Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Banging on the door of the Accessible Toilet

416 replies

HunterHearstHelmsley · 10/12/2023 09:30

Why do people do this?!

I've just used the accessible toilet (I need to use the accessible toilet). I'd barely sat down and someone started banging on the door. I wasn't in there an unreasonable amount of time - probably about 30 seconds when the door banging started and 3 minutes overall. I was in there because I needed to be, banging on the door isn't going to make me quicker. If someone was taking the piss, it'd probably make them stay longer!

It's not the first time it's happened but it's so frustrating. It happened a few weeks ago also, that time was a woman wanting to use the baby change... the baby change wasn't even in the accessible loo!

It's really annoyed me this morning, it's not something I've noticed when using non-accesible toilets so I think it's just an accessible loo thing. But whyyyy?! I can't go faster 😩

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
pollymere · 11/12/2023 23:40

I knock because on some of them, if you turn your key it opens the door even if someone is using it.

It's usually quite a polite knock though.

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 11/12/2023 22:24

FancyFanny · 11/12/2023 20:53

No, you are wrong. There's no regulation or law and many places have one large accessible toilet only. Accessible toilets are so disabled people CAN access the toilet- not so they can avoid a queue.

Where I work, there are only two staff toilets. One is accessible, the other is not! There are currently no staff with disabilities- it is there in case we have visitors that are or staff in the future that are. Are you telling me we should all use the one toilet and leave the other free just in case a disabled person happens to visit. If we employ someone with a disabilty will all the 29 staff have to share one toilet while the one person with a disability has exclusive use of the accessible toilet?

In my work I am the only woman so I get exclusive use of ladies toilet/shower/ locker room. Thirty blokes share the gents ( it is bigger with two loos / two showers and some urinals).

There are people who would quite like to use my shower room and given I’m only onsite for a few hours a week I can understand that having a third of the facilities sit empty most of the time might get annoying. They don’t though because there are rules.

I suspect if a disabled staff member joined the team management would send a message round asking those who do not need it to avoid the accessible facility.

SawX · 11/12/2023 22:14

coffeeaddict77 · 11/12/2023 15:22

Surely you wouldn't run into a shop with heels on then? That would only increase the speed at which the nerves get pinched.

And this is why somebody needs to spend five years in medical school followed by several years' experience before they can question me, or anyone, about their disability. Shame on you.

SawX · 11/12/2023 22:13

Rosscameasdoody · 11/12/2023 14:48

Nice. Common sense is out of the window, so the abusers just carry on because PC behaviour dictates that you can’t reasonably challenge people for fear of causing offence. OK then. This thread is batshit.

"Common sense" like your completely inaccurate assessment that a disabled person could never run a few metres in heels? You don't have sense and you don't have a point.

kaboomy · 11/12/2023 21:32

@DotAndCarryOne2 Sorry but you are wrong. Where an enlarged stand alone unisex accessible toilet room is provided it’s intended solely for the use of disabled people, wheelchair users, and their carers. It’s not for general use. Where smaller single sex facilities are provided within standard male or female toilet facilities, they can be used by non disabled people as they are intended for other users who may, for whatever reason, need a larger space than a standard cubicle.

You are incorrect. They are accessible toilets that anyone can use. There is nothing in law to stop the several public from using them. But as a courtesy people should reserve them for those in need.

As it is impossible to tell whether someone has a disability or illness it is impossible to judge anyone using them anyway.

FancyFanny · 11/12/2023 20:53

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/12/2023 18:46

Sorry but you are wrong. Where an enlarged stand alone unisex accessible toilet room is provided it’s intended solely for the use of disabled people, wheelchair users, and their carers. It’s not for general use. Where smaller single sex facilities are provided within standard male or female toilet facilities, they can be used by non disabled people as they are intended for other users who may, for whatever reason, need a larger space than a standard cubicle.

Edited

No, you are wrong. There's no regulation or law and many places have one large accessible toilet only. Accessible toilets are so disabled people CAN access the toilet- not so they can avoid a queue.

Where I work, there are only two staff toilets. One is accessible, the other is not! There are currently no staff with disabilities- it is there in case we have visitors that are or staff in the future that are. Are you telling me we should all use the one toilet and leave the other free just in case a disabled person happens to visit. If we employ someone with a disabilty will all the 29 staff have to share one toilet while the one person with a disability has exclusive use of the accessible toilet?

juice92 · 11/12/2023 20:30

The larger toilet cubicle with extra handles, in a larger set of cubicles, in my mind should be used by everybody..

BUT

Should a disabled person come to the front of the queue explaining that they need that toilet they should go first and be given priority (this would mean that 99% of the time they'd have to wait a couple of minutes at most). Especially in cases where there is also a separate disabled loo (for example in the office I work in or at many supermarkets) or there might be multiple of these larger cubicles. To keep a cubicle or cubicles empty at all times in times of queues, does not make sense, and could mean that some people who would not normally need an accessible loo could find themselves in an emergency situation (for example someone with mild IBS, a really heavy period, a weak bladder or someone just very very desperate for a wee).

People who are not disabled choosing to use the accessible loo when other options are available, that's wrong. People choosing to use an entirely separate disabled toilet, where there are other toilets (men are awful for using them for poos in the workplace) are also wrong.

The real core issue is though, that we just don't have enough toilets.

BackOfTheMum5net · 11/12/2023 20:11

Since getting a baby and needing to use the only place with a baby change, I have noticed this happening a lot.

A couple of weeks ago somebody obviously decided I wasn’t changing him fast enough and went and asked for the radar key… and were given it! Thankfully they got an eyeful of baby’s bum and not mine!

Isthisexpected · 11/12/2023 19:59

It does make me want to hang on to walking aids when I don't really need them because they provide a modicum of protection from arseholes.

^ I kept my aids longer than I really needed to. I couldn't tell you why at the time but reflection it was because the world was so much less scary with them.

TurquoiseMermaid · 11/12/2023 19:51

People are so determined to be offended it’s utterly pointless.

And the idea that disabled people who want to live free of being policed and confronted are "choosing" to be offended really is the cherry on top.

MrsAvocet · 11/12/2023 19:50

It’s easier now I use a walking stick
Yes I think that is a pretty common experience. My late Dad had rectal cancer at a relatively young age and used disabled toilets to change his colostomy which regularly attracted comments. When he started to walk with a stick the comments instantly dried up even though it was a complete red herring really - he still used regular toilets when he didn't need to change his bag but he now looked disabled enough.
I've noticed similar at various stages after my own operations. I've found an exponential decrease in consideration from other people when external evidence of disability is reduced. I've just had a long spell in plaster and most people were pretty courteous to me when I was out and about. Now on crutches but with no plaster, it's significantly different, and over the next few months my transition to annoying slow middle aged woman that it's ok to shove out of the way will be complete as I learn to walk unaided again. It does make me want to hang on to walking aids when I don't really need them because they provide a modicum of protection from arseholes.

TurquoiseMermaid · 11/12/2023 19:48

in actual fact they are trying to find a solution which will benefit all disabled people.

Except the disabled people you're accosting and forcing into a position of being forced to defend themselves, making them scared because they don't know if you'll believe them or not, what proof you'll demand of them, and what your response will be, whether you'll escalate it or not - they don't know if you're one of the "you don't look disabled" brigade who are physically violent or not, just that you're part of the same gang who are dangerous to disabled people because you think it's okay to confront disabled people.

Disabled people experience insanely high amounts of scrutiny and most people are extremely ignorant about what disability is. We live in a very ableist world, and the Tories and the right wing government have spent years whipping up hatred of disabled people and trying to portray us all as workshy shirkers who steal your tax money and that we all live on benefits and get free cars and are probably faking being disabled anyway. People feel entitled to confront disabled people in a way they wouldn't dream of confronting anyone else (even those engaged in obviously antisocial behaviour) because they think "my taxes pay this person's cushy lifestyle".

Look at every single thread on MN that's about disability, they always end with people claiming to have a neighbour who got a free car and has a flatscreen TV from faking disability, the mentality that disabled people are liars out to scam is extremely widespread, and a big part of how that dangerous mentality is spread is this idea that most disabled people aren't really properly disabled.

More than half of all wheelchair users are ambulatory wheelchair users, many mobility impaired people don't use wheelchairs at all, and plenty of disabled people have disabilities that are not mobility-linked (but may still need to use an accessible loo).

The actress Ruth Madeley (who is a wheelchair user) received huge amounts of abuse after appearing on Doctor Who recently because at one point she was seen with her legs crossed, and people assumed that meant she was just faking needing a wheelchair. A LOT of people think wheelchair=completely 100% paralysed from the waist down, and that anyone who isn't completely paralysed is a faker.

To you, it might just be one comment, but to the disabled person, it might be the 50th comment they've received that week, and some of those comments might have been abusive or threatening, or included actual physical violence. I'm assuming you're a wheelchair user yourself, Lovelysausagedogscrumpy, and that does somewhat make a difference, but fundamentally being confronted and policed about your disability isn't okay.

Because all the comments add up, and when you cannot leave your home without the fear of abuse and people thinking they're entitled to confront you and demand personal information about your body, that creates real fear and trauma. Because the fact is you have no way of knowing whether someone who decides to break social norms by confronting a stranger is violent or not, you have five seconds to make a decision how to handle someone acting outside of social norms so as to reduce the chance they'll take the confrontation further.

The answer seems to be don’t speak up in case of causing offence - just put up with it ?

It's really frightening how often minorities speaking up about how much fear and trauma they experience gets reduced down to "being offended." It happens all the time on threads about racism too, this agenda to portray minorities who want to live their lives without abuse are just choosing to be offended.

Disabled people who just want to be able to use a loo without being challenged are not "offended" we are SCARED.

EggNoggin · 11/12/2023 19:30

What will you get out of this situation?

The warm glow of righteousness I think.

Teder · 11/12/2023 19:25

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 11/12/2023 18:24

If you ask someone who has used an accessible toilet if they know it's an accessible toilet, you're doing it because you've looked at the person, judged that they don't need to use the toilet, and are telling them that. There's no other reason for asking. If you thought they were disabled you wouldn't ask.

No. You’re doing it because it’s a resource reserved for the disabled and you’re not sure if the person has a disability or not. It’s not about judgement, it’s about making sure the resources are available for those who need them. That’s to the advantage of all disabled people so I’m struggling to see why someone with a hidden disability would be offended given that abuse of facilities intended for the disabled is so widespread and that the objective is to protect them for all. Everyone benefits. I give up now. People are so determined to be offended it’s utterly pointless.

Edited

I am not offended in the slightest. I am however, absolutely adamant that I do not owe anyone an explanation on why I am entitled to use the same facilities.

You might very politely approach me and say ”Excuse me, this is a disabled parking space / accessible toilet for the use of people with disabilities“ and I will respond “yes and I need it”

then what?!!! will you be enquiring further? What will you get out of this situation?

The “high heels running” example is just a very exaggerated example. As someone with an invisible disability, I can tell you I walk very slowly and I don’t wear high heels but I do get challenged regularly. It’s easier now I use a walking stick but those people who think they have the right to point out the flaming obvious in a Tesco car park aren’t making a bloody bit of difference to challenging the actual abuse of disabled facilities.

WrongSwanson · 11/12/2023 19:20

EggNoggin · 11/12/2023 19:15

That’s the second time you’ve quoted me and not included the full quote - it puts what I’m saying out of context. As I said, I give up now. It’s pointless.

I did it for brevity considering people will only just have read your own post!

It was also completely reasonable to query that sentence specifically

EggNoggin · 11/12/2023 19:15

That’s the second time you’ve quoted me and not included the full quote - it puts what I’m saying out of context. As I said, I give up now. It’s pointless.

I did it for brevity considering people will only just have read your own post!

WrongSwanson · 11/12/2023 19:10

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 11/12/2023 18:24

If you ask someone who has used an accessible toilet if they know it's an accessible toilet, you're doing it because you've looked at the person, judged that they don't need to use the toilet, and are telling them that. There's no other reason for asking. If you thought they were disabled you wouldn't ask.

No. You’re doing it because it’s a resource reserved for the disabled and you’re not sure if the person has a disability or not. It’s not about judgement, it’s about making sure the resources are available for those who need them. That’s to the advantage of all disabled people so I’m struggling to see why someone with a hidden disability would be offended given that abuse of facilities intended for the disabled is so widespread and that the objective is to protect them for all. Everyone benefits. I give up now. People are so determined to be offended it’s utterly pointless.

Edited

But what has made you unsure other than the fact you can't see the disability? Can you see how crappy this is for people with hidden disability to be constantly doubted and made to explain themselves?

It's shit enough from able bodied people (like the fact some people at work think it's funny to "joke" about how they are being "virtuous" and getting the stairs if they see me waiting for a lift) but it's phenomenally frustrating when it comes from other disabled people

WrongSwanson · 11/12/2023 19:06

I love the way some people believe that them being unsure whether or not another person is disabled entitles them to question people!

This.

It just feels like there is a stupendous level of ignorance about hidden disability.

If someone had the temerity to ask me I think I would just say "no I am using it for fun" and leave it at that. It's none of their business.

And yes I might have taken a child in their with me because they are small and I can't just leave them roaming around outside. Doesn't make me less disabled.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 11/12/2023 18:51

EggNoggin · 11/12/2023 18:43

No. You’re doing it because it’s a resource reserved for the disabled and you’re not sure if the person has a disability or not. It’s not about judgement

Okay, so you ask someone if they know it's an accessible toilet and they say yes. What then? What exactly have you achieved? A pisstaker is hardly going to care are they?

I love the way some people believe that them being unsure whether or not another person is disabled entitles them to question people!

For a start, it's none of your business. Yes, disabled facilities are abused, is it your job to start questioning people, no.

That’s the second time you’ve quoted me and not included the full quote - it puts what I’m saying out of context. As I said, I give up now. It’s pointless.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/12/2023 18:46

FancyFanny · 11/12/2023 18:34

Nobody has a right to challenge anyone about using a disabled toilet. They are there to facilitate wheelchair users and people with disabilities that require additional space or room for a carer to attend. They are not for the 'exclusive' use of people with disabilities, or for anyone to be able to access the toilet immediately at any given time, and there is no law saying that able-bodied people can't use them. There are certain times when the non-disabled might benefit from them- in times of emergency and it's none af anybody'd business why anyone else is using them.

Sorry but you are wrong. Where an enlarged stand alone unisex accessible toilet room is provided it’s intended solely for the use of disabled people, wheelchair users, and their carers. It’s not for general use. Where smaller single sex facilities are provided within standard male or female toilet facilities, they can be used by non disabled people as they are intended for other users who may, for whatever reason, need a larger space than a standard cubicle.

EggNoggin · 11/12/2023 18:43

No. You’re doing it because it’s a resource reserved for the disabled and you’re not sure if the person has a disability or not. It’s not about judgement

Okay, so you ask someone if they know it's an accessible toilet and they say yes. What then? What exactly have you achieved? A pisstaker is hardly going to care are they?

I love the way some people believe that them being unsure whether or not another person is disabled entitles them to question people!

For a start, it's none of your business. Yes, disabled facilities are abused, is it your job to start questioning people, no.

TrixieMixie · 11/12/2023 18:39

It’s very rude to bang on the door. I did it on the train last week though because I could hear a bloke talking on his phone in the loo - he’d been in there for ages!

FancyFanny · 11/12/2023 18:34

Nobody has a right to challenge anyone about using a disabled toilet. They are there to facilitate wheelchair users and people with disabilities that require additional space or room for a carer to attend. They are not for the 'exclusive' use of people with disabilities, or for anyone to be able to access the toilet immediately at any given time, and there is no law saying that able-bodied people can't use them. There are certain times when the non-disabled might benefit from them- in times of emergency and it's none af anybody'd business why anyone else is using them.

fetchacloth · 11/12/2023 18:32

WillowTit · 10/12/2023 11:11

you should say something when you come out,
it is not necessary to bang on the door, you are in there

I've had to say something before in that situation because banging on the door is unnecessary and rude. Banging on the door is not going to speed up the process.
I'm in there because I'm having a wee, not because I fancied a sit down for a while.🙄

Bigstones · 11/12/2023 18:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread