Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think they should replace the Christmas tree?

185 replies

BloodOrangeCheesecake · 09/12/2023 20:29

Hi all,

Apologies for any mistakes - English is my second language.

I bought a real Christmas tree at our local farmer’s shop few days ago, kids got all exited about decorating it this evening - only for us to find out that every single tip of every branch is chopped off (I’m assuming to make Christmas wreaths)

AIBU to contact the shop and ask to replace it?

DH says to leave it but it annoys me - I don't want a butchered Christmas tree.
It is quite visible (at least to me) and can’t really be covered with baubles etc

AIBU to think they should replace the Christmas tree?
OP posts:
BloodOrangeCheesecake · 09/12/2023 23:53

bridgetreilly · 09/12/2023 23:45

So if you buy a top, get home, and realise its got a hole in that you didn't see...

If goods are faulty, you have a right to a refund or replacement. This tree is not faulty, the OP doesn’t like it. So the equivalent would be buying a top, getting it home and deciding you don’t like it. Plenty of shops will let you return or exchange in that situation, but they don’t have any obligation to do that. Market stalls or farm shops tend not to have those generous return policies because they can’t afford to. The OP needs to accept that this was her mistake and suck it up.

Dear god, every tip of every main branch (about 20-30) is chopped off.

How is the tree not faulty???

OP posts:
StillWantingADog · 09/12/2023 23:50

BloodOrangeCheesecake · 09/12/2023 23:28

Well good on you, I guess. But for me £65 is quite a bit of money.

Analogy with turkey was crap one, I admit, but let’s say you bought £65 Lego set (or something similar along these lines) for your kid and some bricks were missing because shop decided to make one extra Lego set (wreath in my case) out of them to make some extra £.

You will just suck it up, right? 🙄

No because the Lego would have been in the box so no way to know the pieces weren’t there before opening

you literally picked your tree out because you liked the look of it. It wasn’t in a box or packaged up (it seems).

you obviously think you have a case to return it so by all means give it a shot. I’d suck it up and be more careful next year.

GabriellaMontez · 09/12/2023 23:48

Wtf! The reason she doesn't like the.tree is because it's had bits cut out off it.

All over!

She didn't just change her mind!

bridgetreilly · 09/12/2023 23:45

So if you buy a top, get home, and realise its got a hole in that you didn't see...

If goods are faulty, you have a right to a refund or replacement. This tree is not faulty, the OP doesn’t like it. So the equivalent would be buying a top, getting it home and deciding you don’t like it. Plenty of shops will let you return or exchange in that situation, but they don’t have any obligation to do that. Market stalls or farm shops tend not to have those generous return policies because they can’t afford to. The OP needs to accept that this was her mistake and suck it up.

BloodOrangeCheesecake · 09/12/2023 23:44

GabriellaMontez · 09/12/2023 23:37

£65 for a tree that's been hacked at? No way! I've never had anything like this. Not ok. I'm stunned that anyone thinks it is!

I am too kinda stunned with the way this tread went🤣

In addition to 18inches branches for the wreaths…

I feel my damn tree is like proverbial Mumsnet chicken that can magic up 4 meals and feed a family of 8 for a week🤣

Apparently I should be happy that someone made some wreaths (out of the tree I paid for), sold them for £50 each and then sold me butchered tree for £65

OP posts:
GabriellaMontez · 09/12/2023 23:39

bridgetreilly · 09/12/2023 23:36

Of course you can’t get a replacement. You saw the tree beforehand, and you bought exactly what you saw. It isn’t their fault you were in a rush and didn’t bother looking to see if it met your precise specifications. They haven’t mis-sold, the tree isn’t faulty and you have no consumer right to another tree.

And yes, a replacement is a freebie and it would be incredibly grabby.

So if you buy a top, get home, and realise its got a hole in that you didn't see...

Do you keep it, because its your own fault? Or return it?

GabriellaMontez · 09/12/2023 23:37

£65 for a tree that's been hacked at? No way! I've never had anything like this. Not ok. I'm stunned that anyone thinks it is!

Goldbar · 09/12/2023 23:37

DecemberSleet · 09/12/2023 23:34

Yes, I think the Lego analogy is the same - Lego is to be played with for years. It needs to be perfect.

This is a one off event. And it still does a job.

It works be like spending £60 on a birthday cake which is a bit shit.

I might complain. But ultimately I'd chalk it up to experience and not go there again. As long as the cake was edible and not covered in swear words or something mad!

Would you be fine about it if your birthday cake arrived with chunks gouged out of it?

bridgetreilly · 09/12/2023 23:36

Of course you can’t get a replacement. You saw the tree beforehand, and you bought exactly what you saw. It isn’t their fault you were in a rush and didn’t bother looking to see if it met your precise specifications. They haven’t mis-sold, the tree isn’t faulty and you have no consumer right to another tree.

And yes, a replacement is a freebie and it would be incredibly grabby.

Tryingmybestadhd · 09/12/2023 23:34

Contact them and ask to return it . I wouldn’t want it either

Goldbar · 09/12/2023 23:34

That tree looks terrible, OP. I'd ask for a replacement. They'll probably argue it was sold as seen, but no, I wouldn't be happy with that.

There's loving a tree's natural imperfections, yes, but there's nothing natural about the way that tree has been butchered.

DecemberSleet · 09/12/2023 23:34

Yes, I think the Lego analogy is the same - Lego is to be played with for years. It needs to be perfect.

This is a one off event. And it still does a job.

It works be like spending £60 on a birthday cake which is a bit shit.

I might complain. But ultimately I'd chalk it up to experience and not go there again. As long as the cake was edible and not covered in swear words or something mad!

BloodOrangeCheesecake · 09/12/2023 23:33

Perihelion · 09/12/2023 23:19

My tree bought in Scotland has also had a few branches chopped off. But is actually the best shaped tree I've ever had.
I don't think it was for wreaths, but to shape it. I wonder if the late pruning is to do with the weather this year, or a lack of workers to prune earlier in the year.

Edited

Maybe you are right. Though on mine every single main branch tip is missing. I mean who has time for such meticulous pruning??

OP posts:
BloodOrangeCheesecake · 09/12/2023 23:30

Switcher · 09/12/2023 23:23

That would really annoy me too, and I'd just sit there being annoyed.

That’s what I’ll do, I guess.

And will leave my money elsewhere next year.

OP posts:
BloodOrangeCheesecake · 09/12/2023 23:28

Schmusimausi73 · 09/12/2023 23:17

I’m a foreigner as well and I’m still rolling my eyes at your “dilemma” 😂

Well good on you, I guess. But for me £65 is quite a bit of money.

Analogy with turkey was crap one, I admit, but let’s say you bought £65 Lego set (or something similar along these lines) for your kid and some bricks were missing because shop decided to make one extra Lego set (wreath in my case) out of them to make some extra £.

You will just suck it up, right? 🙄

OP posts:
Switcher · 09/12/2023 23:23

That would really annoy me too, and I'd just sit there being annoyed.

Perihelion · 09/12/2023 23:19

My tree bought in Scotland has also had a few branches chopped off. But is actually the best shaped tree I've ever had.
I don't think it was for wreaths, but to shape it. I wonder if the late pruning is to do with the weather this year, or a lack of workers to prune earlier in the year.

Schmusimausi73 · 09/12/2023 23:17

BloodOrangeCheesecake · 09/12/2023 22:16

I feel that pile on is because i’m a foreigner - it is something i notice quite regularly on here: responses are usually harsher and OP is often ridiculed even if AIBU is completely valid

I’m a foreigner as well and I’m still rolling my eyes at your “dilemma” 😂

Snugglemonkey · 09/12/2023 23:17

Scarletttulips · 09/12/2023 20:31

LOL - some people are starving and cold this Christmas.

Someone being worse off does not make op unreasonable for being unhappy with her tree.

wronginalltherightways · 09/12/2023 23:14

I'd ask for a new one; it will dry out and go brown faster.

That's not on.

ShouldGoToBed · 09/12/2023 23:09

This would annoy me too, we buy a real tree every year and I’ve never seen one that’s been hacked about like this. If your kids won’t be upset I’d take it back.

Wellscunnered · 09/12/2023 23:06

Your English is terrific and you’re not wrong to be unhappy

User3735 · 09/12/2023 23:05

Sorry, so many typos. This year we decided to save some money*

TwoMoreBoxesJayne · 09/12/2023 23:04

I wouldn't like it either. YANBU

User3735 · 09/12/2023 23:04

Yeah you aren't being OTT. This year we decide gonsave some moment and get a supermarket tree, knew we were taking a risk not being able to see it, and it IS rather sparse on branches and the worst tree we've ever had, BUT we only paid £26 for a large one. Of course I wouldn't take it back, that was the risk we took. But that is not your situation, you bought a full price locally sold tree which would have been over £50, and I've never had a real tree butchered like that. If you'd bought it for £20 I'd say let it go, but not at that price.

We nearly bought a £55 Costco tree. Then last night we were in Costco and they were clearing all the trees for £9.99! Nothing wrong with them, they just want all the real trees gone. I felt bitter about our £26, I'd be crying if I'd spent £65! OP take it back or call and ask for a partial refund?