Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my friend her ds is a shit?

289 replies

MidnightMidwinter · 11/12/2023 09:12

I made friends with a very lovely lady 11 years ago through our NCT group. We’re really close - been on holiday together multiple times, always round each other’s houses etc. Our sons were in the same class at primary school and were pretty good friends, mainly because we did stuff all together at weekends though, tbh, as they’re both very different kids.

Both our DSs have started at the same secondary in September. DS and friend’s DS were put in different tutor groups and no longer really hang out at all as friend’s DS is sporty and play football at lunchtimes and my ds doesn’t. We live pretty rurally and it’s a 45 minute journey door to door. They get the bus Mon-Weds but I give them a lift on Thursday and Friday as it’s on my route. Friend’s DS lived about 100m away from us so not going out of my way at all to pick him up and it’s just what you do, isn’t it?

Anyway, in about May I got a converted van that I use as my car. It’s my pride and joy and I try and keep it as clean as possible as never had a nice vehicle before. Every time I’ve given friend’s DS a lift he’s immediately started eating his lunch in the van and I ask him not to. He huffs and rolls his eyes but will eventually put his sandwich away, always after having made an seemingly deliberate amount of mess in doing so. Not just a few crumbs but smears of jam on the seats/ crisps stamped into the floor kind of thing.

On Thursday I dropped them off, said “gooodbye” and friends DS opened his hand, showed me 4 little black plastic things and smirked at me. I was confused and didn’t think much more about it. Then on Friday I noticed he was fiddling with the sliding curtain that goes across the window next to where he sits. I ask him to stop as I need to see out of the window and again he huffs, rolls eyes and says “fine” before carrying on for a few seconds and eventually stopping.

Cleaning out the van this weekend I open the sliding door and the curtains just fall off their runners. Looking at the opposite window I see there are little black plastic bits on the end of each runner to stop this happening. I’m 99% sure this is what friend’s DS showed me on Thursday morning and then he then decided to unthread the curtains on Friday on purpose.

I’m so bloody angry with him. It’s such a nasty thing to do and I almost feel like I’m being bullied by an 11yo! I know if I tell his mum it will be a huge issue - she’s forever going on about people making things up to get him into trouble, convinced that he’s a very sweet boy, just overconfident and that people don’t like that. But he’s not, he’s just a shit. I am absolutely not giving him lifts anymore.

I thought I’d give it a few days to make sure I wasn’t blowing it out of proportion but I’m still furious. AIBU to tell my friend this or am I just being over precious about my van?

OP posts:
PieAndLattes · 11/12/2023 10:46

I’d message the mum and say, ‘Mavis, can you tell Arnold to return the plastic stops for my camper van blinds? He removed them on Thursday and showed them to me as he got out of the van but I didn’t realise what they were until the curtains fell down on Friday morning. While you’re at it, let him know that he is not to be eating in the van. He doesn’t listen to a word I say but hopefully he’ll listen to you. He’s on his last legs and if there’s any more of his nonsense he can walk to school. You must have the patience of a saint’.

SallyWD · 11/12/2023 10:46

You have to tell her when you explain why you won't be giving him lifts. I would really want to know if this was my child.
I wonder why he does it. Pushing boundaries, attention seaking, doesn't like you? Weird behaviour!

Rosscameasdoody · 11/12/2023 10:44

SisterMichaelsHabit · 11/12/2023 09:41

I really think you're reading malice into the innocuous behaviour of an 11-year-old.

friends DS opened his hand, showed me 4 little black plastic things and smirked at me.

Are you sure he wasn't trying to show you that these things had come off and (assuming you, as the adult and the owner of the vehicle, would recognise them) that he thought you would know what to do about it? And that when you didn't ask for them back or say "oh thanks I'll sort those out" he decided they weren't important? Because that's more in line with how 11-year-olds think and it seems a bit extreme and frankly horrible on your part to go on a massive rant of character assassination aimed at an 11-year-old for fidgeting with something in your vehicle.

