Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my friend her ds is a shit?

289 replies

MidnightMidwinter · 11/12/2023 09:12

I made friends with a very lovely lady 11 years ago through our NCT group. We’re really close - been on holiday together multiple times, always round each other’s houses etc. Our sons were in the same class at primary school and were pretty good friends, mainly because we did stuff all together at weekends though, tbh, as they’re both very different kids.

Both our DSs have started at the same secondary in September. DS and friend’s DS were put in different tutor groups and no longer really hang out at all as friend’s DS is sporty and play football at lunchtimes and my ds doesn’t. We live pretty rurally and it’s a 45 minute journey door to door. They get the bus Mon-Weds but I give them a lift on Thursday and Friday as it’s on my route. Friend’s DS lived about 100m away from us so not going out of my way at all to pick him up and it’s just what you do, isn’t it?

Anyway, in about May I got a converted van that I use as my car. It’s my pride and joy and I try and keep it as clean as possible as never had a nice vehicle before. Every time I’ve given friend’s DS a lift he’s immediately started eating his lunch in the van and I ask him not to. He huffs and rolls his eyes but will eventually put his sandwich away, always after having made an seemingly deliberate amount of mess in doing so. Not just a few crumbs but smears of jam on the seats/ crisps stamped into the floor kind of thing.

On Thursday I dropped them off, said “gooodbye” and friends DS opened his hand, showed me 4 little black plastic things and smirked at me. I was confused and didn’t think much more about it. Then on Friday I noticed he was fiddling with the sliding curtain that goes across the window next to where he sits. I ask him to stop as I need to see out of the window and again he huffs, rolls eyes and says “fine” before carrying on for a few seconds and eventually stopping.

Cleaning out the van this weekend I open the sliding door and the curtains just fall off their runners. Looking at the opposite window I see there are little black plastic bits on the end of each runner to stop this happening. I’m 99% sure this is what friend’s DS showed me on Thursday morning and then he then decided to unthread the curtains on Friday on purpose.

I’m so bloody angry with him. It’s such a nasty thing to do and I almost feel like I’m being bullied by an 11yo! I know if I tell his mum it will be a huge issue - she’s forever going on about people making things up to get him into trouble, convinced that he’s a very sweet boy, just overconfident and that people don’t like that. But he’s not, he’s just a shit. I am absolutely not giving him lifts anymore.

I thought I’d give it a few days to make sure I wasn’t blowing it out of proportion but I’m still furious. AIBU to tell my friend this or am I just being over precious about my van?

OP posts:
MidnightMidwinter · 12/12/2023 22:59

Givemethereins · 12/12/2023 22:38

This 100 %. If we all went around dropping friends and holding zero tolerance boundaries without acknowledging bonds with people, society would fall apart.

You've know this lad for some years, he's been part of your close knit family life. How about just starting with the basics of speaking honestly to him; that it upset you he took the black things and didnt listen to your rules about eating in the van. so much so you are considering not taking him anymore.
And before this, repeat your feelings honestly to the mum, a close friend of yours.
And give them a chance to make amends.

I’ve no plans on dropping friends, I’d love to be able to stay friends with her. I absolutely will not be giving her son anymore lifts, though. If she feels that’s reason enough to end our friendship then it clearly means less to her than I hoped.

My boundaries haven’t been zero tolerance. I’ve continued to give him lifts since September despite him constantly refusing to respect my rule of not eating in the car and has gone beyond and actively made a mess while eating/ putting away the food after I repeatedly tell him. It’s the active destruction of my property and the smirk with which he showed me that was my line in the sand.

OP posts:
sherahprincessofpower · 12/12/2023 22:51

@t1dmama I didn't tell her mother, no, because she was in the throes of an abusive relationship which I knew was affecting all of them.

I understood that the DD was hurting herself, and I love my friend.

But I did take an almighty step back, which wasn't actually hard to do as my friend kind of lost interest in me anyway when she moved away and started a new relationship.

