Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Banging on the door of the Accessible Toilet

416 replies

HunterHearstHelmsley · 10/12/2023 09:30

Why do people do this?!

I've just used the accessible toilet (I need to use the accessible toilet). I'd barely sat down and someone started banging on the door. I wasn't in there an unreasonable amount of time - probably about 30 seconds when the door banging started and 3 minutes overall. I was in there because I needed to be, banging on the door isn't going to make me quicker. If someone was taking the piss, it'd probably make them stay longer!

It's not the first time it's happened but it's so frustrating. It happened a few weeks ago also, that time was a woman wanting to use the baby change... the baby change wasn't even in the accessible loo!

It's really annoyed me this morning, it's not something I've noticed when using non-accesible toilets so I think it's just an accessible loo thing. But whyyyy?! I can't go faster 😩

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Sirzy · 12/12/2023 10:12

The key I think is always keeping in mind what we can see of someone is only a tiny picture of their reality.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 12/12/2023 10:05

T1Dmama · 12/12/2023 09:46

I find this so arrogant and ignorant.
I came out of a disabled toilet with my daughter, someone passed a comment about us not ‘looking disabled’….

I always wonder how society got so ignorant to disabilities.

For example colostomy bags are so small these day that you can hide one under a skin tight dress and no one would know…but you need the bigger cubicle in order to manoeuvre, I had a friend have one at 17 for a whole year… it’s awful to think people would bang on the door or shout at her when she left, she went through so much!

My daughter has an invisible disability, we do usually use the normal toilets, but if the queue is ginormous and she’s desperate then we occasionally nip in the accessible one as it is simply safer for not to wait in line… but she hates queue jumping etc because of comments made in the past, which I find extremely sad.

I always wonder how society got so ignorant to disabilities.

Me too. I’m early sixties and in the ‘old days’ most disability benefits were awarded for disabilities that were clearly evident. Disabled loo usage and blue badges were the same. The assumption was that if you couldn’t see it, it wasn’t there. Thankfully we’ve mostly moved on from that, but there are still those who will jump to that conclusion. I think as a society we’ve become a lot more inclusive of disabled people but there’s still a way to go if some of the comments here are anything to go by and translate into the general population beyond MN.

Justfinking · 12/12/2023 10:01

Agree so much with @Bigstones I can honestly say I never recall once in my life when I was so put out because I didn't use the disabled toilet. The attitude of people towards disabled people is truly disgusting

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 12/12/2023 10:00

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 09:26

I presume your DS doesn't drive though. I wouldn't assume that a person that is being driven has no need of a disabled space even if they bounce out of the car and run to the shop as there are obviously many conditions that don't prevent running but still require a blue badge. However, I can't think of any condition whereby the person can drive and run and also needs to park in a disabled space..

Blue badges aren’t just awarded in respect of mobility issues though. They can be for anything from a serious heart condition to having a stoma and urgency/incontinence issues. So being able to run doesn’t necessarily mean you’re not disabled - you may be rushing for the loo before you have an accident or something similar.

pam290358 · 12/12/2023 09:57

Bigstones · 12/12/2023 09:31

I don’t know how many times people need to be told to use common sense… in the (statistically unlikely) event that you don’t have any disabled staff then obviously you use both toilets.

In the event that a single member of staff is disabled- then continue using both since there are only a few of you, but just don’t be a dick about it! You know, maybe just give the disabled member of staff first dibs on the only toilet they can actually use.

I really don’t understand why so many people feel the need to pop up with “but what about?!” gotcha! Comments- do you genuinely think that disabled people are greedy toilet horders that are just revelling in having something you don’t like three year olds with a new doll?

We aren’t, we just want to be able to take a piss like everyone else. You really don’t loose anything by trying your best to keep accessible toilets free for disabled people when at all practicable.

This. Well said.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 12/12/2023 09:54

Sirzy · 12/12/2023 09:31

Just because you can’t think of a condition doesn’t mean it doesn’t exisit. That’s why people with more understanding of the individual decide who should and shouldn’t have a blue badge.

in the whole they are a battle to get in the first place

I agree. There’s actually another thread on here about PIP (Personal Independence Payment) and some of the comments actually suggest that the Motability scheme should be abolished because if you can drive, you’re not really disabled !! But I do think, as others have suggested, that if you have a variable condition and are able to park elsewhere on good days then you should. And on the question of being able to run, thinking about it, I think people need to remember that blue badges are not just awarded for mobility issues - they can be in respect of heart conditions, incontinence and other issues unrelated to mobility.

T1Dmama · 12/12/2023 09:46

Sell123 · 10/12/2023 10:03

I've had this. I have an invisible disability. When I left, an old lady shouted at me that I shouldn't be in there etc.

I find this so arrogant and ignorant.
I came out of a disabled toilet with my daughter, someone passed a comment about us not ‘looking disabled’….

I always wonder how society got so ignorant to disabilities.

For example colostomy bags are so small these day that you can hide one under a skin tight dress and no one would know…but you need the bigger cubicle in order to manoeuvre, I had a friend have one at 17 for a whole year… it’s awful to think people would bang on the door or shout at her when she left, she went through so much!

My daughter has an invisible disability, we do usually use the normal toilets, but if the queue is ginormous and she’s desperate then we occasionally nip in the accessible one as it is simply safer for not to wait in line… but she hates queue jumping etc because of comments made in the past, which I find extremely sad.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 12/12/2023 09:38

Peablockfeathers · 12/12/2023 08:55

But people self governing spaces and facilities invariably will catch plenty of people with a genuine need in the cross fire and its horrible to feel like you have to justify yourself to someone. In honesty do you really think someone who thinks it's fine to use facilities when they don't need them because they're selfish is going to listen to someone taking it upon themselves to challenge them? No. But it could well really affect someone else.

I agree. I think it’s really difficult and I’ve experienced both sides of the coin so to speak. I’m old school, as you may have gathered by some of my posts and replies - been disabled since birth with a degenerative condition, and am now in my early sixties. When I was younger I could walk fairly well but have bladder and bowel problems which necessitated the use of the then ‘disabled’ toilets. I’ve been challenged numerous times over the years and have come to the conclusion that if you ignore the arseholes who just want to be nosy and demand you give every detail of your condition, most people are only looking out for others by challenging and are mostly reasonable - many people if not disabled themselves have told me that they have disabled relatives and have seen them struggle because they couldn’t access the facilities, so I think you have to look at the reasoning.

I don’t get challenged so much these days because I’m mostly in a wheelchair, but I do get it that when you’re desperate and don’t have much control, finding the accessible loo occupied by someone who doesn’t seem to have much need for it is frustrating. But hidden disability exists, so it’s difficult to tell who is in need and who is just selfish. I have able bodied friends who will openly tell me they will always use the ‘disabled’ loo because the facilities are so much more convenient - more room, hand basin next to the loo, hand drier etc. it’s completely lost on them that those facilities are not meant for them.

I think challenging someone who doesn’t look disabled is not ideal, but as disabled people we all know facilities like accessible toilets and blue badge spaces are widely abused, but as disabled people we don’t want to unnecessarily cause anyone else distress. So other than challenging respectfully and with the experience that comes from being disabled ourselves, I don’t think there is an easy solution.

What I do agree with though, is the post upthread which suggests that just because you have legitimate eligibility for something, it doesn’t mean that you should use it if you don’t need to. I’m another who has had a blue badge for years - old enough to remember when it was the orange badge !! On my good days I wouldn’t use it. Similarly accessible toilets. Maybe if we all self regulate as a starting point and examine our own behaviour with regard to entitlement for entitlement’s sake, that would help, and maybe if/when we are challenged try to remember that it’s probably not a personal slight against you, but someone just trying to ensure these facilities are better targeted . Beyond that I don’t know what the answer is.

Sirzy · 12/12/2023 09:31

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 09:26

I presume your DS doesn't drive though. I wouldn't assume that a person that is being driven has no need of a disabled space even if they bounce out of the car and run to the shop as there are obviously many conditions that don't prevent running but still require a blue badge. However, I can't think of any condition whereby the person can drive and run and also needs to park in a disabled space..

Just because you can’t think of a condition doesn’t mean it doesn’t exisit. That’s why people with more understanding of the individual decide who should and shouldn’t have a blue badge.

in the whole they are a battle to get in the first place

Bigstones · 12/12/2023 09:31

FancyFanny · 11/12/2023 20:53

No, you are wrong. There's no regulation or law and many places have one large accessible toilet only. Accessible toilets are so disabled people CAN access the toilet- not so they can avoid a queue.

Where I work, there are only two staff toilets. One is accessible, the other is not! There are currently no staff with disabilities- it is there in case we have visitors that are or staff in the future that are. Are you telling me we should all use the one toilet and leave the other free just in case a disabled person happens to visit. If we employ someone with a disabilty will all the 29 staff have to share one toilet while the one person with a disability has exclusive use of the accessible toilet?

I don’t know how many times people need to be told to use common sense… in the (statistically unlikely) event that you don’t have any disabled staff then obviously you use both toilets.

In the event that a single member of staff is disabled- then continue using both since there are only a few of you, but just don’t be a dick about it! You know, maybe just give the disabled member of staff first dibs on the only toilet they can actually use.

I really don’t understand why so many people feel the need to pop up with “but what about?!” gotcha! Comments- do you genuinely think that disabled people are greedy toilet horders that are just revelling in having something you don’t like three year olds with a new doll?

We aren’t, we just want to be able to take a piss like everyone else. You really don’t loose anything by trying your best to keep accessible toilets free for disabled people when at all practicable.

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 09:29

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 08:33

Surely the point in this context is that if you can run in heels and you are using a parking space intended for someone who has mobility difficulties you should be selective in how you use your badge. On a good day when you can run in your four inchers, maybe leave the space for someone else. I have a fluctuating condition and on days when I can walk pain free and don’t have to use my chair, I park elsewhere. There are people for whom not finding a disabled space in a supermarket car park means they can’t do their shopping. It’s called consideration for others. Just because you have the badge doesn’t mean you should use it if and when you don’t need to.

Exactly. I only use disabled parking if I need it too.

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 09:26

Sirzy · 12/12/2023 08:38

That depends on the nature of the condition though.

ds generally doesn’t wear heels but on a good day can bounce out of the car and look fine. But that can change in an instant and he can have a flare of one of his conditions meaning he is in pain/struggling to breathe/at risk of unconsciousness or in a massive meltdown over something. He needs to be able to get to the car quickly hence having a blue badge.

now we could use his wheelchair every trip but when we don’t need it we don’t and shouldn’t have to to avoid other people thinking they are experts!

I presume your DS doesn't drive though. I wouldn't assume that a person that is being driven has no need of a disabled space even if they bounce out of the car and run to the shop as there are obviously many conditions that don't prevent running but still require a blue badge. However, I can't think of any condition whereby the person can drive and run and also needs to park in a disabled space..

Peablockfeathers · 12/12/2023 08:55

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 12/12/2023 08:36

Or possibly less piss takers using facilities not meant for them, if they know they will be challenged ?

But people self governing spaces and facilities invariably will catch plenty of people with a genuine need in the cross fire and its horrible to feel like you have to justify yourself to someone. In honesty do you really think someone who thinks it's fine to use facilities when they don't need them because they're selfish is going to listen to someone taking it upon themselves to challenge them? No. But it could well really affect someone else.

Sirzy · 12/12/2023 08:38

That depends on the nature of the condition though.

ds generally doesn’t wear heels but on a good day can bounce out of the car and look fine. But that can change in an instant and he can have a flare of one of his conditions meaning he is in pain/struggling to breathe/at risk of unconsciousness or in a massive meltdown over something. He needs to be able to get to the car quickly hence having a blue badge.

now we could use his wheelchair every trip but when we don’t need it we don’t and shouldn’t have to to avoid other people thinking they are experts!

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 12/12/2023 08:36

EggNoggin · 11/12/2023 19:30

What will you get out of this situation?

The warm glow of righteousness I think.

Or possibly less piss takers using facilities not meant for them, if they know they will be challenged ?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 08:33

SawX · 11/12/2023 22:13

"Common sense" like your completely inaccurate assessment that a disabled person could never run a few metres in heels? You don't have sense and you don't have a point.

Surely the point in this context is that if you can run in heels and you are using a parking space intended for someone who has mobility difficulties you should be selective in how you use your badge. On a good day when you can run in your four inchers, maybe leave the space for someone else. I have a fluctuating condition and on days when I can walk pain free and don’t have to use my chair, I park elsewhere. There are people for whom not finding a disabled space in a supermarket car park means they can’t do their shopping. It’s called consideration for others. Just because you have the badge doesn’t mean you should use it if and when you don’t need to.

pam290358 · 12/12/2023 08:20

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/12/2023 08:07

Where an enlarged stand alone unisex accessible toilet room is provided it’s intended solely for the use of disabled people, wheelchair users, and their carers. It’s not for general use

That isn't true - if you are eg in Costa and the only loo is like that, anyone can use it. They just make their sole loo accessible because they don't have space for more.

However, without wanting to play disability top trumps, people in wheelchairs get priority in my view. If you have a health condition that doesn't affect your mobility, you can find another loo to use. The person in a wheelchair can't.

It's a bit like using a lift because you can. If you can use the stairs, do, and leave the lift for those who need it.

Sorry but it is true. Have a look at building regulations and the Equality Act. Dispensation is granted where premises are too small to provide standard facilities as well as an accessible toilet, and they make the accessible loo available to all, so that they are technically fulfilling their obligation to provide accessible facilities for those who need them. Where premises provide standard male/female facilities and a unisex stand alone accessible toilet, it is for the use of disabled people and their carers, and not up for grabs when you don’t feel like queuing.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 08:10

FancyFanny · 12/12/2023 07:39

Why would they? Being in a wheelchair doesn't mean you need the toilet to be available immediately with no queue does it? Disabled doesn't = bowel problem! The toilet is there so that we can offer wheelchair users the use of the toilet, not the right to never wait!

There is some confusion as to accessible toilets on this thread. If single sex enlarged accessible cubicles are provided within standard male/female toilets they can be used by anyone who requires extra space - not necessarily exclusively disabled people. Where a stand alone unisex accessible toilet room is provided separately from standard male/female facilities, that is exclusively for the use of disabled people and their carers. It’s not a separate toilet to be utilised when you can’t be bothered to wait in a queue.

I’ve volunteered for disability charities helping with PIP applications for many years and I’ve never come across a wheelchair user yet who hasn’t got a bowel or bladder problem, and in most cases both. Any disability which affects the spine will almost certainly carry with it some effect on bodily function and with conditions like Spina Bifida there can be serious urgency or total loss of control - whether or not the person is in a wheelchair and many other disabilities commonly include incontinence and urgency, not to mention the use of catheters and stomas.

If we expect disabled people to work and contribute do you not think it reasonable to provide proper facilities so that they are not put at risk of the humiliation of having an accident at work because they can’t access facilities which are actually meant for them ?

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/12/2023 08:08

Why would they? Being in a wheelchair doesn't mean you need the toilet to be available immediately with no queue does it? Disabled doesn't = bowel problem! The toilet is there so that we can offer wheelchair users the use of the toilet, not the right to never wait

but it does mean they can't easily find another one that is wide enough to allow them inside with their wheelchair.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/12/2023 08:07

Where an enlarged stand alone unisex accessible toilet room is provided it’s intended solely for the use of disabled people, wheelchair users, and their carers. It’s not for general use

That isn't true - if you are eg in Costa and the only loo is like that, anyone can use it. They just make their sole loo accessible because they don't have space for more.

However, without wanting to play disability top trumps, people in wheelchairs get priority in my view. If you have a health condition that doesn't affect your mobility, you can find another loo to use. The person in a wheelchair can't.

It's a bit like using a lift because you can. If you can use the stairs, do, and leave the lift for those who need it.

Greezynogreasy · 12/12/2023 07:49

Very bad mannered and entitled to knock on a toilet door.
Disability can be invisible eg people who need to self catheterise but are able to walk perfectly well without aids.

There is still a lot of ignorance regarding disability.

FancyFanny · 12/12/2023 07:39

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 11/12/2023 22:24

In my work I am the only woman so I get exclusive use of ladies toilet/shower/ locker room. Thirty blokes share the gents ( it is bigger with two loos / two showers and some urinals).

There are people who would quite like to use my shower room and given I’m only onsite for a few hours a week I can understand that having a third of the facilities sit empty most of the time might get annoying. They don’t though because there are rules.

I suspect if a disabled staff member joined the team management would send a message round asking those who do not need it to avoid the accessible facility.

Why would they? Being in a wheelchair doesn't mean you need the toilet to be available immediately with no queue does it? Disabled doesn't = bowel problem! The toilet is there so that we can offer wheelchair users the use of the toilet, not the right to never wait!

Fraaahnces · 12/12/2023 02:16

I’m not in the habit of challenging people because up until recently, I had a friend with cystic fibrosis. She was young and pretty and able to walk approximately 10-20 meters on a good day. After that, a wheelchair was absolutely needed. She was challenged frequently.
I must admit that I often think about the dickheads that prop in disabled car parks with the engine running while they are waiting for someone they’ve just dropped off.

SawX · 12/12/2023 00:35

I've thought a lot about using a stick even though it doesn't help me, but just as some kind of visual representation of the pain I'm in. But then I think no, fuck it and fuck the people who think they have the right to judge my disability.

Passingthethyme · 11/12/2023 23:42

MrsAvocet · 11/12/2023 19:50

It’s easier now I use a walking stick
Yes I think that is a pretty common experience. My late Dad had rectal cancer at a relatively young age and used disabled toilets to change his colostomy which regularly attracted comments. When he started to walk with a stick the comments instantly dried up even though it was a complete red herring really - he still used regular toilets when he didn't need to change his bag but he now looked disabled enough.
I've noticed similar at various stages after my own operations. I've found an exponential decrease in consideration from other people when external evidence of disability is reduced. I've just had a long spell in plaster and most people were pretty courteous to me when I was out and about. Now on crutches but with no plaster, it's significantly different, and over the next few months my transition to annoying slow middle aged woman that it's ok to shove out of the way will be complete as I learn to walk unaided again. It does make me want to hang on to walking aids when I don't really need them because they provide a modicum of protection from arseholes.

This is really depressing, I do wonder if it's because there are so many CF about (just look at this thread), so people basically don't trust anyone anymore and don't give people the benefit of the doubt. I must say, I myslef have become much more cynical of people over the past few years (not about this topic specifically, but things in general). It's the breakdown of a well functioning society really, where it's every person for themselves and to hell with anyone else. It's very sad