Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Banging on the door of the Accessible Toilet

416 replies

HunterHearstHelmsley · 10/12/2023 09:30

Why do people do this?!

I've just used the accessible toilet (I need to use the accessible toilet). I'd barely sat down and someone started banging on the door. I wasn't in there an unreasonable amount of time - probably about 30 seconds when the door banging started and 3 minutes overall. I was in there because I needed to be, banging on the door isn't going to make me quicker. If someone was taking the piss, it'd probably make them stay longer!

It's not the first time it's happened but it's so frustrating. It happened a few weeks ago also, that time was a woman wanting to use the baby change... the baby change wasn't even in the accessible loo!

It's really annoyed me this morning, it's not something I've noticed when using non-accesible toilets so I think it's just an accessible loo thing. But whyyyy?! I can't go faster 😩

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
pam290358 · 12/12/2023 12:46

Bigstones · 12/12/2023 12:42

No.

Larger accessible cubicles in a row of cubicles were probably installed for the use of everyone who needs more space (so people with small children etc).

Stand alone accessible toilets are installed with the intention of them being for the sole use of disabled people, unless they are the only toilets- eg, a lot of Starbucks have only one large accessible bathroom.

That is why you frequently need a special key to open them (and a lot of venues you have to go and request a key, you can’t even use your own radar key).

They are not there to ‘make everyone’s life easier’ they are there so that disabled people who are unable to use a normal toilet can actually access a toilet when they are out, and therefore we don't have to stay at home forever.

No- no one has bothered to enshrine this in law so you won’t get arrested for deciding you can’t be arsed to queue for a normal toilet and using the accessible one instead. You probably won’t even be challenged by anyone- but you will be behaving like a selfish wanker.

This thread is like banging my head against a brick wall.

I think I’m out as well. Banging your head against a brick wall describes it perfectly.

Bigstones · 12/12/2023 12:42

Redebs · 12/12/2023 11:12

Accessible toilets are supposed to make everyone's life easier. There's no point in leaving it empty if there's a queue for normal stalls and no one needs it.
I used to use one if I needed to during a heavy period, because I needed a sink inside the cubicle. That's completely reasonable, I think.

People with urinary urgency or IBS might need to use one, even though they don't have a disability.
Some people with small children need the space. Pregnant women might need it.

The toilet is accessible to make life easier for people with additional needs.

No.

Larger accessible cubicles in a row of cubicles were probably installed for the use of everyone who needs more space (so people with small children etc).

Stand alone accessible toilets are installed with the intention of them being for the sole use of disabled people, unless they are the only toilets- eg, a lot of Starbucks have only one large accessible bathroom.

That is why you frequently need a special key to open them (and a lot of venues you have to go and request a key, you can’t even use your own radar key).

They are not there to ‘make everyone’s life easier’ they are there so that disabled people who are unable to use a normal toilet can actually access a toilet when they are out, and therefore we don't have to stay at home forever.

No- no one has bothered to enshrine this in law so you won’t get arrested for deciding you can’t be arsed to queue for a normal toilet and using the accessible one instead. You probably won’t even be challenged by anyone- but you will be behaving like a selfish wanker.

This thread is like banging my head against a brick wall.

Bigstones · 12/12/2023 12:31

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 11:06

According to this, a stoma alone would not normally entitle you to a blue badge. People with one have probably got additional health issues that mean they are entitled to one. https://iasupport.org/information-support/faqs/

There is a lot of variation in how LA’s interpret the blue badge guidelines so there is an element of pot luck.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 12/12/2023 12:14

EggNoggin · 12/12/2023 12:11

You’re posting on a thread condemning people for being judgmental, but you don’t seem to have any difficulty in being judgmental yourself do you ?

I'm certainly judging you because of the ignorance of your actions, yes. Disabled people on this thread have pointed out to you how they feel when approached by the toilet police. And you keep talking about a workable solution. Well, isn't it obvious that your idea of a workable solution isn't?

Many people with hidden disabilities just want to be left alone to get on with their lives without people such as yourself intruding on their daily activities.

But no, you continue to think your own actions are perfectly fine, even when other disabled people tell you they're not.

There have been people here talking about using a stick when they don't need one, just so people like you will leave them alone.

So yes I judge you for going out of your way to make other disabled people's lives even more awkward than they already are.

Edited

Can’t be bothered with this any more. You’ve clearly not read my posts or you’ve not understood them. This is a terrible thread, way off course from the original point of the OP and a godsend for people bent on misunderstanding and attacking others. Far from discouraging judgment, the thread is full of it. I’m out.

