Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my friend her ds is a shit?

289 replies

MidnightMidwinter · 11/12/2023 09:12

I made friends with a very lovely lady 11 years ago through our NCT group. We’re really close - been on holiday together multiple times, always round each other’s houses etc. Our sons were in the same class at primary school and were pretty good friends, mainly because we did stuff all together at weekends though, tbh, as they’re both very different kids.

Both our DSs have started at the same secondary in September. DS and friend’s DS were put in different tutor groups and no longer really hang out at all as friend’s DS is sporty and play football at lunchtimes and my ds doesn’t. We live pretty rurally and it’s a 45 minute journey door to door. They get the bus Mon-Weds but I give them a lift on Thursday and Friday as it’s on my route. Friend’s DS lived about 100m away from us so not going out of my way at all to pick him up and it’s just what you do, isn’t it?

Anyway, in about May I got a converted van that I use as my car. It’s my pride and joy and I try and keep it as clean as possible as never had a nice vehicle before. Every time I’ve given friend’s DS a lift he’s immediately started eating his lunch in the van and I ask him not to. He huffs and rolls his eyes but will eventually put his sandwich away, always after having made an seemingly deliberate amount of mess in doing so. Not just a few crumbs but smears of jam on the seats/ crisps stamped into the floor kind of thing.

On Thursday I dropped them off, said “gooodbye” and friends DS opened his hand, showed me 4 little black plastic things and smirked at me. I was confused and didn’t think much more about it. Then on Friday I noticed he was fiddling with the sliding curtain that goes across the window next to where he sits. I ask him to stop as I need to see out of the window and again he huffs, rolls eyes and says “fine” before carrying on for a few seconds and eventually stopping.

Cleaning out the van this weekend I open the sliding door and the curtains just fall off their runners. Looking at the opposite window I see there are little black plastic bits on the end of each runner to stop this happening. I’m 99% sure this is what friend’s DS showed me on Thursday morning and then he then decided to unthread the curtains on Friday on purpose.

I’m so bloody angry with him. It’s such a nasty thing to do and I almost feel like I’m being bullied by an 11yo! I know if I tell his mum it will be a huge issue - she’s forever going on about people making things up to get him into trouble, convinced that he’s a very sweet boy, just overconfident and that people don’t like that. But he’s not, he’s just a shit. I am absolutely not giving him lifts anymore.

I thought I’d give it a few days to make sure I wasn’t blowing it out of proportion but I’m still furious. AIBU to tell my friend this or am I just being over precious about my van?

OP posts:
lucya66 · 11/12/2023 13:24

i think if you call him a little shit to the mother she will not respond well. Approach it reasonably and ask her to help.

oakleaffy · 11/12/2023 13:24

He's a little pshcitt.
Don't give this bratty boy a lift again.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 11/12/2023 13:20

SeasonsGreasons · 11/12/2023 10:00

Well first of all, not all 11 year olds are created equal, some are more mature than others. Some can sit still on a 45 minute journey, others are more lively and will get bored and restless. I would suggest your friend's DS is the lively type, hence the sport playing in his break times, and wanting to eat his lunch in the car to pass the time. And kids fiddle with things when restless, and may unintentionally break things in doing so. I have a 9 year old who does that a lot. I find it's a good idea to give them something to occupy them if they're fidgety.

But you seem to know the kid well, so you know more about his personality than I do. Maybe he is just a spiteful child.

@SeasonsGreasons - if it was a genuine accident, why did the boy show the bits to @MidnightMidwinter, smirk at her, and pocket them? Surely he would either have hidden them (for fear of being told off) or handed them over and explained the accident.

Also, if it had just been one that 'came off by accident', I could understand that - but if one comes off accidentally, you don't go on fiddling with more of them so they all fall off too. Once may be an accident, but the second, third and fourth times look increasingly deliberate.

momonpurpose · 11/12/2023 13:17

MidnightMidwinter · 11/12/2023 10:17

Also I’m not going to buy fidget toys for a kid who deliberately broke my curtains.

