Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Banging on the door of the Accessible Toilet

416 replies

HunterHearstHelmsley · 10/12/2023 09:30

Why do people do this?!

I've just used the accessible toilet (I need to use the accessible toilet). I'd barely sat down and someone started banging on the door. I wasn't in there an unreasonable amount of time - probably about 30 seconds when the door banging started and 3 minutes overall. I was in there because I needed to be, banging on the door isn't going to make me quicker. If someone was taking the piss, it'd probably make them stay longer!

It's not the first time it's happened but it's so frustrating. It happened a few weeks ago also, that time was a woman wanting to use the baby change... the baby change wasn't even in the accessible loo!

It's really annoyed me this morning, it's not something I've noticed when using non-accesible toilets so I think it's just an accessible loo thing. But whyyyy?! I can't go faster 😩

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/12/2023 15:28

coffeeaddict77 · 11/12/2023 15:22

Surely you wouldn't run into a shop with heels on then? That would only increase the speed at which the nerves get pinched.

I thought that. This thread just gets crazier. Surely if you can run in heels you shouldn’t be taking up a disabled space. But I don’t think we’re allowed to say that for fear of causing offence to those with hidden disabilities who can do this, but still exercise their right to the space because they have the badge.

Bigstones · 11/12/2023 15:23

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 11/12/2023 15:08

Interesting turn to the thread. Why do you think this is about anyone feeling superior or passing judgment ? I agree absolutely that no one has the right to demand the details of anyone’s disability, but I think all disabled people have the right to challenge someone’s use of accessible facilities if they think they have a reason to. It’s been said numerous times that no-one is suggesting that we demand the intimate details of someone’s condition - just a quick ‘do you know that’s an accessible facility for the disabled’ or something similar will suffice and if the answer comes back affirmative then that’s the end of it.

The poster was right when they said that these resources are finite and becoming harder to access. If we’ve got to the point where we think it’s better to allow people who are not entitled to use these resources to continue to abuse them, than challenge something we see as not right, then the abuse will continue and as always it’s the genuinely disabled who will be at the receiving end - as evidenced by some of the experiences recounted here. So ID cards maybe ? Locked facilities and the key issued only to those who are identified in some way, as eligible to use them ?

It would be extremely annoying to have to carry an id card or fanny around finding someone to give you the key… why the fuck should we have to just because some people are selfish wankers?

coffeeaddict77 · 11/12/2023 15:22

SawX · 11/12/2023 14:43

I really don’t think it’s unreasonable to suggest that if someone can jump out of a car with no difficulty and run in four inch heels, then whatever hidden disability they may have is not impacting their mobility at that present time, so it’s really not appropriate for them to be taking up a space which someone else may be genuinely in need of

With my disability, I can run into a shop wearing heels. It takes a couple of minutes for my spinal nerves to be pinched to the point I'm in agony and can only hobble back to my car. So stuff you and your "at the present time" nonsense.

Surely you wouldn't run into a shop with heels on then? That would only increase the speed at which the nerves get pinched.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 11/12/2023 15:17

Polimi · 11/12/2023 14:51

What does confronting achieve? If you’re so inclined check their blue badge when they’ve gone. An arsehole who’s not entitled is probably just going to ignore you anyway and there’s disabled people that don’t want to be confronted, I don’t want to tell a stranger what my problems are.

I think in the case of blue badges the problem lies not in the lack of spaces available, but the wholesale abuse of the concession. My local supermarket has blue badge spaces right along the front window up to the entrance of the shop. Having had a quick scan one day on my way in I was shocked to find that only a couple of the cars parked there were actually displaying the badge. Clearly no one checks and it’s supposed to be an attendant car park. None of this is down to those with hidden disabilities - it’s down to those who abuse. Unfortunately in some cases it’s difficult to tell one from the other, so if we can’t challenge for fear of causing offence we just continue in the same vane - circling round and round until we find a space and keeping quiet. It’s difficult.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 11/12/2023 15:08

Sirzy · 11/12/2023 14:50

But what gives you the right to challenge people? Why do you think you’re so superior you can pass judgement?

Interesting turn to the thread. Why do you think this is about anyone feeling superior or passing judgment ? I agree absolutely that no one has the right to demand the details of anyone’s disability, but I think all disabled people have the right to challenge someone’s use of accessible facilities if they think they have a reason to. It’s been said numerous times that no-one is suggesting that we demand the intimate details of someone’s condition - just a quick ‘do you know that’s an accessible facility for the disabled’ or something similar will suffice and if the answer comes back affirmative then that’s the end of it.

The poster was right when they said that these resources are finite and becoming harder to access. If we’ve got to the point where we think it’s better to allow people who are not entitled to use these resources to continue to abuse them, than challenge something we see as not right, then the abuse will continue and as always it’s the genuinely disabled who will be at the receiving end - as evidenced by some of the experiences recounted here. So ID cards maybe ? Locked facilities and the key issued only to those who are identified in some way, as eligible to use them ?

Polimi · 11/12/2023 14:51

What does confronting achieve? If you’re so inclined check their blue badge when they’ve gone. An arsehole who’s not entitled is probably just going to ignore you anyway and there’s disabled people that don’t want to be confronted, I don’t want to tell a stranger what my problems are.

Sirzy · 11/12/2023 14:50

Rosscameasdoody · 11/12/2023 14:48

Nice. Common sense is out of the window, so the abusers just carry on because PC behaviour dictates that you can’t reasonably challenge people for fear of causing offence. OK then. This thread is batshit.

But what gives you the right to challenge people? Why do you think you’re so superior you can pass judgement?

Rosscameasdoody · 11/12/2023 14:48

SawX · 11/12/2023 14:43

I really don’t think it’s unreasonable to suggest that if someone can jump out of a car with no difficulty and run in four inch heels, then whatever hidden disability they may have is not impacting their mobility at that present time, so it’s really not appropriate for them to be taking up a space which someone else may be genuinely in need of

With my disability, I can run into a shop wearing heels. It takes a couple of minutes for my spinal nerves to be pinched to the point I'm in agony and can only hobble back to my car. So stuff you and your "at the present time" nonsense.

Nice. Common sense is out of the window, so the abusers just carry on because PC behaviour dictates that you can’t reasonably challenge people for fear of causing offence. OK then. This thread is batshit.

SawX · 11/12/2023 14:43

I really don’t think it’s unreasonable to suggest that if someone can jump out of a car with no difficulty and run in four inch heels, then whatever hidden disability they may have is not impacting their mobility at that present time, so it’s really not appropriate for them to be taking up a space which someone else may be genuinely in need of

With my disability, I can run into a shop wearing heels. It takes a couple of minutes for my spinal nerves to be pinched to the point I'm in agony and can only hobble back to my car. So stuff you and your "at the present time" nonsense.

Sirzy · 11/12/2023 14:31

It’s not down to random strangers to question someone’s need. Unless it’s your job then it’s nothing to do with you.

someone questioning ds on his needs would probably stop him wanting to go to that place, or out at all.

being disabled is tough enough without people passing judgment about if they are disabled enough.

Blue badges are tough to get. If someone has one it is because they have proven to people that they need it. You can’t decide they don’t just because of how they look.

Teder · 11/12/2023 14:28

Rosscameasdoody · 11/12/2023 13:50

Simply stating facts as you see them isn’t ignorant. I also have a hidden disability and before I was confined to a wheelchair I was challenged numerous times when using disabled concessions because my condition wasn’t obvious . I don’t have a problem with it either - as long as the challenge is polite, relevant and not intrusive. If, as disabled people - regardless of whether the disability is hidden or not - we don’t challenge when we think we have reason, then we risk the further erosion of resources meant for our use. We all know that that these resources - accessible spaces, blue badge parking, etc, - are open to widespread abuse. So if you aren’t open to the suggestion that it’s up to us to challenge in order to protect these resources, what do you think the solution should be ?

I think the comments about disabled parking spaces are valid and I really don’t think it’s unreasonable to suggest that if someone can jump out of a car with no difficulty and run in four inch heels, then whatever hidden disability they may have is not impacting their mobility at that present time, so it’s really not appropriate for them to be taking up a space which someone else may be genuinely in need of. This is basic common sense. More and more, blue badges seem to be issued with no consideration of whether the specific qualifying disability actually impacts mobility, and at the same time disabled parking in town and city centres is becoming harder to access. There seems to be a correlation between the two, and only on MN is it considered judgmental or ignorant to suggest that.

Edited

Good for you that you didn’t mind being challenged. Lots of people would mind very much and it is intrusive.

It is absolutely not ok to question anyone’s health unless you’re their medical professional.

Bigstones · 11/12/2023 14:21

Wednesday6 · 11/12/2023 13:25

Could that have been a child? They are often taken to accessible ones when the parent has pushchair, bike, etc

They shouldn’t be.

Rosscameasdoody · 11/12/2023 13:50

WrongSwanson · 11/12/2023 13:28

So much ignorance about hidden disability. My condition doesn't make me walk differently or look different, it doesn't even cause me pain. It doesn't mean I don't need a space. It causes profound weakness that gets worse throughout the day. To the point if I over do it I can't lift my head or arms off the bed or even speak. So you don't get to judge a hidden disability based on a snapshot in time

Simply stating facts as you see them isn’t ignorant. I also have a hidden disability and before I was confined to a wheelchair I was challenged numerous times when using disabled concessions because my condition wasn’t obvious . I don’t have a problem with it either - as long as the challenge is polite, relevant and not intrusive. If, as disabled people - regardless of whether the disability is hidden or not - we don’t challenge when we think we have reason, then we risk the further erosion of resources meant for our use. We all know that that these resources - accessible spaces, blue badge parking, etc, - are open to widespread abuse. So if you aren’t open to the suggestion that it’s up to us to challenge in order to protect these resources, what do you think the solution should be ?

I think the comments about disabled parking spaces are valid and I really don’t think it’s unreasonable to suggest that if someone can jump out of a car with no difficulty and run in four inch heels, then whatever hidden disability they may have is not impacting their mobility at that present time, so it’s really not appropriate for them to be taking up a space which someone else may be genuinely in need of. This is basic common sense. More and more, blue badges seem to be issued with no consideration of whether the specific qualifying disability actually impacts mobility, and at the same time disabled parking in town and city centres is becoming harder to access. There seems to be a correlation between the two, and only on MN is it considered judgmental or ignorant to suggest that.

WrongSwanson · 11/12/2023 13:28

pam290358 · 11/12/2023 12:59

We agree to disagree then, ok. And we’ll also have to agree to disagree on challenging people using accessible toilets if there’s a suspicion that they’re abusing them. I’m not talking about abusive or intrusive questioning or demanding to know the details of the condition. I’m talking about people simply pointing out that the facilities are there for the disabled.

As I explained upthread I’ve been challenged like this numerous times and where it’s polite, not intrusive or offensive, and intended to protect the facility from abuse, I see no reason to be offended - if they’re just being nosy and intrusive they get short shrift and I’m not suggesting for a moment that anyone needs to disclose details of their condition. If you’re eligible to use the facilities you just say so - if they persist, it’s ’mind your own business’. End of. Some people here seem to think disabled people are delicate doily’s and need to be cosseted. We don’t. We’re perfectly capable of speaking up when we need to, and should be invested in keeping these facilities free from abuse and available to those who need them.

Same with disabled parking spaces. Abuse is widespread but people get flamed on MN for challenging even those who are clearly abusing them - if someone pulls up into a disabled space, jumps out of the car in 4 inch heels and runs into the shop, regardless of any hidden disability, they clearly don’t need to take up a disabled space, while someone may be driving round looking for somewhere to safely use a wheelchair, or for a space nearer the door because walking is difficult or painful. Blue badges are being handed out like sweets if what I see locally is anything to go by, and if a hidden disability doesn’t affect your mobility then I don’t see the need. If we don’t challenge when it’s reasonable these concessions will end up meaningless.

So much ignorance about hidden disability. My condition doesn't make me walk differently or look different, it doesn't even cause me pain. It doesn't mean I don't need a space. It causes profound weakness that gets worse throughout the day. To the point if I over do it I can't lift my head or arms off the bed or even speak. So you don't get to judge a hidden disability based on a snapshot in time

Wednesday6 · 11/12/2023 13:25

Could that have been a child? They are often taken to accessible ones when the parent has pushchair, bike, etc

pam290358 · 11/12/2023 13:13

mollypuss1 · 11/12/2023 13:08

We will have to agree to disagree. Just because you see no reason to be offended by being questioned (no matter how politely) not everyone else feels the same. There are plenty other posters on this thread who have said similar. That doesn’t mean those people are ‘delicate doily's’ as you put it.

Yep, agree. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, and to have their say on a pubic forum. I’m disabled myself, have been all my life, so I understand the challenges and I’m just as entitled to my opinion as anyone else. And you, and everyone else on this thread are just as entitled to either agree or disagree with it. That’s the beauty of free speech.

mollypuss1 · 11/12/2023 13:08

We will have to agree to disagree. Just because you see no reason to be offended by being questioned (no matter how politely) not everyone else feels the same. There are plenty other posters on this thread who have said similar. That doesn’t mean those people are ‘delicate doily's’ as you put it.

pam290358 · 11/12/2023 12:59

mollypuss1 · 11/12/2023 11:40

They did recount actual experiences before I posted this, however that doesn’t change the fact that this response was to a comment they made to me prior to them doing so. Their comments afterwards are irrelevant to my response to this specific post. I did read ‘that far’, I’ve read the whole thread. It still doesn’t change my response to this post made prior to those comments. However, I don’t agree that it is ever acceptable to call someone out for using a disabled toilet when there is no way of knowing if they truly need it or not without questioning them. Disabled people should not have to explain their disabilities to anyone.

We agree to disagree then, ok. And we’ll also have to agree to disagree on challenging people using accessible toilets if there’s a suspicion that they’re abusing them. I’m not talking about abusive or intrusive questioning or demanding to know the details of the condition. I’m talking about people simply pointing out that the facilities are there for the disabled.

As I explained upthread I’ve been challenged like this numerous times and where it’s polite, not intrusive or offensive, and intended to protect the facility from abuse, I see no reason to be offended - if they’re just being nosy and intrusive they get short shrift and I’m not suggesting for a moment that anyone needs to disclose details of their condition. If you’re eligible to use the facilities you just say so - if they persist, it’s ’mind your own business’. End of. Some people here seem to think disabled people are delicate doily’s and need to be cosseted. We don’t. We’re perfectly capable of speaking up when we need to, and should be invested in keeping these facilities free from abuse and available to those who need them.

Same with disabled parking spaces. Abuse is widespread but people get flamed on MN for challenging even those who are clearly abusing them - if someone pulls up into a disabled space, jumps out of the car in 4 inch heels and runs into the shop, regardless of any hidden disability, they clearly don’t need to take up a disabled space, while someone may be driving round looking for somewhere to safely use a wheelchair, or for a space nearer the door because walking is difficult or painful. Blue badges are being handed out like sweets if what I see locally is anything to go by, and if a hidden disability doesn’t affect your mobility then I don’t see the need. If we don’t challenge when it’s reasonable these concessions will end up meaningless.

pam290358 · 11/12/2023 12:38

Roosmarjin · 11/12/2023 11:38

It's funny how disabled people (generally, I'm aware that twitter / x isn't representation of disabled people) don't like that term. It's not embracing, it ignores the challenges we face

What really is wrong with disabled? It's not a dirty word

This. Successive governments have also changed the names of sickness and disability benefits so that they don’t reflect disability - think Sickness Benefit becoming Employment and Support Allowance, or Disability Living Allowance becoming Personal Independence Payment. The reasoning for this is becoming clearer as these benefits are made harder and harder to claim by the very ‘disabled’ people they’re supposed to help. So editing out the word ‘disabled’ and replacing it with vague allusions to different abilities, as you so rightly say, makes it easier to ignore the challenges faced by disabled people.

Maybe we should put our energies into practical ways of making the lives of disabled people easier and being more inclusive in behaviour, rather than wasting that energy on pointlessly redefining words that need no further explanation, with phrases that just muddy the waters and are of no practical use to anyone.

pam290358 · 11/12/2023 12:27

Fraaahnces · 11/12/2023 11:30

Don’t be patronizing. Where I live it is the common-use term. It also embraces people with hidden disabilities.

The word ‘disabled’ embraces people with hidden disability just fine, as well as those whose ‘differences’ are there for all the world to see !! Disabled people don’t need to be patronised by having our ‘status’ constantly updated with different PC phrases. Handicapped was a word I didn’t like and I think that was the general consensus, but disabled isn’t offensive or non-inclusive in any way.

Bigstones · 11/12/2023 12:02

Fraaahnces · 11/12/2023 11:30

Don’t be patronizing. Where I live it is the common-use term. It also embraces people with hidden disabilities.

Where do you live? It’s a stupid phrase that perpetrates the myth that being disabled somehow makes people ‘special’ or have special abilities to replace those that they have lost.

My condition doesn’t make me ‘differently abled’, it makes me unable to walk around, need to use continence aids, it makes my arms weak so I can’t feed myself sometimes… it takes away these abilities, literally disabling me.

SawX · 11/12/2023 11:45

Fraaahnces · 11/12/2023 11:30

Don’t be patronizing. Where I live it is the common-use term. It also embraces people with hidden disabilities.

"Differently abled" is patronising. Call us disabled please.

Polimi · 11/12/2023 11:41

Sirzy · 11/12/2023 11:31

It really doesn’t.

disabled is a word that covers it just fine. Wooly phrases don’t help and just make it seem like disabled is some sort of bad word!

Quite, I have a hidden disability, I’m disabled by it not differently abled.

mollypuss1 · 11/12/2023 11:40

pam290358 · 11/12/2023 10:19

No, they clarified what they meant and recounted actual experiences by way of explanation long before you posted this. You just didn’t read that far. They also didn’t accuse the other poster of anything. That poster was clearly angry and took an aggressive tone because she had been challenged and was genuine - that’s always going to happen but it’s no reason to attack another poster for their opinion.

I have a hidden disability - if I’m not in my wheelchair it’s difficult to tell what’s wrong just by looking at me. I’ve been challenged numerous times on using the accessible toilets. Mostly by polite people pointing out that the toilet is not for general use, and yes, there has been the odd ‘you don’t look very disabled’.

And mostly I’ve explained that yes I do have a health condition and am eligible to use the toilet. I don’t take offence and I don’t think many similarly disabled people do either because they recognise that there are piss takers and if they go unchallenged the resources provided to the disabled by these facilities will be eroded. Disabled people are not fragile and precious, and if we all took offence the way some people here seem to, we’d never get out of bed.

If people are polite and accept what you say it’s fine. You’re always going to get goady ignorant and offensive people who demand to know the ins and outs of your condition - because they’re not interested in keeping the facilities clear for those who need them, they’re just nosy. So to them ‘fuck off and mind your own business’ is a complete sentence with no further need for explanation. But I don’t see any reason to be offended if challenged in the right way. The alternative is that these resources will eventually be meaningless.

They did recount actual experiences before I posted this, however that doesn’t change the fact that this response was to a comment they made to me prior to them doing so. Their comments afterwards are irrelevant to my response to this specific post. I did read ‘that far’, I’ve read the whole thread. It still doesn’t change my response to this post made prior to those comments. However, I don’t agree that it is ever acceptable to call someone out for using a disabled toilet when there is no way of knowing if they truly need it or not without questioning them. Disabled people should not have to explain their disabilities to anyone.

Roosmarjin · 11/12/2023 11:38

It's funny how disabled people (generally, I'm aware that twitter / x isn't representation of disabled people) don't like that term. It's not embracing, it ignores the challenges we face

What really is wrong with disabled? It's not a dirty word