EggNoggin · 12/12/2023 12:11

You’re posting on a thread condemning people for being judgmental, but you don’t seem to have any difficulty in being judgmental yourself do you ?

I'm certainly judging you because of the ignorance of your actions, yes. Disabled people on this thread have pointed out to you how they feel when approached by the toilet police. And you keep talking about a workable solution. Well, isn't it obvious that your idea of a workable solution isn't?

Many people with hidden disabilities just want to be left alone to get on with their lives without people such as yourself intruding on their daily activities.

But no, you continue to think your own actions are perfectly fine, even when other disabled people tell you they're not.

There have been people here talking about using a stick when they don't need one, just so people like you will leave them alone.

So yes I judge you for going out of your way to make other disabled people's lives even more awkward than they already are.

Rosscameasdoody · 12/12/2023 12:08

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/12/2023 11:46

And FYI heavy periods do not constitute a disability unless there’s an underlying condition causing them, but IBS and other conditions causing urinary or bowel urgency/incontinence, definitely do

And FYI, heavy periods are not normal so there IS an underlying condition causing them, but most women don't know what it is.

I did actually qualify what I said - it’s even in your quote. I was making the distinction between someone needing to use the accessible toilet because of a health condition affecting periods, and someone just nipping in to change sanitary products.

pam290358 · 12/12/2023 12:03

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 11:58

Yes, I have a blue badge myself and am well aware that it often comes down to the opinion of the person interviewing whether you need one. However, I don't think a stoma alone would mean someone gets one nowadays. They either answered the questions in a way that suggested they have additional health needs or your experience relates to a few years ago (,it has been made harder to get one more recently)

We’ll have to agree to disagree then. I’ve done several blue badge applications and if you say you have a health condition you have to back it up with medical evidence, so you can’t just suggest it. As I said, it’s my experience that local authorities can and do use discretion to award in this way when the condition dictates it.

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 11:58

pam290358 · 12/12/2023 11:51

These are guidelines only, and ileostomy is only one of a range of stomas which deal with different aspect of bodily function. I worked and volunteered within several different disabilty charities and have known quite a few people granted a blue badge in respect of a stoma or and other bowel conditions such as severe IBS and Crohn’s disease, with no other disability present. If the stoma isn’t well controlled, Crohns or IBS is severe, or the person has little or no control over bowel or bladder, and is vulnerable to accidents then local authorities have the discretion to grant the badge according to the level of severity.

Yes, I have a blue badge myself and am well aware that it often comes down to the opinion of the person interviewing whether you need one. However, I don't think a stoma alone would mean someone gets one nowadays. They either answered the questions in a way that suggested they have additional health needs or your experience relates to a few years ago (,it has been made harder to get one more recently)

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 12/12/2023 11:57

EggNoggin · 12/12/2023 11:46

Oh don't be ridiculous. Like has been said many times on this thread, ignorant people like yourself who take it upon yourselves to be the toilet police are causing people with less obvious disabilities distress. But you don't care about that, such is your zeal for catching out supposed pisstakers and feeling smug about it.

I am neither ignorant nor smug and if you read back through my posts you’ll see that I’ve tried to make considered replies from the point of view of being disabled myself. And there are several posters here posting in a similar vein. All have been similarly attacked. it’s not about catching out the pisstakers and feeling smug about it and there is no intention to cause distress to those with less obvious disabilities distress. It’s about trying to find a workable solution to make sure as far as possible that the facilities provided for the use of disabled people are kept for that purpose. It’s to the benefit of all disabled people - hidden disability or otherwise.

You’re posting on a thread condemning people for being judgmental, but you don’t seem to have any difficulty in being judgmental yourself do you ?

pam290358 · 12/12/2023 11:51

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 11:06

According to this, a stoma alone would not normally entitle you to a blue badge. People with one have probably got additional health issues that mean they are entitled to one. https://iasupport.org/information-support/faqs/

These are guidelines only, and ileostomy is only one of a range of stomas which deal with different aspect of bodily function. I worked and volunteered within several different disabilty charities and have known quite a few people granted a blue badge in respect of a stoma or and other bowel conditions such as severe IBS and Crohn’s disease, with no other disability present. If the stoma isn’t well controlled, Crohns or IBS is severe, or the person has little or no control over bowel or bladder, and is vulnerable to accidents then local authorities have the discretion to grant the badge according to the level of severity.

EggNoggin · 12/12/2023 11:46

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 12/12/2023 08:36

Or possibly less piss takers using facilities not meant for them, if they know they will be challenged ?

Oh don't be ridiculous. Like has been said many times on this thread, ignorant people like yourself who take it upon yourselves to be the toilet police are causing people with less obvious disabilities distress. But you don't care about that, such is your zeal for catching out supposed pisstakers and feeling smug about it.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/12/2023 11:46

And FYI heavy periods do not constitute a disability unless there’s an underlying condition causing them, but IBS and other conditions causing urinary or bowel urgency/incontinence, definitely do

And FYI, heavy periods are not normal so there IS an underlying condition causing them, but most women don't know what it is.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/12/2023 11:45

Just because you can’t think of a condition doesn’t mean it doesn’t exisit. That’s why people with more understanding of the individual decide who should and shouldn’t have a blue badge. in the whole they are a battle to get in the first place

They are, but the point remains that those who are mobile have options and those who are in a wheelchair do not.

It's worth reading Melanie Reid's column on this - she is a tetraplegic after a horseriding accident and wrote an article for the Sunday Times about 10 days ago. She talked about trying to get a disabled bay at a hospital and seeing ambulant people using bays. I can totally see why she'd be frustrated.

I also think it's fine for someone with heavy periods to use an accessible loo, but not if a wheelchair user is waiting. Use the standard loos instead (assuming they are available and it's not Costa with one single loo).

Rosscameasdoody · 12/12/2023 11:41

Redebs · 12/12/2023 11:12

Accessible toilets are supposed to make everyone's life easier. There's no point in leaving it empty if there's a queue for normal stalls and no one needs it.
I used to use one if I needed to during a heavy period, because I needed a sink inside the cubicle. That's completely reasonable, I think.

People with urinary urgency or IBS might need to use one, even though they don't have a disability.
Some people with small children need the space. Pregnant women might need it.

The toilet is accessible to make life easier for people with additional needs.

Once again this is not correct and has been addressed several times on the thread. Single sex larger cubicles within standard male/female toilet blocks are meant for access by anyone who needs more space - not necessarily disabled. Think mums with pushchairs. Separate unisex large stand alone accessible toilets are meant to accommodate wheelchair users as well as the ambulant disabled, and are meant solely for the use of disabled people and their carers. They are not there to mitigate queues for standard toilets. And FYI heavy periods do not constitute a disability unless there’s an underlying condition causing them, but IBS and other conditions causing urinary or bowel urgency/incontinence, definitely do.

EggNoggin · 12/12/2023 11:40

Spendonsend · 12/12/2023 11:12

The most eye opning thing is that if 24% of people have some sort of disability why on earth have we got such poor toilet provision in general. I dont see a quater of toilets being accessible toilets.

It's absolutely appalling.

And some supposedly accessible toilets are so tiny you can barely move in them when there's a wheelchair user plus carer.

It's very obvious who is trying to get away with the minimum provision possible and who actually cares about providing a decent quality toilet for those with additional requirements.

Those who believe they have the right to harass people using these toilets would be better off expending their energies campaigning for better provision, both in quantity and quality.

Rosscameasdoody · 12/12/2023 11:34

Spendonsend · 12/12/2023 11:12

The most eye opning thing is that if 24% of people have some sort of disability why on earth have we got such poor toilet provision in general. I dont see a quater of toilets being accessible toilets.

Because government doesn’t care about disabled people. Tory government in particular. Look at how disability benefits have been tinkered with over the years so that fewer people are eligible. It’s not that they are not disabled, just that the benefits they need are put beyond their reach in the name of preventing fraud, when we all know that fraud in disability benefits is less than 2%. If they don’t care about proper support, they’re certainly not going to care about whether we can pee when we need to !!

Redebs · 12/12/2023 11:18

FancyFanny · 11/12/2023 18:34

Nobody has a right to challenge anyone about using a disabled toilet. They are there to facilitate wheelchair users and people with disabilities that require additional space or room for a carer to attend. They are not for the 'exclusive' use of people with disabilities, or for anyone to be able to access the toilet immediately at any given time, and there is no law saying that able-bodied people can't use them. There are certain times when the non-disabled might benefit from them- in times of emergency and it's none af anybody'd business why anyone else is using them.

Absolutely so

Spendonsend · 12/12/2023 11:12

The most eye opning thing is that if 24% of people have some sort of disability why on earth have we got such poor toilet provision in general. I dont see a quater of toilets being accessible toilets.

Redebs · 12/12/2023 11:12

Accessible toilets are supposed to make everyone's life easier. There's no point in leaving it empty if there's a queue for normal stalls and no one needs it.
I used to use one if I needed to during a heavy period, because I needed a sink inside the cubicle. That's completely reasonable, I think.

People with urinary urgency or IBS might need to use one, even though they don't have a disability.
Some people with small children need the space. Pregnant women might need it.

The toilet is accessible to make life easier for people with additional needs.

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 11:06

Rosscameasdoody · 12/12/2023 11:00

I think they were just examples of disability not directly linked to mobility. But in my own experience blue badges absolutely are issued for continence issues alone. Stoma patients and those with incontinence/severe urgency issues can access the blue badge scheme without any other disability or mobility issue if their condition is severe enough to cause involuntary voiding or they have an unstable and difficult to manage stoma.

Edited

According to this, a stoma alone would not normally entitle you to a blue badge. People with one have probably got additional health issues that mean they are entitled to one. https://iasupport.org/information-support/faqs/

FAQs - Ileostomy & Internal Pouch Association

https://iasupport.org/information-support/faqs

Rosscameasdoody · 12/12/2023 11:00

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 10:31

Someone with a serious heart condition probably wouldn't be driving and running. I'm pretty sure urge or continence issues alone wouldn't make someone eligible for a blue badge (although obviously it is a reason for using disabled toilets) where I live.

I think they were just examples of disability not directly linked to mobility. But in my own experience blue badges absolutely are issued for continence issues alone. Stoma patients and those with incontinence/severe urgency issues can access the blue badge scheme without any other disability or mobility issue if their condition is severe enough to cause involuntary voiding or they have an unstable and difficult to manage stoma.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 12/12/2023 10:55

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 10:25

Biology isn't your strong point is it?

I agree, clearly not. Horribly ignorant and ableist comment. Spinal injury is a common reason for people to be confined to a wheelchair, and it can affect bodily function in a range of ways - sometimes very severely and causing issues from urgency, to complete bowel/bladder incontinence and involuntary voiding. Many wheelchair users have stomas for this reason, or have to use catheterisation to control bladder. It’s not just wheelchair users either - many disabilities have bowel and bladder incontinence/urgency in common. I don’t think this poster understands that for some people if they can’t find an available accessible toilet they’re going to have a very public and very embarrassing accident. That’s one of the reasons we have accessible toilets and why the unisex stand alone accessible toilets should always be left free for the sole use of disabled people.

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 10:31

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 12/12/2023 10:00

Blue badges aren’t just awarded in respect of mobility issues though. They can be for anything from a serious heart condition to having a stoma and urgency/incontinence issues. So being able to run doesn’t necessarily mean you’re not disabled - you may be rushing for the loo before you have an accident or something similar.

Someone with a serious heart condition probably wouldn't be driving and running. I'm pretty sure urge or continence issues alone wouldn't make someone eligible for a blue badge (although obviously it is a reason for using disabled toilets) where I live.

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 10:25

FancyFanny · 12/12/2023 07:39

Why would they? Being in a wheelchair doesn't mean you need the toilet to be available immediately with no queue does it? Disabled doesn't = bowel problem! The toilet is there so that we can offer wheelchair users the use of the toilet, not the right to never wait!

Biology isn't your strong point is it?

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 12/12/2023 10:25

juice92 · 11/12/2023 20:30

The larger toilet cubicle with extra handles, in a larger set of cubicles, in my mind should be used by everybody..

BUT

Should a disabled person come to the front of the queue explaining that they need that toilet they should go first and be given priority (this would mean that 99% of the time they'd have to wait a couple of minutes at most). Especially in cases where there is also a separate disabled loo (for example in the office I work in or at many supermarkets) or there might be multiple of these larger cubicles. To keep a cubicle or cubicles empty at all times in times of queues, does not make sense, and could mean that some people who would not normally need an accessible loo could find themselves in an emergency situation (for example someone with mild IBS, a really heavy period, a weak bladder or someone just very very desperate for a wee).

People who are not disabled choosing to use the accessible loo when other options are available, that's wrong. People choosing to use an entirely separate disabled toilet, where there are other toilets (men are awful for using them for poos in the workplace) are also wrong.

The real core issue is though, that we just don't have enough toilets.

Larger toilet cubicles which are within blocks of standard male/female toilets, are not actually for the exclusive use of disabled people - they can be used by anyone who needs a bit more space. Mums with pushchairs, etc. The stand alone unisex accessible toilets however are not. They are intended exclusively for the use of disabled people and their carers. They are not meant to deal with keeping the queues for the standard toilets down, they are there for the convenience of people who have difficulty using standard toilets and in many cases they are the only facilities some disabled people can use.