Right? I couldn't agree more! Even suggesting that is nuts!

momonpurpose · 11/12/2023 13:12

He is a little shit. Tell the mother and cut the rides off. Apology or not she needs to see that just because she doesn't understand actions have consequences the rest if the world does

DC1888 · 11/12/2023 13:06

MidnightMidwinter · 11/12/2023 09:39

I won’t actually call him a shit to his mum. I’ll just tell her what he did and explain why I won’t be giving him lifts any longer. I very much doubt she’ll believe he did it, though, that’s the problem. She’s told me some outrageous things he’s done over the years and it’s always been a misunderstanding or people taking a dislike to her son for no reason. She doesn’t seem to pick up on the fact that these things don’t constantly happen with other parents.

I'm afraid its a sign of bad parenting on her part. By letting him get away with things he will continue to behave like this, there's no deterrent.

100% tell her, me i'd be letting rip.

WinterDeWinter · 11/12/2023 13:06

MidnightMidwinter · 11/12/2023 09:56

I think that’s really good advice. Thank you.

It is good advice but I thnk you should also ask her to get the black things back.

And I would definitely tell her about the deliberate smearing of food too - and tbh I really couldn't not say something about her being 'in a bit of denial about how he is.' But that probably would cause a 'froideur at the very least...

GreigeO · 11/12/2023 12:59

"Hi, Friend. Damian took the end bits off the curtain runners in the van on Thursday. Can you ask him to give them back. Thanks. The curtain won't stay on without them."

Perfect

Nicole1111 · 11/12/2023 12:53

Once you’ve cooled down I’d just message explaining as non emotively as possible, because she’s unlikely to just accept you saying you can’t do it without an explanation why. Say
“I’m afraid I won’t be able to give ds a lift anymore. I’ve had a few issues with him ignoring basic requests around respecting my vehicle, but nothing serious enough to talk to you about, and something I felt I could manage myself. The other day though he removed some items from the van though which has caused some minor damage. He did show me he had them as I drove off so are you able to check if he still has them so I can fix the damage.” I feel like that evidences that you haven’t just jumped to saying you can’t take him but his behaviour has escalated.

minipie · 11/12/2023 12:52

MidnightMidwinter · 11/12/2023 09:39

I won’t actually call him a shit to his mum. I’ll just tell her what he did and explain why I won’t be giving him lifts any longer. I very much doubt she’ll believe he did it, though, that’s the problem. She’s told me some outrageous things he’s done over the years and it’s always been a misunderstanding or people taking a dislike to her son for no reason. She doesn’t seem to pick up on the fact that these things don’t constantly happen with other parents.

I wonder how he turned out like this 🤔

I think factual description and not giving lifts is the way forward.

If she has any sense she will give him a major bollocking and send him to grovel to you.

If not… no loss.

Mix56 · 11/12/2023 12:51

I would tell the mother that the lifts are stopping as her son has deliberately damaged your van & messes it up in spite of repeated requests to stop.
& that the plastic pieces (name?) he removed cost x & you want to be refunded.
(Print out the item
If she tries to deflect, you tell her he unstuck them then showed you the damage & pocketed the pieces.
Lifts are over... Too bad.

agent765 · 11/12/2023 12:48

You need to call in and catch them both together.

It'll show on Little Damien's (love this!) face if asked in front of his mother.

Unless he really is a budding psycho in the making. In which case you and your DS need as little contact as possible with him.

Oh, and if you decide to ask him for the bits back while he's in your van you need to have your phone recording first. Or fit a little cam in there somewhere.

He sounds like a nightmare - the typically over-indulged little angel who can do no wrong in his parents' eyes and will ultimately end up bringing a load of trouble to the door.

It seems from most other replies that a lot of people have encountered this type of kid before and a few have contributed with their own.

Sconehenge · 11/12/2023 12:47

God he sounds a bit like a sociopath! I wouldn’t want my DS being friends with him.

CherryBlossom321 · 11/12/2023 12:46

This is a horrible situation to be in when it involves a friend who won’t acknowledge or deal appropriately with their child’s wrongdoing.

I had a friend for years who I was incredibly close to, and who was lovely in every respect EXCEPT that she could never accept that her child had behaved inappropriately.

Over years, her daughter hurt mine repeatedly. Other people witnessed it, and other people’s children were also on the receiving end of some horrible, bullying behaviour. A number of us on a number of occasions tried to bring the issue to my friend, and she would become defensive, angry and deny everything, to the point of flipping the script and telling others it was their child, not hers.

