Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Banging on the door of the Accessible Toilet

416 replies

HunterHearstHelmsley · 10/12/2023 09:30

Why do people do this?!

I've just used the accessible toilet (I need to use the accessible toilet). I'd barely sat down and someone started banging on the door. I wasn't in there an unreasonable amount of time - probably about 30 seconds when the door banging started and 3 minutes overall. I was in there because I needed to be, banging on the door isn't going to make me quicker. If someone was taking the piss, it'd probably make them stay longer!

It's not the first time it's happened but it's so frustrating. It happened a few weeks ago also, that time was a woman wanting to use the baby change... the baby change wasn't even in the accessible loo!

It's really annoyed me this morning, it's not something I've noticed when using non-accesible toilets so I think it's just an accessible loo thing. But whyyyy?! I can't go faster 😩

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 21:21

DwightDFlysenhower · 12/12/2023 20:12

I don't think it's a thing to leave the larger cubicle empty in a row of cubicles in the ladies is it?

An elderly relative of mine is pretty good on her feet, but finds turning around in a tight cubicle a bit harder now and prefers to use a cubicle with an outward opening door if the venue has one. She just joins the general queue though and uses it when it's available when she's at the front. She doesn't go down the side of the main queue.

No, the larger cubicles in the rows within the single sex male/female toilets are for general use by anyone who needs a bit more space for whatever reason - they’re not exclusively for disabled people. But the separate unisex accessible toilets are only for the use of disabled people and carers.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 21:16

Redebs · 12/12/2023 16:05

I'm sure nobody wants to force a woman to rinse a menstrual cup in a communal sink area with her trousers round her ankles, before shuffling back into a cubicle!

Or for someone with IBS to have an episode of explosive diarrhoea that leaves her dripping faeces?

Or for a pregnant woman to pee herself because the toilet stall is too small to use?

I have given a radar key to a relative with IBS because the thought of her having a bowel event and either not being able to get there in time, or not being able to clean up afterwards is inhumane.

Using a menstrual cup is a choice. Menstruation isn’t a disability but if you must, the single sex larger cubicles within the standard male/female toilets can be used by non disabled people who require more space. Same goes for a pregnant woman. But as has now been said numerous times the stand alone unisex accessible toilets are for the sole use of disabled people and their carers. And someone with IBS is perfectly entitled to use the accessible toilets, it’s a disability. If you use the stand alone one to rinse out your menstrual cup or whatever else, you may be condemning someone whose only option is to use that toilet to having an embarrassing accident. Which is exactly the kind of selfish behaviour we’re discussing here.

Passingthethyme · 12/12/2023 20:32

Redebs · 12/12/2023 16:05

I'm sure nobody wants to force a woman to rinse a menstrual cup in a communal sink area with her trousers round her ankles, before shuffling back into a cubicle!

Or for someone with IBS to have an episode of explosive diarrhoea that leaves her dripping faeces?

Or for a pregnant woman to pee herself because the toilet stall is too small to use?

I have given a radar key to a relative with IBS because the thought of her having a bowel event and either not being able to get there in time, or not being able to clean up afterwards is inhumane.

What pathetic excuses. If you choose to use a menstrual cup, uoir problem. Also, I'm sure most pregnant people manage in a normal cubicle as well as fat people, see plenty on planes. I just find it so appalling that people really want to argue about this and justify their poor behaviour any way they can

DwightDFlysenhower · 12/12/2023 20:31

Convention, that's the word I meant.

DwightDFlysenhower · 12/12/2023 20:12

I don't think it's a thing to leave the larger cubicle empty in a row of cubicles in the ladies is it?

An elderly relative of mine is pretty good on her feet, but finds turning around in a tight cubicle a bit harder now and prefers to use a cubicle with an outward opening door if the venue has one. She just joins the general queue though and uses it when it's available when she's at the front. She doesn't go down the side of the main queue.

Winnading · 12/12/2023 20:08

The blue badge thing is odd. My local authority require reams of information and then still say no.
I've applied for my step mother so I can take her places. She cant walk 20ft now, so I thought I'd have a go at the blue badge so I could at least take her shopping and not park at the far end of the carpark. But I ended up buying a wheelchair instead. Much less stress than getting a blue badge. And if we go at quiet times I can usually find two spaces together to get her out of the car and into the wheelchair.

She is a pensioner, so I'm not certain but she gets carers allowance and state pension. Nothing else that I'm aware of.

Oh and I'm sure you'd all have a hissy fit if you saw me running from or to the car if I did have a blue badge.

coffeeaddict77 · 12/12/2023 18:56

pam290358 · 12/12/2023 12:03

We’ll have to agree to disagree then. I’ve done several blue badge applications and if you say you have a health condition you have to back it up with medical evidence, so you can’t just suggest it. As I said, it’s my experience that local authorities can and do use discretion to award in this way when the condition dictates it.

Yes, you do have to provide medical evidence of the condition but that doesn't always show how it effects the person living with the condition. Where I live whether you get a blue badge a lot of the time will depend on the assessment of one person asking a series of questions and using the answers to determine whether it is necessary.

Bigstones · 12/12/2023 16:38

Redebs · 12/12/2023 16:05

I'm sure nobody wants to force a woman to rinse a menstrual cup in a communal sink area with her trousers round her ankles, before shuffling back into a cubicle!

Or for someone with IBS to have an episode of explosive diarrhoea that leaves her dripping faeces?

Or for a pregnant woman to pee herself because the toilet stall is too small to use?

I have given a radar key to a relative with IBS because the thought of her having a bowel event and either not being able to get there in time, or not being able to clean up afterwards is inhumane.

You again…

If you choose to use a menstrual cup then it’s up to you to manage that appropriately- taking up an accessible toilet is not appropriate. You have other options to manage your periods.

If you are pregnant then you have a temporary condition that means you need more space/quicker access- it’s fine to use the accessible toilet in this situation.

If you have ibs which causes you to have urgency or loss of control or means you have a big clean up to do then you have an illness/condition which means that you require an accessible toilet, so you use the accessible toilet.

Any more ‘gotcha!’ scenarios you would like me to clear up for you?

Bigstones · 12/12/2023 16:17

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 13:42

I think the problem is that the rules are open to interpretation and some local authorities are better than others at recognising real need and using common sense. That said however, I think I would be querying with the local authority why they are insisting on him being in receipt of disability benefits before they will issue a badge.

A fair number of people I’ve assisted with blue badge applications don’t qualify for PIP in a way that would automatically entitle them to a blue badge - some don’t qualify at all as they miss the threshold by minimal points. In those cases the LA has always applied their own medical assessment to determine entitlement. Crohns is really debilitating and if he uses walking and mobility aids too, then someone somewhere isn’t doing a proper job of assessing his needs, and are relying on ticking a box to prove eligibility. PM me if you think I can help.

Thank you. Yes, I’m sure he shouldn’t be caught in this situation, but it isn’t for me to deal with… his immediate family are managing it all and to be honest I don’t think he makes it easy for anyone. He doesn’t want to accept he is disabled.

Redebs · 12/12/2023 16:05

I'm sure nobody wants to force a woman to rinse a menstrual cup in a communal sink area with her trousers round her ankles, before shuffling back into a cubicle!

Or for someone with IBS to have an episode of explosive diarrhoea that leaves her dripping faeces?

Or for a pregnant woman to pee herself because the toilet stall is too small to use?

I have given a radar key to a relative with IBS because the thought of her having a bowel event and either not being able to get there in time, or not being able to clean up afterwards is inhumane.

Beentheredonethat123 · 12/12/2023 15:12

OP this is standard practice and a majority of the time it's the only way to know if it's occupied, without just going ahead and unlocking the door with your radar key.

It gives the occupier the opportunity to say 'engaged', 'hold on' or whatever.

Believe me, it's far better to have a knock on the door than hear a key already unlocking it whilst you're on the loo! FAR more panic when they're already on their way in!!

I do disagree with the banging though, it should be a polite knock.

EggNoggin · 12/12/2023 15:01

I'm sorry for that. My MP is very community minded, and would be keen to be involved.

Rosscameasdoody · 12/12/2023 14:53

EggNoggin · 12/12/2023 14:23

And there's not been much in the way of explaining just how challenging people actually works.

Ideal solutions would be to increase provision. What's your MP said about the subject when you've approached them?

I’ve approached my MP several times regarding this issue because not only are the accessible toilets in my area abused, they’re also in a disgusting state most of the time. I’ve also approached on several other disability issues but my MP is Tory. Need I say more ? They pay lip service with a reply saying they’ll look into it and nothing ever happens.

EggNoggin · 12/12/2023 14:23

Rosscameasdoody · 12/12/2023 14:04

Why is it arrogant to want to protect concessions from abuse, for the benefit of all disabled users ? It’s obviously not ideal to challenge people but what’s the alternative ? Lots of criticism on the thread, and in some cases downright nastiness and judgment directed at those advocating for challenging, even in a respectful or discrete way, but there’s not much in the way of alternative suggestion as to how to protect the concessions we all value as disabled people.

And there's not been much in the way of explaining just how challenging people actually works.

Ideal solutions would be to increase provision. What's your MP said about the subject when you've approached them?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 14:12

WrongSwanson · 12/12/2023 14:01

But if they'd been two teenage girls with wheelchairs smelling of weed, or a mother in a wheelchair with a tantrumming toddler, op might have reached a different conclusion. It's the assumption that no visible disability= no disability.

I give up then. Speaking as a wheelchair user myself I wouldn’t think of using an accessible toilet for either of those purposes because I have first hand experience of the issues disabled people face and am aware that people in genuine need may be waiting to use the facility. That’s about courtesy and consideration for others isn’t it ?

Rosscameasdoody · 12/12/2023 14:04

EggNoggin · 12/12/2023 13:51

If some disabled people are happy being challenged, fine, many aren't.

I'm quoting myself here because I can't edit any more.

Those of you who are fine with being questioned and therefore have decided that because you're fine with it, then it's obviously okay to approach anyone else...

I.e. I'm fine, therefore it is fine, and others should be fine with it too.

Have you no idea how arrogant that is?

Why is it arrogant to want to protect concessions from abuse, for the benefit of all disabled users ? It’s obviously not ideal to challenge people but what’s the alternative ? Lots of criticism on the thread, and in some cases downright nastiness and judgment directed at those advocating for challenging, even in a respectful or discrete way, but there’s not much in the way of alternative suggestion as to how to protect the concessions we all value as disabled people.

SawX · 12/12/2023 14:01

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 08:33

Surely the point in this context is that if you can run in heels and you are using a parking space intended for someone who has mobility difficulties you should be selective in how you use your badge. On a good day when you can run in your four inchers, maybe leave the space for someone else. I have a fluctuating condition and on days when I can walk pain free and don’t have to use my chair, I park elsewhere. There are people for whom not finding a disabled space in a supermarket car park means they can’t do their shopping. It’s called consideration for others. Just because you have the badge doesn’t mean you should use it if and when you don’t need to.

Did you read my reply? I can run and then ONE MINUTE LATER be in terrible pain from walking. And mine is hardly a rare and exotic disability.

WrongSwanson · 12/12/2023 14:01

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 13:55

As for toilets, it's no one's business who is using them. I've just reread the entire thread, and early on there were examples of two teenage girls smoking weed, and a woman using the toilet to calm her tantrumming child. Apparently it was obvious that none of these people was disabled and the poster could tell they weren't disabled.

No. The poster actually said that in those cases it wasn’t that their appearance suggested no disability, but their behaviour - they clearly weren’t using the facilities for their intended purpose. I think the whole point here seems to be that if we can’t challenge for fear of causing distress or offence to someone, then there is no reasonable solution so the concessions continue to be abused. So no point in complaining.

But if they'd been two teenage girls with wheelchairs smelling of weed, or a mother in a wheelchair with a tantrumming toddler, op might have reached a different conclusion. It's the assumption that no visible disability= no disability.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 13:59

EggNoggin · 12/12/2023 13:51

If some disabled people are happy being challenged, fine, many aren't.

I'm quoting myself here because I can't edit any more.

Those of you who are fine with being questioned and therefore have decided that because you're fine with it, then it's obviously okay to approach anyone else...

I.e. I'm fine, therefore it is fine, and others should be fine with it too.

Have you no idea how arrogant that is?

So what’s the solution ? The facilities continue to be abused and if no-one says a word even when it’s clear there’s abuse, then the concessions will end up meaningless. In the case of disabled parking spaces they already are in some places. You only have to walk along the disabled spaces at the front of our local supermarket to see that lots of people are now arrogant enough to park in them without a badge at all - because they’re not being called out on it, so the abuse continues.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 13:55

As for toilets, it's no one's business who is using them. I've just reread the entire thread, and early on there were examples of two teenage girls smoking weed, and a woman using the toilet to calm her tantrumming child. Apparently it was obvious that none of these people was disabled and the poster could tell they weren't disabled.

No. The poster actually said that in those cases it wasn’t that their appearance suggested no disability, but their behaviour - they clearly weren’t using the facilities for their intended purpose. I think the whole point here seems to be that if we can’t challenge for fear of causing distress or offence to someone, then there is no reasonable solution so the concessions continue to be abused. So no point in complaining.

EggNoggin · 12/12/2023 13:51

If some disabled people are happy being challenged, fine, many aren't.

I'm quoting myself here because I can't edit any more.

Those of you who are fine with being questioned and therefore have decided that because you're fine with it, then it's obviously okay to approach anyone else...

I.e. I'm fine, therefore it is fine, and others should be fine with it too.

Have you no idea how arrogant that is?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 13:42

Bigstones · 12/12/2023 12:54

We don’t even need an interview or to be questioned here- you go online and there is a list of benefits that automatically mean you can have a blue badge (the correct level of PIP etc)-

At the time I didn’t have these benefits because of various boring admin issues so I emailed saying I need a blue badge, I’m an ambulatory wheelchair user- and they emailed back half an hour later saying that’s fine use this link to send a photo. No medical or other evidence required.

However, my uncle in a different area has severe crohns, has various bits of his inside missing, various bags, canes and wheelchairs etc and needs a carer at all times, but has been refused a blue badge because he is a stubborn old bugger and won’t claim the benefits that would entitle him 🤷‍♀️. They won’t issue one based on the fact he needs it, only if he gets the benefits.

I think the problem is that the rules are open to interpretation and some local authorities are better than others at recognising real need and using common sense. That said however, I think I would be querying with the local authority why they are insisting on him being in receipt of disability benefits before they will issue a badge.

A fair number of people I’ve assisted with blue badge applications don’t qualify for PIP in a way that would automatically entitle them to a blue badge - some don’t qualify at all as they miss the threshold by minimal points. In those cases the LA has always applied their own medical assessment to determine entitlement. Crohns is really debilitating and if he uses walking and mobility aids too, then someone somewhere isn’t doing a proper job of assessing his needs, and are relying on ticking a box to prove eligibility. PM me if you think I can help.

EggNoggin · 12/12/2023 13:38

That's interesting about LA's different ways of assessing for Blue Badges. Where I live it used to be just answering questions, but it's now tightened up so that you have to send a benefits letter and doctor's letter about the disability. Plus you may be asked to go in for an interview. My mum's had one for many years now, so the letters are enough to get it renewed.

With the BB I'm the driver. So there are times when I've had to drop off, find somewhere to park, then go back. When doing thus I park in ordinary bays but use the badge mostly, but if some of the posters on this thread saw me they'd be having a seizure. Other times I park in a disabled bay with my mum, take my mum somewhere, but then for whatever reason have to come back to the car myself for something, or to move it closer to where my mum is to pick her up (if it's raining for example).

As for toilets, it's no one's business who is using them. I've just reread the entire thread, and early on there were examples of two teenage girls smoking weed, and a woman using the toilet to calm her tantrumming child. Apparently it was obvious that none of these people was disabled and the poster could tell they weren't disabled.

But how can anyone tell? I mean, really? You just can't.

If some disabled people are happy being challenged, fine, many aren't.

I've a hidden disability, my mum's physical one is obvious, but she also has a hidden one. People rattling at toilet doors absolutely terrifies her! We have received looks and comments on exiting when others decide she's taken "too long".

I get looks when I use the accessible toilets, which unnerves me and I start questioning myself, and probably then look flustered or guilty. Is that the proof some people use to determine how "obvious" it is that someone's taking the piss.

I dread going out sometimes. The sheer inadequacy of most disabled toilets when I'm with my mum, the judgmental looks when I'm parking the car on my own or going to the loo.

Jesus Christ, life is difficult enough for disabled people and their carers, and the last thing we need is other disabled people joining the lookers and questioners.

Speaking for myself, I just want to be left alone!

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/12/2023 13:33

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/12/2023 11:45

Just because you can’t think of a condition doesn’t mean it doesn’t exisit. That’s why people with more understanding of the individual decide who should and shouldn’t have a blue badge. in the whole they are a battle to get in the first place

They are, but the point remains that those who are mobile have options and those who are in a wheelchair do not.

It's worth reading Melanie Reid's column on this - she is a tetraplegic after a horseriding accident and wrote an article for the Sunday Times about 10 days ago. She talked about trying to get a disabled bay at a hospital and seeing ambulant people using bays. I can totally see why she'd be frustrated.

I also think it's fine for someone with heavy periods to use an accessible loo, but not if a wheelchair user is waiting. Use the standard loos instead (assuming they are available and it's not Costa with one single loo).

I can relate to this too being a wheelchair user. The parking situation in my local hospital is dreadful. There is one disabled car park with twenty spaces available on a first come first served basis. I’ve now started trying to make sure my hospital appointments aren’t during hospital visiting hours because it’s a nightmare trying to get into a bay to deal with the wheelchair - standard spaces aren’t wide enough.

Numerous times I’ve been sitting waiting and I’ve seen people running back and forth to cars putting bags in, locking up and disappearing back into the hospital. It’s obvious to me that in many cases they are not disabled themselves but are using the blue badge of whoever they are visiting, to park.

It’s infuriating and it’s why I’m one of the posters on here asking what the solution is if we can’t challenge something we see as amiss. Hidden disability is a problem and of course we don’t want to unnecessarily distress people, but eventually these concessions are going to be meaningless unless some way is found to tackle abuse.

Bigstones · 12/12/2023 12:54

pam290358 · 12/12/2023 12:03

We’ll have to agree to disagree then. I’ve done several blue badge applications and if you say you have a health condition you have to back it up with medical evidence, so you can’t just suggest it. As I said, it’s my experience that local authorities can and do use discretion to award in this way when the condition dictates it.

We don’t even need an interview or to be questioned here- you go online and there is a list of benefits that automatically mean you can have a blue badge (the correct level of PIP etc)-

At the time I didn’t have these benefits because of various boring admin issues so I emailed saying I need a blue badge, I’m an ambulatory wheelchair user- and they emailed back half an hour later saying that’s fine use this link to send a photo. No medical or other evidence required.

However, my uncle in a different area has severe crohns, has various bits of his inside missing, various bags, canes and wheelchairs etc and needs a carer at all times, but has been refused a blue badge because he is a stubborn old bugger and won’t claim the benefits that would entitle him 🤷‍♀️. They won’t issue one based on the fact he needs it, only if he gets the benefits.