Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let DS stay off school on his birthday?

194 replies

Niffler29 · 10/12/2023 18:53

DS has asked if he can have the day off school on his birthday. He’s 12 and in his first year of high school so no exams coming up or anything. No issues at school/life in general, he’s a good kid. My initial response is no but if I’m being honest, I’ve never worked on my birthday in my life and the company I work for these days gives a an automatic holiday on your birthday so I can kind of see his point.

AIBU to consider it? I think I am but would like other people to confirm so I feel less bad🤣.

OP posts:
GardenGnomic · 11/12/2023 09:21

This is really weird - first time I've come across something on Mumsnet where I just cant fathom the other point of view. I'm in the 'you go to school' crowd. You wear a birthday badge, you have friends round for birthday tea and you do bigger celebration at the weekend.

Its not pearl clutching about importance of schooling (I have one on a reduced timetable), its different views in what makes a birthday special. What are you on about - you have to have the day off school loons? I did used to have a friend who insisted on being 'king for the day' on his birthday and having every whim met - so that I guess.

CurlewKate · 11/12/2023 09:16

@MarmitePizza "But you were able to set out as if you were going to school for the day and just drive straight past and go to the beach instead?"

Yep. We live 10 miles from the beach. We always have basic beach stuff in the car. And we are also in the fortunate position of being able to afford spontaneous fish and chips, so no picnic needed. As a point of detail we didn't, on that occasion, have towels in the car so I bought two hideous knock off Disney ones from the beach shop.

BooBooBaloo · 11/12/2023 09:05

madaboutmad · 10/12/2023 20:57

A friend of mine started working in a school and when it rained, loads of kids would be off. Fuck it, why not, who wants to walk in the rain!

Aaah the flaky adults of the future.

A bit like an intern we had a few years ago who didn't turn up to work because it had snowed (a small amount that had not affected the local roads which had all been well gritted) and she didn't think she had to work because it was a 'snow day'. The poor thing got a nasty shock about the real world that day 🤣

pizzaHeart · 11/12/2023 09:00

I never heard about this before joining MN. I’m very relaxed about attendance - if DD doesn’t feel well with cold or periods she stays home but I consider it’s reasonable. I wouldn’t hesitate to take her off school one or two days for holidays if it’s easier logistics wise, I did it once. But why should she stay home on her birthday? DH and I usually meet her up at school and go somewhere for a special treat/ dinner. A few times she had party with friends straight away after. Why stay at home for this particular day ?
I would consider this request as a sign that something wrong. What does exactly your DS want to do what he can’t do after school or on a weekend? Or what does he want to avoid at school? If he feels generally tired by now then you need to look at his routine but not let him stay for his birthday, one day won’t help.

Highlights12 · 11/12/2023 09:00

What excuse would you give to the school. Will you lie & say he's sick because I don't think they would be impressed if you tell the truth.

MarmitePizza · 11/12/2023 09:00

CurlewKate · 10/12/2023 20:07

Well, I have high achieving adult children and one day when they were about 10 and 6 on a whim I drove straight past school and we went to the beach. They still remember it.

Really? “On a whim?”

One thing I hate about going to the beach is getting all the stuff ready - costumes, towels, shoes, picnic etc.

But you were able to set out as if you were going to school for the day and just drive straight past and go to the beach instead?

BooBooBaloo · 11/12/2023 08:55

Skyisbluegrassisgreen · 10/12/2023 19:02

He’s just a kid give him a day off and a fab birthday - adults could book a days holiday if they want why are kids not allowed the same rights.

Because children are not adults? This 'if an adult can do it, why can't children?' thing is complete nonsense because they are necessarily different

Children are taught things in large groups, most adult jobs do not function in that way.

TheBraves · 11/12/2023 08:50

*hasn’t

TheBraves · 11/12/2023 08:49

I’ve let my kids have their birthdays off school when they’ve asked, only a couple of times each. They’re good kids and very engaged with their education so it hasn’t caused any issues. One of my children hated all the attention at primary school and sometimes it was too much for her. She hadn’t asked since being at secondary as there’s no fuss.

Lindtnotlint · 11/12/2023 08:49

I think it is worth thinking ahead to the next few years where you are dealing with a teenager who can make his own choices about whether to turn up or truant. For me it’s about the values you want to teach. Is it “we don’t skive. School matters”. Or is it “it’s ok to skip school to have fun when you have a good excuse like a birthday”.

I don’t think either is deeply wrong, but I for sure know which one I want my kids subscribed to!

SquigglePigs · 11/12/2023 08:47

I wouldn't let him. I don't like it in that I've always booked the day off for my birthday and so has DH and we're lucky enough to be in industries where it's easy. Now DD is in school leave is more precious so we're less likely to do that.

I was lucky as a kid and only had to go to school once or twice on my birthday as it usually fell in half term, which also means it's likely to be in DD's half term now. DH's and DD's are nowhere near a school holiday unfortunately.

I won't be letting her skip school on her birthday, much as part of me is quite tempted! We just made a big fuss of her on her "birthday party day" the weekend nearest her birthday and then had treats after school on the actual day.

x2boys · 11/12/2023 08:43

Bearonthestair · 10/12/2023 19:12

I'm sure he could. Do you not get annual leave? This place is batshit. Let him take it off. Life is short.

Only if he gets a job that allows him to book.annual.leave ,schools have set holidays ,many work places don't .its swings and roundabouts when i was nurse I mainly booked my birthday off every year ,but had to work weekends ,nights ,Xmas etc .

x2boys · 11/12/2023 08:35

Skyisbluegrassisgreen · 10/12/2023 19:02

He’s just a kid give him a day off and a fab birthday - adults could book a days holiday if they want why are kids not allowed the same rights.

Because they don't work they attend school.which have Set holidays and only some Adults can book a days holiday ,if they have Jobs that allow them to do that ,I Don thunk teachers can just books days holiday because it's their birthday .

Crumblecakes · 11/12/2023 08:33

Let him have the day off! Ignore all the horrified pearl clutchers/fun police on here.

One day out of the year wont kill him, it’s Xmas anyway so they won’t be doing much this week.

He’ll still be able to hold down a job when he is older I’m sure, unless of course you let him do it every year and he’ll obviously end up destitute or in prison.

kirbykirby · 11/12/2023 08:30

BillionaireTea · 11/12/2023 08:16

It's also really nice to be in school on your birthday- the day feels special and people sing to you etc . when I was 12 my friends would have done something like a little cake.

Not if you are being bullied and hate school. Not everyone has a good school experience with lots of friends.

ticktickticktickBOOM · 11/12/2023 08:26

No!

Birthdays can be celebrated wherever you are: school, work, hospital.
Let him have fun with his friends at school on his birthday - give him a big bag of sweets to share with his mates and give him a special packed lunch

Pottedpalm · 11/12/2023 08:25

Chickenwing2 · 10/12/2023 21:24

I would. Let him stay off and have a birthday pyjama party day with games and movies and snacks. He will have a lovely memory for the rest of his life which is far more valuable than 1 day of school.

A ‘lovely memory’ of not getting dressed, staying in the house stuffing junk snacks and staring at a screen?
I’ve never heard of taking a day off for a birthday being a thing. His teachers can’t take a day off.

kirbykirby · 11/12/2023 08:25

No. He should be up a chimney cleaning it and then give him gruel after.

Seriously, let him have the day off if he has good attendance. It won't make a difference in the scheme of things. People on MN are so uptight and miserable about such things.

marshmallowfinder · 11/12/2023 08:23

You go to school. That's that and have nice birthday things when you get home. I've always gone to school/work on my birthday. Not so self-entitled as to think I'm that special.

BillionaireTea · 11/12/2023 08:17

I never went school on my birthday and have always booked the day off work

I never went TO school

BillionaireTea · 11/12/2023 08:16

It's also really nice to be in school on your birthday- the day feels special and people sing to you etc . when I was 12 my friends would have done something like a little cake.

BillionaireTea · 11/12/2023 08:14

Actually high achieving people often don't use their annual leave - which is sometimes stupid and workaholic, and sometimes reflects a desire to sacrifice comfort now to achieve more later.

CagneyAndLazy · 11/12/2023 08:14

blackfluffycat · 11/12/2023 06:12

I'm curious. What do you tell the school?

Both my dds birthdays are during the school holidays. Just luck it fell that way but grateful.

I imagine they just lie about why the child was off - entitlement, you see...

I mean, who cares about school, teachers annd education anyway?

Clearly not many on MN...

wherethewildtbingsgo · 11/12/2023 08:10

ace249 · 11/12/2023 07:58

I let my youngest take the day off for her birthday. She has perfect attendance otherwise. I also take the day off for my birthday.
We've not turned out to be criminals or terrorists either. Yet.
(assuming that comment was tongue in cheek, but you never can tell these days)

The difference between you taking a day off and your daughter taking a day off is that you have a legal right to take time off and you do so in line with your employer's annual leave policy. You also presumably aren't taught the same thing on the same day as your colleagues and aren't setting a poor precedent for other colleagues.

I'm genuinely amazed that people can't see the difference between a child "taking a day off" ie skiving and an adult booking a day of annual leave which they are entitled to and paid for. Unless of course you're saying you never book the day off but simply don't turn up leaving your colleagues to cope because "it's my buuurrffffdayyy so I'm special"

ace249 · 11/12/2023 07:58

I let my youngest take the day off for her birthday. She has perfect attendance otherwise. I also take the day off for my birthday.
We've not turned out to be criminals or terrorists either. Yet.
(assuming that comment was tongue in cheek, but you never can tell these days)

Swipe left for the next trending thread