Her daughter damaged things in our house, helped herself to my products and makeup (I started locking my bathroom door when she was in our house!), stained our new carpet. The final straw was a few months ago when she attempted to steal something which belongs to my daughter. I caught her in the act and told her to give it back which she did, straight away. She then rang her dad to come and collect her and told him a bunch of waffle in the car about being falsely accused etc.

Once again, my friend chose to believe her, asserted that myself and my daughter were lying, and the friendship has come to a very sad end. Others stopped bothering with them years ago, and we should probably have done the same.

I don’t envy your position. Ultimately your good nature is being taken advantage of and if had my time again, I wouldn’t put up with as much as I have.

Katbum · 11/12/2023 12:36

Just tell her what he did and that therefore you won’t be giving him a lift any more. If she acts defensive you can just say, ‘I have no reason to lie to you about this; if it were me I’d address it with my child’ and leave it at that.

skyeisthelimit · 11/12/2023 12:33

Just tell her that he took the bits and ask if he can return them. Then advise that due to the repeated damage to the vehicle, you are unable to take him any more.

ISSTIUTNG · 11/12/2023 12:20

Firstly, the lifts end now. You don't need to name call him to his mum (that will never end well) but tell her the facts and that unfortunately you can no longer give him lifts.

Honestly, it's sad that you might lose a friendship with a nice woman but on the other hand is any friendship worth such a lack of respect? I wouldn't tolerate this behaviour from my nieces/nephews never mind some kid I met at an parent group.

I could almost guarantee as well that he's tormenting your DS in similar ways. Is sports the real reason your son stays away from him or is he just a good judge of character? If you don't stand up to him then your ds is going to struggle to and that could lead to real issues in future. Model the correct way to deal with this assertively.

Your son is 11 now. You needed to have made his needs and his friendship preferences a priority 10 years ago and you definitely need to now that he's older and trying to navigate his friendships independently

Newgirls · 11/12/2023 12:19

I think he doesn’t want a lift with you anymore and lacks the brains to deal with that in a mature way

BungleandGeorge · 11/12/2023 12:18

If she’s a friend I’d speak to her about it. You haven’t actually given her the opportunity to do anything about it?

Leah5678 · 11/12/2023 12:14

SnowSwan · 11/12/2023 10:17

"Hi, Friend. Damian took the end bits off the curtain runners in the van on Thursday. Can you ask him to give them back. Thanks. The curtain won't stay on without them."

Good choice of name 🤣🤣🤣

SirVixofVixHall · 11/12/2023 12:12

Moveoverdarlin · 11/12/2023 12:04

I’d pop round and talk to them both over Christmas in a jokey manner ‘Oi Jack I need those clips back for my van that you swiped, my curtains fall down with them. If you no longer have them, you need to order me some, call it my Christmas present! Also I’m imposing a new ‘no food rule in my van’. I love that van more than the kids and life itself, so I want perfect behaviour or you can all literally jog on.

Then at least you’ve said it and if he plays up again, you can tell him to walk next Thursday.

This is what I would do.
Let both the boy and his Mum know that he is on thin ice, give him one more chance to behave, and if he doesn’t then no more lifts. A cheery “I don’t have people in my lovely van who don’t behave properly “ end to any lift giving.

Moveoverdarlin · 11/12/2023 12:04

I’d pop round and talk to them both over Christmas in a jokey manner ‘Oi Jack I need those clips back for my van that you swiped, my curtains fall down with them. If you no longer have them, you need to order me some, call it my Christmas present! Also I’m imposing a new ‘no food rule in my van’. I love that van more than the kids and life itself, so I want perfect behaviour or you can all literally jog on.

Then at least you’ve said it and if he plays up again, you can tell him to walk next Thursday.

3luckystars · 11/12/2023 11:54

Dot Cotton

Ellie1015 · 11/12/2023 11:53

Justonemorecoffeeplease · 11/12/2023 09:54

Meant to add this - I've got some really good friends whose children just don't get along with mine. We've never made it into a issue between us. One even was part of a group that bullied my daughter in primary school and we just asked the Head to address it.

In your case I'd simply say that the lift situation wasn't working so you can't do it anymore. If the mother presses for a reason just tell her that her DS has damaged your van and has treated it and you with disdain. If she can't cope with that I'm not sure I'd want to continue the friendship anyway.

I think this is perfect advice. Don't continue lifts and don't explain unless friend asks. Saves an awkward conversation if she already knows son can be hard work and doesn't want to deal with it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread