Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree with Nigel Farage?

284 replies

nds241 · 11/12/2023 09:12

I expect to be completely flamed here!

But I find myself agreeing with him. I've been watching TV this morning and have seen him do a couple of interviews following his exit from the jungle.

I voted Remain back in 2016 and have always voted Labour. So in the past I've obviously had very different political views from him m, but everything he said this morning about a population crisis, there being no real leader of the opposition and the Conservative Party being in a complete shambles made sense. I think he does speak a lot of what maybe others would be afraid to say. I honestly feel confused as to why I find myself agreeing with him.

Tell me I'm being unreasonable!

OP posts:
Whataretheodds · 11/12/2023 15:15

Megifer · 11/12/2023 15:12

"BUT I blame the government for not having the infrastructure in place to deal with it"

Just reposting that bit of my post that answers your question.

That still assumes immigration is the primary problem rather than part of the solution (staffing, tax receipts etc)

ConstantRain · 11/12/2023 15:15

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 14:51

You'd be amazed how many immigrants think there's too much immigration to this country.

It's true that many immigrants think this. It's because they want to quietly get on with their lives then see the racism when immigration becomes more of a problem (it always was a problem probably but they started to feel accepted as they worked and dc made friends at school and so on)

Megifer · 11/12/2023 15:12

Whataretheodds · 11/12/2023 12:57

Really, @Megifer ?

The one reason is immigration? Not the massive loss of skilled human resource from the NHS (partly because of the hostile environment), a decade of system underfunding, a widening gap between rich and poor, an ageing population with inadequate social care for many of the reasons above?

"BUT I blame the government for not having the infrastructure in place to deal with it"

Just reposting that bit of my post that answers your question.

EasternStandard · 11/12/2023 15:06

LakieLady · 11/12/2023 15:04

I read somewhere recently that if the UK birth rate continues on its current trajectory, by the end of the next decade it will be below 1 per woman.

The "replacement rate", ie the birth rate required to keep a population stable, is generally accepted to be 2.1 per woman.

When you factor in increasing life expectancy, that would be an utter disaster.

It could be good on climate issues though and new tech may mitigate

LakieLady · 11/12/2023 15:04

SilentNightDancer · 11/12/2023 09:26

There is a distinction between birth rate and population.

In the UK the birth rate is falling, as fewer babies are being born here, but the overall population is increasing due to immigration.

I read somewhere recently that if the UK birth rate continues on its current trajectory, by the end of the next decade it will be below 1 per woman.

The "replacement rate", ie the birth rate required to keep a population stable, is generally accepted to be 2.1 per woman.

When you factor in increasing life expectancy, that would be an utter disaster.

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 15:04

Anisette · 11/12/2023 14:58

This is just absurd. The infant class size limit of 30 is simply an arbitrary number, there is no way that having just one more child in class tips the quality of education over from good to bad.

People don't get into their nearest schools for plenty of reasons, the most frequent one being that the good schools are heavily in demand and become oversubscribed very quickly. It may be because of immigrants, but it's just as likely to be because Anglo-Saxon natives are savvy at negotiating the admission system and ensure that they buy houses near the popular schools, go to the right churches etc.

If there aren't enough school places, blame a government which has been consistently underfunding education ever since it came into power.

I said 15% of my dcs class was from EE...that is not an insignificant figure. Do you honestly think if schools in EE had a sudden influx of British kids that the people there would be absolutely fine with it?

Anisette · 11/12/2023 15:02

Porridgeislife · 11/12/2023 11:43

The key word is skilled workers. And in the case of social care workers (and many other sectors), a background that can be verified.

Undocumented young men with few language or work skills won’t solve the workforce gap. You also may as well ditch border force if an unresolved asylum claim is the threshold for legal work.

You've fallen for the Mail trope that asylum seekers are only ever undocumented young men. You need to educate yourself on the facts.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 11/12/2023 15:01

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 14:51

You'd be amazed how many immigrants think there's too much immigration to this country.

Indeed. The Polish porter in the Hospital my Mum was in said he was going back to Poland because the area he lived in had been ruined by an influx of Romanians.

Anisette · 11/12/2023 14:58

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 11:18

Can you describe an example of how migration has negatively effected you?

Yes. My dcs reception class ten years ago...at capacity of 30. Halfway through the term goes up to 31 because a child has arrived from Easter Europe and there's no space in primary schools in area. An extra child in a class at capacity isn't enhancing my dcs education. At secondary school age, we didn't get into our nearest school..less than a mile away

This is just absurd. The infant class size limit of 30 is simply an arbitrary number, there is no way that having just one more child in class tips the quality of education over from good to bad.

People don't get into their nearest schools for plenty of reasons, the most frequent one being that the good schools are heavily in demand and become oversubscribed very quickly. It may be because of immigrants, but it's just as likely to be because Anglo-Saxon natives are savvy at negotiating the admission system and ensure that they buy houses near the popular schools, go to the right churches etc.

If there aren't enough school places, blame a government which has been consistently underfunding education ever since it came into power.

leilani83 · 11/12/2023 14:56

NoCloudsAllowed · 11/12/2023 14:54

He'll say whatever he thinks people want to hear to get them to support him.

Then he'll use that support to get publicity, and use that publicity to influence the Tories rightwards.

And he'll do it al because he's representative of some libertarian dickwads who think we should all be scrapping it out in the mud for a few capitalistic crumbs - no mat leave, holiday pay, employment or environmental protections etc. That's the agenda, immigration is neither here nor there. It's a device.

Exactly.

NoCloudsAllowed · 11/12/2023 14:54

nds241 · 11/12/2023 14:47

I don't feel like NF is implying that we should have no migration. But it definitely needs to be controlled as it's unsustainable the way it is now. That, and a mix of the Tories severely underfunding social services for the past 13 years has been disastrous.

He'll say whatever he thinks people want to hear to get them to support him.

Then he'll use that support to get publicity, and use that publicity to influence the Tories rightwards.

And he'll do it al because he's representative of some libertarian dickwads who think we should all be scrapping it out in the mud for a few capitalistic crumbs - no mat leave, holiday pay, employment or environmental protections etc. That's the agenda, immigration is neither here nor there. It's a device.

EasternStandard · 11/12/2023 14:52

Anisette · 11/12/2023 14:38

The "higher birth rate" solution is absurd. People stick to around 2/3 children for lots of reasons that have nothing to do with whether they can afford a larger house, so you would have to change an entire generation's mindset before that had any realistic effect; and you would still have to wait 20 years for the resulting extra children to grow up.

It is of course self-evident that Farage's objections to migration have sod-all to do with any moral objection to skilled people leaving their country of origin. Expelling recent arrivals wouldn't help their countries of origin either, given that there is no way you could force people to return there rather than go to any other country of their choice.

Tbf AI might override the need to lift birth rate or have high net migration anyway

Comedycook · 11/12/2023 14:51

You'd be amazed how many immigrants think there's too much immigration to this country.

user1471447924 · 11/12/2023 14:50

I don’t think your beliefs are what you might like to think they are.

nds241 · 11/12/2023 14:47

I don't feel like NF is implying that we should have no migration. But it definitely needs to be controlled as it's unsustainable the way it is now. That, and a mix of the Tories severely underfunding social services for the past 13 years has been disastrous.

OP posts:
Anisette · 11/12/2023 14:38

Dotjones · 11/12/2023 10:02

Or we could try to resolve the situation by encouraging a higher birth rate. One way to do this would be to stop immigration and reduce pressure on housing so that younger people would be able to afford a bigger home to have a family.

Using immigration as a sticking plaster is a very short-sighted approach. It's a bit like having a really smelly toilet and trying to mask the smell with air fresheners rather than doing the unpleasant thing of giving it a thorough clean. It's dealing with the symptom not the cause.

