be high because immigrants are now filling (or partly filling) massive shortages in mainly public sector professions - healthcare, doctors/nurses, teaching, care work…

The public can’t or won’t do these jobs as the Tories have been complicit in creating a cost of living crisis AND in making public sector jobs badly paid and a toxic/overbearing environment.

Immigration isn’t still high for jokes - it’s because the country will collapse without it. So with their current rhetoric the Tories are having their cake and eating it all the while taking the public for mugs. Which, to be fair, many of them are.

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 12:21

Net migration was 3/4 million last year...and yet all our problems with social care and filling vacancies etc are still with us. How many more people do we need?

howrudeforme · 11/12/2023 12:18

Population crisis, well yes in terms of housing and facilities.

but he fails to say we need more migrants here to help buffer an ageing population and our economy is based on many businesses relying on cheap and expendable labour. Additionally we can’t recruit to many roles in health and teaching.

so at face value he’s right and we’d all agree but it’s the lies/xenophobia etc and his complete disinterests in trying to keep the economy afloat that it worrying.

brexit was voted on for feelings rather than facts. That’s what he plays on.

GrammarTeacher · 11/12/2023 12:11

Immigration is not the issue with the lack of GP appointments. It's the lack of GPs. Lots of my students want to be doctors. Few GPs, partly because they've seen the racist abuse many GPs get locally. Nobody should have to put up with that. NF isn't that clever and he certainly isn't a man of the people. He's a nasty, racist hypocrite and the country would be better off if he wasn't platformed so much. Don't forget how often he has failed to be elected to parliament.

Lampzade · 11/12/2023 12:08

NoCloudsAllowed · 11/12/2023 10:53

He's very good at politics. The things you mentioned have objective truth at the heart (ageing population and falling birthrate, tories are a mess, starmer isn't exactly firing up the nation)

However he then discreetly leads people to a cause of the problem and a solution that don't make sense.

Eg immigration. Maybe it's been too high, that was a calculated decision by politicians who could have restricted it under eu rules. Farage heaped up everything on immigration and blamed it for housing crisis, difficulty seeing a gp etc. Proposed brexit as a solution. Brexit means France now under no obligation to stop refugees heading to UK so volume of refugees arriving goes up. Need a new foreign bogeyman so they pick on echr. Really we just need sensible rules, competent government and international collaboration.

They're all about getting people riled up with a sense of being hard done by but they never have positive solutions. It's all about getting rid of regulations and authorities to let corporations do whatever they want. They make it sound like it's about individual freedom but before you know it, you're on a zero hours minimum wage contract, the waterways are full of shit and etc. They don't believe in civil society.

Farage was in the national front and flirted with nazi stuff at school - he's the same person, he's just found a respectable mask to wear.

All of this

BIossomtoes · 11/12/2023 12:08

StoodySmithereens · 11/12/2023 12:04

I heard him in the jungle saying that we can’t get a Dr appointment because of immigrants. He did it to hit a nerve with the people. But I must admit that I’ve thought that for a long time now.

The reason people can’t get a GP appointment is nothing to do with immigration and everything to do with the government fucking up and underfunding the NHS for 13 years.