Also if the curtain things can be removed by a child, that's a choking hazard for younger children, and I'd be more annoyed with the manufacturer for making such a shit design TBH.

Are you his mum ?

SeasonsGreasons · 11/12/2023 10:44

LongDarkTeatime · 11/12/2023 10:39

Please don’t use the label ADHD to excuse this behaviour. Hyperactivity (or reduced inhibitory control for any reason) does not cause you to smirk or stop you from apologising for going against someone’s wishes. It would be awful for those with ADHD to be labelled with this behaviour.
If this child does have extra needs it’s their parents responsibility to identify and meet them.

Hang on a minute, your the first person to mention ADHD on this thread!

Rosscameasdoody · 11/12/2023 10:41

You need to tell her what happened. She may have passed off other incidents as people trying to get her son into trouble, but if your friendship is as strong as you say, she won’t be able to dismiss what you say so easily. If she does, or she takes offence, I think you should maybe step back a bit from the friendship and have as little to do with her DS as possible because there sounds as though there are problems, both with his behaviour, and with her ability to discipline and set boundaries for him. The problem will get worse if she doesn’t take ownership of it as a parent so yes, I’d say something but keep it factual and calm.

PogoStickPrincess · 11/12/2023 10:40

Anyone defending the kid in this thread is part of the reason why 11-year-olds who 'innocently' do bad things become teenagers who are constantly in trouble and not fun to be around for other kids.

Be very firm and frank with his mother. He broke the pieces. He showed them to you, but didn't tell you where they had come from or why he had them, and didn't offer to give them back to you or apologise for breaking them off in the first place. He either learns to sit down and behave himself, or he no longer gets to enjoy the privilege of being in your vehicle.

If his mother argues, you just reiterate: it's not up for discussion, you're not having an unruly pre-teen who can't listen to simple instructions in your vehicle. She has two choices: ensure he complies with your simple instructions, or tell him he's getting the bus.

If she goes with the former, let her know the consequences for any further damage or mess, deliberate or otherwise, are that he has to get the bus until you receive a genuine and sincere apology from the child himself. And you don't have to accept any BS apologies; kids like this learn from their parents that the words are what matters and not the intention behind them, so it's probably about time that he figures out that drawling 'I'm sorry' while smirking isn't going to cut it.

WowOK · 11/12/2023 10:39

I'd say..

Hi Sue,

I won't be giving Teddy a lift to school anymore moving forwards.

@MidnightMidwinter

He can think about his shit behaviour on his 45 daily bus journey. I might even wave when I pass.

LongDarkTeatime · 11/12/2023 10:39

Please don’t use the label ADHD to excuse this behaviour. Hyperactivity (or reduced inhibitory control for any reason) does not cause you to smirk or stop you from apologising for going against someone’s wishes. It would be awful for those with ADHD to be labelled with this behaviour.
If this child does have extra needs it’s their parents responsibility to identify and meet them.

badger2005 · 11/12/2023 10:38

Kevin.

CheshireCat1 · 11/12/2023 10:35

If one of my children behaved like that I’d definitely want to know so that I could deal with it. You need to speak to his mum.

YouBelongWithMe · 11/12/2023 10:35

Damien 🤣

Tracker1234 · 11/12/2023 10:34

Sister Michaels - what a daft response.

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 11/12/2023 10:29

Imagine if he is really called Damien!!

Heyhoherewegoagain · 11/12/2023 10:29

SisterMichaelsHabit · 11/12/2023 09:41

I really think you're reading malice into the innocuous behaviour of an 11-year-old.

friends DS opened his hand, showed me 4 little black plastic things and smirked at me.

Are you sure he wasn't trying to show you that these things had come off and (assuming you, as the adult and the owner of the vehicle, would recognise them) that he thought you would know what to do about it? And that when you didn't ask for them back or say "oh thanks I'll sort those out" he decided they weren't important? Because that's more in line with how 11-year-olds think and it seems a bit extreme and frankly horrible on your part to go on a massive rant of character assassination aimed at an 11-year-old for fidgeting with something in your vehicle.

Also if the curtain things can be removed by a child, that's a choking hazard for younger children, and I'd be more annoyed with the manufacturer for making such a shit design TBH.

Hello mum of little shit

Behindyouiam · 11/12/2023 10:28

YANBU he is so wrong!

EvilElsa · 11/12/2023 10:26

I'd tell her calmly and factually what has happened and about the attitude with eating in the car, say it clearly isn't working out with lifts and that you will be stopping. Don't call him names (although I'd be bloody tempted). If she is a decent person she will be embarrassed rather than angry at you. I'd be mortified.

BreadandButterDinners · 11/12/2023 10:25

Hi Op,
Definitely send the DM a message asking her to ask him for the curtain runners back.
Have you asked your son how he is getting along with him at the moment? I'd be concerned this boy is a bully.

Workawayxx · 11/12/2023 10:21

SnowSwan · 11/12/2023 10:17

"Hi, Friend. Damian took the end bits off the curtain runners in the van on Thursday. Can you ask him to give them back. Thanks. The curtain won't stay on without them."

This. I’d just be really factual about and go from whatever response you get.

if she says he did and will give back or he did but chucked them, very sorry etc then you can keep giving lifts. If any sort of lying/shifting blame etc then I’d just say you can’t give lifts any longer and hope the friendship survives.

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 11/12/2023 10:20

His behaviour isn't yours to deal with. Give his dm the facts and leave them to it. School runs are stressful enough without added dc making it worse...

Justonemorecoffeeplease · 11/12/2023 10:19

SnowSwan · 11/12/2023 10:17

"Hi, Friend. Damian took the end bits off the curtain runners in the van on Thursday. Can you ask him to give them back. Thanks. The curtain won't stay on without them."

"Damien" 😂😂😂

MidnightMidwinter · 11/12/2023 10:17

Also I’m not going to buy fidget toys for a kid who deliberately broke my curtains.

OP posts:
SeasonsGreasons · 11/12/2023 10:17

TomatoSandwiches · 11/12/2023 10:03

If he were like your child I imagine t
He would have tried to hide the buts he took of or broke but no he made the choice to show op whilst smirking.
That's a shit not a child with extra energy struggling to contain themselves.

He possibly would hand them to me with a shifty smile, as if to say "I took these off, but please don't yell at me". And I guess that could be interpreted as a smirk.

SnowSwan · 11/12/2023 10:17

"Hi, Friend. Damian took the end bits off the curtain runners in the van on Thursday. Can you ask him to give them back. Thanks. The curtain won't stay on without them."

MidnightMidwinter · 11/12/2023 10:16

SeasonsGreasons · 11/12/2023 10:00

Well first of all, not all 11 year olds are created equal, some are more mature than others. Some can sit still on a 45 minute journey, others are more lively and will get bored and restless. I would suggest your friend's DS is the lively type, hence the sport playing in his break times, and wanting to eat his lunch in the car to pass the time. And kids fiddle with things when restless, and may unintentionally break things in doing so. I have a 9 year old who does that a lot. I find it's a good idea to give them something to occupy them if they're fidgety.

But you seem to know the kid well, so you know more about his personality than I do. Maybe he is just a spiteful child.

Sorry, I should have clarified. It’s a 45 minute journey for them Mon-Weds as they have to walk to bus stop and then from bus stop at the other end. It’s only about a 25 minute drive door to door.

OP posts:
HollyJollyKissmass · 11/12/2023 10:16

I think the kid sounds like a bit of a pest and a wind up merchant but he is only 11 so would think it an overreaction to cut all contact with people you’ve been friends with for years over some bits of plastic.

If you’ve known him as long as you have I don’t get why you wouldn’t be firmer about the food mess etc.

You can be nice but firm- ‘New car, we’re not eating in here because of the mess’ while taking his food off him. You’re letting him rule you and then fuming to yourself afterwards. But really, the behaviours you’ve mentioned so far are trivial compared to the teenage years that lie ahead.