Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask riding school to turn a horse into a unicorn

488 replies

MoanaPisa · 10/12/2023 18:44

Bare with me

I’ve always told DD that horses that she sees are actually unicorns but they hide their horns until they see a real princess. I know some might ridicule but it’s really no different from telling a child that Santa comes down the chimney etc

Anyway DD has been asking to ride a unicorn so I’ve booked her a riding lesson at the stables for her 5th birthday. I really want to make it memorable and special for her so I’m thinking she could wear her princess outfit that she’s getting for Christmas but also - WIBU to ask the riding school to put a horn on the horse that DD will be riding? I’ll provide it of course. DH thinks I’m mad to ask but she would love it to think the unicorn had showed its horn because she’s in a princess dress? Or is it cheeky to ask?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Newuser75 · 11/12/2023 10:49

@Grumpsy oh I totally agree that I don't think a riding school would allow it. I'm just saying that a well trained pony shouldn't be expected to spook at a child riding in a dress or wearing a bonnet with a unicorn horn on it. I have 4 horses and none of them would bat an eyelid at this.

Grumpsy · 11/12/2023 10:56

@Newuser75 i have one, she’d probably bolt or spin with something that rustles too much depending on the time of year and what mood she’s in, but she’s a tbx not a child’s pony.

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/12/2023 10:59

You can really tell the people on the thread who have real life experience training horses and those who are just parroting what they’ve been told when their kids are at an RS. An RS might tell you that doing something will spook a pony - but that is code for “we don’t want you to do it” not “it is innately dangerous”.

A good RS should have cages on stirrups, or safety stirrups, for small children who won’t be wearing good riding boots - and even in the right boots you can still slip through the stirrup and get dragged.

People all around the world ride in full dresses, carrying flags, and god knows what. A little kid in a princess dress should not be an issue for the pony, and if it is, it shouldn’t be in that environment.

twistyizzy · 11/12/2023 11:03

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/12/2023 10:59

You can really tell the people on the thread who have real life experience training horses and those who are just parroting what they’ve been told when their kids are at an RS. An RS might tell you that doing something will spook a pony - but that is code for “we don’t want you to do it” not “it is innately dangerous”.

A good RS should have cages on stirrups, or safety stirrups, for small children who won’t be wearing good riding boots - and even in the right boots you can still slip through the stirrup and get dragged.

People all around the world ride in full dresses, carrying flags, and god knows what. A little kid in a princess dress should not be an issue for the pony, and if it is, it shouldn’t be in that environment.

I have ridden for over 40 years, trained numerous ex-racers into riding horses, BHSAI qualified etc etc. I am one of those posters who has said it wouldn't be safe.
DDs BHS + PC Centre wouldn't allow this, I asked the owner. Their insurance wouldn't allow it.
Horses who do battle re-enactments/military parades etc have been trained for that for years, a riding school pony won't have been. Horses aren't machines hence the insurance element. I also personally object to the whole painting of ponies etc etc as it focuses on the wrong thing (opposite of horse welfare and knowledge)..

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 11/12/2023 11:04

@FourLeggedBuckers I don't ride, I don't own a horse, I am not even that keen on being close to them because of how big/powerful they are, however they are amazing animals and should be loved and admired as horses and not made into mythical creatures at our whim. Telling a child that a horse is actually a unicorn, and that the child is actually a princess, is well beyond the level of make believe 'princess days'. Also complaining that castles are well, like castles and not some fairy tale building which never actually existed, is ridiculous too.
Let the child read fairy tales, watch films, get some princess dress up clothes, a toy unicorn even, but trying to manufacture something which further promotes that she actually IS a princess is ridiculous! Actual princesses don't look like the fairy tale ones anyway, and even those who did had fairly crappy lives!

PosyPrettyToes · 11/12/2023 11:11

@FourLeggedBuckers I'm another one who is against it. I've been riding for 37 years. I've ridden at riding schools in multiple countries, owned multiple horses and ponies over the years, and worked at livery and racing yards. It's a really stupid and potentially unsafe idea.

Balloonhearts · 11/12/2023 11:13

MindHowYouGoes · 11/12/2023 10:30

a 5 year old on a lead rein pony at a riding school is not going to fall off and get dragged by the pony. What on earth is going on with this thread?

OP make sure the dress is made of tulle and not neoprene so that it can rip in case of emergency.

I don't know where you ride but my niece and I both ride and both of us were off the lead rope and started learning rising trot in our first lesson. As are most kids I see starting out.

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/12/2023 11:14

@twistyizzy ”Their insurance wouldn’t allow it” is entirely different to “it’s dangerous”. RS insurance is a nightmare and it’s a perfectly valid reason not to do it.

I don’t think the OP should do it for all sorts of reasons, including the fact it’s daft and pointless. My posts throughout the thread have been about the depressing number of people who have low expectations of horses and training.

Having trained many horses for reenactment, I can assure you that flag work is a tiny amount of additional training on an otherwise well trained mount. And that is a hell of a lot more flapping around (and changing direction with the wind) than a small kid in a dress.

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/12/2023 11:15

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 11/12/2023 11:04

@FourLeggedBuckers I don't ride, I don't own a horse, I am not even that keen on being close to them because of how big/powerful they are, however they are amazing animals and should be loved and admired as horses and not made into mythical creatures at our whim. Telling a child that a horse is actually a unicorn, and that the child is actually a princess, is well beyond the level of make believe 'princess days'. Also complaining that castles are well, like castles and not some fairy tale building which never actually existed, is ridiculous too.
Let the child read fairy tales, watch films, get some princess dress up clothes, a toy unicorn even, but trying to manufacture something which further promotes that she actually IS a princess is ridiculous! Actual princesses don't look like the fairy tale ones anyway, and even those who did had fairly crappy lives!

I agree with all of this and posted similar upthread. Current posts are about the horse training side of this only!

Bordesleyhills · 11/12/2023 11:18

twistyizzy · 10/12/2023 20:43

Is it licensed or insured?

I’m sure it is -insuredit is extremely safety conscious with hats and body protectors - they do parties and pony rides- that’s face it in the horsey world insurance with kids is so so important. I’ve never had cause to go near as I’m a horse owner of 40 odd years myself- my 4 year old is tractor mad and won’t go near and my 14 month old too young.

twistyizzy · 11/12/2023 11:18

@FourLeggedBuckers well considering that most of the ponies used for 4 yr olds are shitlands with all the tricks they involve I still say it isn't safe. They frequently drop shoulders, get down to roll etc whilst kids are on top. With sensibly dressed kids this isn't a problem and actually teaches them to ride through the situation but with a kid in a dress that could get caught up etc then no it isn't safe.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 11/12/2023 11:19

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/12/2023 11:15

I agree with all of this and posted similar upthread. Current posts are about the horse training side of this only!

I have seen horses do all sorts of amazing things, and can assume much work is put in beforehand to perfect the skills. I wonder if having a horn strapped to it's head, and being ridden by someone in different clothes, is also something that would need a bit of training/acclimatising for the pony, and so that expecting a normal riding school pony to just be able to happily do this is a bit unreasonable? Again though, I would be against anything which promotes this ridiculous 'being a princess and a horse being a unicorn' scenario. Horses have been used for work and entertainment value in the past, but this is a step too far for me!

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/12/2023 11:26

twistyizzy · 11/12/2023 11:18

@FourLeggedBuckers well considering that most of the ponies used for 4 yr olds are shitlands with all the tricks they involve I still say it isn't safe. They frequently drop shoulders, get down to roll etc whilst kids are on top. With sensibly dressed kids this isn't a problem and actually teaches them to ride through the situation but with a kid in a dress that could get caught up etc then no it isn't safe.

Again, I find this really depressing. I’ve trained shetlands to carry flags (not for reenactment), and for general work. They’ve all taken to it well and been reasonably polite, pleasant animals. Shetlands get such a bad rep, but it really isn’t deserved. They’re characterful and clever, but they aren’t the devil, and if they are behaving poorly, there’s a reason for it, same as any other horse.

Ponies behaving like this are really unhappy in their work and that reflects really badly on the RS you’re holding up as a model of good training and risk assessment.

twistyizzy · 11/12/2023 11:30

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/12/2023 11:26

Again, I find this really depressing. I’ve trained shetlands to carry flags (not for reenactment), and for general work. They’ve all taken to it well and been reasonably polite, pleasant animals. Shetlands get such a bad rep, but it really isn’t deserved. They’re characterful and clever, but they aren’t the devil, and if they are behaving poorly, there’s a reason for it, same as any other horse.

Ponies behaving like this are really unhappy in their work and that reflects really badly on the RS you’re holding up as a model of good training and risk assessment.

Oh fgs. These shetlands live out most of the year apart from a few lessons per week with young kids. In winter they go hunting with the owner's grandkids etc. They are extremely well looked after however are all 15 yrs + so have learned all the tricks of the trade. Horses aren't machines and we shouldn't expect them to be, that's part of the joy of being with them because they each have their own personalities.
The yard is the best in the area, over subscribed with waiting lists because they turn out fatsric riders and have very high levels of welfare etc. As an experienced rider/owner and AI myself it is the only yard within a 30 mild radius that I would ever send my DC to.

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/12/2023 11:33

@Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter my point in this thread has been precisely that, no, clipping a horn (of the commercially available kind, designed to be clipped to the browband of a bridle) to the pony’s bridle and putting a kid in a princess dress on it should not require additional training. If it does, the pony really shouldn’t be being used in the RS.

The questions of good taste you raise about the idolisation of princesses, the historical inaccuracy, the gender stereotyping, treating animals as object (etc) are all valid objections in my opinion.

curaçao · 11/12/2023 11:39

Please dont bring your dd up like this OP. She isnt a princess and I think it would be quite offensive to ask a riding school to do this. They are professionals and you are treating them as though they are there to pander to you and your daughters silly over-indugent whims.

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/12/2023 11:42

twistyizzy · 11/12/2023 11:30

Oh fgs. These shetlands live out most of the year apart from a few lessons per week with young kids. In winter they go hunting with the owner's grandkids etc. They are extremely well looked after however are all 15 yrs + so have learned all the tricks of the trade. Horses aren't machines and we shouldn't expect them to be, that's part of the joy of being with them because they each have their own personalities.
The yard is the best in the area, over subscribed with waiting lists because they turn out fatsric riders and have very high levels of welfare etc. As an experienced rider/owner and AI myself it is the only yard within a 30 mild radius that I would ever send my DC to.

I can only judge by what you’ve said about these ponies’ behaviour, and you’re describing some pretty serious objections to their work, and some unsuitable behaviour for children learning to ride.

I absolutely believe that horses aren’t machines, and that means that their behaviour has significance and - more importantly - we have a moral obligation to understand that behaviour. It is no longer acceptable to ignore red flags in a horse’s behaviour so that we can continue to do what we want with them. I think that’s a good thing.

Perhaps you overstated their behaviour in your previous post and did this RS a disservice. Perhaps you overstate the quality of their welfare and training. Perhaps the standard of RSs is just appallingly low (and I do believe this is true). It really doesn’t matter as the RS isn’t identifiable from your posts, but I remain unimpressed.

margotrose · 11/12/2023 11:47

twistyizzy · 11/12/2023 11:18

@FourLeggedBuckers well considering that most of the ponies used for 4 yr olds are shitlands with all the tricks they involve I still say it isn't safe. They frequently drop shoulders, get down to roll etc whilst kids are on top. With sensibly dressed kids this isn't a problem and actually teaches them to ride through the situation but with a kid in a dress that could get caught up etc then no it isn't safe.

Any horse, Shetland or otherwise, that brushes like that shouldn't be anywhere near children. It's far too dangerous.

The yard I go to has Shetlands btw, and none of them have ever behaved like that.

twistyizzy · 11/12/2023 11:48

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/12/2023 11:42

I can only judge by what you’ve said about these ponies’ behaviour, and you’re describing some pretty serious objections to their work, and some unsuitable behaviour for children learning to ride.

I absolutely believe that horses aren’t machines, and that means that their behaviour has significance and - more importantly - we have a moral obligation to understand that behaviour. It is no longer acceptable to ignore red flags in a horse’s behaviour so that we can continue to do what we want with them. I think that’s a good thing.

Perhaps you overstated their behaviour in your previous post and did this RS a disservice. Perhaps you overstate the quality of their welfare and training. Perhaps the standard of RSs is just appallingly low (and I do believe this is true). It really doesn’t matter as the RS isn’t identifiable from your posts, but I remain unimpressed.

Don't preach to me about pain behaviour in horses, I'm all over it as we all should be.
I'm not exaggerating or minimising anything. I'm not engaging any further as you seem to be playing your experience and concern about horse welfare over my own. I am extremely happy with the RS thank you and as it is run by a BHSI and is a PC A+ centre (gets more pupils through A+ tests than any other RS in the whole county) I'm sure they don't give 2 hoots about your opinion.

margotrose · 11/12/2023 11:50

X-post with you @FourLeggedBuckers!

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/12/2023 11:59

And you, @twistyizzy, are trying to play your (low level) BHS qualifications as though they’re relevant to a discussion about behaviour and training. I’m glad you’re happy with your choice of RS, but from what you’ve said, I do have concerns. You brought your choice of RS into the discussion, not me. If you can’t handle different opinions about them, that was inadvisable.

twistyizzy · 11/12/2023 12:01

@FourLeggedBuckers if I'm good enough to be a BHS welfare officer then I think I'm qualified to choose a decent RS. Thank you for your concerns though and have a lovely day.

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/12/2023 12:03

No comment! But yea, you have a nice day too.

CaptainMyCaptain · 11/12/2023 12:10

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 11/12/2023 11:04

@FourLeggedBuckers I don't ride, I don't own a horse, I am not even that keen on being close to them because of how big/powerful they are, however they are amazing animals and should be loved and admired as horses and not made into mythical creatures at our whim. Telling a child that a horse is actually a unicorn, and that the child is actually a princess, is well beyond the level of make believe 'princess days'. Also complaining that castles are well, like castles and not some fairy tale building which never actually existed, is ridiculous too.
Let the child read fairy tales, watch films, get some princess dress up clothes, a toy unicorn even, but trying to manufacture something which further promotes that she actually IS a princess is ridiculous! Actual princesses don't look like the fairy tale ones anyway, and even those who did had fairly crappy lives!

100%. Let children be imaginative by all means but don't tell them things are true that really aren't true.

I hate all the Disney Princess crap anyway and unicorns aren't real. I would never tell a child they were real. I used to conduct farm tours for school groups. If a child wanted to see a unicorn I told them they were only in stories as did the other guides. No doubt we ruined their lives 🙄.

Nevermind31 · 11/12/2023 12:20

It’s not safe to ride in a Princess dress (and I doubt the riding school is insured for it).
the flapping could set of a horse, it could get caught on the saddle or reins, it will not be warm or comfortable…
and the riding school might not have s horse that is comfortable and used to a head dress (do you really want your daughter on a horse that is not used to/ comfortable in a piece of equipment, wearing something unsuitable???). Has this piece of equipment been tested and approved for rider safety?
Horses are animals with likes and dislikes, easily spooked, and not some party accessory…
just get your daughter used to the fact that she is not a real princess…

Swipe left for the next trending thread