Lemondoughnut · 12/12/2023 22:50

Just a thought but if there are other curtains in the van, could you remove one of the bits and have it 3D copied? They seem to be able to 3D print everything.

Jeannie88 · 12/12/2023 22:48

If our son had deliberately done such a thing like this I would want to know. The more times people call him out for this type of behaviour the more his Mum will have to face up to it. You have to tell her as yes it is vindictive and unacceptable.

T1Dmama · 12/12/2023 22:42

sherahprincessofpower · 12/12/2023 22:13

YANBU, I had a very sadly similar situation with a long term friend who lived very close.

When our DD's went up to secondary school they pretty soon parted ways, although we stayed family friends.

One time, in the throes of the early covid lockdown when we were allowed to meet outside but not go in people's houses I arranged to meet my friend and her DC after at work at, say, 5.

Anyway, for some unknown reason my friend texted me at 4PM saying she was sending the kids over to me.

I had a work call that I could not absent myself from in any way (I am a psychologist, it was a private counselling session, I could not answer the door or explain anything). So...just as my call was about to start and the kids arrived at the door I leaned out of the window and said - "you need to go home, we'll come and see you at five."

About a week later we got an 'anonymous' card through the post addressed to my husband saying "I love you, have you told the bitch yet?" (referring to me).

For reasons I won't go in to we worked out it was friend's DD.

Absolutely fucking galling to have a child I've known since she was tiny, treated as one of my own, cared for, cooked for, picked up from school etc do something so downright fucking horrible.

So yes, YANBU to cut off helping out this child and if he's anything like my friend's DD (now 16, physically assaults her Mum and younger sister and refuses to go to school) you are better off cutting ties now.

ONG!! What happened? Did you tell the friend what her DD had done?

Lemondoughnut · 12/12/2023 22:41

JesusAndMaryPain · 11/12/2023 18:35

Oh god, I hear you.
Your friend won't respond well to any criticism of her little darling.
In a similar situation, I've considerably backed off the friendship. When I'm with her she continues to bring up his many virtues and how wronged he is by others....I just sympathise. My DS backed off as soon as they could. I miss the fun we used to have but it's also a relief!

Ditto. So sad to lose a good friend this way but the same thing happened to me. My DS, at this age, was a total pain in the bum but so was his best friend whose mother I was very close to.
At parent's evening I was waiting to speak to a teacher who was in the process of telling friend that her DS had to keep being moved in class as he wouldn't stop talking and was very rude when asked to stop. My 'friend', who didn't know I was standing behind said "I suppose you have to move him to keep him away from the bad influence of..." my DS!
I was gob smacked. I'd never shied away from criticism as I knew he was a handful but she genuinely could not accept that her DS ever did anything wrong.
I didn't tell her I'd heard this but the friendship drifted eventually.
It often makes me wonder if some mums feel they should never be honest about their DC's behaviour for fear it will be used against them?

Givemethereins · 12/12/2023 22:38

KTheGrey · 11/12/2023 09:42

Tell your friend about the eating as well as the curtain, offer the opportunity to step up, admit wrong doing and make it right.

If there's a lovely turnaround, wonderful.

If not, no more lifts.

This 100 %. If we all went around dropping friends and holding zero tolerance boundaries without acknowledging bonds with people, society would fall apart.

You've know this lad for some years, he's been part of your close knit family life. How about just starting with the basics of speaking honestly to him; that it upset you he took the black things and didnt listen to your rules about eating in the van. so much so you are considering not taking him anymore.
And before this, repeat your feelings honestly to the mum, a close friend of yours.
And give them a chance to make amends.

Lemondoughnut · 12/12/2023 22:18

SnowSwan · 11/12/2023 10:17

"Hi, Friend. Damian took the end bits off the curtain runners in the van on Thursday. Can you ask him to give them back. Thanks. The curtain won't stay on without them."

"Damian" 🤣😅🤣😅

sherahprincessofpower · 12/12/2023 22:13

YANBU, I had a very sadly similar situation with a long term friend who lived very close.

When our DD's went up to secondary school they pretty soon parted ways, although we stayed family friends.

One time, in the throes of the early covid lockdown when we were allowed to meet outside but not go in people's houses I arranged to meet my friend and her DC after at work at, say, 5.

Anyway, for some unknown reason my friend texted me at 4PM saying she was sending the kids over to me.

I had a work call that I could not absent myself from in any way (I am a psychologist, it was a private counselling session, I could not answer the door or explain anything). So...just as my call was about to start and the kids arrived at the door I leaned out of the window and said - "you need to go home, we'll come and see you at five."

About a week later we got an 'anonymous' card through the post addressed to my husband saying "I love you, have you told the bitch yet?" (referring to me).

For reasons I won't go in to we worked out it was friend's DD.

Absolutely fucking galling to have a child I've known since she was tiny, treated as one of my own, cared for, cooked for, picked up from school etc do something so downright fucking horrible.

So yes, YANBU to cut off helping out this child and if he's anything like my friend's DD (now 16, physically assaults her Mum and younger sister and refuses to go to school) you are better off cutting ties now.

Slightlyboredandseverlyconfused · 12/12/2023 22:12

Ah. It’s called Sugru moldable glue.

Slightlyboredandseverlyconfused · 12/12/2023 22:10

MidnightMidwinter · 12/12/2023 07:22

Ooh, that’s a really good idea! Thank you! I was considering using putty but I know I’d make a right mess of that.

Or you can get putty stuff to mend charger wires with. I’ll see if I can find a link.

TooningOut · 12/12/2023 21:32

I would tread very carefully, I like @AllyArty's advice. He has the makings of a bully and I'd want to make sure I wasn't leaving my son exposed.

She's unlikely to believe you or take your side based on past behaviour so I can't see you telling her what happened will change things. I'd make my excuses about the lifts and try to find a replacement myself, he's not going to still have them anyway.

What a little shit, definitely on his way to becoming a big shit.

Jillybloop393 · 12/12/2023 21:20

PieAndLattes · 11/12/2023 10:46

I’d message the mum and say, ‘Mavis, can you tell Arnold to return the plastic stops for my camper van blinds? He removed them on Thursday and showed them to me as he got out of the van but I didn’t realise what they were until the curtains fell down on Friday morning. While you’re at it, let him know that he is not to be eating in the van. He doesn’t listen to a word I say but hopefully he’ll listen to you. He’s on his last legs and if there’s any more of his nonsense he can walk to school. You must have the patience of a saint’.

This. With just one difference - I wouldn't give the little shit another chance to damage my vehicle, so I'd be saying that I sadly wouldn't be able to take him any more. If his DM doesn't like it, tough, let her cope with the little brat!

sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 12/12/2023 21:13

I think you need to keep things fairly short & snappy. Something like 'Hi Mother of Damian, it's become clear that the lifts aren't something your evil little bugger enjoys, so it's best we don't continue with them. Also, if he can return the curtain hooks he broke off & took with him, I'd very much appreciate that as replacements aren't available.'

For those who say young kids can't be little shits... oh my. There was a boy in reception class with DS who made every other child's life a misery. I was even warned by two teachers not to let DS become too close. The horrible thing was that his mum was absolutely lovely, but completely useless at dealing with him. In the end the rest of us would just leave parties, the park, etc. if they turned up because she'd just laugh and say 'oh you're SO energetic!' whilst her son was kicking other children in the shins, pulling their hair, and so on, until the room was filled with 25 crying 5yo children & this horrible boy being praised for his enthusiasm. And before anyone says anything, no, he didn't have ADHD, etc. He was just a boy who had never been told he wasn't the messiah.

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/12/2023 20:58

nomadmummy · 12/12/2023 18:56

I began reading the comments and I'm more concerned about the mums responding 'fuck that' and 'He's a little shit'!!! Are you seriously talking about a misbehaving 11 year old boy like he's an an 18 year old? Are you kidding me?

OP - someone posted that you should politely explain what's happened. If you're really a friend you'll sit down with her and be empathetic to her views. clearly this is a kid who is acting differently at home than outside the home and that's not unusual. But for the parent it is hard to imagine.

Back to all of you - kids at that age can act out and have behavior issues for a myriad of reasons. It can be imitation, frustration, testing boundaries, attention-seeking, ADHD, etc. Figuring out what antecedents there are to his behavior is a good first step. In this case it wouldn't shock me if you discovered the times the boy gets in trouble with others is when he's hungry. In kids if they're blood glucose is too low it can come out as anger, irritable, misbehaving. And that is NOT the child's fault. His mom may not see this because she's knows when he needs food (and may think all kids are like that and therefore all adults would realise this).

OP - if he can eat in his vehicle it could be hard to understand. Ask him before he gets in if he is hungry and needs to eat because he is not eating in the car.

I began reading the comments and I'm more concerned about the mums responding 'fuck that' and 'He's a little shit'!!! Are you seriously talking about a misbehaving 11 year old boy like he's an an 18 year old? Are you kidding me?

If he was 18 he'd be an "absolute shit", or a "total shit" - he's 11, so "little shit" fills the bill.

Don't make the assumption that all children are sweetness and light - they are just as capable of shitty behaviour as adults are.

MirabelMadrigal · 12/12/2023 20:49

@Justonemorecoffeeplease so your friends daughter was part of a group that was bullying your daughter and you simply addressed the headteacher?

Did your friend not try to stop it? Did you stay friends with the mum? I cant begin to imagine how upset my daughter would be if I carried on meeting up with her bully's mum

ToWhitToWhoo · 12/12/2023 20:27

YANBU to tell his Mum what he did; it went way beyond minor misbehaviour. Probably best not to actually use the phrase 'a shit' though!

moomoomoo27 · 12/12/2023 20:25

nomadmummy · 12/12/2023 18:56

I began reading the comments and I'm more concerned about the mums responding 'fuck that' and 'He's a little shit'!!! Are you seriously talking about a misbehaving 11 year old boy like he's an an 18 year old? Are you kidding me?

OP - someone posted that you should politely explain what's happened. If you're really a friend you'll sit down with her and be empathetic to her views. clearly this is a kid who is acting differently at home than outside the home and that's not unusual. But for the parent it is hard to imagine.

Back to all of you - kids at that age can act out and have behavior issues for a myriad of reasons. It can be imitation, frustration, testing boundaries, attention-seeking, ADHD, etc. Figuring out what antecedents there are to his behavior is a good first step. In this case it wouldn't shock me if you discovered the times the boy gets in trouble with others is when he's hungry. In kids if they're blood glucose is too low it can come out as anger, irritable, misbehaving. And that is NOT the child's fault. His mom may not see this because she's knows when he needs food (and may think all kids are like that and therefore all adults would realise this).

OP - if he can eat in his vehicle it could be hard to understand. Ask him before he gets in if he is hungry and needs to eat because he is not eating in the car.

I remember being 11, and 18 year olds are much better behaved. 11 year old just started secondary school kids are desperate to fit in with the cool kids and end up being little shits until they grow out of it. I remember the boys in my form spitting on other people's heads from the stairs above, tripping everyone up, yelling in people's faces when they walked past them, pulling their ties, opening their bags and taking stuff out. All things that seem hilarious at 11 (and definitely not at 18). It was very common.

Cerealkiller4U · 12/12/2023 20:21

@Justonemorecoffeeplease youre still friends with the mum who builled your daughter????

yetanotherdaytoday · 12/12/2023 20:13

As this is such a longstanding friend I'd approach it differently.

This isn't some random child who's being a shit to you, it's a boy you know well.

I'd say to her that you have something to discuss with her. And then say you're concerned about her DS and wanted to let her know how he'd behaved towards you.

Tell her what he did. Say you can't let him in your van again as you suspect he was pushing you to see where your boundaries are, so you now have to establish firm boundaries. (This is how I read the situation anyway).

But that you're talking to her to let her know it was concerning given it seems so out of character and that you are here if she needs anything or wants a chat.

MagicFarawayTea · 12/12/2023 20:10

Autumnleaves89 · 11/12/2023 09:45

@SisterMichaelsHabit are you the kids mum 😂

I was thinking this! Being 11 years old does not mean you are entitled to be a little shit. It’s a clear reflection of weak parenting.

brownless0 · 12/12/2023 19:59

I had a VERY similar issue . A neighbour and I worked in the same place and I had a car and she didn't. Since we were neighbours i offered her lifts. But I began to dislike her very quickly after months of lifts for free.

She kept interfering with my driving nearly causing a crash and then acting like it was my fault when she was playing co-pilot. PICKED HER NOSTRILS and smeared them on my seat all the time and ate and left crumbs Ye gods!
Then would ask me to take her on short diversions to the shop. She even told me to stop and give her friend a lift on the street!

She NEVER paid for the petrol or even offered like one would like "oh here's £20 and let me get it seeing that i'm chauffeured everyday from home".
This is what I did.
I said I have another errand to run in the morning and in the evening i'm going shopping so it will be difficult. Eventually she got the hint and started using someone else in my area. She did enquire a few times but i made my excuses not to go.
She did talk shit behind my back after the lifts stopped though. USER.

But WHO gives a F. I paid for my car, valet it regularly, MOT, Insurance, repairs.
So my suggestion. Don't tell her the real reason, just say can't go in mornings.

Sproutier · 12/12/2023 19:53

Mtlso · 12/12/2023 19:26

Why don’t you give him one more lift and set your phone up to record him somehow, ask him about the curtain things - show his mum and say that you knew she’d never believe the change in his behaviour, so you got proof. When kids get to the end of Y8/start of Y9, it’s like they’ve had personality transplants, so you definitely don’t want to be doing it until then. Best to nip in the bud now. Also wait for it to be a full moon, kids turn wild on a fm.

I can see why this might feel like a good idea, but I wouldn't do it. Some parents would absolutely go off the deep end at another adult recording their child without their knowledge or permission.

On a happier note that mouldable glue sounds like a great idea. I might have tried it old school with a bit of matchstick and silicone sealant, but the glue sounds much more fun.

Tigger1895 · 12/12/2023 19:30

SisterMichaelsHabit · 11/12/2023 09:41

I really think you're reading malice into the innocuous behaviour of an 11-year-old.

friends DS opened his hand, showed me 4 little black plastic things and smirked at me.

Are you sure he wasn't trying to show you that these things had come off and (assuming you, as the adult and the owner of the vehicle, would recognise them) that he thought you would know what to do about it? And that when you didn't ask for them back or say "oh thanks I'll sort those out" he decided they weren't important? Because that's more in line with how 11-year-olds think and it seems a bit extreme and frankly horrible on your part to go on a massive rant of character assassination aimed at an 11-year-old for fidgeting with something in your vehicle.

Also if the curtain things can be removed by a child, that's a choking hazard for younger children, and I'd be more annoyed with the manufacturer for making such a shit design TBH.

I think we’ve found the mother of said 11 year old.

Mtlso · 12/12/2023 19:26

Why don’t you give him one more lift and set your phone up to record him somehow, ask him about the curtain things - show his mum and say that you knew she’d never believe the change in his behaviour, so you got proof. When kids get to the end of Y8/start of Y9, it’s like they’ve had personality transplants, so you definitely don’t want to be doing it until then. Best to nip in the bud now. Also wait for it to be a full moon, kids turn wild on a fm.