It's also morally questionable to use immigration in this way. You do realise that for every doctor or carer who comes to the UK, that's one less doctor or carer available in their country of origin? This is the main reason we should end immigration and expel recent (say last 25 years) arrivals, to redress the balance and help other countries rather than our own selfish needs.

The "higher birth rate" solution is absurd. People stick to around 2/3 children for lots of reasons that have nothing to do with whether they can afford a larger house, so you would have to change an entire generation's mindset before that had any realistic effect; and you would still have to wait 20 years for the resulting extra children to grow up.

It is of course self-evident that Farage's objections to migration have sod-all to do with any moral objection to skilled people leaving their country of origin. Expelling recent arrivals wouldn't help their countries of origin either, given that there is no way you could force people to return there rather than go to any other country of their choice.

LongDarkTeatime · 11/12/2023 14:33

FYI the anti-immigration brigade have moved over to this thread. With these threads I’m wondering if the Daily Fail journalists were needing a bit more fodder today?
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/ami_being_unreasonable/4960999-house-building-is-out-of-control?utm_campaign=thread&utm_medium=share

Anisette · 11/12/2023 14:28

Porridgeislife · 11/12/2023 09:54

Brilliant idea. Undocumented migrants will almost certainly pass enhanced DBS checks essential for working with vulnerable adults 👍

Since when were all asylum seekers undocumented migrants?

Crikeyalmighty · 11/12/2023 14:28

@BIossomtoes clearly only the guardian and the new European sold there!!

Anisette · 11/12/2023 14:25

nds241 · 11/12/2023 09:17

@hangingonfordearlife1 He was talking about reducing net migration levels, I think that's what he meant by population crisis

But you know that the subtext is that he only wants to keep out foreigners he disapproves of, mainly because of the colour of their skins.

therealcookiemonster · 11/12/2023 14:18

furtivetussling · 11/12/2023 14:04

You 'think' that is what he meant.

Did he go on to explain what he thinks is the cause of this population crisis and what his methods would be in order to tackle it?

of course. he must have meant compulsory sterilisation.

Crikeyalmighty · 11/12/2023 14:15

@Clavinova nah- I don't- I think he was in there as a sop to those not on the far left- just as I personally think that's the reason the other way around why Angela Rayner is there. I've never heard her make a great speech .

BIossomtoes · 11/12/2023 14:05

But the left have such control over the media

😂😂😂😂😂😂
Essex must be a parallel universe.

furtivetussling · 11/12/2023 14:04

nds241 · 11/12/2023 09:17

@hangingonfordearlife1 He was talking about reducing net migration levels, I think that's what he meant by population crisis

You 'think' that is what he meant.

Did he go on to explain what he thinks is the cause of this population crisis and what his methods would be in order to tackle it?

JaneyGee · 11/12/2023 13:59

Well, he enrages the smug, bullying, sanctimonious, intolerant, sneering liberals who dominate this country. And anything that upsets them makes me happy.

Of course he’s right about immigration. I am in rural Essex, which is now so crowded I could scream. At time, I feel like I’m suffocating. The traffic is so awful I hardly bother going out. I wouldn’t dream of visiting a local beauty spot on a sunny Saturday, for example. And I had to give up yoga after work because I just sat in traffic. My quality of life is deteriorating because of the sheer number of people. My local woods have been hacked into so developers can build blocks of flats, and at the other end of the village a giant new estate is being built that is more like a small town.

Last year, net immigration was 750,000. If you add in illegals, it was probably close to a million. If this continues, we’ll have to build two new Manchesters every year. There is only one word for this - insanity. But the left have such control over the media (along with the universities, publishing and the arts), and are so bulllying and vicious when people protest, that most of us keep quiet. This isn’t going to stop. People need to realise that the migration crisis is only just beginning. Africa’s birth rate is so high their population is going to double by 2050. I’ll be voting Reform next year, and I don’t give a f- what anyone on here thinks about that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread